Everything at Amali is great, and the price isn't too bad for NYC. Started with the octopus, which was great, and ended up getting pastas for our meals. All the pasta was homemade and delicious. The service was good and the place was very cozy and cute. read more

Amali - Tagliolini - Mediterranean Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Tiny portion, over salted shrimp, overprice, def better options around. Nothing special. read more

Amali - Shrimp salad - Mediterranean Near Me - New York, New York

This place is super cute! It's kind of small but I love how cozy and intimate it was. My friend and I came for happy hour and sat at the bar. We got: - persimmon spritz: I actually do enjoy the actual persimmon fruit so I wanted to try this. It was refreshing and not too sweet - Aperol spritz: This was a solid Aperol spritz - Coppa which came with bread, feta butter, fried olives: nice to share! Feta butter was yummy. Shoutout to José who was super lovely and recommended the coppa to us! read more

See all

My 19 year old son took me out for dinner at Amali on 60th in Manhattan. It was my first time trying Mediterranean food. The place has a nice upscale vibe, but it still felt welcoming. Our waiter was super polite and kept our water glasses full the whole time. We had the fingerling potatoes to start, with French bread and a garlic butter spread. For the entree we both had the chicken and rice with feta--everything was really flavorful. I also tried crème brûlée for the first time, and it was amazing! Even though I wasn't familiar with the menu, I ended up loving everything. A little pricey, but worth it for the experience. read more

See all

3.6/3.7 overall. Quite expensive for the food you get and the lengthy wait didn't help. Twice they handed me a dish that an acquaintance ordered instead and then a nearly an additional hour wait to receive a prosciutto sandwich and fries. Nothing to really complain about the food I ordered. Also complementary bread with feta butter. read more

Amali - Mediterranean Near Me - New York, New York

I recently booked a private event here, and it was an absolute disaster. This was my second time hosting/visiting, and after a mediocre first experience, I was asked to come back and decided to give them another chance. Big mistake. This time was significantly worse. A few major issues from our event: Awful Customer Service: The General Manager treated my team like trash and acted as if we were beneath them. The sheer disrespect and rudeness from the management team were shocking. Poor Facility Maintenance: The ceiling was literally leaking water onto one of my guests during the event. Disorganized Policy: We reserved the space for an hour before our event to set up, yet they refused to let my guests inside until 5 minutes before the start time, leaving everyone waiting outside. For a place that handles private bookings, their lack of professionalism and basic hospitality is unacceptable. I will never bring my business back here, and I strongly warn anyone else against booking an event with them. Save your money and go somewhere where you and your guests will actually be respected read more

Came for brunch and thought the food was just average. Appreciate the warm bread and butter service. Food, however, is on the saltier side. Got the carbonara pasta and shrimp salad. The shrimp on the salad was a bit heavily salted but the citrus in the dressing balanced it a little. I did like the zest of the dressing - but it may be a bit too sour for some. I would not order the pasta again but I wouldn't mind having the salad again. read more

Amali - Mediterranean Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Laura Geller Beauty knows how to delight her beauty influencers. One way is to treat them to a fabulous meal at Amali, a great restaurant with all the right perks. Amali NYC provided excellent service in a room full of excited, talkative people excited about the holiday festivities and connected with many familiar social media personalities, including some of the Housewives of New Jersey. A night to remember with photo pops, Laura Geller Beauty gift bags, and a new product personalized with your name in calligraphy. An excellent Italian festive holiday dinner in NYC cheers to Amali for a wonderful holiday celebration to remember. read more

Amali - Beauty Guru Laura Geller with beauty influencers - Mediterranean Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My friend and I were shopping in the area when we got caught in the rain and decided to find a nearby spot for lunch. We stumbled upon Amali and chose it because they offered a lunch tasting menu. The restaurant is small, chic, and cozy the perfect little escape. When we arrived, there were three tables seated. It took the host a moment to greet us as he was tidying up, and our server took a bit longer than expected to come over, but once things started rolling, service was pleasant. We started with a signature cocktail, Every Rose has its Thorn (margarita) which was perfect! A tropical escape in a glass. They brought out bread with feta butter, which was so good! For lunch, we both chose the $39 tasting menu. I ordered the octopus and salmon salad, while my friend had the spicy feta with steak and eggs. The octopus was nicely charred, and the feta was flavorful with a sweet-savory balance. The salmon was grilled nicely, though the salad itself was underwhelming for the price. My friend enjoyed her steak and potatoes. We also tried orange wine and a Hugo spritz. My first time having one, and it was so refreshing it might just be my new favorite drink! Overall, Amali is a lovely, cozy spot a nice little find on a rainy NYC afternoon. read more

Decent Mediterranean restaurant-- good but not great. We both ordered the lunch tasting course menus. - Soup of the day: 9/10 (pretty good squash soup with hints of curry! It was very warming on a cold day.) - Skirt steak: 9/10 (pretty decent steak with huge portion sizes) - Duck: 7/10 (I was expecting more of a grilled duck steak and not a sandwich. Overall, the duck was a bit lacking in flavor.) Ambiance was very cozy and cute and service was good. read more

