This was a delicious and memorable meal! The service was impeccable, the food was delicious, the room was gorgeous, and the unique touches were clever. Choosing your steak knife was fun and unexpected; the drinks had distinctive ingredients; the staff was knowledgeable , kind, and friendly. Highly recommend. read more

Carversteak - Three sauces - bernaise (the best), point Reyes blue cheese, bordelaise - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

(5/5) I stumbled upon Carver's Steak thanks to a special offer through the InKind app, and what I expected to be a quick catch up over drinks turned into one of the most memorable hospitality experiences I've had in New York. It was pouring rain when we arrived, and before anything else, Jasmine greeted us with a warm smile and immediately offered a bag for my umbrella. It was such a small gesture, but it instantly made us feel welcome. Without a reservation, I assumed we'd be limited to the front dining area. Instead, we were led into a beautiful dining room tucked in the back with gorgeous lighting, artwork on the walls, and the perfect corner booth for two. Our server, Marie, was exceptional. She walked us through the menu, shared her genuine favorites, and never once pushed the most expensive items. It felt like getting recommendations from a friend rather than a sales pitch. We started with the martini flight, another cocktail, the small seafood tower, Wagyu skewers, and six oysters. The warm bread that followed was the perfect addition, and everything we ordered was delicious. Just when we were debating whether to order another drink or dessert, Brandi stopped by and asked if we enjoyed bourbon. Minutes later, she was tableside crafting an Old Fashioned from a beautiful cocktail cart. It was completely unexpected and made the evening feel even more special. As we were wrapping up, the team mentioned that the restaurant was part of a larger space and invited us to explore. We wandered upstairs and discovered an incredible collection of Broadway memorabilia, a live music venue, and even a private room filled with theater history. Then we made our way to the rooftop, where Willie welcomed us and showed us around. The views overlooking the Hudson River alone are worth the visit. What started as a casual girls' night became an experience we'll both remember. A heartfelt thank you to Jasmine for the warm welcome, Marie for outstanding service, Brandi for the unforgettable tableside cocktail, and Willie for making us feel like returning guests before we'd even left. Five stars without hesitation. No notes. I cannot wait to come back and introduce more friends to Carver's Steak. read more

See all

A recent evening at Carversteak was thoroughly enjoyable. The room has great energy -- lively atmosphere, good music -- and our server Mark was attentive and excellent throughout. The food was strong overall. Here's the breakdown: Excellent: The seared crab cake, wagyu beef skewers, and beet salad were all standouts. Honestly, those three dishes at the bar with one of their martinis might be the perfect night on its own. Very Good: The 8 oz filet mignon, branzino, and caviar potato popsicles all delivered. The popsicles were enjoyable, though at $48 they're more of a treat when someone else is picking up the tab. Needs Work: The Baked NYC dessert was the one clear miss. The Swiss meringue should be warm, crispy, and airy -- ours arrived cold and dense. A shame, because the strawberry pour-over and presentation were excellent. read more

Booked Saturday dinner here while in city for a long weekend. This is a newer steakhouse but for me - I have this ranked higher than several other places we have been to. All due respect, I think this is better than Sparks and Keens, both of which I found horrendously overrated. Anyway - We were sat in the atrium and had a younger guy - taller and bigger as our waiter. Started off with a standard old-fashioned rather than the table side old fashioned experience they provide upon request. It was good - made with Woodford. We went with splitting a caesar salad and the cheesesteak sliders as our starters. The caesar was standard but still very good. The Wagyu cheesesteak bites were.. INCREDIBLE. Reminded me of a comfort food and a mix between French onion soup and cheesesteak. Succulent meat, perfect cheese sauce and just a great item you have to try. For my entree I went with the filet medium. We shared mac and cheese and broccolini as sides and also got the sauce flight with bernaise, bourbon peppercorn and blue cheese sauce. All three were great. As dessert I went with the chocolate cake which was massive and very rich. Dark lighting, loud music and subtle comfort - an elegant looking place and the food backed up the fanciness. Well done. read more

See all

Overall was good but quite expensive. Shrimp Cocktail was delish. Sadly our Ribeye Cap was overcooked. Martini was said to be the coldest! read more

