After years of being in the area for plays, shopping and university related stuff and not being able to get in due to the wait time not fitting our plans or schedule, we finally made a reservation online to have a meal at this legendary place. We showed up and the place was buzzing with a line out the door. I checked in at the podium and hostess said table will be ready in 5 minutes. 2 minutes later, we the hostess to our table. Looking around everything was the old classic/stereotypical ideas of a what a great steakhouse should be and it did not disappoint. Sal was our waiter, he was friendly, professional and one look we could tell we were in the more than capable hands and nothing would be amiss. He told us about the specials, lunch or dinner menu options. The other wait staff worked like a team that has been together for years, checking on everyone in our section, delivering our orders, refilling our glasses, answering questions, bussing our table everyone with smooth and practiced motions. 2 Caesar salads, 1 8 oz filet w/baked potato, 1 surf and turf w/broccoli everything cooked and presented to perfection. For dessert, the legendary cheesecake with coffee and the baked Alaska. It was the perfect ending to a great meal. In this restaurant the waiters make everyone feel important and special and maybe it's a little pricey but it's New York and they have been around for a really long time so they knew what they are doing and are doing it GREAT. read more

I don't believe that there is or could ever be a "perfect" steak. That being said, tonight I may have had the closest thing to a perfect stake. I first thought, "this is really good". Then it got more delicious the more I ate. But the "pièce de résistance" occurred when my daughter, who doesn't like steak tasted a bite a said, "I never knew steak could taste like that ". The crab cake and stuffed shrimp were very good also but not quite as good as the steak. The ambiance of the whole vibe reminds me of an old movie, where important people from all walks of life go to have a good meal. Our servers where top notch also, If I had to nitpick, I would confess the Mac & Cheese was a little dry and lacked flavor. Also the fries were a little over done but I came for the stake and I left a happy man. read more

See all

The filet mignon streak was great and perfectly seasoned. Got the baked potato that was cooked just right. Wife had the halibut nut felt it was a bit bland. The staff did an excellent job! Don't recommend the key lime pie it was a bit too tart. Overall we enjoyed our meal. read more

Had an exceptional experience at Gallagher's. Got lucky with a roomy spot at the bar and enjoyed a full dinner. I started with the Gorgonzola salad which was simple but perfect. Great vinaigrette dressing with healthy chunks of cheese. For the main intent with their signature Rib Steak and would say it is up there with the greats in the city. Perfectly cooked to medium rare with lots of earthy notes. I closed with the tiramisu which was large and tasty. A shout out to the bartender Stewart who was very friendly and made great recommendations. A top notch experience! read more

See all

This was such a wonderful meal. Perfectly old school NY. Our servers were amazing and have been working together here for over 20 years. Alberto was the epitome of a true gentleman and such a pleasure to interact with. The steak was outstanding as were the cocktails and wine. Just solid service, atmosphere, food.....everything! I would definitely come back here before a show because it's so convenient and worth every penny. read more

Valentine's dinner well done (or shall I say medium rare?)! We were seated promptly after coat check and started off with two delicious cocktails-- Sidecar and Ziegfeld Follies. For starters, we got the steak tartare and tuna poke. For main, we shared a porterhouse for two with a side of mac n cheese, followed by a decadent cheesecake. Steak tartare 4/5: creamy texture, smooth and paired with lightly toasted bread. I enjoyed each bite, savoring the hints of mustard and pickle. If you're a savory fan, you'll enjoy this. Spicy tuna poke 3/5: besides the wonton chips being delicious, the poke itself was ok. It was bland in flavor compared to the poke I usually eat on the west coast and found that the radish chunks were too big. The quality was fresh but I'd skip this next time. Porterhouse 5/5: we got a mixed cut of medium rare ribeye and filet mignon, which was such a splendid eat. The steak was cooked to perfection and came out on a hot plate. I liked that it wasn't salty at all and paired really nicely with their signature steak sauce (tomato based). It's a perfect portion for two people Mac n Cheese 4/5: nothing crazy but still delicious and classic. It's my go-to side dish for steak NY Cheesecake 5/5: i usually don't get cheesecake but this was great! Creamy smooth with a nice base. Imagine a soft graham cracker with a touch of cinnamon. It was paired with a decadent strawberry puree and overall not too sweet! read more

