I'm not a super heavy fella. But the metal chair I sat in was giving way. The whole back just bent. So my only criticism would be to get some new seats. The coffee and service were great! Super cute little coffee shop on a super cute Main Street. I got a regular coffee with oat milk. Didn't need any sugar or sweetener. Went down smooth and was so scolding hot that I couldn't drink it for 10 minutes. Instant gratification. Not like a lot of places where you gotta get Cold Brew just so you don't forget you got it and leave it on the corner of your desk until lunchtime. I expect to be in town more often and plan on making this my coffee shop of choice. read more

Cai's is a nice cafe to study at in Metuchen! I recently caught up with a friend here and we also decided to do a co-working session! There is free wifi and the drinks here are good. They do serve food so if you get hungry you can order a salad or sandwich. They serve both breakfast and lunch! Most cafes also aren't able to accommodate or modify matcha into an Americano style (where it's just water with no milk) but Cai's is able to! read more

Cai's Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

Love coming here just to have me time. Service was great, the cookies were too sweet for me, the latte was perfect, I prefer it hot(is it possible to request that?) over all the place is cozy and warm. read more

Cai's Cafe - Oatmeal Raisin cookie with Vanilla latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

Skip the food and flavored drinks here! Bagel pantry is a much better choice or I'll try Brewed Awakening across the street next time. My friend and I ordered 1 flavored matcha (which she didn't like at all) and two different toasts (caprese and avocado). The toasts were not good and the caprese was smothered in dried herbs. It also felt a little dark and not super clean inside. read more

Love this locally owned coffee shop in the heart of downtown Machuchen. On a cold Monday came by as a suggestion from another local business and was not disappointed. As entered, we could smell the aroma of good, strongly made coffee. The chill music and vibe of this Cafe would be perfect for studying or relaxing. The staff was superb as they made the coffee extra hot as requested with a design for our Yelping images. It was easy to get to with metered parking up front and was exactly what was wanted on a cold, windy day. Return: likely read more

See all

Cai's Cafe is a popular spot in downtown Metuchen. Very nice aesthetic with fireplace and surrounding couches and tables. The coffee is spot on but that's the limit of their range. A few pastries which looked shipped in and snacks like bags of chips. I would like to see this spot add some hot food options and fresh baked goods. read more

See all

The wait times were exceptionally long. It took more than 15 minutes for me to get a basic drip coffee. The coffee was good but not worth the wait time. People who ordered complicated drinks after me got them before mine was ready. The staff was ok, but they clearly couldn't handle the 5-6 people in line. The decor was dark leather sofas and plenty of tables to sit. Power strips and Wi-Fi are available. read more

Cai's Cafe - Inside - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

See all

it is a good place to stay and work! Really recommend!! I like to study here!! And The coffee tastes good! Really recommend London frog read more

See all

Found this random piece of plastic in my shaken espresso. Not the friendliest of employees. Also had flimsy straws, not the best for iced coffees read more

Cai's Cafe - Plastic found in drink - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

This is one of my favorite cafes to get work done. I love going to cafes and putting on headphones to get my work done. The staff is always so nice! The ambiance is always a calm vibe that allows me to get work done. I love the food menu it's not an extensive menu but still diverse enough to give good options. read more

TLDR; cute reasonable cafe. Adjust your expectations. Cute place in the heart of Metuchen. Parked on a side street. Not too packed on a Sunday even though there was a street fair going on. I'm slightly disappointed since this place was so hyped but not bad. First of all, this is not waiter service. You order at the counter and seat yourself. You pick up drinks when they shout them out. Food gets delivered to you. It wasnt initially clear on coming in so there was a tiny bit of confusion. Standard cafe mismatched furniture. One of the chairs at our table was almost falling apart which didn't seem safe. Food did not come out altogether which was really annoying. My meal and my husband's came out but my mother in law only got her side plate of scrambled eggs. By the time she got her French toast, she was done with the eggs. They also weren't cooked as well as she prefers. We had to keep asking the staff for stuff - napkins, syrup (it didn't come with the French toast???), I wanted to ask for more hot sauce but the girls delivering the food didn't ask how our meal was, didn't stay, etc. they would drop our food and run. The good: I had an oat milk chai latte that was excellent. So few places can do a chai with your milk choice because they're premade usually. Like a different review said, cafe drinks hit differently when served in a mug (for here). For some reason my mother in law's tea was served in a paper cup (maybe because of size?) and she had to wait for her milk. On the bright side, she said it was fantastic decaf tea. I had the Buffalo chicken avocado mash (avocado toast). It's pretty standard - like something you would make at home but not in a bad way. Just nothing stellar. Mashed avocado. Multigrain bread. Pieces of chicken in a very creamy Buffalo sauce. Had very little Buffalo flavor. Could have been stronger. Served with good ranch on the side. Husband ordered a breakfast platter but it came as a sandwich. He didn't mind and ate it anyway. He said it was good. Mother in law got the Texas toast French toast, my brain was expecting huge thick slices, this was pretty standard bread. You can tell that it wasn't crusty or dried out bread, just fresh bread dipped in batter. So it was good but not revolutionary. Her French toast came with a huge side of fresh fruit, mostly blueberries with some strawberries. That was a nice surprise and huge portion. Bathrooms are nice and clean (two gender neutral ones next to each other) read more