See all

Carversteak just opened a month ago and I'm so happy it's here. The ambiance, the service, and the food were all amazing. They start with bringing out some pretzel loaf broad with a dijon mustard butter. The bread was soft and warm, and paired perfectly with the butter. For an appetizer, we had a Thai chili hamachi that they poured fresh coconut milk over when they served it. The flavor of the coconut milk mixed with the yellowtail was amazing. I had a 22oz ribeye for dinner and it was prepared perfectly. We also ordered four sides (asparagus, mac & cheese, potato puree, french fries) and I can't call one out that was best, we enjoyed them all. Before your steak arrives, they bring out a set of knives for you to choose from. I chose a beautiful damascus steel knife. Overall it was an amazing experience! read more

See all

Amazing new addition to midtown - finally good martinis in the area! Happy to find it.

not just dinner... a full NYC steakhouse experience the Old Fashioned cart rolls up tableside (and yes, it's a whole moment), the espresso martini = divine, and the steak? cooked to a perfect medium rare that melts in your mouth add in whipped mashed potatoes, jumbo shrimp that did not miss, and that unmistakable Theater District energy... it's giving classic New York with a modern glow-up brand new since March and already making their mark -- this is one you're gonna want on your list Service was also top tier. read more

See all

Ambiance was 10/10 music was soulful at a decent sound level. Nicely decorated and we could read our menus without a flashlight. Service was good. Table side Old fashion cart over hyped however drinks were really good. The food it was plentiful but served room temperature and expensive! Soup was lukewarm and poured over into a cold bowl. read more

See all

Was excited to try Carversteak as we did like the previous restaurant Rosevale Kitchen which is attached to the Citizen Hotel. Love the bar there and the vibe. Super renovations made this space transform into a higher end feel. Women at the door were lovely when greeting us and we were off to a great start! Our server Dario I think was the top server there from what I saw. Super attentive, not pushy and upselling just truly wanted to offer a great experience. He guided us well and didn't rush us at all. We actually started with the Caesar salad and the mini waygu cheesesteaks before we even ordered our dinner. Both were very good. Those mini cheesesteaks are insanely delish. They have someone with a cart that offers a drink experience. She came over was very sweet but we decided to just order from the bartenders and not partake in the cart service. I do appreciate how she shared th prices, so ty for that!! For dinner we split a Mac and cheese and a Kansas City. Mac is super cheesy in a good way topped with breadcrumbs and steak was cooked absolutely perfect. Shockingly we ordered dessert as it we were celebrating the hubbs birthday. Do not leave without getting that chocolate cake. OMG. Highlights for sure were the top notch service by all but mostly Dario. We will absolutely be returning. Great experience. read more

See all

Great service and great comforting atmosphere. Not as a sexy and sophisticated look as the original location in Las Vegas but the quality still stands. The food was excellent and so were the drinks. Can't wait to come here again. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious! The branzino was light, flaky, and crisp on the outside. The wagu cheesesteak bites were delectable! read more

See all

Genuinely one of the best steakhouses we have ever gone to in NYC. Especially for the pricing. The Lovely Lady Martini I had was just the perfect mix of sweet, yet spirit forward, and the steaks just melted in your mouth. The service was amazing, specifically from our server Mark and the Manager Leroy. It was such a nice and cozy restaurant that was calming enough for us to enjoy our meal. This has definitely become a new special occasion spot, along with our Sunday date night list. read more

See all

This is a great venue to have a pre-broadway show dinner. It's only 6 minutes away from Broadway theaters and it's in a quiet neighborhood. The interior has a high ceiling, well-lit setting and spacious, unlike the steak houses in CA that are usually dark with low beam settings. I ordered from the pre-theater menu which was flavorful and delicious with nice presentation as well. My son ordered from the regular menu which he also enjoyed although they didn't bring his chimichurri as the sauce. We shared the appetizer and dessert that was included in my pre-show menu, good enough to share with another person and he also ordered a dessert that was shared. From beginning to end we enjoyed it all. Our drinks from zero-proof menu were also delicious. The staff were friendly and attentive especially Ali (not sure of the spelling) she made us feel special. She brought a case of steak knives to choose from for your dinner. That was awesome and a lovely treat. I greatly appreciate that touch. We will be back when we visit NYC again. You have to watch one of the Broadway shows whenever in town and have a lovely nice dinner before the show. read more

