Cafe Sole in Key West was an absolute gem. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt cozy, welcoming, and authentically local. The food was outstanding -- fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. The seafood was clearly top-quality, and every dish we tried was perfectly prepared. If you're visiting Key West and want a dining experience that combines excellent service, fresh seafood, and a charming setting, Cafe Sole is a must-visit. read more

The food was good, the service was good, the place was nice and I would dine here again. The staff was exceptional. I ordered the Ingram salad and French onion soup. Both were super flavorful and rich. My husband ordered escargot and filet and no complaints there either. While he ate the escargot he would have preferred the classic preparation and missed the garlic in his escargot. We tried the Bananas Foster for dessert. The portion seemed slim, not even an entire banana. The strawberries were dehydrated and we would have preferred fresh. Cafe Sole had their own spin on classic French dishes and it works for them but if you do not like deviating from tradition be prepared. read more

See all

Nice charming location, but overall was dissapointing. Some items just not well described on the menu - e.g. their Foie Gras Cafe' Sole is really more of a spread, not the same. The conch carpaccio was pretty good but we asked that the capers be more on the side. Even though our server Hristo agreed to do that it wasn't. The Angels on Horseback (or wrapped dates), not worth it. The Duck a'L' orange was also good but would've been better if actually baked in the sauce that came on the side so a bit dry as a result. And the rack of lamb, was suppose to be medium rare as the server stated. But only 1 of the 5 ribs was medium rare, the rest were past medium. Presentation of the rack also not even appetizing. The key lime pie with the homemade marshmallow was suprisingly good though. But not returning, sorry. read more

Everything was wonderful. The food was great, lots of flavor and cooked perfectly. The service was fast and friendly. read more

Came here on a weeknight with my bf. Parking in the area is a little hard but he found somewhere to park a couple blocks down. The place itself is tight and small, the tables are close to one another. We sat in the outside area and had a nice server. We ordered the Conch Carpaccio, the Artichoke Aphrodisiac and the Escargot a la Bourguignon. We enjoyed all of these appetizers a lot. The Artichoke Aphrodisiac sauce was really good. The conch carpaccio was fresh and delicious and the escargots were good. Will definitely want to come back and try more items off the menu but so far we enjoyed what we had here! read more

See all

Great Hog snapper specialty of the house. Beautiful setting and service was pretty good. Definitely worth a visit! read more

Cafe Sole - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Get the hogfish! We have eaten everywhere on the island, literally and this is hands down our favorite. Far away from the crowd where the food has to shine. And it does. Lots of outdoor seating which is always nice when the weather cooperates. We always love our meals here. Vibes are immaculate. read more

See all

This place is off the beaten path in Old Town Key West. It is definitely worth the walk. We sat on the patio, which was well lit and private (we were the first people there). Not only did we get seated right away, they brought us the best hummus I have ever had. My husband does not like hummus, he tried it though, and absolutely loved it. (picture to follow). I had the stone crab claws (2) and cream of mushroom soup which both were amazing. The only thing I did not like about the soup was the peppercorn's. Otherwise, it was the best mushroom soup with Asiago cheese I have ever experienced. My husband had the linguini and clams. I have to give our server credit, she did tell him the clams were tiny and quite a bit of work, and she was very honest! We will definitely return. read more

Still one of our very favorite places in Key West. Great food and ambience! Hogfish is their specialty and it lives up to its hype. I always say I'm going to try another entree but, when push comes to shove, I order the hogfish.`Many wonderful appetizers to try. read more

Café Sole is a cute little restaurant with the perfect romantic vibes--cozy, intimate, and just the right spot for a relaxed evening in Key West. Hands down, they serve the BEST Key lime pie in town. We always order two slices to enjoy right at the bar, plus a whole pie to take home. The pie's texture is rich and creamy, and the sweet meringue topping isn't overpowering--it perfectly balances the slight tartness of the lime filling. Honestly, it's addictive! This visit we tried some apps too--the clam linguini was flavorful and fresh, and the lobster bisque was rich and satisfying with generous chunks of lobster. The bartender recommended a lovely glass of Riesling that paired beautifully with our seafood dishes. The staff were friendly and attentive, which made the whole experience even better. We're definitely coming back next time for dinner to try more from the menu! If you're in Key West, don't miss Café Solé--and definitely don't leave without trying that Key lime pie! read more