Cai's Cafe - View - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

See all

I clearly don't spend enough time in Metuchen because I was blown away by how packed the main street was with amazing little shops and eateries. And Cai's Cafe is definitely one of those gems. Firstly, the two lovely ladies working the day I stopped in were so friendly and helpful. They made suggestions, didn't rush my order, helped me get on the wifi. They were awesome. And on top of just great people working here, the coffee was fantastic and the food was just what I was looking for. I got an oat milk latte and the eggy avocado toast. I love that they put my latte in a real mug because I was staying and not taking everything to go. If there is one thing that makes a cup of coffee over the top when it is already great, it is a real mug. It came out piping hot and was a perfect pickmeup. The Eggy Avocado toast was also wonderful. I ended up needing to add a little salt to give it more flavor, but it was still a perfect and filling snack. I ended up getting a tea after I was done working and the ladies helped me pick a nice herbal/decaf one. They have plenty of tables, all spaced out really well so no one is on top of each other, as well as a few couches. I stayed for awhile, got some work done and even switched from a table to the couch half way through when I was ready to unwind a bit more. The streets are lined with parking spaces (metered) and there are plenty of shops nearby if you want a spot to grab coffee and then walk. Highly recommend a stop here! read more

Cai's Cafe - Eggy Avocado Toast and latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

See all

Cute place with great location but that's all I can really say. The coffee was priced reasonably but rightfully so since I thought it was flavorless and tasted watery. There wasn't much selection of baked goods. The service was meh. The cashier didn't even smile or ask, "May I help you?" The barista was pleasant though. Seaters could use reupholstering but I sat in the newer looking loveseat and it was the best seat in the house. read more

Cai's Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

See all

Iced lattes are warm, extra ice did not help. Very little espresso to the milk ratio. Drinks lacked flavor, syrup usage was very faint for the volume of the drink. read more

Walked through this town heading back to NYC and almost every shop was closed. Thank goodness this spot was open and was pretty busy. My challenge is always GF options which is not as common in some of the smaller shops. They had pastries and coffee's but not GF we figured out their shakes are actually GF which I was grateful for. She suggested the peanut butter banana smoothie which was great and filling. Cute spot and a nice alternative to some of the chain coffee shops if you're looking to work in an open space. read more

Came here for coffee on a Sunday morning. It was fairly busy there. The place has nice ambiance with couches for lounging and sit down tables for food. There is a vast selection of flavors you can add to your coffees/lattes. We ordered two latte flavors that we haven't seen anywhere else. I got the raspberry white chocolate latte and my wife got the lavender latte. The raspberry white chocolate latte had a nice raspberry flavor that didn't taste artificial and the white chocolate balanced the tartness of the raspberry without being too sweet. The lavender latte was also deliciously unique. My wife wanted it to be a little sweeter so I told her to ask for some honey to make it a honey lavender latte and that helped bring out the slightly florally lavender flavor more. Overall I think if your looking for something different than your run of the mill lattes this is the place. read more

Cai's Cafe - Raspberry mocha latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

Asked for a single espresso, received what looked like about four ounces of liquid in a full-size paper cup (you can't see very well in the photo). Barista clearly did not know what she was doing read more

Cai's Cafe - Single espresso - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

I'm surprised to see Cai's only has a 3.5 because I quite love it! Have only been here a handful of times but their lattes are consistently good. Perfect balance of syrup to milk to espresso. Never too sweet. I've tried the maple latte, the gingerbread latte, and have had a plain latte quite a few times, both hot and iced. The baristas are always friendly and quick. The place is always clean and welcoming. I have not tried any of their limited bakery items so can't comment on food. But Cai's is definitely somewhere I will frequent for a good latte! read more

