Every time we visit Carmella's (and it's often) we're happy campers. We have purchased items at the market but more often than not we actually get pizza or pasta or the sandwiches, but not tonight. Tonight we embarked on the focaccia with marinara and ricotta followed by their short rib. Just wow. The bread was so fresh with chunks of roasted garlic, the marinara is homemade, and top it off with ricotta. Be still my heart. Then we enjoyed the short rib with very buttery mashed potatoes and some great au jus. I'm glad we branched out tonight. Thanks for a great meal Dustin and Joe! read more

Carmella's - Short rib dinner with mashed potatoes - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Ate there 2 weeks ago. Big expectations. Results? Meh Margherita pizza burnt on bottom Chicken picatta was swimming in olive oil Canned beers were good read more

They not only serve pizza but they have delicious other options as well! The buffalo wings were surprisingly really good, a decent sized wing and good sauce! Bonus was the extra ranch! They know what the people want. The little gem salad was very good too! Thick chunks of bacon and blue cheese dressing. A great pairing! read more

Carmella's - The Frankie - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Loved our pasta dishes & the patio! So grateful to have this gem nearby. It's a bit pricey but happy to support a local business.

I had delicious pizza from here. However this is the 2nd time I went in the morning when online it said they opened at 7am, and even at 7:45, they had the doors fully locked with people inside. Please change your hours or put signs on your doors with times you are actually open. I tried opening a few times and just met with stares. read more

Carmella's - Hours open - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Denver, Colorado

As much as I love their moneyball pizza, the last time we ordered, they really messed up the timing. My husband placed the order at 3:45 pm for pickup at 5:00pm and we he got there, after waiting for 10 minutes they realized they hadn't started his order and somehow had the time for pickup wrong. It took another 20 ish minutes to make the pizza at that point, all with a hungry toddler fussing. My husband did call in the order instead of ordering online. They gave us a complimentary dessert for waiting which was a nice gesture (the miso caramel banana pudding) but we weren't fans unfortunately. The banana pudding itself was great but the miso gave it a very bitter taste. I also have yet to have the pizza as crunchy as the first time we got it, even after asking for it extra cooked (we've had it 3 times since). It's been a solid 8/10 everytime but the first time we had it was a 10/10 and I'm sad I can't experience that again. read more

Carmella's - Money ball pizza - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Had an event on this side of town, so my friend and I decided to beat traffic and check this place out before. There's a high-end specialty food market with a well-curated offering high quality items and a nice selection of beer and wine. On the other side there's an eatery with app, pizza, and sandwiches. I was pleasantly surprised to find a variety of lambic and enjoyed a new to me grape varietal Tilquin. We also have the meatball appetizer and the margarita pizza, both were quite delicious! I really liked the addition of giardinera in the red sauce that came with the meatballs, it added a nice kick of Chicago flair. Was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the pizza! One of the better ones I've had in Denver. Both were very flavorful with quality fresh ingredients. I would recommend this spot for a casual lunch or dinner! They also had a selection of tasty-looking desserts. Service was great too. read more

See all

Fantastic food !! We tried various sandwiches and then ended with Little Man Ice Cream. Connected to an Italian market that had fantastic options. The general manager stopped by to check if we were satisfied and enjoyed everything and everyone we interacted with was so nice. My husband swears his Italian sandwich was the.best he ever had. Caprese sandwich also fantastic and the meatball sandwich with their incredible marinara sauce rocked. We need one closer to our house read more

I'm so happy Carmella's opened up in our neighborhood! Despite being a small shop, the carefully curated selection of food is great for picking up last minute dinner items, putting together a picnic or throwing together snacks for book club. The kiddos love grabbing a slice of pizza and having dinner on the patio outside and I've gotten a lot of helpful input on the wine side of the shop. Such a gem! read more

Great neighborhood restaurant and store. Literally right down the street from me so it's very convenient. It's got good pizza to eat and good selection of drinks food and wine to buy off the shelf. Their ice cream is pretty good too. During the day at lunch, it's packed with high school children. But the times that I go for dinner and weekends it's never packed and I can always get my food pretty fast. Prices are a little bit more expensive, but not bad. Service is always friendly. read more

Was excited when this place opened. Pizza is good but overpriced. After multiple interactions with the staff I won't be back. Staff is unhelpful and comes across as arrogant. Would rather drive further away for overpriced food! read more

We love Carmella's! Their menu is really varied, providing options that you can't get just anywhere with very fresh ingredients. Great vegetarian options. I especially love their Panuozzo sandwiches! Their take-out pizza is yummy too! read more

We tried their pizza and it was amazing! Very high-quality ingredients and perfect crust. We will be back.

