Totally blown away at the flavor and quality of the food here. This is my new "go-to" pizza place. Normally a meat pizza is greasy and falls apart, we ordered a vegetarian and an All Meat pizza. Both were perfect and packed with toppings. Cooked to perfection. I'm very picky about pizza and they exceeded expectations. The staff was also great. Very friendly. read more

The pizza was simply amazing. Decided to get this for father's day for me and my dad to try together and we got a half cheese half all meat. There was no meat on the cheese side and it tasted delicious. Even my dad loved it again said it was an "8 out of 10" in his books. We even got the garlic bread and it really was a whole foot long loaf of bread. Perfect to have with guests or split over multiple meals. The person working behind the counter was lovely and chuckled at my dad's poor jokes. Nice and quiet. It is an easy spot to miss your turn so make sure you are ready when you got here for the first time. read more

We order delivery quite a bit. The pizzas are always hot and delicious. Delivery always arrives earlier than promised. I have NEVER had any issues. This is my go to place when I don't feel cooking. I highly recommend. read more

Crust was good and the sauce was great. It wasn't super sweet or savory but a perfect balance. We ordered for pick up and noted that there wasn't a sign telling us we were in the right place so that was a little confusing But over all delicious. Super inexpensive. I would skip the mozzarella sticks. They were rubbery and a little cold and the breading was to be desired but that's our only pit for so many peaks. read more

I have ate Mama Mia's pizzas several times! It's always Delicious! They provide several choices! Always, friendly staff! read more

Decided to branch out from Domino's tonight. I can honestly say this was the "cleanest" pizza I've ever had, practically no grease whatsoever. Woman at the counter for carry out was very nice as well. Great price. 5/5 read more

Mama Mia's Pizza - Large cheese pizza with bacon and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

They exceeded my expectations the food was good, they make a great thin crust. We ordered over the phone, and found out they delivered to our house. The delivery was prompt and the people were friendly and helpful read more

If you have never tried the roadkill, do yourself a favor and RUN. Delicious Service was friendly & fast! read more

Mama Mia's Pizza - Roadkill - Pizza Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

Been our go to pizza and sub restaurants for more than 30 years. Great flavor and always hot and exactly as ordered. read more

Good pizza good price. Would have pizza delivered during many overnights for travel soccer and travel hockey. I always try to be a patron for local companies, they didn't disappoint. read more

They serve up some mean grub for sure! Not cheap like they use to be, but the quality is as good if not better than it ever was. Not as cheap for sure. You just remember that! Good selection of subs for sure. The pizza is pretty killer. Enough cheese and toppings on this one! I think they pretty darn good. Roadkill Sub rocks, Devils Sub is king! Lots of meats and such here! Use to be dirt cheap 20 years ago. Times have changed, still good though. Prices here are actually pretty good for it being 2021. Back in 2000 I could get foot long subs for around $8. Now what are they? $14 or something like that with coupon. Good though I tell you. read more

Came here to order food. I Got the Pepperoni Sub and it was Delicious. The Prices Were Cheap. The Workers Were Nice.

I just have a comment to make. When placing an order they are now asking would you like to add the tip to your card or settle up for it at the door. Since when is a tip mandatory? They get a delivery fee now maybe they should give that to the delivery driver or at least split it with them. Its making the cost of pizza too expensive, I guess thats why most places stopped delivering at all. I dont that we should be expected to pay a delivery fee as well as a tip, splitting the delivery fee would be the way to go since they are using their own car for it. How much do they collect in delivery fees compared to what they pay a driver hourly in that same hour? read more

We LOVE Mama Mia's pizza! Every pizza we have ever ordered is perfect. Great pizza for any night of the week! This is our go to place! The employees here super nice...please don't change a thing! read more

Mama Mia's is a great option if you are on a budget and need to feed a bunch of hungry kids. It's an upgrade over Pizza Hut, Little Caesars but definitely not my favorite place to order from. I'm shocked they don't offer breadsticks, odd for a pizza restaurant. 3 out of 5 stars. read more

Consistently amazing every time! Friendly and fast service, great food, and decent prices. There are so many place around town where the service quality has gone completely down the tubes, thankfully Mama Mia's is not one of them, and can always be relied on for a good eating experience. read more