See all

Got the restaurant week menu: Manhattan clam chowder, sliced filet mignon and dessert for addition $4! The clam chowder was punchy and tangy. The filet mignon was soft and delicious although I wished for more, only 4 slices haha. The key lime pie was not my favorite, it was overly sweet. Service was attentive. The ambiance was sophisticated but not stuffy. Overall, this was a nice first experience at the steakhouse. read more

See all

I had dinner at Gallaghers last weekend before a show. Gallaghers is a classic, and now I know why. Gallaghers was opened by a Ziegfield dancer (Helen Gallagher) and a partner in 1927 as a speakeasy and steakhouse. I'm sure a lot has changed at Gallaghers in that almost 100 years, but it stills retains so much history and charm. The menu is classic, and I had a very hard time choosing what to order (the downside of a solo meal - you can't try as much). I ended up ordering their jumbo shrimp cocktail, the beefsteak tomato and onion salad, and their bone-in New York sirloin sliced. Everything was delicious. (One note: I like onion a sort of absurd amount. You know people who just can't abide raw onion? I'm not one of those people. While I love the idea, I'm not sure I get their tomato and onion salad. The two slices of white onion were a half-inch thick - just entirely too much raw onion to the amount of tomato. Even for this girl. Is it meant to be a salad? They bring it with dressing! Or are you supposed to eat it as a side with the steak? But it's not listed with the sides? I don't know. But it was the one bite that made me go "huh?" I didn't hate it, but I don't get it either.) I also had a martini, which went great with my meal. The service is just the best. It's a classy place (white tablecloths, uniformed servers), but the service lives up to the class of the place. The servers wheel carts around the restaurant like an elegant game of Tetris. And the ambiance is great, too. Gallaghers is a classic for a reason. I'll definitely be back. read more

See all

Gallaghers Steakhouse opened in 1927 on 52nd Street as a Prohibition-era speakeasy. After Prohibition ended in 1933, it became Broadway's first steakhouse. We went for my birthday. Started with the French onion soup. Our waiter kindly split one order into two bowls. Main was the 28-day dry aged porterhouse for two plus the charred crispy Brussels sprouts on the side. We finished with cheesecake and chocolate fudge cake. One of the best steakhouses in NYC. Classic vibe that's cozy and upscale, like Polo Bar but with a steak focus. Service was attentive and respectful from all staff members. read more

See all

My sister had been to this place once before, so we decided to come again on our last visit to New York. It was my first time. Service was good, a little bit slow. But that seemed to be the theme for this trip, lol. We ordered two steaks and I got the Ahi pepper steak. Everything was good! Since we were also celebrating my birthday, we ordered the Keylime pie. Which is my favorite. They also did bring out a little small something for my birthday. But they didn't offer that originally when we were deciding on dessert. Didn't really need both, but glad I got to try it. SYOY! read more

See all

I love me a great deal and gallaghers has one of the best lunch specials around. And the best part? If you are seated and ordered before 4pm repeat 4pm you can have the awesome deal! Their sliced filet is cooked perfectly with awesome flavor. The Manhattan clam chowder is just tasty. And the dessert is standard but a really good portion. I never had dinner here but im sure its awesome! read more

See all

Great restaurant Great food excellent service The restaurant was very busy but Sunday the hostess was extremely in control while staying on top of providing An excellent table for us and following up with us to make sure our experience was wonderful as we left the restaurant the atmosphere was very friendly Would highly recommend this restaurant read more

Came here for lunch after a morning at MOMA. Got the munch special with the Manhattan clam chowder, chopped filet mignon with mushroom sauce, and the NY cheesecake. I've never had Manhattan clam chowder but it was really good. The steak was ok, nothing special. The cheesecake was creamy and good. Overall not the best steak meal by any means, but for the price is absolutely worth it. read more

