This evening my husband took our daughter and her friend to Pizza Forum for dinner, it was a win because we had coupons to use on Pizza & Bread sticks. It was her friends very first visit. Her words were, "wow this is the nicest restaurant I've ever been to." It was our 2nd visit, actually was better than the first visit. We ended up ordering the girls a cheese pizza and a pepperoni pizza plus an order of bread sticks. The girls ate a couple bread sticks and 4 slices of pizza each. They loved the pizza. The bread sticks were loaded in butter and garlic sauce. My husband and I ordered an XL pepperoni and mushroom pizza. It was so delicious. Yes, we have plenty of leftovers for tomorrow's lunch or dinner. Cold pizza is the best ever. The restaurant was nice and clean. Bathrooms were also clean, that's a plus in my book. Nasty bathrooms make for a bad experience. Our server was great, altho it took her a bit to refill my drink, all is good she got to it. Over all we had a pleasant experience this evening. They played Christmas Music in the background. That was nice for the Holiday. Very enjoyable to listen to. We will definitely be back to Pizza Forum. read more

See all

I generally LOVE any pizza from here. However last time toppings stopped 2-4 inches before the crust! Great in the center but "naked" all around the outside. If you carry out you might want to view your pizza before you take it home. read more

Best pizza in Auburn. Adding meatball on a pizza is phenomenal. Very calm , quiet and welcoming inside Employees always have a good attitude read more

The pizza here is exceptional! The owners are always the ones cooking and delivering food so you get a personal touch getting your food here. Probably one of the top 5 pizzas I've had, food is always on point and never had a bad here yet! read more

The best sauce and breadsticks. Great service and fun atmosphere. Favorite local pizza place.

Cute spot on the square. Loved the bread sticks. Even if you don't usually get an appetizer I highly recommend not skipping out on these pillowing soft garlicky buttered sticks from heaven. Pizza was tasty. We ordered Hawaiian and Deluxe. The Hawaiian had a generous portion of pineapple which most don't. The owner was super friendly and attentive. We will be back. read more

Food is yummy Service is ok Ambiance is casual There were 25 of us on a Friday and we were all served efficiently read more

Food and customer service were great! My son was so excited to get a hotdog from the vendor, who was very cool too! We all had a great time! read more

Strange experience. Food ok. Service very questionable. At pickup, I gave my name. Young lady behind the counter gave a strange, puzzled look then asked if I had paid. Assured her I paid when ordering online. When she brought the order, I asked if there was fork and knife in the bag. This really threw her off for some reason. She didn't answer, started walking back to kitchen, paused to shoot me another completely puzzled look. She came back with a fork. "No knife?""No" was reply. I said "that's weird", and got nothing but the same confused look. Ordered pick up to take to a hotel room with no cutlery and had a salad in order. Just odd, very odd. read more

See Greeks/Pizza Forum reviews for my recap on their food. This location is nicely located on the Auburn town square. We were here for a car show and decided to get a pizza to go instead of fair food. The facility is spacious and in decent repair for an older building. Not much has been done to marry the pizza fare with a historic building. The team seemed a bit unorganized. However there was a lot of customers and chaos going on outside. We had the garden supreme pizza. Still one of my favorite combinations of crust, sauce and toppings. read more

Good pizza nice people and great service. We've ordered takeout from here several times and never been disappointed.

Very good pizza and some of the best breadsticks drowning in garlic butter you can find.

In a non-Covid world I'd give 5 stars but with current circumstances I'm giving 3. Pizza was great, servers were nice and order was ready in time frame given. Unfortunately, not a single employee was wearing a mask. This area has a weird mix of nearly all wearing mask (Kroger) and nobody wearing one (Pizza Forum). read more

My coworker and I were working in Aurburn for three days, and a local resident pointed us toward Pizza Forum. What a great find! We ordered the Garden Special. It had several different kinds of veggies piled on it. So many veggies that it HAD to be healthy, right? : ) The crust and sauce were perfect. Both were unique, not what you would find at other pizza places. The garlic breadsticks were simply the best ever. My search for perfect breadsticks is over. There is no way that there could be better breadsticks anywhere Soooo delicious, and drenched with garlic butter. I confess, we loved it so much the first night that we came back the very next day to try a different pizza and appetizers. Looking forward to my next trip to Auburn...... read more

Great Pizza! The sauce is sweet, and the crust is good as well. Breadsticks were fantastic. They had a $6 special for a 9" pizza with a soft drink. Would recommend. read more

Pizza Forum - two hot dogs in a basket - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, Indiana

See all

My goodness they Stromboli was a gift from the gods. It's not huge but bread was perfectly crispy and the Italian sausage was awesome. Garlic breadsticks were exactly that. Awesome garlic butter. It'll take a shower to get the smell off your fingers. I could repeat that meal many days a week. read more

Best pizza! Fresh ingredients and awesome crust. Ate here twice in one week because it's so good. Garden supreme is excellent and so is the Roma! read more

Pizza was good. But it looked like they hurried when they made it. Pepperoni was tossed in clumps on the pizza and not much cheese. Got a salad that included a hard boiled egg in it. Egg was like an after thought and throw in corner of container whole. Glad i ate a piece of pizza first as when I cut into the egg, it was rotten. Horrible surfer smell came from the egg and ruined the salad and my appetite. read more

