We've been in Fort Wayne for nearly three years now and have driven by Oley's hundreds of times, but never stopped in... Boy, have we been missing out. We ordered pizza on a random Friday and were blown away by this gem - The pizza is some of the best, if not the best we've had in Fort Wayne. It's kind of a mix between Giordano's tavern style and Riverbend, but my God was it good... Outstanding crust, good red sauce, and loaded with toppings. We couldn't be both more pleased and surprised... We will definitely be back. Dave Portnoy 8.2 read more

Oley's Pizza Shoppe - Pizza Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

Oley's Pizza is hands down one of Fort Wayne's best pizza spots. The pizza always arrives hot when delivered, and ordering over the phone is super easy -- the staff are friendly, patient, and helpful every time. The house salad dressing is a standout -- very, very good. Honestly, anything you try here is likely to please. The atmosphere inside is great, making it perfect for large groups and families looking for a comfortable place to enjoy a meal together. Whether dining in or getting delivery, Oley's consistently hits the mark. read more

So here is the update. When I got my credit card statement, I found out they had actually charged my credit card TWICE for a pizza that wasn't even the pizza that I had ordered. read more

The man at the counter in the hat is a very nice gentleman with great customer service and I loved the food

Their double decker pizza never disappoints. The staff was really friendly, even though it was close to closing. Even though the pizza is super thick, it is never undercooked. It's my favorite comfort food. read more

One of the best slices you're going to find in Fort Wayne. They pack this double crusted beast with all the pizza goodness - flavorful sausage, meaty pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, poblano peppers, onion and a cheese blend. You don't want to miss this if you're a fan of the Chicago Style or deep dish. read more

Oley's Pizza Shoppe - Oley's delicious Deluxe Double Crust Style Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

See all

I've been coming here for 20 years and have never had such a messed up relationship experience. The low-energy waiter didn't know the menu, couldn't identify where the beer list might be, whether or not they served iced tea, and when we ordered two side salads, he brought out two giant plates of iceberg covered with tons of carrot, 2 tomatoes, and one ounce of ham. For $9!!! When I brought this to the attention of the young female employee, she apologized and said this was only his fourth day. (It takes four days to find the beer menu and learn if your restaurant serves iced tea???) The right thing would've been to remove the $18 for salads we didn't order or realize we were getting. But that did not happen. Just a lighthearted apology and a shrug. It'll be a very long time before we go back. And DO NOT order the pathetic excuse for a chef salad! read more

Always amazing! Double crust is second to none! The supreme is literally supreme!! The triple pepperoni is also delicious! Give it a try and you'll be hooked! read more

We love there supreme double crust and garlic cheese bread with a side of cheese sauce. a small is way more than two can eat. This is our Fort Wayne favorite. read more

Population isn't the only reason Fort Wayne's version of deep dish pizza doesn't have the name recognition of Chicago's or Detroit's. This variation has the same bland sauce you'd find at Pizza Hut, gobs of flavorless mozzarella and the crust is like a thick version of a saltine cracker, sans the salt. The service for takeout was good and the interior was clean, so at least there's that. read more

I tried the double crust pepperoni this evening for dinner. It was ok, in my opinion. It was overwhelming with cheese and the crust needs to be a touch crisper. It had a great flavor, but it was to much of a good thing for me. My companion had the hot wings and garlic cheese bread, both were ok, I tasted each, strictly for verification purposes,heeeeheeee! They weren't awful, but I've had much better. It was an ok first experience. I don't see myself becoming a regular. I gave 3 stars be wise I felt everything was ok, but nothing was great. read more

Oley's Pizza Shoppe - Double crust pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

Don't buy the bread sticks, way over priced for zero seasoning and rom temp. Normal.pizzas are okay. The only reason I would go back is for the double crust. Love having a cheese stuffed pizza. read more

Delicious food , wings are best in city , delivery was very fast also, will order again

Pie was under cooked. Sausage had no taste. On the plus side the pie was ready when we picked it up.