See all

I stopped in to Carversteak for a late night dinner. I cannot say that I am impressed as the yelp* community. The restaurant is very attractive, and the soundtrack very 80's. I began with a Lobster Bisque special. It was delicious. I ordered a Filet Mignon as my main. It was tasty, but very small. You'll have a choice of five different knives to cut your Steak. A bit too fussy for my taste. A glass of Sangiovese helped compliment my dinner. Bathrooms are located in the basement, and you'll need a road map to find them. My bill was larger than usual, and although it was a good experience, I don't think that I'll be returning. read more

Carversteak - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

An absolute 10/10 experience from start to finish. The ambiance is upscale yet inviting, the food is exceptional, and every detail is clearly intentional. A special thank you to Jon, the manager, who truly elevated the evening; his attentiveness, professionalism, and warm energy made us feel like VIPs. You can tell he genuinely cares about every guest's experience. Can't wait to come back! read more

Carversteak - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

The restaurant was amazing! The ambience, music, service and food. You'll get THE best wine and people in my group had old fashions made table side. Try the umi appetizer! To DIE for! My branzino was also superb. Expect to spend some money but the experience was worth it! read more

One of the best dining experiences in Manhattan! Service, ambiance, food, drinks, vibes were all OUT OF THIS WORLD! Their martini and old fashioned program is unmatched. It's not something to be skipped. The pretzel rolls automatically brought to the table really started the night off with a bang!! I was mistaken in thinking their vegan menu from another location was available, but they perfectly accommodated the dietary restrictions regardless and did so DELICIOUSLY! Counting down the days until we get to go back. read more

See all

When I head back to my homeland in London from the US I especially like to book a few of the nicest high end restaurants with friends. It's a special rare treat and don't care how much I spend, Usually £200 each or so, so probably even higher end than this place. They never make me feel like i don't belong which was the vibe I got from some of the Carversteak staff. I was dressed okay, linen shirt and shorts in this 100 degree heat. Others were dressed similarly to me and seemed to use fewer manners!! The food was stunning, crab cake and then a steak entree. I just felt looked down upon. I had a $100 food credit from the hotel that forms part of the building. So what would anyone do, you have a cocktail and a couple of courses in their nicest place to eat. At the end the waiter Ben could see I had just signed the receipt and was ready to leave but still said to me loudly "do you want me to apply your coupons" like he was shaming me for using them! I had tipped 25% of the full $102 check so I wasn't being cheap. I started to say as I always do "thank you for the nice service" and halfway through the sentence he had already walked away. read more

Amazing experience! Reese and Eric in particular were very welcoming and professional. Eric gave great recommendations while Reese showcased a fantastic old fashioned experience with a lovely personal touch! I also received one the best martinis I've ever had from Rebecca. Overall I HIGHLY recommend Carver thanks to its knowledgeable staff and classy ambiance. read more

My husband and I went to Carversteak to celebrate one of our anniversaries. I work relatively close but i had never her of the steak house because its brand new. However, this is NOT just a steakhouse, it's an actual experience - so much care and attention to detail was given to our time there. Jazz the Sommelier was friendly and very knowledgeable at wine suggestions (which were robust) and even offered us complimentary champagne to celebrate. Our server, Marie, was a STAR. Her energy and vast knowledge of the menu were impressive; we took almost all of her suggestions and were not disappointed. The meal was great, from the perfectly cooked T-bone steak to the off-menu warm cheesecake. They really make you feel special. Carver Steakhouse ALSO offers an Old Fashioned experience like I've never had before - Brandee was our mixology queen and created table-side service with the bourbon of our choice. Lastly, we were given a tour of the building, which includes a museum of Broadway paraphernalia and a BEAUTIFUL rooftop with the most epic NYC skyline views. There is a blue bourbon room and even a photobooth to capture the perfect memory. We would definitely return for a special occasion, and I can't wait to get my colleagues to the rooftop for a happy hour. Thanks for the experience Carversteak! read more