See all

Favorite steakhouse in NYC. I don't know where to start. The old school feel. The awesome service. The food. THAT steak sauce! Everything here is awesome. I make sure to make reservations every time I go as it does get packed. Coming here is always my favorite meal in the city. 3 of us came in on Monday night, my table all had filets, medium/medium rare and they were cooked perfect. Calamari to start. Mac and cheese, sautéed mushrooms and mashed potatoes as our sides - all delicious. And that steak sauce, I don't know what they put in it, but I need it bottled up and shipped to me! I'm not usually one to use sauce with my steaks, but that stuff is GOOD. I will eat every last drop. Thanks for another great dinner, til next time! read more

See all

If you want to feel the pulse of Old New York, you go to Gallaghers. Established in 1927 by former Ziegfeld girl Helen Gallagher and Jack Solomon, it started as a Prohibition-era speakeasy. Even after transitioning into a legendary steakhouse, it has kept that "Runyonesque" charm, with wood-paneled walls and red-checkered tablecloths that have hosted everyone from Babe Ruth to Frank Sinatra. The Highlights: The Hickory Grill: Gallaghers is one of the few places left in the city that still grills over hickory logs rather than gas broilers. You can smell that deep, smoky aroma the moment you walk past the glass-encased meat locker on 52nd Street. The Prime Rib: While the New York Strip is their "claim to fame," the Roast Prime Rib is a massive, melt-in-your-mouth masterpiece. It's thick-cut, perfectly marbled, and served with just enough jus to let the dry-aged beef shine. Jumbo Shrimp: Whether you get the classic Shrimp Cocktail or the Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp (packed with crab meat and finished with mustard butter), the seafood here is world-class. The shrimp are consistently snappy, fresh, and large enough to require a knife and fork. A Touch of History: The walls are practically a photography museum. Keep an eye out for the photo of Jackie Kennedy (Jackie Onassis); she was a frequent guest, often seen dining here alongside other 20th-century icons. It's the kind of place where you aren't just eating a meal--you're sitting in the same booths where Broadway history was made. Pro Tip: Even though it's a high-end steakhouse, their 3-course lunch special is one of the best "bang-for-your-buck" deals in Midtown. It's a great way to experience the history without the full dinner price tag. read more

See all

Food: My niece and I went to Gallagher's for lunch during the height of the NYC holiday season. Every table was booked so be sure to RSVP in advance! We both loved our $39 three course lunch meal: filet mignon, fingerling potatoes, in a mushroom in wine sauce. Plus Brussels sprouts to share. We both had the cesaer salad appetizer. I finished with the creamiest cheesecake ever and she had the creamiest/richest ice cream! The food was excellent and well priced. The most important thing, however, is that you definitely try the dense brown bread that is served before your meal. It is a date, walnut bread that will knock your socks off! Service: This first thing I noted was that our hostess pulled out our table when she brought us over. This was such a nice touch so you don't have to worry about squeezing in sideways while others are seated beside you. I also noted that my custom Gallagher's steak knife was warm. That was neat! We were tag teamed by two waiters. Harry was our main waiter and he was quite friendly and attentive, also doling out sightseeing recommendations. Our food was well timed and without delay. Gallagher's knows how to handle a full house. Ambience: Music was playing in the background and it wasn't too loud. I wish we had time peruse the old time pictures on the walls of famous actors and the like. We overheard a conversation at the table next to us and actors like George Clooney on Broadway frequent Gallagher's. And recently the three actors from the play, Art, were in: James Corden, Neil Patrick Harris, and Bobby Cannavale. So prepare to be star struck! read more

See all

Two Broadway shows and two classic NY steakhouses in one day. These are the kind of experiences that make early morning gym visits and vacation savings funds worth it. Because it was not even noon and we had a 1pm show to catch, my +1 and I kept it (relatively) light with a wedge salad, a half dozen oysters, bread and butter service, along with a martini. Though I was jealous of the gentleman sitting next to us at the bar enjoying a steak salad with onion rings on top. The timing on everything was perfect, and we made it across the street to the August Wilson theater with time to grab some M&M's before the show began. Next time, I plan on having the Gallagher's dinner experience. read more