When I first started coming here, the service was so great, food was prepared nicely, and was just an overall great spot. Unfortunately, there has been a tremendous decline in service, maybe due to staff shortage. However, their coffees, teas and breakfast options are still delicious. read more

See all

I ordered a flavored iced latte and what I got was no flavor and burnt espresso in milk. The shop wasn't even busy so I'm not sure what happened. read more

Really cute cafe in the downtown area. The space was big and had a nice atmosphere. There was a good amount of seating. I had the hot chocolate and it was very good! Will definitely stop by again next time I'm in the area. read more

Cai's Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

Cai's is the coffee shop Metuchen has always needed. I love walking to Cai's with my family. The coffee, teas, and snacks are great. The staff is professional and prompt. Cai's a great meeting, catch up, hang out, or study spot. There is a good variety of seating for different groups. Like most coffee shops, it can get busy and a little loud during peak times. The only downfall is you may smell like Cai's for the rest of the day, so typically I plan my outfit around a visit to Cai's and change into something else afterward if I have plans. I usually love their music selection. One time I went and they played only Lana Del Rey, it was heaven. Bring quarters for street parking. read more

Cai's Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

I used to be a near-daily regular for 2 years; however, for certain reasons and events, I stopped going because I felt unwelcome on the basis of my identity and not my character. Prior to that, I genuinely felt a sense of community from the baristas and the other regulars, especially coming out of the pandemic. I made a lot of friends through this space and have fond memories. 1 star for the friendly baristas who work hard to keep this place afloat. They- the people behind the register day in, day out- really do a lot to create a welcoming atmosphere and community. The work that they put in deserves to be commended, and I stand by that. They work hard with what they are given in order to create a good customer experience. 1 star for the ambience that actually made the place feel cozy and the okay coffee (see other recent reviews). The food is okay too but overpriced for what it is in quantity and quality, especially when compared to other options nearby. I don't think this is a reflection of the baristas but more of business practices. 1 star for the good memories. I really wanted to continue liking and giving this place my business but alas. Minus 1 star for what was said and done. Use your judgement when patronizing this cafe. Tip your baristas. And take advice from their bathroom walls: Be a nice human. read more

See all

Stopped in for a quick cup of coffee. Noticed drip for the day was Guatemalan. Ordered and done. Service was quick. One sip and I knew it was good. The vibe is typical cafe with WiFi and lots of students on laptops cramming for upcoming midterms and assignments. read more

Decent Cafe Overall a decent cafe, nothing special. The cafe is very cold and doesn't have an amazing vibe to it. The food itself was good. I got a mocha oat latte which was good but not amazing. I also got the peanut butter banana toast which I enjoyed and would recommend. read more

If you're looking for a hip place to hang with a good coffee and great, live music --Check our Cai's Cafe. The ambience is hip, there's plenty of seating, and a good variety of menu items. The caprese toast was tasty. The live musician was very talented. The only downside was street parking and the staff could have been a little more attentive. read more

Cai's Cafe - Caprese toast & latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

Waited long for my croissant only to found out she forgot. I walked out with my croissant not warmed.

I love this coffee shop!!!! Izzy is the best and I literally had the best BLT and latte ever. Thanks so much

Incredibly rude staff. Do to the holiday they decided to close at 2 pm. This is fine, I walked in at 1:39 to which they replied can't you see we are closing. I will never come back. Closing at 2 would typically mean 2. Being rude to customers while never benefit any establishment. Sad thing is I was recommended this. Can't wait to tell everyone my experience read more

Recently visited this place again and we tried different coffees the coffees are freshly brewed and tasted great. The coffee flavours are really good and the croissants are also great. The place is cozy and the people are welcoming as well. read more

See all

So let me start by saying this is not a breakfast place this is a coffee shop. They try to make themselves look like something that they are not my wife and I want to try a new place on a Sunday morning for breakfast so we decided to give cai's cafe a try my wife started with an ice lavender coffee and I went with a plan americano ice coffee her coffee was ok because it had lavender syrup in it and not so much coffee but mine was extremely disgustingly strong to where it give me a headache for food they don't have much to choose from as they only have a 2 x 2 griddle in the back and no kitchen my wife order a BLT with avocado and I ordered a grilled cheese with avocado and mine literally looked like a two-year-old put it together and it's really hard to mess up a grilled cheese it did not taste good at all. My wife's Sandwich was depressing She sent back the first one because there was barely anything on the slices of bread and the bread was not toasted The second one that they gave her barely had a quarter of a piece of bacon on it and that is the picture that I posted That bread was also not toasted if you looking for a breakfast place do not waste your time or money and don't come here there's so many other better places around that have better food and better coffee oh and the best part 2 coffees and 2 sandwiches $38 I mean really ? No thanks never again read more

