My company hosted a dinner for 24 at Carmine's in Times Square. The meal was delicious, in spite of being known as touristy. This is the best location and the restaurant is buzzing! It's loud but exciting and very NYC. The portions are gigantic. I pre-ordered our dinner and I think next time I would skip the appetizer. The Cesare Salad was everyone's favorite. The penne bolognese, rigatoni ala vodka and the chicken parmigiana (favorite), were all great. Order the cannoli's and tiramisu! Excellent for a hungry group. read more

Our family had such a magical time attending The Grandest Princess Ball Ever at Carmine's! We dressed our daughter as Princess Anna from Frozen, and she absolutely stole the show. From the moment we arrived, the atmosphere felt so special and full of excitement for the kids. The event itself was beautiful. The princesses were wonderful with the children, and everyone had the chance to dance, sing along, and even create Mother's Day cards together. Watching our daughter light up while interacting with the princesses truly made the day unforgettable. The desserts included with the tickets were mediocre. The entire experience created such sweet family memories that we'll cherish for a long time. We also decided to purchase the hot buffet, which included Caesar salad, mixed salad, penne alla vodka, penne with garlic & oil, chicken parm, chicken cutlet, meatballs, and sausage & peppers. The food overall was good, and there were plenty of options for everyone. The kids' drinks were complimentary, while alcohol was a separate charge. Our little princess loved her Shirley Temple with extra cherries, and I really enjoyed my Jameson and ginger ale. The Caesar salad was especially good with their homemade dressing, and the huge croutons definitely made an impression. Maybe a little over the top, but still tasty! I ended up slicing the chicken cutlet into the Caesar salad, and it was honestly phenomenal together. The chicken cutlet itself was flavorful and one of our favorite items. The penne alla vodka was also very enjoyable. Unfortunately, the chicken parm was very dry and lacked flavor. We also skipped the meatballs after being told they contained pork. In hindsight, I probably should have looked up the ingredients beforehand, but we decided to pass on them. The only downside of the experience was a misunderstanding regarding the buffet. I was approached by a waitress asking whether we had already spoken to someone about eating. I initially thought the buffet was included with our event tickets, but apparently it was separate. I must have missed that information pw, so I ended up purchasing meal tickets for my family on the spot. I just wish the interaction had been handled a little more warmly and clearly. Aside from that small issue, we genuinely had a wonderful time. The event was beautifully organized and full of joy, music, laughter, and magical moments for families. Seeing our daughter so happy made everything worth it, and it turned into such a memorable Mother's Day celebration for us all. read more

See all

The service at Carmines is impeccable! Carmines especially this location in Times Square gets busy so we made a reservation before hand. We were running behind after watching a show on broadway, but called and they were able to hold our table for us. The portions are family style and decently priced especially for the location. Were ordered clams, seafood pasta and drinks. Everything was delicious! read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I mean, how can you not love Carmine's? This place is just so NYC silly in every way possible. One of us came here a few years back with her father before Phantom shut down (RIP!!!!!) and wanted to recreate the experience before the whole family went to Operation Mincemeat (don't bother--the current casting is terrible). It was Saturday night, and the place was packed. Like, PACKED. They even had a bouncer at the door preventing people from coming in unless they had a reservation, which, luckily, we did. One of us started with their frozen cosmo, and...so fun! So silly! Why not? It was so good! Our daughter will forever remember this place because we let her have a coca-cola for the first time in her life because she needed the caffeine to be able to stay up for the show. For food, we got the caesar salad, the chicken marsala, and the penne a la vodka. Portions for the salad and the pasta were indeed HUGE, but we'd say that the chicken was not piled as high, and we pretty much finished it. The food is not bad! It's not world-shattering, but considering the sheer quantity that is coming out of the kitchen, we do have to say that the quality is better than expected. We ate a good amount. One fun thing to note: there is a birthday celebration literally every five minutes here, so when we told our waitress that it was our daughter's birthday at the end of the month, she encouraged us to go for the song, and we did, and it tickled our kiddo pink. The tiramisu and the spumoni were OK...the latter definitely felt like it was something they got from a production facility elsewhere. Our waitress was really sweet, and we had a fun time. The whole scene was pure chaos but the restaurant also felt like everything was under control. Four stars, and we would definitely do it again as a pre-Broadway meal (but under no other circumstances). read more