Amali - Soup of the day - Mediterranean Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Good, not great. Came for brunch on my birthday and had a good experience. The shakshuka was very good, it could have used a little more flavor and it came out a bit too hot but besides that it was very good, the dip we got was phenomenal. Great service and very cute ambiance. read more

See all

Amali is a true neighborhood gem. Greek inspired with a NYC vibe. Pastas are cooked Al Dente Fish are perfectly cooked, which may take some time Burger is delicious Service is attentive despite challenging configuration of the restaurant (back room, terrace, upstairs room.) Quality has been consistent for 10+ years and I hope it will continue for the next 10 years. read more

DELICIOUS! Best restaurant we ate at in the city our whole trip. The service was amazing and they were very attentive and kind. The ambiance is very cool and chill. The restaurant is very pretty and not loud. We walked by it and decided to try it out and I am so glad we did. We ordered the mushroom appetizer which was my favorite. We also ordered the feta appetizer and I do not love feta and this was delicious! For our mains we shared a burger and got broccoli and cauliflower on the side. The sides had the perfect flavor and were cooked perfectly and the burger was also amazing with the fries. Highly recommend coming here! read more

Amali - Mushroom appetizer and Spicy Feta - Mediterranean Near Me - New York, New York

RATING: 7.8/10 PRO TIP: Was able to seat us on a Friday at 7pm right away, though it got crowded quick. If you choose the pasta, get the cavatelli, trust me. You probs haven't heard of this place but you'll be pleasantly surprised. The bread that they give you is fresh, coated with sesame seeds and comes with a delicious spread we couldn't get more of. Surprised to say the least. CAVATELLI Of the pasta options available, I elected for this one while my friend got the pappardelle and we both agreed this one was better. It was PERFECTLY al dente and had this nice bouncy chewiness to it, with the savory meatiness of the lamb and a little smokiness as well. It was a really good dish and I was pleasantly surprised. They have a pretty large drink menu too and you'll be able to find something you like. For me, I like sweet drinks/cocktails so I feel like I was really happy with my choices. The ambience is busy, a little elevated, but the dining room is def packed; you are just inches away from other tables. Nice space otherwise. Service was attentive. FINAL CATEGORY: GREAT (terrible / bad / ok / good / GREAT / excellent) read more

See all

First time at this Mediterranean restaurant, host and wait staff very nice, room was nicely decorated but the lighting could have been a little brighter so we could see the delicious food that was being served but the room was very inviting and comfortable for a night out. Had the grilled clams, the breadcrumbs were nicely toasted on top of delicious local clams in orange butter. For the entree, I had the red snapper served on Moroccan rice wrapped in grape leaves. The fish was nicely prepared and very tender. read more

Amali - Grilled Roasted LI Clams - Mediterranean Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I am so glad my friend told me about this restaurant!  There were 4 of us on a Friday night for dinner, I believe only one person in our party had been there before.  Apparently they have new menu items since the last time she was there.  It was full for dinner in the main room by the time we left, plus the back room was full with at least one very large group. There's an upstairs area that can be used for private events but we didn't have a chance to take a look.  There are also a couple of small tables outside. Convenient location, lovely space, delicious creative house cocktails (with cool names!), delicious and beautifully presented food (and good portions!). The staff was attentive and friendly and helpful.  They have an extensive wine list and were able to answer questions/make suggestions to those of us having wine. If I were to label the cuisine, I would say "upscale Mediterranean." According to Amali's website the menu reflects the historical cuisines shared by modern day Greece, Italy, France, and Spain.  Note their service model (which is mentioned in the beginning of their menu) - they include an 18% hospitality surcharge in order to pay their staff above-market wages for service workers. To drink I had the "October in Astoria" because I was in a bourbon mood.  It was really great! My friend prefers gin and had the "Easy Virtue". The 4 of us shared everything - started with the autumn squash hummus and roasted sunchokes. For mains  - we were told when we first sat down that there were only two ducks left so we reserved one. It is on the menu as "entrees for two" but it would easily be enough for 4 people if you also share an appetizer or two. The spice roasted duck was PHENOMENAL and unlike any preparation of duck any of us had eaten before.  It includes spiced duck plus duck kofta (made from the duck leg?), plus homemade pancakes and veggies and jalapeno yogurt sauce on the side.  As a main it comes with two sides - we chose the fingerling potatoes (prepared crispy and way better than we expected!) and the brussels sprouts. - apparently some of the fresh pastas on the menu are new.  We decided to go with the short rib cappelletti - it melts in the mouth OMG. After that much food (the duck was a large portion!) we unfortunately did not have room for dessert. read more

See all

The food was delicious. I had the branzino. Perfection! Also my friend and I split the carrot hummus- also delicious. I highly recommend this Mediterranean restaurant read more