Cai's Cafe - BLT Avocado BLT - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

Outdoor seating is well spaced apart. Staff very friendly, coffee certainly comparable to other 'fancy coffee' places at a much better price. Range of teas is terrific. Have not eaten there yet, but definitely a place to frequent in town. read more

Coffee is amazing right now!! Closing in about 19 minutes and my cup of smooth perk me right up is as fresh as the morning sunshine!! The relaxing jazz music helps set the mood for me..staff is courteous and friendly..brought me my cup of coffee after I sat down.. read more

Cai's Cafe - Drip Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

I was there last weekend w/ a friend from college and her sister. Ambiance is nice and low key. Very friendly place to sit, read, and get coffee. The server that made my caramel apple latte was nice. I would come back again. read more

My mom, sister and I popped into Cai's Cafe on a Sunday for lunch. None of us are in this area all to often so the cute outside appearance and fairly full house is what got us in the door. After reading the menu they have posted up on the wall, we all decided to get a sandwich of some sort. My mom and I both got the chicken pesto sandwich while my sister had the three cheese grilled cheese. The sandwiches all came with chips. My sandwich was fresh and filling, but lacked in flavor and wasn't very memorable. It definitely could have used more pesto. The multigrain bread was good, but I wish it had been better toasted like we had been told it was going to be. I was honestly wondering if it had been toasted at all. My sister said her grilled cheese was just alright. I tried a bite of it and thought it was very cheesy but that's really all I can say about it. Service was pretty slow. Our three sandwiches took quite a bit of time to prepare and we had to remind staff of the beverages we ordered a couple different times. The cafe was crowded at the time we were there, but at a place where customers seat themselves they really had me scratching my head. All in all, I definitely wouldn't go out my way to return to Cai's Cafe but they did provide us with fresh food that filled our bellies so three stars it is for me. read more

Cai's Cafe - Three cheese grilled cheese at the top and the other two are chicken pesto sandwiches - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

See all

The place is crowded, not enough sitting, $12 chicken sandwich was meh (diner would be better), the wait time was very long. However, I came to this place on Saturday afternoon...It just seemed not organized.. I would only recommend this place if you want to just grab cup of coffee quickly. read more

Hot Shot (espresso + hot chocolate) with a shot of Nutella is delicious! Cai's is HUGE with plenty of seating, free WiFi, an extremely friendly staff, and a cute lending library in the corner that includes the complete Harry Potter series and some children's books. It's great for studying, catching up on work, or relaxing. They're also renovating the downstairs portion and turning it into a wine cellar! How unique. *Tip: Metered street parking. read more

See all

I like Cai's a lot for the ambience and the coffee. I've taken coffee to go and have sat down to get some work done. With free WiFi, plenty of seating, and quiet (but not too quiet) noise levels, it's a great place to stop in. I have never tried the sandwiches but I have tried a baked good. To be honest, I wasn't impressed. I'd definitely stick to the coffee here. Don't forget to type in your phone # for rewards! read more

The vibe of this cafe is really nice, lots of people either chatting or studying. The cold brew was excellent and they have tons of fun flavor options. Would be nice if there was even more seating because it was hard to find a spot on a Sunday morning. read more

Cai's Cafe - Cold Brew Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

I've been here a few times. Each time nothing exceptional to note, good bad or otherwise. Workers are generally welcoming. But today was just ridiculous. My friend ordered avocado toast and iced mocha, I ordered caprese toast. My order came out 30 minutes later. I asked about the order about 15 min in. My friend got hers within 10 minutes. When I finally received it the cheese had that "melted and left to harden" look and taste on the edges. Underneath the tomato was straight up unmelted cold cheese. No, it wasn't packed. Yes, they had enough workers, at least 4 people behind the counter. Service was below average. While friendly, they were completely unapologetic about taking 30 minutes to toast bread, slice some mozzarella and tomato, and assemble (possibly warm?). The mocha was Hershey-like chocolate sauce which was not melted in and sat at the bottom of her drink despite trying to mix it in. I didn't try it so I have no opinions on it. The place has a cool vibe and looks like it would be nice to study here. But they really showed they do deliver on service. read more

See all