Mama Mia's on St. Joe Road in Fort Wayne is our go- to pizza place. Everything we've ever ordered has been excellent. They make great pizzas, of course, and also terrific sausage rolls and wonderful subs. Things are reasonably priced too. And on top of everything else, the staff is very friendly. There's absolutely nothing not to like about this place! read more

We have been ordering from Mama Mia's for over 13 years now. They have great pizza, crust is hand made. The All Meat pizza is our favorite always loaded with toppings! Love their subs - they have great wings too! Very reasonable price. The staff is always friendly. We order at least 3- 4 times a month. Will never go anywhere else. Very loyal satisfied customer! read more

Someone brought their pizza to my house a few weeks ago, and it was outstanding. So I decided to order it tonight even though there are several great pizza places closer to me. The woman who answered the phone was rude. When I arrived, staff was rude. Pizza was mediocre. I won't be going back. Sorry. read more

Definitely a hole in the wall joint. Pick up or delivery only. I've been coming here for about 17 years whenever I come to Fort Wayne. I have yet to be disappointed. Highly encourage any of the sandwiches especially a roadkill read more

DO NOT TRY TO CALL AND ASK WHAT TIME THEY CLOSE. They will tell you what time they close the doors but they won't tell you they stop taking orders 30 minutes before that. So, you'll call back at 10:30 pm on your phone (consequently 10:31 pm on theirs) and the dude who answers the phone will tell you they're closed. You'll ask how that's possible when you called less than an hour ago and the same guy told you they closed at 11pm. He'll act like a butt and tell you that they stop taking orders at 10:30. Well if you're like me, then you'll you ask them why they didn't include that extremely pertinent info when you called the last time. He'll act like a snot and tell you that your clock is wrong and that he won't make your food. The food isn't all that amazing, I'll just go to River Bend for pizza and Corner Pocket for wings instead. We won't might miss the Road Kill, but we'll find a suitable replacement because we won't be back. read more

Very good and cheap pizza! I also like their program where if you order there ten times you get a free pizza.

I ordered from the one on Dupont Road but that one isn't listed so here we go. I am new to town and was craving some pizza & wings, which totally aren't here, dont waste your time or money, I ordered them and an hour later they showed up, the wings were unbelievably cold and soggy, no level of crispness at all, gross, I couldnt even eat them, they went straight to the trash and I love wings, but these were some of the worst I have ever had. Then I went for a slice of the pizza, I could have made a better pizza in the microwave, If you want delivery go with Papa Johns or another chain, it will at least be tolerable, this place is gross, I will never order or eat here again. Very disappointed to have just blown $20 here. read more

I give it 5/5, as does my dining companion. and we believe that as a pseudo pizza connoisseurs, we can give a fair descriptive analysis of the pizza. Firstly, great prices across the board here. A coupon for two $5.99 medium 2-topping pizzas was used for this first-time visit ($13.000 even with tax). Not an expensive place at all. The 1st pizza was a double bacon pizza, which satisfied myself and my dining companion Thoroughly. The bacon was on top of the cheese and was certainly a doubled up topping. The 2nd pizza was pepperoni and onion,also satisfying. The pepperoni and onions were partially covered with cheese and then baked. I brought up that I am not usually a fan of pepperoni, as well as other toppings, beneath the cheese. My dining companion made a good point however, noting the reduction of topping "slippage." His point was fair, although I pointed out that it is most important with things like vegetables and maybe bacon. I was pleased, however, to see that the pepperoni and onions weren't entirely covered in cheese, which allowed the pepperoni to crisp some, and the onions to have exposure for cooking as well. All in all we both felt they did well in this aspect. My dining companion remarked that while there were a lot of crumbs from the bacon and maybe some cheese topping might have helped, we certainly weren't disappointed at the amount of bacon and the accumulation of bacon onto our plates while eating. The criticism, I'd say there was slightly too much crust (e.g. the sauce and cheese didn't reach within 1" of the edge.). This is not such a strong criticism so as to give it less than a 5/5, given all its other positive qualities. read more