WOW when they say family style and generous portions, they truly mean it!! I can't believe I haven't made my way to Carmine's yet as it is one of the NYC staple spots. The vibe is cozy, warm with the perfect touch of the hustle and bustle of the kitchen and bar. We intentionally knew we were ordering too much, but there were so many items we wanted to try, so we were happy to take back leftovers. We started off with drinks- I highly recommend the "hot and dirty" Pepperoncini martini (I got it with gin instead of vodka) so delicious and spicy! We ordered a few things including the garlic bread, caesar salad, penne vodka, veal marsala and chicken scarpariello. Despite being so crowded, service was friendly and prompt! We didn't have room for dessert, but I'm sure it would be delicious. read more

See all

Made reservations for 5:30pm, and the restaurant was already insanely packed! We waited about 20 minutes before being seated. Our waitress was incredibly kind and patient, explaining the dishes and even showing us pictures. We had 4 adults and 2 kids and still had leftovers. We ordered the fried calamari, white zuppa di mussels, Caesar salad, meatball pasta, and lasagna. Everything was delicious, though the meatball pasta was the least favorite. The lasagna was the clear standout--flavorful, filling, and something I'd happily reorder. And dipping the bread into the mussel broth was a 10/10! A busy, lively restaurant that I'd definitely recommend for groups. read more

See all

I made a reservation which is definitely recommended as it's located in the heart of Times Sq and and it's a popular restaurant amongst tourist and theatre goers. There's plenty of seating for 1 or more with bar seating available in addition to large tables. Wait staff was attentive. Explained the menu hadn't changed in YEARS but there was some added features as well. The dishes are family style so bring your appetite and some friends! read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

What a fun restaurant and close to Times square. It was packed on a Friday night, glad we made a reservation for 13 and they were able to accommodate us. There were large parties and a party going on, a murder mystery dinner with people dressed in outfits from the 1920s. The ambiance is great, cool chandelier lighting and old photos and plenty of nostalgia and history. Family style Italian food, you get plenty to eat. The staff was nice, quick, attentive, happy to take a group photo, and sing happy birthday and bring out a treat. We tried some of their bread, caprese salad, and another salad, calamari, clams, pasta, meatballs, a chicken dish, and a few other items. It was fantastic. Great food, great taste, but I did not see any prices or the bill, it was probably expensive. Enjoy my photos. read more

See all

MASSIVE food portions. This place is family style and suitable for like big parties. Our server was hilarious - he said the meatballs were small and they weren't at all. Everything was delicious and our pasta dish was from the special menu. Server took good care of us and the place was busy. We had a reservation and came a bit earlier than that but got seated on time. This place is right in Times Square, so expect long lines and long wait. Put a reservation in and this place is well known for their food. read more

See all

Carmine's Time square highlight massive, shareable portions of southern Italian cuisine, a vibrant vintage atmosphere, and a highly central location, though visitors frequently cite long wait times and a chaotic, noisy environment. Meals are served family-style and are designed to be shared by groups of 4 or more. Popular enormous dishes include the Chicken Parmigiana, Rigatoni with Sausage & Broccoli, and the Zucchini Fries. The food is straightforward, heavily garlicked, and packed with butter and rich flavors. Expect lively, indulgent, and comforting plates reminiscent of a large Italian-American wedding feast. The restaurant has a bustling, cozy ambiance like old New York, but patrons note that it can get very loud during peak dinner hours. Service is generally rated as attentive and friendly, but wait times can stretch on--even for those with reservations. read more

See all

Carmine's is a family-style Italian staple in the Times Square area. The dark wood and family photos on the walls are incredibly inviting, creating a wonderfully authentic ambiance. First off, the homemade bread is next-level. On my most recent visit, I tried the rigatoni with sausage and broccoli based on our waiter's recommendation, and it absolutely did not disappoint. The portions are massive, so you will definitely leave with leftovers for later. The cocktails are equally delicious, and they even add a little flare to the espresso martini by putting a logo right on the foam. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Had friends in from Texas. It never disappoints. Very enjoyable for them, quality and quantity of the meal. read more

Second time dining @ Carmines and it was quite possibly one of the best meals I have had in NYC. Made reservations for 830, we were seated a few min. after check in. It was PACKED. Wednesday night. Love everything about this spot. Last time I had sat outside for a quick lunch, so this was really my first time experiencing it in all it's glory. Our waiter was amazing, wish I could remember his name. He recommended a pasta special which we ordered. SO so good. Also got the Caesar salad, chicken parm. The family style portions are huge! I ordered the Aperol spritz as well, it hit the spot with such an amazing meal. The ambiance, the music, the decor top notch. It was the perfect dinner and night after a long travel day! read more