Pizza 5 stars; gyro 1 star (avoid it), breadsticks - mixed reviews maybe 2? The breadstick was good because it was homemade but the 2/3 cup of melted butter flavor oil wasn't ideal in the bottom of the basket. The order of six breadsticks didn't need to be drowned. We got cheese to dip them and that too was a mistake as it was nacho cheese. Pizza was great, the crust was really good. The gyro meat was cold and crusty. Almost like they heated it up in the microwave too long. It was dried out and super thin. Probably the worst gyro I've ever had. We also ordered the Saturday pasta special which was pasta with meatballs. The sauce was good but I think there may have been 2 meatballs. Should I come back, we'll stick to pizza only. There was one waitress and one guy bussing tables. He seemed mad that he was working. The place was super busy when we got there at 7pm. We waited for the busser to clean the table and when he finished he pointed to it when he caught my eye. He also didn't speak when dropping off a box. It's a Greek Pizza place that's what I ordered a gyro. My daughter said that there were no towels in the bathroom. Overall I was disappointed. read more

See all

One of the best pizza places in my small town. Employees are super awesome and the pizza is amazing.

Everytime I've ate here, I have never had a round pizza. Always oddly shaped and just thrown together. Hire a cook who actually cares!

The Pizza is awesome. Their sauce is different than ANYONE else's. Also, their breadsticks are AMAZING, but they have made them smaller recently. Bummer. The service is hit and miss. Definitely has a small town feel. But we will be back. read more

Super product but service is slower than homemade molasses. Their cheese blend is the best. I was introduced to greek's pizzeria during my old BSU days. read more

This is the closest to Greek/Chicago fusion pizza in this part of Auburn, and they have done a sincere-and effective-reproduction of the excellent fare in Chicago. I like it. I ordered a large with basic pepperoni for way less than I could have in an average city. And it fed two adults and 2 young children. The sub-style of this pizza is alike to Giordanos in Indy, not Lou Malnatis or Unos, if you have tried these Chicago pizza chains. This means the sauce is flavorful, slightly sweet, and doesn't have chunks of tomatoes in it. I actually prefer no chunks in the sauce, so it was perfect for me. It was so good; a picky six year old daughter just spooned the sauce off the top and ate it direct, much how she does frosting off a cupcake, to my dismay. The crust is dense, like a pie crust, not "bready" like a standard chain. It's buttery and flavorful. This one was cooked a little too much, hence 4 stars, but almost good enough to be five. The service was terrific. read more

The food here is amazing but I highly recommend eating in the restaurant!! We have tried the delivery 3 times now and have had to wait 1 1/2 hours for delivery from auburn to Garrett approx. 4 miles. By the time your food gets to you it's cold!! I love the pizza and the sandwiches and shells. But pry will not order again due to the poor delivery!! Mind you I had to call them 3 times and was always told it's on the way.. read more

Food was very good at lunchtime. Service is not the best. Friendly but forgetful. Maybe needs more help . Good lunchtime spot .

This place is awesome! Pepperoni bread to start, 2 different pizzas and a Parmesan chicken sandwich. All were spectacular! Great service! Definitely be back! read more

Great place, friendly & courteous. Clean with good food I would recommend this to anyone for a quick hearty bite.

Good pizza and great service! Prices are a bit steep but worth it for the food. Great atmosphere, very relaxed environment.

Great place for a pizza. They make their own sauce and bread. There are great daily specials. The service is prompt and attentive. One of my favorite local eats. read more

Great pizza. Ordered by phone, was ready on time an excellent. Old style pizza,obviously prepared on-site from fresh ingredients.

My wife and I live 60 miles from here and every time we are close we stop it's always excellent hot wings and pizza try the wing pizza I don't know how you could hate it read more

Yum! Found this place thru Yelp while on a road trip. Not fancy - lots of locals and kids playing arcade games, older folks out on a Friday night. Had the BBQ chicken pizza - Delish. Really wonderful crust. Reasonable price, food worth a longer wait than fast food. read more

the pizza came with no sauce and then the waitress was being rude when we asked her questions about the sauce and wouldnt give us any

Food was mediocre, the waitress was unfriendly to the point of being rude. The busboy was the only employee that was pleasant and did a good job. Been there 2 times and the service was the same both times. Doubt I will be going back read more

One of my favorite pizza places in town. My family and I always order the same combination when we come here: an XL pizza forum special and a cheese pizza with extra cheese. Their pizza forum special is hands down one of my favorite deluxe pizzas around. Mushrooms, green bell pepper, onion, pepperoni, and sausage. Yum. Honestly, their crust and sauce are what make their pizzas stand out. The crust is obviously brushed with a garlic butter sauce, so it tastes amazing. I really like this location's atmosphere. Their are wooden booths as well as open seating and bar stool chairs in the back. The only complaint I have are the prices. Pizza forum is kinda expensive. Two XL pizzas (one being a deluxe) is usually around $40. Still, they have daily specials so you can get a good deal depending on the day you go here. read more

The Pizza Forum in Kendallville is excellent, and so was this location when it first opened. The quality of the food has taken a turn for the worse. The white pizza is by far my fave. Unfortunately the last white pizza I received seemed to have more grease than cheese. Cutting back on toppings to save some dough? read more