See all

We had an excellent meal on Thanksgiving night at this charming restaurant on the romantic walled in open air patio. Unique take on fois gras to start then I had the Hogfish (which melted in your mouth just like our waiter Max said it would) and hubby had the Thanksgiving plate which was surprisingly fantastic! Oh and the KLP! Wow. We had a lovely time and would return. They offer wine by the glass in the teeny waiting area which was a unique and nice touch. Merci Cafe Sole! read more

Cafe Sole - This key lime pie with amaretto laced Chantilly cream was divine! - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

We had our last dinner in Key West at Cafe Sole! It's hidden off the beaten path on a quiet street and it is the perfect spot for a romantic date night and some of the most delicious food! We ordered the stone crab claw clusters and the special shrimp ceviche for appetizers and they were both delicious! For dinner we had their speciality the Hogfish & I got the fruit of the sea (seafood pasta) the angel hair was cooked perfectly and the fish was some of the best we have ever eaten. The service was great, they have a huge wine selection and got the dessert trio which was a perfect combo of crème brûlée (our favorite) key lime pie and pecan pie and ice cream! Highly recommend this place for dinner! read more

See all

We had Cafe Sole recommended to us by two different locals touting the duck as outstanding. Cute little cafe well off Duval with a covered & walled patio as well as inside and on street tables. Our server, Allan, was very helpful and friendly. Great wine list by the glass, as well as bottles. Almost every bottle was available by the glass. (Note: they do NOT have a full bar) We started with the Beet and goat cheese with arugula and raspberry truffle vinaigrette salad. The kitchen was kind enough to split it for us to share. This salad was outstanding. The flavors melded so well, and you could taste the truffle (but you weren't gone to burp it up for the next 12 hours, haha) My husband got their specialty, the Hogfish snapper Sole which was very tender with a wonderfully rich hollandaise sauce. It was served with mashed potatoes, risotto, carrots and beans (Lima beans?) I got the Duck a L'orange, which was delicious. It was 2 drumsticks & thighs. The first one was cooked PERFECTLY, though the second one on the plate was overdone and dry - but still great flavor. The l'orange sauce had a nice spice to it. It was served with asparagus and broccolini, mashed potatoes and a roasted tomato. We would have tried the desserts (they looked very good), but we had to meet folks elsewhere. Definitely a place to try if you want to get away from Duvall street. Make a reservation! read more

See all

Disappointing . I've been telling all my friends that this is the best in town. Tonight it was not. Service was bad. Food was less than expected from previous experiences. . Everything has gone down hill. I had the scallops and they were half the size of what they usually serve and they were topped with two little dried shrimp that could have been jerky. The pate was half the portion from last time which was a few months ago. I believe a change has been made and it's for the worst in my opinion. read more

Back to Café Sole, and it was just as amazing as the first time! The service was spot on super friendly, and made us feel right at home. The cozy welcoming vibe sets the perfect mood, but it's the food that truly steals the show. Every dish is packed with flavor and creativity just unforgettable. We'll definitely be back to Café Sole season after season! read more

See all

Welcome to France in KW. The food is excellent, the pace is slow (although the staff is hustling) and the setting is romantic and cozy. The idea is to actually feel like you're in France so don't come in expecting anything less than the full experience. Lots of Europeans dining here on the nights we've been in. Order a bottle of wine (excellent selection) and have a coffee with dessert! We had the signature portobello mushroom soup, arugula salad and the hogfish specials of the house--all outstanding. The scallops and duck are also wonderful. Everyone around us was raving about their food (and the dining area is packed so you will hear everyone's thoughts!). We tried the key lime pie (loved the marshmallow topping!) and it is different and magical. Service was excellent. One word of caution: chairs are hard for a long dinner so grab a pillow off the benches--it helps! read more