The double crust is amazingly delicious! I was told by co-workers here that this is the best place in Fort Wayne for pizza and I think they were spot on. The pizza is unlike any other place I've tried before and that's saying something as I'm a pizza nut. The double crust is two very thin layer crusted pizzas combined on top of one another to form one semi-deep dish type pizza. People say it's Chicago style but really it's not, other than it's a deep dish type pizza. Chicago style has the sauce on top and is usually deeper than this. Try the deluxe, double-crust pizza and you will not regret it! read more

Oley's Pizza Shoppe - The double crust Deluxe...mmm - Pizza Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

My fiancee is a born and raised Hoosier and according to him this place is a Fort Wayne staple. We went here close to 9p on a Saturday night for some pizza, since I've never been, but the dining area was closed. Bummer, but no biggie- we decided to order take out. The lady that was working was kind of rude (hence the 4 star rating) but other than that everything else was OK. The place is way small and has an old timey feel to it. But the first thing you notice when you first walk in is the smell. IT.IS.AMAZING. We shortly received out order after it was placed and went back home. As a first timer at this place all I can say is I'm speechless. The deep dish pizza is a mouthful of warm, cheezy goodness I never knew I needed until that moment. It literally is like having two pizzas cooked into one. If you're considering going here as a first timer, do it... you can thank me later! read more

Double crust . Check Facebook for updates. Pizza is expensive but filling. Online ordering available

Went here to try the pizza because I have herd alot from other people who recommended it. Me and my wife are kind of spoiled in this type of food, we spend alot of time in Chicago, so it is very hard to find pizza that matches up. Oleys fell far short. We got the bread sticks as well as the cheese covered mushrooms. The mushrooms were fresh, that was a plus however they were just sliced and put on a plate and covered in cheese. No seasoning, no oil or butter, just mushrooms and cheese. The bread sticks were the same. Baked bread. While fresh, it was very bland, no seasoning, butter or anything. The Pizza was on about the same level. The ingredients were good but the overall experience was blahhh. I even mentioned to my wife at one point that Jacks pizza from the grocery store was better. Needless to say, I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here again. read more

See all

Quiet little shop in the middle of nowhere! But damn it's good. I don't recommend the pizza if your not a cheese fan cause it is loaded with cheese from the first bite to the last. You will be lucky if you don't make a mess when you scoop up a slice as the cheese ooozes. Sausage rolls are amazing and the salads are simple but leave you craving them days later, and did I mention the garlic knots!!! read more

Double crust deluxe is amazing. It isn't exactly cheap, and diameter seems a bit small (about 2" less than advertised), but the volume of filling and taste/dough texture make it well worth it. read more

Apparently this place is well-liked around here so I thought I would give it a try as I haven't found one pizza place that is worthwhile in this area, but unfortunately Oley's was just another disappointment. I ordered the deluxe. Although there was a lot of cheese, it didn't have much taste to it. There was almost zero sauce, which made it rather dry. And there was so much sausage that it overwhelmed the taste of the whole pizza. There was only a little bit of the other toppings. Definitely nothing special. Prices were reasonable and the service was good, so there's that...maybe I'll go back and try something besides their pizza. read more

This oley's is definitely not as good as the other location. Pizza was good but crust was like a cracker. It was disappointing

Even though the pie was only 7.25 pounds,,the Deluxe Double Crust is still delicious. Still looking,in StLouis, for a pizza this thick. Still good after all these years. read more

See all

If you like a lot of oil from the sausage and cheese, it is very good. Too much for our taste. It was very HOT when we got it home which is a plus. They had the carry out safety down pat, come in notify you are there, get a number and wait in your car. Very good! It took 75 minutes to get a pizza ordered online on a Sat. at 5p. That seems a little long compare to other shops. read more

If you like a lot of oil from the sausage and cheese, it is very good. Too much for our taste. It was very HOT when we got it home which is a plus. They had the carry out safety down pat, come in notify you are there, get a number and wait in your car. Very good! It took 75 minutes to get a pizza ordered online on a Sat. at 5p. That seems a little long compare to other shops. read more

A deep pizza for sure. Always love Oley's. This isn't the original off 24, but they mimic is good enough to get 5 stars. I don't got to go down 24 anymore. This place here will serve it up thick and give you that deep deep dish of pizza loaded with that sauce and cheese. Couple pieces you will be bloated up. Enough! Good pizza to feed lots of folks. It's good and if you're plugged up this stuff might be the unclog you need. All that cheese and sauce will get you flowing! read more

Double crust deep dish meat pizza and garlic knots & cheese. One of our favorite pizza places now. Kids also really liked the pizza. One piece w the knots and you're stuffed. We will be back for sure. read more

Double crust magic. We simply had half cheese and half pepperoni. The garlic cheese bread was OK. The pizza is the real hit here. Also- this is different than the Oley's on 24. read more

Have only gotten carry out from Oley's, but the food has been great every time. Breadsticks, pizza, and sandwiches are all great!

