We had prompt and professional service here. The ambiance was pleasant and we especially loved the outdoor seating. The food was very flavorful and yummy. Especially the pizza! We just got pepperoni but it was super yummy, plenty of sauce,cheese etc.. I got the tri tip sandwich which was also yummy, could've used more sauce but was good. Highly recommend! read more

Captains Cove - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

I decided to try Captain's Cove today after hearing good things about the new ownership. I went for lunch with a few coworkers and bosses. At first glance, the place looked great--clean, modern, and nicely decorated. The atmosphere felt welcoming for both younger and older guests. Our waitress was friendly and attentive, especially since we were the only ones there at the time. However, things started to go downhill when we looked at the menu. The prices were surprisingly high for this area--honestly more in line with what you'd expect in a bigger city like LA. It immediately set a higher expectation for the food. I ordered the tri-tip sandwich with garlic fries. The fries were crispy, but there was barely any actual garlic--just a faint hint of garlic oil. When I think of garlic fries, I expect to see and taste real garlic, not just a suggestion of it. The tri-tip sandwich was the biggest disappointment. It came with only two very thin slices of meat--more like deli cuts than a hearty tri-tip portion--along with arugula and a spread that didn't really complement the sandwich. The flavors just didn't come together. To make matters worse, the root beer was flat, and while the waitress was kind, drink refills were minimal--basically once when we sat down and once when we were finished. For $22 per sandwich, the value just isn't there. For what we spent as a group, we could have had a much better meal elsewhere--honestly even in places like Pebble Beach. I understand businesses have overhead, but pricing needs to match both the quality and the local customer base. The people who live and work here year-round are the ones who will sustain the business, especially during slower seasons. Unfortunately, based on this experience, it'll be a while before I return. read more

Pizza is very tasty, ambiance is your standard pizza place with sports tv, beer, wine etc. live music was a bit loud for me but many people like it. read more

We had such a wonderful experience for our grandmas 80th birthday party here. The staff was so accommodating when it came to us decorating, putting in our order early, and meeting the needs of all the guests. The service was incredible during the party- they did a great job keeping pitchers full and checking in on our pizza/if we needed anything else. We were able to bring our own cakes and sing and celebrate. They also set us up with a combination of indoor and outdoor tables. It was a beautiful day and we were thankful for the rolling garage door that allowed us to move in and out. The food itself was amazing! The shipwreck pizza was my personal favorite. We're thankful for all their help and would definitely recommend! read more

Just a little update on my prior post. I have to say that we've been to Captains Cove 5 times since they opened and can't say enough about their food, beverages, atmosphere and staff. We've had burgers, appetizers , pizza and salads. We have not been disappointed. I must say though our favorite things has been the Eye Patch pizza and the Summer Salad. The pizza dough is great with the hot honey bbq sauce and crispy jalapeños. Summer salad is incredible. Tomatoes, watermelon, feta crumbs, cucumbers and a house made vinaigrette. . Stop by. You won't be disappointed read more

Captains Cove - Summer Salad at Captains Cove near Heritage Ranch - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

A great place to eat and relax! Delicious food, great service! Good beer menu! Glad this place is here! read more

Captains Cove - Games inside including Ms. Packman! - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

Personal size is perfect for a family of 4 We got 2 different kinds of pizzas food was delicious and service was excellent as well. Ambiance is great many folks visiting from local lake. read more

Captains Cove - Garden Treasure pizza - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

The owners of Captains Cove are trying to overcome a bad rap that this restaurant was left with from prior owners. WOW. They are doing a great job! This place is a hidden gem. Service is great. The food was really good. I had the BBQ burger with onion rings. The burger was one of the best burgers I've had in a long time! Onion rings were crunchy and not greasy. My husband had the Buffalo Chicken Salad. He said it was excellent. The arugula in the salad was peppery and it complimented the buffalo chicken nicely. The dining area is an airy open space that even when full would not feel crowded. We will definitely return. Great experience. I highly recommend Captains Cove! Sorry for no pics. I will post some after my next visit. read more

Tonight was my second time here. The first time, the pizza was great, but they did not use white sauce as requested and my husband and I have horrible acid reflux so we were a little disappointed. However...all the appetizers we ordered were on point and super yummy! Tonight we wanted to try something different. We ordered 2 burgers, medium, with onion rings and a side of fries. Little bit disappointed because our burgers were cooked well done, but the onion rings ROCKED! Our side of fries were a little soggy, but hey...they were ordered TO GO, so you get what you get. The taste was great, texture just a little off. So for $57 we got 2 1/4 lb burgers with onion rings as a side, and 1 order of fries. Will I come here again? Absolutely. Will i make sure to double check my burgers is medium instead of well done? Yes. BUT! Overall, the taste and the quality was absolutely there. I can't wait to hit the lake again, and come in amd grab some grub at the new lake spot! Would have given 5 stars based on taste, but my apologies to the owners because I really like a medium burger! I know this place will do well in the future, based on friendly staff and really tasty food! YOUR ONION RINGS ROCK!!!!!! read more

Definitely better than the old pizza business that was at the same location. Garlic Parmesan fries are a must try. Kids had the OG burger, and we had the bar b air chicken pizza with the fried jalapeño . Will repeat read more

We came here for dinner and this place is an absolute treat -- delicious pizzas, fresh salads, and amazing customer service. I'll definitely be coming back and highly recommend this spot. It's truly a hidden gem and I'm so glad we stopped by. A special shoutout to sweet Connor who waited on us and took care of every request. read more

Awesome atmosphere - pizza and wings are good, service is awesome. Must go every time we visit Naci. Never disappoints.