A fantastic shrimp scampi I will never forget. Everything about Sole was equally beautiful and delicious. The outdoor seating we had was charming and majestic with a very classy appeal. It gave off an intimate vibe despite the amount of seating. My beef carpaccio had a thinly cut freshness that was a good teaser for the rest of my meal. My highlight was my shrimp scampi that I couldn't give enough praise for. I'd go back here just to order this again. The noodles absorbed the sum of its parts so well with the oil and sauce. I don't know how else to describe how it tasted so good. I really enjoyed the key lime pie as well. I found torching the cream on top slightly unnecessary, the cake itself along with the graham cracker crust more than made up for it (which honestly didn't really need to be made up for.) The staff was exceptional as well. We didn't have to wait long for service and everything came as expected. They gave us good wine recommendations as well. read more

See all

I've been to Cafe Sole before, and they didn't disappoint this time. Wife got the beet salad with truffle oil who b she thought was great. Both of us got the hogfish which is spectacular (their specialty). Their wine list is very good. Highly recommended! read more

Had dinner here Saturday night 7/22. Service was top notch. Atmosphere was very nice. We had 2 orders of French Onion soup. Way too heavy on the sherry. 1 order of lobster bisque that was absolutely amazing. Filet Mignon was superb, the duck L'orange was superb as well. The mashed potatoes were awesome. My wife had the Saganaki for her entree and she said it was good. Desert was Key Lime pie topped with meringue. You could barely taste the lime flavor. We did enjoy our meal. It's definitely worth a try for other newcomers. read more

See all

This was our first time here and they are only open for dinner. My wife had the wedge salad, lobster bisque and the hogfish - she savored every bite. I had the baby clams and the snapper, which was equally as good. Very romantic place to take someone to, as it's a little dark, candlelit and you feel you have your own personal space to have a conversation. The service here is super friendly, extremely responsive - never had to wait for anything. We certainly will come back here the next time we are in Key West. If you haven't been, it's worth looking into. read more

See all

This place is amazing! A very intimate atmosphere with a few tables inside and a few more outside. Our server was fantastic and informative about the dishes. Everything we got for food was amazing, the fish was fresh, the lobster bisque was amazing and the key lime pie fantastic. They only serve wine and beer no cocktails but they have a good selection. A great date night spot as it's super quiet and cute inside. Amazing place! read more

See all

I arrived with a party of 6, immediately was unpleasantly greeted with my service dog. We were given two different waiters without an explanation. I had to request a refill on drinks, the waitress at the time wasn't keeping accountability of our drinks. The first beer I ordered game with a cold glass, the second beer was delivered but the old glass was left at the table, as the same as the original glass. food delivery took approximately 1 hour. Out of the 5 entries that were ordered, 5 were delivered on time. When the waitress only delivered 5, she walked away with not saying when the last entrie would be delivered. 3/4 of the way of dinner service, no drinks were offered Pasta was bathed on oil, had no real flavor. Muscles and clams were dry and almost non existent. read more

Cafe Sole - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

We waited an hour for our entre. Customers that came after us received their meals before us. We walked out and our order still wasn't ready. read more

We made reservations in advance at an early hour, 5:30 (they open at 5) as we had an event to attend and we were promptly seated. The restaurant was better than half full and I can imagine that they just kept getting busier. Warm, French style bread with an herbed compound type butter followed our being seated along with drink and food menus. The wine menu is extensive. My husband ordered two appetizers for dinner so as to save room for key lime pie; French onion soup and a pear/blue cheese salad. The salad was very large and he was unable/unwilling to finish it lol. The soup was very hot, thick and tasty. I ordered the diver scallops with shrimp. They were beautifully presented and cooked perfectly. They came with a bearnaise sauce and were accompanied by mashed potatoes, beans (fava?), shredded sweetened carrots, rice and tomato Provençal. Of the four items, i tried them all but I only ate the carrots. I may have been missing something but the sides were very bland. The key lime pie was gorgeously presented and an unusual take from the traditional pie. It was delicious. The staff were very attentive and friendly and the rest rooms were clean. I am glad that we came and would like to try again. read more