See all

This is a must when in NYC. I would encourage making a reservation to avoid the waitlist as well. The food was spectacular and family size servings for everything. Can't say enough good things about meal prep and the servers actually serve you food on your plate at the table. The lasagna was very good with just the right amount of sauce. The salad was epic and the dessert to finish off the night was by far one of the best choices. Staff is excellent and friendly. Great experience and can't wait to visit again. read more

See all

Amazing time for sharing food with everyone you know. This place is packed, so you have to make a reservation, and the tables are packed together pretty tightly, but the art deco posters and the jazzy oldies add for a great old school Italian vibe. Dishes are all served family-style with huge portions for 2-4. We did ask for a bread basket, which had an array of plain white, cheesy, and marinara topped bread. The chicken parmesan was sliced really then and covered with a generous layer of mozzarella. We paired with broccoli, which was sauteed and super garlicy. Both were more than plenty for two people. We planned on having leftover parm, but it was too delicious. We saw another table with the Titanic dessert, and we were jealous but too stuffed. Maybe next time! Despite the crowd, service was great and the bathrooms were clean. The food came quickly and was all delicious. This is a great place the larger your party size so you can try a little bit of everything. read more

See all

Carmine's - Time Square Very nice restaurant in the heart of Times Square, great for a large group or just a couples date. Food is generous and very well done. Calamari - share the calamari, very well done with great dipping sauce and a large generous amount. Zucchini is also a great shareable dish with a large amount to go around. Ceasar Salad, I could probably pass on salad for another dish, but for salad lovers, go for it. Porterhouse Steak this is a must order, best entree on the menu and when paired with other dishes is enough for 6 people to share. Don't pass this up Chicken Marsala an okay dish, but complimented our meal perfectly. Penne Vodka this entree was a winner, another large generous dish, well prepared and very good . Justin was our server and took care of our table of six very well read more

See all

Cuisine: 7 Service: 6 Decor: 8 Value: 8 Overall: 7 After all these years, Carmine's is still one of the best place to eat for a large group of out-of-towners in the heart of Time Square imho. Does it have the best red sauce Italian food in NYC? No. Does it still have the best prices for giant platters? Maybe. Is it still a beautiful rustic looking restaurant that gives your guests the best Godfather vibes? Yes! Remember! Come with a group is my best advice. For me, the Fried Calamari is a must order at this place, though you need at least six eaters to finish the whole thing. Chicken Parm is very solid too. Way too much pasta, but I did enjoy the Penne alla Vodka. Everything else was alright, just not sure they are great deals anymore, especially the Baled Clams. I don't come here often and that's for good reason. However, give the restaurant its due respect for the purpose it serves - a decently priced meal for a large group in the middle of Time Square possibly rushing to catch a Broadway show. In that regards, this old school joint really fills the role. read more

See all

I would recommend finding somewhere else to get Italian in the city. This was pretty bland and essentially a fancy looking Olive Garden. Also if you're going with just one or two other people you will have to all agree on what to get because it's only family style portions, so not really a good place to try multiple items. Would. It go back read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The food was good the servings are huge one portion can fill 4 people. The service and ambiance was good the wait was like 15-20mins no reservations read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Shrimp Fra Diavolo & Lasagna - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Do we eat before the show or after? It's the all important question for theatergoers. We decided, since our show was at 7pm with no intermission, we would order the food to be picked up after the show. We ordered the Veal Scaloppini with Lemon and Butter, and the Rigatoni Country Style. We went into a side door which was great so we didn't have to deal with the crowds. Carmine's is always crowded. Beware of the huge portions as it's family style. The meats aren't as big, but delicious. I love the ambiance of the dark woods and steeps up and down the little sections, so your party can feel like it's private. If you've never eaten here, go. And if you have eaten here before, go again. read more

See all

We had an event in carmines at a private room with 200+ people. Which I was so shocked because I had no idea that Carmines would be able to accommodate. Definitely a great spot for anyone planning a huge party, will keep this place in mind for my baby's parties. The food was served all family style, we got a plate for our section of the table about 6 people. Which I think it was not enough food. Every plate was cleared so fast. We got salad, eggplant parm (which was delicious!), pasta alla vodka and a chicken with spinach dish. Overall solid space for a large party, food was ok as well. They even have their own Carmines wine. read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great food, great service by Justin, great ambiance! We ordered the following, see pictures! Super good! Five star for this place!!