Came here for an early date night dinner before heading to see a play. Gallaghers' greets you with a tantalizing display of various cuts of meat viewable from the entryway while waiting for your table or coatcheck and has the classic steakhouse atmosphere. We sat in the rear dining room with views into the kitchen where it was clear that the staff hustled through the early dinner rush. We enjoyed two rounds of wine and cocktails with our meal and enjoyed the fried calamari appetizer special. The calamari was perfectly crispy and salty (tentacles included) and served with a smooth tangy tomato sauce. The porterhouse for two was a perfectly cooked and solid portion for us and paired perfectly with the buttery, velvety mashed potatoes and crispy savory brussels sprouts. The peppercorn crust and au poivre sauce were also delicious but the real star condiment was the house steak sauce - I would've easily bought a bottle of it to enjoy at home. Our servers timed our ordering and meals perfectly and were the perfect facilitators of our meal. I could see them hustling through the bustling dining area but didn't feel like we were neglected at all. Would definitely recommend for a night out or special occasion. read more

Gallaghers Steakhouse - Porterhouse for two, Mashed Potatoes, Brussels Sprouts - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

We had lunch last Saturday at Gallaghers for the first time. The restaurant was very busy at around 2 pm when we arrived. We ordered the prix fix menu with the 8oz fillet mignon which had at a $22 supplement for each steak we had. Considering the amount of food we decided to leave a good amount of the fillet steak to be taken home to enjoy the next day. We told waiter we wanted to take the steak and bread home and he understood. Two containers came back so we assumed one was bread and the other was the steak. When we opened the containers the next day there were a few slices of bread in each of the containers.... No steak to be found. In all our years of taking home leftovers this has never happened to us. Considering the amount and cost of the steak we feel this issue should be addressed and others going to the restaurant should be aware of this! read more

It had been a while since I went to a steakhouse before going to Gallagher's, and honestly it kinda reinforced what I thought. Perhaps it is hubris, but I feel like grilling a steak at home (reverse sear) is going to yield similar results to a steakhouse if you invest in the quality of the meat - probably because a $75 steak at a steakhouse is probably only $25? of actual steak, while cooking a $75 steak at home means you can get a much better cut. We ordered a filet mignon and a dry aged New York sirloin. I ordered my New York sirloin medium rare, but it came out pretty much medium well. It was a thick cut and wasn't cooked super evenly, so some bites came out very chewy, and the middle was medium at best. It feels like the steak was overcooked and too chewy, and some of the fat wasn't properly rendered. Also, the dry aged taste was too overpowering - I've had dry aged steaks before but this was on the stronger side of the nuttiness. Overall I came away thinking that I could really have cooked a better steak. The filet mignon was solid, but overall not super impressed by the spot. It probably didn't help that service was rushed and our seats were cramped. We had to move our tables any time our neighbors wanted to get out of their seats, and vice versa. Probably wouldn't come back, don't think it's worth it. read more

Gallaghers Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

I've walked by this place for decades, and always said to myself "one day...I'll go". Well that day came. A casual lunch with co-workers, during restaurant week, seemed like the perfect time to go. Place was quite busy, and has that old school charm. Big bar, all types of pictures on the walls, red leather seats. I was even asked to remove my winter hat, while I was seated. I really appreciated that. Chivalry is not totally dead. The 4 of us decided on the Restaurant Week / Lunch Special for $34.00 {See Picture} Choice of 4 apps, 3 entrees (unless you wanted to pay $22.00 more, for the other 2 options), 3 desserts. To start: 2 Manhattan Clam Chowders - It was ok. Needed more clams. Soup of The Day - Beef Barley. Looked and smelled great, and the saddest Caesar Salad I've ever seen. Very small in size, that appeared to be the last serving in the bowl. Old lettuce that was turning red, and just thrown on the plate. Actually, every Caesar that went by on the serving cart looked just as bad. We all had the Sliced Filet as our main. It was ok. About 4 bites of meat, with a bunch of flattened potatoes, giant chunks of onion and wilted watercress as a garnish. The steak sauce saved the meal as best it could. Desserts were fine. Maybe the meal would have been better had we ordered something from the regular menu. Maybe it was an off day. Maybe coming back for dinner would be a better experience. Maybe..we'll see. read more