See all

We came here for a Valentine's dinner and upon arriving, we advised the gentleman at the host stand that we had reservations, when he couldn't find them, we checked our cell phone app to learn that we inadvertently made reservations at the wrong "Café Sole" as the one we selected was in Jupiter, FL, not Key West... Oops! They were packed and had a long line waiting as well, so we thought we were out of luck, then he suggested it would be an hour wait, but he could fit us in, which we would willingly accept. Or, he said we could sit at their bar! Yes, they have a very small, two-person bar, but it was beautiful, quaint and perfect for our V-Day dinner! From the moment we sat down, all the staff who engaged us were very friendly and helpful! They have a very nice winelist, so we selected a nice bottle and then I noticed they were pouring a lot of Caymus and when I asked, I learned that it was only $25/glass, so I opted for one of those too! We started our dinner with the stone crab claws, which are a fair deal at $50 for 2 medium size claws. The meat was buttery and tasty! I got a bowl of their gazpacho, which was very enjoyable and slightly on the chunky side, but I enjoyed the texture. Their bread and spread for the bread was very nice and that spread is like a bold, herbed garlic with EVOO - really tasty. The gazpacho also has a heavy presence of garlic, again something I enjoyed. The wife got their beet salad and she loved every bite of it! For our entrées, we both got fish; I got the Grouper and she got the Hog Fish and both were prepared perfectly! The lima beans and mashed potatoes that came with both dishes were very flavorful! These entrées were huge, I had a tough time finishing mine, which is probably the first time I've not eaten all my fish! Overall, this was a very enjoyable experience and an excellent dinner... Highly recommend stopping in, but make reservations! read more

See all

We ordered four appetizers which were all home runs. ANGELS ON HORSE BACK, BAKED ARTICHOKES APHRODISIAC, SAGANAKI, TUNA "TATAKI". I ordered the GAZPACHO DE MADRID for my soup it was fantastic! Main course was BABY CLAMS WITH GARLIC, WHITE WINE, PARSLEY AND CRUSHED RED PEPPER OVER ANGEL HAIR PASTA. For my daughter. My wife had the RACK OF LAMB, and my two sons had the HOG SNAPPER ~CHEF CORREA'S AWARD WINNING DISH I ordered the DUCK A L`ORANGE DUCKLING ROASTED TO PERFECTION WITH OUR CLASSIC ORANGE SAUCE MADE WITH FRESH ORANGE JUICE AND DEMI-GLAZE. Dessert, my daughter and I both ordered dessert. My daughter ordered the Keylime pie, which was wonderful, and I ordered the passionfruit flan which was the evenings special. Service was professional with a warm welcoming feeling. Our overall experience is a positive one, and we plan on returning. Ambiance is truly memorable and executed perfectly with a natural great taste in design inside and out. Love this place. If you want to wow your significant other, bring them here. Wine list is amazing too, even though I do not drink any longer, my family does. read more

See all

It's wonderful. Great food and amazing service. The hogfish is the dish! I do love the stone crabs too.

wholeheartedly recommend.Cafe Solé is hands-down my favorite restaurant in Key West. It's the kind of place that keeps you coming back with its incredible food and charming atmosphere. If you're a fan of Hogfish (or even if you've never tried it), this is the spot to indulge. Their Hogfish is simply the best--light, delicate, buttery, and packed with flavor. It's a dish that alone makes the visit worth it. While the vegetables don't stand out and are more of a supporting act, the main dishes more than make up for it. Surprisingly, even the beet salad is a must-try--even for those who don't usually like beets. And if seafood isn't your thing, their ribeye steak is also a solid choice, cooked to perfection and satisfying in every way. The ambiance is a delightful mix of romantic and casual, making it suitable for a date night or a relaxed dinner with friends. Seating is a bit tight, and you'll likely find yourself close to neighboring tables, but it's part of the charm--just enough space for a muted conversation while still enjoying the intimate vibe. Their wine list is fantastic, offering a great selection to pair with their excellent food. Service is top-notch, with attentive and knowledgeable staff who make the experience even better. If you're in Key West, Cafe Solé is an absolute must. From the standout Hogfish to the warm atmosphere, it's a dining experience you won't forget. Don't miss it! read more

Our favorite spot in Key West to eat little fishies! We were told that they were a local favorite.. and they weren't wrong! They had amazing fish.. awesome steak, pate and foie gras! I'm convinced that you can't find a bad item in the menu. The only thing that we regret not trying was their key lime pie. We took particular note of it when the lady next to literally moaned with eyes closed with every bite, to the point that I feared parents would have to cover their child's ears whilst she moaned in ecstasy. Needless to say, my wife in particular is demanding we go back to try it. I'm slightly confused by her sense of urgency.. however shall comply! For more food place tips, IG: @Sarasota_Foodie_Couple read more