Pizza was very good! Will be ordering again! But I will pick up as GrubHub is way too much to use.

This is one of my favorite pizzerias in the country. Every time I come to town I make my way to Oley's. Fort Wayne has a total jewel in Oley's. The double crust stuffed pizza is simply amazing. The bottom layer is packed with cheese, with another layer of crust placed on top of that, then the toppings, and finally a top layer of cheese. All inside of a Chicago style, deep-dish pan. It's Incredible! I highly recommend the deluxe! read more

Oley's Pizza Shoppe - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

We were greeted with a warm welcome. Oley's is without a doubt the best pizza place I've eaten at in Fort Wayne. The owner came out several times making sure that everything was good. I told her that it wasn't good at all, it was great. The atmosphere here was relaxing. I wasn't rushed to get through and get out. Ever time another pizza come out I wanted to try it too. The cheesy mushrooms and the deep dish pizza you have to try. They will fill you up without a doubt, then the table next to you gets there's and you get a smell you're ready for more. read more

See all

Double crust!!! This is a great place to get some deep dish pizza. The double crust has crust, cheese, crust and then more cheese and toppings. It's pretty amazing. Not gonna lie it is a little pricey but your definitely getting what you paid for. I would most definitely go back! read more

Ordered a carry out for the Oley's deluxe roll and it was made right on time. The taste was great and fair priced. I definitely recommend. I also STRONGLY recommend the Oley's double crust deluxe pizza! read more

Oley's Pizza Shoppe - Oley's deluxe roll - Pizza Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

See all

Great place to get a pizza! Love ordering to go but stopping in to the tucked away little bar! Great pizza and service is always spot on.

If I could give them 10 STARS I would..... Growing up in Fort Wayne, this was the best pizza and as I have ventured off into the world, I have not been able to find anything comparable. 1,500 miles away and I still crave it! The owners, Rose & Jim Parnin, are absolutely wonderful and treat every guest as family. read more

I was in search of the best sausage roll and the reviews said Oley's pizza. My sister and I went over and purchased one to try, we were not happy for 15.00 we received a 6 inch roll we wanted extra sauce on the inside of the sausage roll not in a separate container. The breading incasing the ingredients was hard like cracker hard we were expecting a dough like crust, soft after coming out of the oven you could hear how crunchy the roll was and dry not juicy once you cut into it we ordered extra ingredients on it barely saw any extras the search continues for the best sausage roll. read more

This place looks/smells pretty grungy, so I wasn't quite sure what I was getting into when someone recommended it. The interior smells like smoke and definitely looks like it could use a good cleaning. I was pleasantly surprised by the taste of the pizza, though. I tried the double stuffed crust pizza and it was very cheesy and delicious. My sister ordered wings and they looked pretty basic, like they had just been dumped out of a bag into a fryer, and she commented they were not very good. I think in the future, I would stick with take-out and try not to visualize the space where the pizza came from. read more

Not a fan, but I haven't tried the DB crust yet. I ordered a pepperoni and mushroom pizza and was excited to try it because of the reviews online and here. First, the crust is paper thin and maybe this would have been okay if I didn't get takeout. The bottom was mushy from sticking to the cardboard and took on it flavor of the cardboard because it didn't have anything to separate it from the cardboard. The crust needs ventilation if traveling. Second, No need for extra cheese because it's layered thicker then the crust. This only makes the crust limp when trying to eat a slice. Third, price. This isn't a gourmet pizza, so I don't think you should be paying almost $20 for an x-lg pizza with only 2 toppings. Also, I was originally going to go for DB crust because of reviews online, but felt $30 was a but stiff. I might try this place one last time, but most likely not because of cost. read more

This is an okay pizza place. Not overly expensive for the amount we got. Pizza took a little bit to get done. Not bad for having to drive out to get the pizza. read more