See all

OMG! Staff was top notch, bit shout out for Dario! The food was amazing! The manager Jon and Derek went to ask how was everything, they do really care about the experience, Thank you so so much! read more

Isabella took very good care of us. Best meal out I've ever had. KC strip was cooked perfectly and was delicious. Giardiera martini was exquisite. read more

Want an overall experience off Broadway that is better than many of the shows on Broadway? Not only is this restaurant beautiful, but the Dirty Experience is the best martini "display" in NYC! William the bartender put on a performance that was Tony award worthy! Their martini bar is beautiful, as are the choices of martinis from merely dirty to filthy and disgusting...plus a ton of different kinds of stuffed olives! And then there are the steaks...wow! 5 star! read more

I was really excited to try Carversteak NYC since it just recently opened, and it absolutely lived up to the hype. I went on a Friday night with my fiancé, and from start to finish, the experience was amazing. The service truly stood out, Alison (Allie) was incredibly kind, attentive, and knowledgeable. She gave great recommendations and made us feel genuinely welcomed throughout the night. At first glance, the space seems a bit small, but once you're inside, it opens up into something much more impressive. There are speakeasy-style areas, hidden details, and so many thoughtful touches that make the whole place feel unique and exciting. We honestly kept discovering new things as the night went on. Overall, it was an awesome experience. We'll definitely be back, especially to check out the cocktail bar and rooftop, which has an incredible, unobstructed sunset view. Highly recommend! read more

Make sure to ask for Brandi's Old Fashioned cart! Traditional and outstanding. Served with hospitality! read more

Carversteak - Old Fashioned - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

What an amazing experience! Best steakhouse in NY. The ambience is absolutely stunning. The drinks are top-notch. Make sure you request the table side Old Fashioned Cart. And the food is spectacular. Can't recommend this place enough. I'm definitely coming back. read more

Carversteak - Decadent chocolate cake - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Pretty place, mediocre food, overbearing, awkward waitstaff ... fine dining, if you consider it's Time Square, but certainly not anywhere else. read more

Possibly the worst service and meal in the Theater District in the last 30+ years. We arrived for a 6pm reservation a minute or two early. We were greeted by a hostess who had our table ready and asked if we had any time constraints. We explained we had an 8pm show a few minutes away. She said plenty of time. She didn't know how wrong she was. The waiter greeted us and asked what time we would like to leave for the theater. We responded 7:40. Be also said no problem. We waited 25 minutes for our drinks. 45 minutes for bread. We inquired numerous times about our appetizers but the response was the are expediting our food. After an hour and numerous complaints we cancelled our entrees and awaited our appetizers. Some of the appetizers arrived, they looked pleasing but they tasted average at best. The final appetizers finally arrived and were ice cold. How was this even possible??? The Manager offered to feed us dinner at 10:30 after our show and comped what we had eaten but honestly NYC has some of the best food in the world. There are dozens of fantastic restaurants in the theater district that have stood the test of time and deliver consistent food and service with a smile. Do yourself a favor if you're reading this review....choose someplace else. We left the restaurant and walked over to one of the pizza places in Times Square so we could eat before dinner. Really Really Really a terrible experience. I don't think this place will last in NYC. read more

Rebecca at the martini bar was the best. Great energy, super personable, and the Pepperoncini Papi martini was delicious. Such a fun vibe all around will definitely be back! read more

Met a friend who was In town for family reunion staying at the hotel and wow did we have such an awesome time! Rebecca or Becca our bartender gave great recommendations Crabcakes are phenomenal. Wagyu bites are melt in your mouth cocktails were delicious we had seriously had a blast!! New gem in the city can't wait to come back for the ribeye steak and Mac n cheese read more

The food is absolutely delicious. The ambience is sophisticated and sexy. The servers are knowledgeable about the menu, and make good suggestions. There is a sommelier as well who will recommend the perfect wine to accompany your meal. It's pricy, but you get what you pay for! read more

I was staying in the hotel next to this new steakhouse and wasn't sure what to expect. IT WAS FANTASTIC! The flavors were fantastically balanced and the cocktails and wines were delightfully curated and offered at the exact right times during my dinner. Both the seafood and steak were perfectly prepared and presented. read more