See all

To start, we shared the Beef Carpaccio, Burrata & Coal-Fired Peppers, and Lobster Cocktail. They were all delicious. For our main, we did the Porterhouse for 3 to split between 3 of us. This was crazy amount of meat for the amount of people. The server was able to have half rare and half medium rare, which was appreciated - both cooked perfectly. On the side, we split the Mac & Cheese and Brussel Sprouts which were tasty. I am usually not a dessert person, but I saw a Banana Split on the menu and had to try it. It was so delicious, one of the best I've had! This was a great choice to celebrate my boyfriends birthday and cap off our time in NYC. read more

See all

I am not a big steak person but for Gallaghers I will be! This is the classic, modern New York City Staple. Full of class and professionalism. Clean, intentional and beautifully decorated. I am so happy that I gave this place a try because it was better than I was told. The steak as well as everything else was cooked to perfection. I was also surprised by the taste because I expected it to taste like other restaurants but nothing about this place is like others. It is unique it every way and if you come here you will notice it automatically. Any steak lovers need to run here immediately. This place is great for dates, family gatherings and celebrations. 10/10. read more

See all

Classic NY steakhouse! Came here for dinner with a friend. Terrific setting, old style walls filled with pictures of the famous and infamous as well as others... Solid service with attention to detail and comfortable, not pressured or hurried. We had lots to catch up about so it was nice to have a leisurely dinner We started with a shrimp cocktail and a shared beet salad. Shrimp was solid, and accompanied by great cocktail sauce as well as horseradish sauce. Love that combo. Beet salad was shared and was ample. Pickled beets with a vinaigrette dressing and arugula with shredded goat cheese. Worked perfectly . Entree was porterhouse for 2. Nice and juicy, it was the perfect size. Cooked perfectly at medium rare. Baked potatoes and creamed spinach rounded out the meal. Nice size potatoes and large helping of spinach. Even took some home Key lime pie was the dessert. A little too sweet for me but I did have some and it was delicious I highly recommend this place!! read more

See all

Fine dining at its finest. Very classy, great service, expensive BUT worth it. Came here after seeing The Great Gatsby (around the corner) The starters - the calamari was nothing special, but it WAS one of the specials of the day they were having so I decided to get it. 8/10 you can get it, but I wouldn't recommend. Entree - New York sirloin was a GREAT cut of meat. I really enjoyed the meal, I almost finished it in one seating but I had to stop myself haha 10/10 recommend! Sides - creamed spinach, skip it. Nothing creamy about it to me, almost tasteless. 4/10 wouldn't recommend. The onion rings perfect sizing, the crunch, the amount 10/10 I thoroughly enjoyed this and would recommend. Overall 8/10 experience, I would come back for sure and try some new items but would repeat some (onion rings lol) read more

See all

This is my first time coming here. We came here Sunday afternoon and it was pretty packed. We decided to get the lunch special ($34) and added the 8oz filet mignon which is an extra $22, which I feel was worth it since you also get side of mash potatoes, cream spinach, appetizer and dessert. Everything was delicious, the char on the steak was excellent. Service was good, the waiter was very attentive and you also get complimentary bread. Overall would come back for special occasions. read more

See all

If you are visiting NY, this is a 10/10 MUST TRY. You'll be coming back for an annual visit just to taste this high quality meat. Their signature steak sauce is incredible, and pairs so well with their fresh salads and vegetable sides. Right outside of Times Square, but has a precious hole-in-the-wall feel. The walls are covered in history and the wait staff is happy to share suggestions to make your night a true culinary experience. If you're trying to decide between options- just stroll on over to Gallaghers, you won't regret it! read more

See all

I am not a huge steak person to start, but Gallaghers was pretty good. The vibes were spectacular and the service was great. The portion sizes were huge. For appetizers, we got the tartare, french onion soup, and baked clams. We also got the seafood tower and everything was fresh and delicious. I thought the steak would have more flavor, but it was perfectly cooked and delicious. read more