See all

This was our favorite place from our trip to Key West. Everything was amazing. The food was unbelievable from our mushroom soup to entrees to the wine. My husband got the duck and the hog snapper was the best fish dish I've ever eaten. Our waiter Alan was friendly, informative and knew everything about the menu. You can tell this place has a master chef. The ambiance was intimate and oh so comfortable. Every trip to the Key West should include Cafe Sole. read more

Cafe Sole - Key Lime Pie - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

The service was excellent, the food was nicely presented, but the food was mediocre. We enjoyed the dinner, but unlikely to return.

The experience was okay for the price. The ambiance was nice as it was half outside with fans and had low lighting. The oysters were very fresh and good even without cocktail sauce. The soups were a little bit salty especially the french onion soup. when hot, the lobster bisque was not as salty. the ingram salad was really good but not that much pear. we got the caviar service which was pretty good and was a good amount but we also asked for more bread with it. we probably wouldn't get the caviar again though. the bread and hummus they have is also very unique and tasty we kept eating it. The hogfish was great and very buttery. can understand why it's their signature dish. The scallops were a little rubbery and not seared. the sides were interesting and kinda not cohesive in my opinion. there was carrots beans potatoes and rice. We got the lamb without the truffle and it was still very good. the pasta dishes are the best--highly recommend them. we got the baby clams appetizer and the fruit of the sea. i preferred the baby clams because it has a bit of a kick with the pepper flakes. the dessert was amazing. the best keylime pie i've had so far the marshmallow really balanced the tartness of the lime. the almond whipped cream really elevated the desserts. the chocolate pecan pie was my favorite though. the bananas foster was also really good and not too bitter from the alcohol. read more

See all

The hogfish was amazing! They are known for this dish and it does not disappoint. Restaurant has small family vibes and feels homey. The staff was very attentive to us the entire evening. read more

This restaurant is truly for discerning diner. It has a fairly broad menu with something for every pallet, from beef to fish and even duck. Appetizers at our table included carpaccio made with beef or conch, escargot, fresh fillet of anchovies, and beet salad. All perfectly prepared. For dinners I had the restaurant speciality, breaded hogfish with an array of vegetables and rice. Other plates included the swordfish special and the scallop under shrimp with a truffle hollandaise sauce. Again, all prepared to perfection. The menu included pastas with fresh seafood, and flank steaks, both tempting but for another night. They only serve two kinds of beer but they do have an extensive wine list, no other alcohol. Lastly, the place offers a nice selection of desserts but I had, because it's Key West, their key lime pie which was some of the best I ever tasted with a marshmallow frosting and a delicate finish as opposed to a hard bitter end. Definitely recommend it. Bull for 4 with wine and dessert was $400 plus tip. read more

A hidden gem in Key West! A great little place with terrific food and great service! Our server, Allen, was professional, friendly and helped my dining companions choose from amongst the many delicious menu items and specials. Wholeheartedly recommend this place! read more

We dined here for the first time last week; it will not be our last! We had a very enjoyable experience. The food was amazing, the wait staff attentive without being intrusive and the atmosphere was comfortable with the noise level at a minimum allowing us to enjoy our conversation. We will recommend it to our friends and family. read more

Delicious fish with very pleasant atmosphere! Was not thrilled with the dog sitting at the table next to us! Apparently this is very accepted in Key West. read more

First time at Cafe Sole we order Grouper Romesco & filet mignon callwas 5 Star !" Great service and enjoyed our dinner. read more

See all

The place is out of the way and quiet. Tables were too close in my opinion for a romantic dinner. Food was fantastic and service was excellent. I would strongly recommend this place. read more

The first time I visited Key West, well over a decade ago, I went to Cafe Sole. And I continue to come here from time to time. It's never going to blow your socks off, but it's always going to provide good service and a familiar menu. It is an intimate dining experience, the staff will always treat you well, and the seafood is tasty. There are better places, but there is a good reason that this place survives. People like it. read more