This classic Italian restaurant in the heart of Time Square still has its touch. Full house even it is already around 10 o'clock at night. I feel like we all came from a Broadway show . Sweet, accommodating and home cooked meal dining is their specialty. As expected, we got it all here tonight. We knew from the start that serving size is gigantic but cant help but to order two platter of favorites for tonight. I enjoyed the garlic and oil pasta tremendously. How it was cooked in its simplicity makes it more perfect. Tastes so good. The stuffed mushroom is full of surprises. My peach and cream beverage balance it all. It was a pleasurable evening with the crowd around us. read more

See all

Dining at Carmine's is one of those classic New York experiences that really lives up to the hype. The place has a lively, old-school atmosphere that immediately makes you feel like you're part of something special. It's energetic, a little loud in the best way, and full of that unmistakable big-city charm. The portions are famously huge and meant for sharing, which makes the whole meal feel more like an event than just dinner. Everything I tried tasted comforting and full of flavor, the kind of hearty Italian food that feels both indulgent and satisfying. It's the perfect spot to go with family or a group of friends so you can try a variety of dishes and enjoy the experience together. Service was fast and organized even though the restaurant was packed, which says a lot about how well they handle the constant crowds. It can feel a bit hectic at times, but that's honestly part of what makes it memorable. If you're looking for a legendary New York restaurant that delivers generous portions, classic flavors, and a fun atmosphere, this is definitely a place worth visiting. read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

First night in NYC with the fam and Carmine's was a great choice for all ages. I loved the family style sharing. We had the calamari which might have been the best calamari I've had. The Bolognese was loaded with flavor. We also tried a white sauce which was creamy and rich. To top off the night, we ordered the titanic for our birthday girl we were celebrating. The wait staff came out with this insane vessel of ice cream and sweet treats, while singing happy birthday! read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

If you do not have a reservation, it would be really hard to get into this place on a weekend and prob most nights. The restaurant is bustling with people and workers alike. It's very loud and hard to hold conversations at the table, but the food is delicious. We grabbed dinner in between Broadway shows and it was delicious. Everything is done family style, so make sure you pay attention to that before ordering. read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Stuffed mushrooms - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This has been a family favorite for decades. The chicken scarpiello is one dish everyone always likes. It's a little different every time I have it, but it's always delicious. Our server was friendly and got all the food out in the right order. The restaurant is always packed and buzzy, but not too noisy for conversation. This was the first time that I had the lemoncello tiramasu pie. It was creamy and delicious. More of a cream pie; I didn't notice any ladyfingers. We did not miss the coffee, read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Limoncello tiramasu - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We went to Carmine's for dinner and had a great experience! The staff was so welcoming and accommodating. The food was delicious and the cocktails were great. It was packed so I highly recommend making a reservation. The food is served family-style so come with a big group and come hungry! read more

See all

Carmine's was one of the highlights of our trip to New York City! We brought my 83-year-old mom, who uses a mobility scooter, and the staff made us feel so welcome from the moment we arrived. The restaurant has a lively, classic New York atmosphere that's perfect for families and groups. Our server was friendly, attentive, and the service was incredibly fast, even though the restaurant was busy. The portions are huge and meant for sharing, which made our meal even more fun. Everything we ordered was fresh, flavorful, and delicious. We left full and happy! If you're visiting Times Square and looking for great Italian food, excellent service, and a memorable dining experience, Carmine's is definitely worth a visit. We'll absolutely be back the next time we're in NYC! read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Mixed Green Salad - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

First time coming here, can't say anything bad!! From the Cesar salad towering off the table to the delicious calamari and mussels, all of the appetizers were delicious. Hassan was great with his service, timing all of our courses to come out at the best times. It can get pretty busy, so make a reservation for sure. Great chill business casual vibe. Highly recommend. read more