All the employees there were extremely towards me and my family we had ordered online and 45 minutes after we ordered we went to go pick it up and it wasn't ready. I asked about my order and they were very rude about it. read more

Scammers!! Ordered delivery and pizza showed up cold and I got the wrong dessert. Do not order from here! read more

See all

Absolutely delicious!!! We ordered online for pickup and it was done right on time. We got half OK artichoke-y and half pepperoni. SO GOOD. The service is always very attentive and helpful here. Grabbed a bottle of wine to bring home too. I highly recommend trying this place. Let's support them so they succeed and stay in our neighborhood! read more

Carmella's - Half and half. Classic pepperoni and OK Artichoke-y - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Picked up a winter kale salad with squash, red onion, grilled chicken breast, sweet potato, goat cheese and croutons. Incredibly good. First time I've ordered from here but if this is any indication of how good it is it will be worth doing again! Food was ready on time too. read more

Great place to have in the neighborhood and they are always improving. Their meals are really tasty.

Holy S*@t that was good pizza. Moneyball is on point! Will definitely be back and can't wait for the family to try it.

I ordered the "Goat Cheese Eggplant" Parmesan, which was a huge disappointment for $23. It was thick and dry. It did not match the ingredient list on the menu, as it was not layered, there was no ricotta cheese, and no spinach. Just a single this piece of thick eggplant with dried out melted cheese on top and a large side of spaghetti. read more

This place has quality pizza. As a professional pizza eater, you can trust my opinion. I go far and wide for great pizza. And I Would go far for this, lucky to have it in the neighborhood. read more

This place was amazing and they were so nice and accommodating! We flew in from south Florida to Denver and I found this place on Yelp while we were driving to Breckenridge. The pizza was so delicious and the kids spaghetti was also freshly made and heavenly. The market is also adorable and we were able to grab essentials for our trip. read more

Very well. Amazing food talking specifically the pizza. Ok well also the chicken parm to. Anyways the service is good because they are patient and helpful etc. The ambiance is good and welcome I really like it. So well job Carmella's. read more

This locally owned joint is a welcome gem to the north central park neighborhood. We are addicted to their pizza (my husband is a New Yorker and they have his approval) - I especially love the moneyball with meatballs and ricotta. Their market also has prepared foods, ready to heat and heat which we really appreciate. read more

If you're black or Mexican don't bother going here. All you get is weird stares and unwelcoming energy. Lost a phone here and when I came to retrieve it not even 20 min after leaving it, they didn't trust that it was mine and clearly was very reluctant to return it. Guess I didn't look white and rich enough. Bummer. read more

absolutely delicious pizza! came out fast and the service was so nice! staff were friendly snd timely! super clean space and comfy atmosphere! 10/10 recommend! read more

Came here for lunch with my daughter - she had pepperoni pizza and a Caesar. She loved them both! I had the delicious three gem salad with chicken. It was so filling and fresh. We also shared a plate of their focaccia - a which was also great. It's inside the Pearl Market - which gives it a cool vibe. My daughter picked up an AMAZING almond coconut donut for us to share for dessert. They also have a coffee bar and serve ice cream from Little Man, Sweet Action and High Point Creamery - this place is perfect read more

Great coffee, pizza, sandwiches, ice cream and friendly staff. We are frequent visitors to this place and love it!

Awesome pizza and burgers (Saturday night is burger night.) A great addition for Central Park.

Exceptional staff, fresh and tasty sandwiches and pizza, shelves are stocked with great finds!

We found this gem, and went for my birthday. The pizza was outstanding! True NY style, and being from NY, I am picky when it comes to people saying NY pizza, but it was truly the best I've had! And the service and people were so kind and accommodating, we will definitely be back! Thank you Carmella's! read more