See all

Been hearing "Gallaghers is the place to go for the meats" and finally decided to check it out. Came for a family celebration, upon entering, the decor is captivating, the service was on point as well. We got multiple dishes to try, my favorite was the porterhouse and the rib steak, cooked to perfection!. Personally I'm not a fan of creamed spinach but not I think I am, simply delicious, the price is slightly high, but the quality of the food does this justice. Highly recommend if the meat cravings arise, swing by and get your fill. read more

See all

I made a reservation for two a few weeks in advance, but when we arrived it actually wasn't too busy, so you could probably walk in without one depending on the night. The service was fantastic from start to finish. Everyone we interacted with was friendly, attentive, and really knowledgeable. They walked us through the specials of the day and gave some great recommendations, which we appreciated since we were trying to keep it "light" before heading to a show right after dinner. We ended up ordering the porterhouse for two, rare, and it was cooked perfectly juicy, flavorful, and more than enough food. Honestly, I was struggling to finish my half near the end because the portion was so generous. For sides, we went with broccoli rabe, corn, and their seasonal heirloom tomato summer salad. The salad was a standout! Fresh tomatoes, watermelon, and onion together made for a refreshing mix that balanced out the richness of the steak. Overall, Gallagher's really lived up to its reputation. It's a classic steakhouse that's clearly been around for a long time for good reason. The food, service, and atmosphere all came together to make it a memorable experience. Highly recommend if you're looking for a true New York steakhouse! read more

See all

NYC STEAKHOUSE TOUR (3nd Stop) . . We could not missed to have dined at Gallagher's--nestled in Midtown just steps from Times Square and Broadway--. This place it's exactly the kind of place you want for a special night in NYC. As soon as you walk in, you're immersed in Old New York nostalgia. Rich, dark wood paneling, white tablecloths, leather chairs, and walls line with photos of celebrities, athletes, boxers, and Broadway legends--plus the iconic glass-front meat locker where beef dry-ages in full view--make you feel like you've stepped into a storied piece of theater-district history. The dining room hums with mellow energy--jazzy Sinatra and Michael Bublé music drifts through the air while friendly staff deliver professional, warm service with just enough wit and anticipation. The Staff was knowledgeable, attentive, and genuinely hospitable. As an example, our server Alberto greeted us immediately after we were seated and remained in contact connection with us for the duration of the experience. Alberto has been working in Gallaghers for over 40 years. I tried the Prime Rib. For something different, you can't go wrong. The prime rib, often described as one of the best in NYC, comes with jus and horseradish cream, while the rib steak delivers smoky, savory perfection. The ambiance is storied and vibrant--classic New York meets lively sophistication. Whether you're seated in the main dining room or at the bar, the environment is refined yet welcoming. The main caveat: it's on the pricey side. Expect generous portions and impeccable quality, but prepare for a higher-end bill. That said, the experience--food, service, atmosphere--is well worth the splurge. I recommend Gallagher's for anyone who values good steak in a setting steeped in Broadway-era elegance. It's an ideal spot or pre-theater indulgence. Just know you're paying for more than a meal--you're paying for a quintessential slice of NYC dining history. read more

See all

My son and I went here on a mom/son date before a Broadway show. I wanted somewhere close to Broadway without being a tourist trap. We hit the nail on the head. The ambiance was special and I loved the white coats on the bartenders. It was super cool seeing the cuts of meat at the front of the restaurant. Our server was attentive and kind. It felt like he knew it was a special night and treated us as such. The food was just as expected...delicious. We probably ordered a little too much but YOLO! Would definitely go back! read more

See all

Amazing experience! We took our son and fiance after the Rockette show. We were there for lunch. We arrived a bit early and they accommodated us. It's a cozy vibe with a beautiful bar and the set up is great. Thank you to the hostess for the great table. Our waiter Harry was fabulous that I went back to tell him how nice he was after we were finished. The lunch special cannot be beat. My future daughter in law and I both did the special ( $34 for 3 courses) and it was delish! My Hubs and son did the steak for two with sides. The oysters were so good. All around amazing. We can't wait to go back. CHEERS! read more