I will never order from this place again. Ordered pizza salad pop breadsticks & hamburger. Picked food up for home (I live 3 miles from location). Everything was COLD. Pizza was clearly dropped because the cold cheese was only on one side of the pizza. Took everything back except forgot salad Jerk at location blamed it on us that we must of let the pizza slide and fall in our car. Hamburger cold was our fault cause of drive. Normally a store apologizes. Offer to compensate for crappy food and service.. nope not this place. We only got grief and accused of it being our fault. Full order wasn't credited Still made us pay for pop. Never again will I go. Called papa johns and got great service and great pizza read more

Soggy, greasy pizza with very little portions. Their redeeming qualities were their prices.....but now they have jacked those up, too! It was worth it when it was reasonably priced to match the quality.....now it's just a waste of money. read more

In the last few months I have gotten Mama Mia's pizza. they have been consistently awesome and now they are my favorite pizza place in town read more

Had Mama Mia the other night for dinner for the first time! Had a pizza the dream roll fries and salad! There was the best I've ever had!! The dream roll was my favorite!!! And there salad is huge and they freshly make them. The staff was very friendly add and took off items I didn't want on my salad. Everything was perfect fast delivery! Ordered them again 2 days later it was that good! Had to foot long sandwiches and omg the best ever!! I will not order from anywhere else again! Best food and great staff!!! Thank you Mama Mia's for having such a great and reasonable prices establishment! So thankful I tried this place!! Will be calling them for sure for Super Bowl!!! read more

My favorite pizza place. They have great pizza and subs. They're way better than the chain places with bland crap they call pizza.

Mama Mias -- thank you! Much appreciation for a small pizza chain that produces consistently amazing products with a high regard to quality and order accuracy coupled with fair pricing!! Been ordering here for about 4 years and I would say that equates to about 2 orders a month equalling around 100 orders. We typically order subs, pizzas, or rolls - to date we have not once had an issue with a single order. It may not seem like much to most people but it is..! We are surrounded by pizza franchises that spend tens of thousands of dollars on R&D, advertising, and equipment that have a propensity to get an order wrong and ourn little fantastic Mama Mias with a small budget can deliver what franchises cant! To reiterate what others have said -great food and great prices! Call in your order today! read more

Yummy Sandwiches I always have liked the pizza. But yesterday my wife grabbed a sandwich. It was named the road kill, lots of meat with delicious mama mias special sauce. I had to try a bite. Now I am a fan of their sandwiches as well as their pizza. Prices are very reasonable. The lobby could be a little cleaner at the Dupont location. But all in all, yummy! read more

The food is good and the service is too. Not everything is great, you just need to know what to get. A half sub is around $3.50 and makes a very inexpensive lunch. The roadkill sub is the best sub in the city. Other subs there are so so. Pizza there is ok, but nothing to write home about. read more

Finally a pizza place where the food is well prepared and tasty as well as economical. Every time I get a pizza from here it is carry-out as there is no dining room, that is just fine because their pizza boxes are nice and thick and that helps prevent pizza accidents. Not like those cheap-tards over at Mancinos; I fall down frequently and that box is not sturdy enough to take an impact...and all to save 19 cents per box. The best pizza is double bacon, then cheese, then double bacon and onion. It is truly the best pizza in Fort Wayne. Do not pass up this opportunity to take home a roadkill sub as well. The salads are fresh and crisp. -jh read more

Great hidden gem! Great food go check it. I got a sub and was impressed with the food.

This is my go-to for pizza. Can't beat those prices! Service is always great and fast.

This pizza is always good- generous toppings, well constructed, good flavor, great prices! My favorite place for delivery in town!

Tired their pizza a few days ago. Nothing to write home about. It's defiantly better than your average chain like Pizza Hut or Papa Johns, but I wouldn't go out of my way to get it. Overall it was okay, but there is much better pizza in Fort Wayne. read more

I haven't had any pizza but am a regular for the sandwiches which are tasty, cheap and a large portion.

I have eat pizza all over the country- and appreciate all of the regional varieties BUT this place's old country Sicilian pizza with ham is my very favorite! Every time we r in town I lobby for mama Mia carry out! I've heard the sandwiches r good too but I don't think I will ever get anything else! And in Fort Wayne Indiana of all places! read more

So, I'm reviewing again because after a few months, I called and ordered food again. 100% better service than before and food is still bomb.