How in the world have I lived on the UWS for this long without trying Bustan? If I had to choose (and it's really really hard to choose...food indecision is so real) I'd say Mediterranean food is my favorite cuisine. So Bustan had been on my list for some time. After dining here on Thursday night, I can report with full confidence that Bustan is a solid spot and worth a visit if you're in the area.
Bustan is a pretty versatile spot in terms of occasion. I happened to come here with a girlfriend but it's a totally viable option for a date as well. Dim lighting (at least around dinnertime, I know this is a popular brunch spot too), beautiful interior (sleek/classy but not too fancy) and great allocation of space considering the front half of the restaurant is on the narrow side. Overall, it's more sophisticated feel in comparison to all that surrounds it (Meatball Shop, Jacob's Pickles, Celeste, etc.). Small plates/dips are more than half the menu, so I'd say sharing is encouraged (though I literally say that in every review). In terms of logistics, I made a rez on OpenTable. We came here at 8 and the place was pretty busy, so I'd recommend making a reservation beforehand if you're intolerant of not being able to sit down right away (no judgment, it's New York, I get it).
We didn't break into the drink menu at all, but I can at least report that Bustan has a solid wine list (as many Mediterranean spots do) as well as some solid beer and cocktail options. If you're in the mood for a cocktail, I'd ask about some of their infused liquors--had I been in the mood to drink I would've opted for a fig-infused vodka drink. Now how bad could that be?
Foodwise this menu is just straight up Mediterranean. You've got plenty of dip options, a generous selection of small plates with a good number of entrees as well, tons of seafood and frequent use of feta, yogurt, dill, chickpeas, olives, etc. The friend I was with thankfully has very similar food affinities so we got a pretty stellar sampling. Our eats, below:
Trio of Dips (Hummus, Baba Ghanoush and Taramasalata) with (unreal) homemade focaccia: A
This focaccia was on another level, my God. For starters, it came out steaming and warm--as fresh as it gets. The only issue here was that the bread-to-dip ratio here was subpar. We finished the focaccia with plenty of dip left and this was us being as carb-ically conservative as possible. But don't worry, you can always order more. Dip-wise, it's hard to pick a favorite. I read a few reviews that said the hummus was pretty meh, but I loved it. I'm a sucker for extra texture (think chunky peanut butter/pulpy orange juice) and the hummus, along with some whole chickpeas mixed in, also had some nice nuttiness going on. Pine nuts maybe? In any case, it made the hummus for me. The baba ghanoush was also fantastic--super flavorful and rich. I suppose that leaves the taramasalata as my least favorite, but I still enjoyed it. Least best is a better term, I suppose.
Grilled Roasted Eggplant with zhoung, pine nuts, fresh crushed tomatoes, zaatar, tahini and mint: B+
The ingredients/preparation looked promising but the execution here fell short for me. It wasn't *bad*but I found the flavor to be lacking overall. Am I a Top Chef judge yet? Don't worry South Park, I don't think I'm a real food critic. Anyway, the eggplant was fine but probably my least favorite dish of the night. The pine nuts added some nice texture I guess but that's grasping straws a bit. Call it a poor man's eggplant parm (or just a healthier alternative to eggplant parm).
Charred Octopus with white bean masabacha, spiced crushed tomato, herb tahini, frisee and sumac pickled onion salad and cilantro oil: A-
If there's octopus on a menu, I will almost always order it. It's certainly in the running for my favorite food. This octopus, though far from the best I've ever had, was still solid. And the preparation was not only aesthetically gorgeous but also interested, varied and flavorful. The beans, frisee and onions were worthy accompaniments and the cilantro oil was a beautiful, unique touch. The octopus itself was cooked decently but not fantastic. The outside could've been a touch crispier and it was softer than I typically like. Other than my extreme snobbiness around octopus, I found this dish to be wonderful and very thoughtful.
Calamari a la Plancha stuffed w/ spicy feta, citrus salad, olives and yogurt mint sauce: A
This was a serious home run. I'm sure people are stuffing calamari (in the culinary sense, at least) all over the place, but this was the first time I had tried it. And man, was it a slam dunk. How many sports cliches can I fit into a paragraph before getting my point across? The answer is a lot. Like the octopus, the preparation here was beautiful. The calamari was yummy and paired well with the feta. And overall, the flavors were fresh and varied. The yogurt/mint sauce was light and fluffy and was super tasty with the citrus. Order it. read more