See all

What a place to be after a show - we sat at the bar and had the best time ever. Saw many groups waiting for a table the whole time we were there, and I wouldn't say that is worth it, but if you can get a reservation or a spot at the bar, this place is great. Amazing cocktails and hugeeeee portions. The chicken parm was everything you want in a chicken parm and the espresso martini was divine. If I'm in Times Square I'll be thinking about this place read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Chicken Parmigiana - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Carmine's is well known for its family style meals, and the portions definitely lived up to the reputation. The dishes were flavorful and perfect for sharing, which is one of the things I've always enjoyed about dining here. We did run into a couple of issues during our visit. A hair was found in the salad, but the staff handled it immediately and replaced it without hesitation. I appreciated how quickly they corrected the situation. Our table was also slanted because of the uneven floor, and that caused one of our drinks to spill. It wasn't a major problem, but it did take away from the overall experience. The food itself was solid and the atmosphere lively, but the combination of the salad incident and the uneven table made this visit less smooth than expected. The staff was responsive, and the family style portions remain a highlight. read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Everything about this restaurant is absolutely amazing! I've been here for my graduation dinner and a dinner date. The food portions are family style which I loved. I love Italian food and this restaurant is Italian food heaven. The service here is phenomenal because the waiter is always attentive and periodically checks on you to see how things are going. Usually I get penne alla vodka pasta with grilled shrimp. I thoroughly enjoy the chicken parm with Cesar Salad as well. I've had the garlic bread with cheese and baked clams before. For dessert, I usually go with the Tiramisu. This place is ideal for large groups but if it's just you and someone else that works as well. I've been to the the Upper West Side location also. I've ordered to-go a few times in the past and will do in the future. read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Feast - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Although we attend many Broadway shows, this restaurant somehow had never been on our radar -- but we're glad we found it. We had a 7:00 PM curtain and chose this spot partly because of its reputation for getting theatergoers in and out efficiently. Our reservation was for 5:30 PM, though we were not seated until about 6:00 PM, so I would recommend allowing at least two hours before showtime just to be safe. Once seated, however, the evening flowed seamlessly. Service was prompt and professional, cocktails arrived quickly (and were excellent), and the food did not disappoint. We shared the Italian salad and a pasta entrée -- both were delicious, and the portions were enormous. We ended up leaving about half. Total bill for three, including tip, was around $180, which felt like a very good value given the quality, portions, and Midtown location. We'll definitely return before another Broadway show. read more

service was good. atmosphere is busy. was not overly impressed with the dishes. they lacked flavor, temperature and the penne vodka was quite bland. read more

See all

One of my absolute favorite places to go after watching a show/ performance. This place always makes me feel like I'm at my Zia's house having dinner during the holidays. I love their food and their portions are incredible! The prices aren't even high for the amount of food you get. Bring a group and order one thing each, believe me you'll have enough to share and for lunch the next day I will always love Carmines! Delicious authentic Italian food. Yum! read more

Bring your Appetite...Carmine's is a good Italian restaurant with big portions. Food is ordered and is meant to be shared (family style). The menu has everything with a lot of choices. If you are a family of four, 2 plates is more than enough. Caesar salad was also delicious (they also provided us with anchovies!!). All the food was delicious. The staff was attentive and was always checking on us. The location is also near Time's Square which is near all the broadway theaters. The restaurant gave that italian feel. Overall a great experience. read more

Carmine's - Time Square - Veal Marsala, Spaghetti Bolognese Meat Sauce, Chicken Parmigiana, Ravioli w/ Cheese - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

about 45 minutes during Christmas week around 10 PM with no reservation, which honestly impressed me given how busy it was. The staff was friendly, attentive, and kept things moving smoothly. Most of the food was flavorful and well portioned. The only thing I wasn't a fan of was the chicken marsala, but everything else we tried was delicious. The atmosphere was lively and perfect for a late dinner in the city. Would definitely return and recommend, especially if you're looking for a solid spot in Times Square with great service and a fun vibe. read more

See all

Best Italian Food in Times Square As usual, every time we return to New York, Carmines is our go‑to choice. The food remains exquisite--fresh, generous in portion, and remarkably well‑priced for Times Square. This visit was with a group of friends, and we ordered Porterhouse, Veal Marsala, and Chicken Parmigiana accompanied by linguini pomodoro and penne al olio. Every dish was delicious and perfectly prepared. Our waitress, Asheley, delivered outstanding service--professional, friendly, and attentive. Her recommendations were spot‑on and elevated the experience even more. Reservations are essential. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Located off W 44th street in time square where there are plenty of foot traffic and plenty of activities and stores nearby. The place had a very vintage atmosphere with all the black and white pictures hanged up all over the restaurant. Our waiter Chen was very helpful by giving us a handful of suggestions based on what our preferences are. He also informed us that the whole restaurant is family style so everything should be shared. Caesar Salad($32.95)- I would say this is one of the best Caesar salads I ever had, everything from the richness of the dressing to the cheesy croutons were very good. The slight anchovy taste was also a nice surprise. Chicken Saltimbocca($38.95)- I would have preferred the chicken thighs over chicken breast since it was dry. The sauce was a little bitter and the spinach added a little earthiness to the dish. Shrimp Parmigiana($45.95)- Nicely breaded jumbo shrimp that was served over a light marinara sauce and covered with a layer of mozzarella cheese. Little Frankie Blue Eyes($8.00)- Very tasty non alcoholic drink with blueberry, pineapple, ginger beer and soda that was not overly sweet. I would suggest trying this place as a group because family style is a lot of food and this way you can try a variety of dishes. Would definitely recommend the Caesar Salad and Shrimp Parmigiana as they were both delicious Visited November 2025 Food- 8/10 Cleanliness- 9/10 Staff- 10/10 read more

See all