Today had the personal Shipwreck and was only able to eat half, it was very tasty. Husband had the Crispy Chicken Sandwich with a side salad. Great amount of tasty chicken. Our friend had the Captain's Calzone which was amazing! We will order it next time! Side salads were perfect side and mixture. Our waitress Jewel was very attentive and very nice. We felt great value and very good food, definitely recommend this place. read more

I enjoy their crispy chicken wings, salad, pizza and hamburgers. Any combo all delicious! They have a great selection of beer and wine selection. However you can bring your own wine If you choose. The service is always good. It is kid friendly with a few pinball & video machines and they have kids karaoke night. read more

1000/10!! What a great place! The decor is awesome for the lake vibe and the atmosphere is fun for families! The arcade is a hit! The food was amazing we had the sunset pizza a little sweet and spicy :) our server Aleks was knowledgeable with the food item and was very outgoing! We will be there all the time! read more

See all

Happy Happy Joy Joy!! This place is awesome! We stopped in after a day in the lake and wasn't expecting much. We ordered a Chicken Caesar Salad and a large pepperoni pizza. The salad was with out a doubt one of the best Chicken Caesar salads I've ever had and the pizza puts the pizza joints in town to shame. The service was excellent and prompt and the inside was spotless. You will not be disappointed!!! read more

Captains Cove - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

Burgers were all burned, tasted charred. Pizza was very overcooked. I really wanted to like this place. We've gone at least six times. Unfortunately this was our last. read more

So happy to have a friendly, comfortable restaurant in our community- that also serves delicious food! Since they've taken over, we've done take out several times, but haven't come in to eat here until tonight. We'll be back for sure! Everyone is welcoming , and the venue looks lovely! Every food choice I've tried has been done very nicely- and the fries are perfect (I'm kind of a fry snob...). Tonight I tried the crispy chicken sandwich- holy moly!! HUGE- and so tasty! Love the hot honey drizzle- it added a little kick. I, being the fry snob I am, actually try not to eat so many of them... so I steal some of my husband's and choose a side salad instead. Have to say- the side salads here are a notch above the norm. Lovely, fresh arugula, lots of veggies- really a delight. Beautifully done, Captains Cove!! read more

Food was so salty we could not eat. Service was great But could not eat food I will not be back. Will discourage people I know from coming

Food was super yummy. The pizzas are great Lamberger amazing chicken Panini was super good. Everything that everyone had their wedge salad so fresh and the staff is amazing super friendly. Definitely return. read more

We just, for the first time, ordered the calzones and WOW, delicious! So fresh! The texture and flavor of the crust was perfect, the fillings were delicious, seasoned just right. We usually get pizzas or burgers and they're always great as well. The service is great, and always with a smile! read more

I have gone here more than once. They have done a wonderful job with renovation and menu items offered. Some of their menu items are below average in taste and portion, while some are just fine. Their wine pour is not worth what they charge. Their service can be spotty. I know prices on everything have gone up in today's economy. Unfortunately, I don't see them here in the long run because our Heritage Ranch community cannot sustain their prices. read more

Stopped in for lunch and we had the fried chicken sandwich. This sandwich was one of the best sandwiches I have ever tasted in my life on planet earth. Breading was perfect, bun was soft and all the flavors perfectly balanced out. This is a must have if you are a fried chicken sandwich lover. I'm a arugula lover which was on the sandwich. If you are not a arugula lover you may want to ask for iceberg. Service was excellent and restaurant was super clean. read more

We go every Friday! Juliette our waitress is wonderful. I wish they had a combination pizza but the Garden Treasure is close if you add pepperoni! read more

Captains Cove - Garden Treasure medium pizza with pepperoni! - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

We got dinner to go here. Great service. The salmon salad was great. I'm glad there are healthy options. The salad had greens, garbanzo beans, quinoa, and nuts. The cauliflower Hawaiian pizza was good too! read more

So good! The lamb burger, chicken sandwich, garlic fries, chicken strips, pizza all of it 1000000/10. So happy to have a great variation of food in an awesome and improved environment, love the decor/vibes, server was friendly and attentive. My 5 year old also loved the arcade games and smashed his food. Love that they offer fruit with the kids menu! read more

Great service and good food, nice clean restaurant with a good selection of pizza and burgers

Good pizza! The salad I got tasted delicious but was a lot smaller than I was expecting. the wings are good too. Excited to have some variations of things other than pizza out here. Not perfect, but I know they're still working the kinks out since they just opened! the ranch is superb! excited to keep trying everything. would love for the salads to be bigger! read more

Best service ever from Juliet who served me the best canzone I have ever had. Defiantly worth the drive.

First time since changing ownership. Food was delicious. More options available than previous establishment. Servers were very nice and accommodating. read more

wonderful employees and very enjoyable environment. Alex and Skye really made our night!

Sat down and no service for 15 mins. Had to go to the bar and order our own food and drinks. New ownership.....still crappy service

Food was fantastic. Loved the captains burger! We also got a bunch of pizza and wings the second night and that was great as well.

The food was great. We had buffalo wings and spicy chicken salad! The staff were friendly and welcoming, we will return.

Firstly service was friendly but ignorant. They messed up our drunk order twice and we didn't have any silverware brought to or on our table. French fries tasted like dirty peanut oil and the burger was okay at best. read more

We just ate there last night and our pizza was excellent! Our friends had the lamb burger, and they raved about it! Looking forward to going back and trying something different! read more

$30 large pizza was not very large, ambiance was strange, put $2 into the arcade... didn't play one game. the wings have all these canned additives on top to fill up the big but empty box. pizza was the real disappointment though as i spent $30 on a large pizza that feeds 2 people. read more