See all

Visiting the city and trying to see as much as possible can be hard work. With checking Times Square off the list there came an opportunity to try Gallaghers Steakhouse. While certainly not your new modern steakhouse this place has been around for years and I know why. They do a good job at making food. The service is quick and in some ways quicker than I like. Most likely from being near Times Square and Broadway, they are used to needing to get people out in a hurry. As you can imagine this place has an old school vibe and they just do it right. The bread service was good and the date nut bread while not anything im looking for is original and different from your standard breads. We all shared a wedge salad with juicy plump tomatoes and a light blue cheese dressing. Perfect size for four to share. My friend saw clams casino on the menu and immediately said, we are getting that. I had never had it before but would definitely try it again. They were delicious. We got a shrimp cocktail and a New England clam chowder because you can't get that just anywhere. I almost forgot to tell you about the bartenders magic on my manhattans. Perfection in a glass. The mains were an 8oz and 14oz filet. The rib steak, which was a giant ribeye and a seared tuna steak. All cooked very well but honestly lacked that punch of flavor aka seasoning. I am not one to add sauce to a steak but my filet could've used a little pick me up. The food was all prepared to the exact requested temperature which is a win. The side were creamed spinach that was so good and not too creamy. Grilled onions and broccoli rabe, because you can't get that everywhere. Finished off the meal with an absolute highlight. The NY Cheesecake. It was light and fluffy not dense and creamy. After a big meal it was a perfect end. To be so close to a tourist spot like Times Square you would think each restaurant would mail it in. But Gallaghers has been there for this long for a reason. read more

See all

Made a reservation for 9:00 pm and was quickly seated. I'd say make a reservation because it was packed when i went. Waiters were great 5/5 Food 3-3.5/5 Ambiance 4/5 We ordered: Bacon Clams casino Salmon tartare Porterhouse for 2 medium rare Mashed potatoes Creamed spinach Mac and cheese I do want to give a higher rating but need to be true to my rating. I've been to many steakhouses and i would recommend this one to at least try for the experience but i wouldn't go back again. Bacon is good if you're into a little kick of spice Salmon was too fishy for me but still good Clams wasn't as flavorful as i thought Porterhouse was pretty good and good portion The sides made up for the appetizers Since it was late and super full, the desserts i didn't try. The pricing is not as bad comparing to other steakhouses. read more

See all

I absolutely loved my experience here and I highly recommend this place to anyone. I brought my husband here for his birthday and the food was absolutely delicious. I got the filet mignon and he got the lamb and they were both so tender. The service was really great service and the environment was really great for a date night. Their cappuccino was also delish. read more

Really good 3 course lunch special for $34 where you get an appetizer, an entree, and dessert. The establishment was nicely decorated and I loved the vibes in there. Food was good with really nice presentation. Service was fast and our food arrived pretty quickly. The staffs were attentive and made sure we have everything we need to have an enjoyable dining experience. Highly recommend checking this place out! read more

See all

As a long time New Yorker I rediscovered Gallaghers. Great service. My lemoncello martini was fantastic as temps outside was 95+. Ribeye, bacon 1 inch thick were show stoppers. Well done! read more

See all

Excellent rib eye, they call it a rib steak. Aged, I don't need to say anything more. No sides, no appetizers, no bread, just the steak...and a glass of a nice cab. I'm dreaming about that steak. read more

See all

Haven't been to Gallagher in a while and it did not disappoint me. When you walk in you are greeted with a friendly " can we help you?" The ambiance is very well set up, displaying their aged meat so you can see it, along with white tablecloths, and large cotton napkins. Their staff are all in uniform, clean and white. They are trained to service you the proper way and not to interfere with your privacy. They bring the food out in rolling carts and know exactly who gets what with no errors. We ordered the lunch special since we were going to a show afterwards and I had the turkey club that was filled with turkey, lettuce and tomato, along with fresh avocado and Brie cheese on the most delicious bread filled with cranberries and walnuts. When ordering they reminded you they had nuts in it. My husband had the special and started off with a wedge salad, sliced filet mignon with mushrooms and potatoes and New York cheesecake. A wonderful experience and most enjoyable read more

See all