Amali - Canary Islands Branzino - Mediterranean Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I had my small group baby shower in the Fireplace room. Food was amazing, and the Enzo who managed serving helping hosting my shower was a great help and very kind. My guests all enjoyed the great dishes and ambience of the restaurant. My bill was ended up higher than expected, but it was definitely worth spending for good food, service and ambience of the restaurant. read more

Amali - My Baby shower was amazing! - Mediterranean Near Me - New York, New York

The restaurant experience is excellent. Their dishes show care in appearance and flavor. The workers have called me by name since my initial visit and remain constantly attentive. Their offerings surpass all others. This spot has proven itself and I tell others! read more

Had a great experience at this intimate spot grabbing dinner with friends. There is a full bar right when you walk in where you can grab a drink while waiting for your party. The sommelier was very helpful in helping us pick a wine. Great service experience!! I'm regards to the food, the 3 apps we got were all incredible (whipped feta, octopus, and brussels and squash). The octopus even has spicy sausage in it which I high recommend. For mains we got the Truffle Tagliatelle from the special truffle menu which I really enjoyed as it was light for a truffle dish. The halibut unfortunately was tasteless. I would not get that again but everything else was quite flavorful! I would love to come back and try more read more

See all

Great food and great service. We loved the restaurant and it's super cozy. We will definitely be back.

I really wanted to like Amali, I REALLY did. Quaint on the outside, chic on the inside. This small restaurant decorated very cute with lights and greenery. The staff were fantastic, everyone very kind. Everyone greets you coming in, and leaving! They even give workers a living wage by adding 18% automatic gratuity/service fee to your bill--a practice where I haven't seen so far spelled out in most NYC restaurants. Great for the workers! I was not too much a fan of the sesame bread and whipped feta (but I think that has to do with my own taste). The bread came warm, was easy to break apart. Sesame everywhere! Haha The feta came in on a stone coaster--which, love the idea cause it was a good portion (gonna do that from now on!) Spanish octopus was excellent--perfect amount of char, flavor, smokiness. The snap peas and potatoes cooked to perfection, and tinged with a nice acidity as well. So far so good! Well, sadly that's where everything else fell short. For our entrees, we had the Agnolotti del plin (like baby ravioli) with Lobster and Black Truffle. The pasta was very soft, very likely to be made in-house. The lobster was seasoned perfectly, very buttery, and you got a good amount--seemed like 2 claws worth. However when you bite into the agnolotti--I could not handle the sweetness of it all. This may be just ME or some people like me, but I am the type of person who does NOT like the blatant mix of sweet vs savory (sorry chicken & waffle and McGriddle lovers)--ESPECIALLY when you are not expecting it. I guess I was missing the part where a server explains to you how the meal is and how it tastes--because from now on, now I have been scarred and now have to ask how something tastes because of this. It would be one thing if the menu said so, but I truly wasn't expecting it. Gave it to a nice homeless man outside. As for the tagliatelle, once again the pasta was very soft, cooked well--but there was a hint of "staleness" in the meat in every bite. Some bites worse than others, but the flavor was there. Maybe not too many people order it, or maybe oxtail has to be cooked a very long time to get rid of the gamey-ness? Idk. We were just a bit let down is all. Again, just my opinion on things, maybe the people who like sweet+savory will think I'm insane, but alas. Taste is taste and can't do anything about that. But otherwise, we will definitely go back for that Spanish Octopus and wonderful service! read more

See all

Super cute restaurant that offers fresh Mediterranean cuisine. We stopped by on a Sunday evening and were seated right away with no reservation. From the squash hummus to the chickpea burger, everything I ate was tasty and flavorful. The dressing that was on the side salad with my chickpea burger deserves its own accolade because it was absolutely delicious. Those that were dining with me also enjoyed their meals (the burger & the cavatelli). Service was friendly but we did have to track down a waiter when we were ready to pay since they had all seemed to disappear at once. Other than that, I would recommend giving this place a try! read more

See all

Cozy restaurant with great food and attentive staff. Because the restaurant is somewhat small, it can get very loud. The spaghetti alla chitarra and basque cheesecake were my favorites. read more

See all

Wow- we had dinner at Amali and it was excellent. The service was perfect, ambiance lovely and the food was amazing. We had smoked squash labneh which was served with a grilled flatbread. We ordered 2 pasta dishes and a side of broccoli - it was all delicious. We hated for our meal to end. Definitely coming back! read more

Great interiors had the burger and the Caesar (it was too dressed). Olives were great as a starter.

The octopus and pasta were great! the service was great, ambiance is really nice. However, there was an unexpected little mouse running around read more

See all

Went ther for lunch was sat by the bar hostess never came back too busy attending a party had one drink and left after waiting 39 min no time for lunch wanted yo make this a usual spot won't be doing that no apology nothing my company has had an event there we will be skipping that my coworker and I couldn't believe the lack of customer service too bad cause we work right across the street read more

It's restaurants like these that make me wish I lived in NYC! We were visiting NY and popped into Amali for some light bites and cocktails during the day. It was around brunch time, so the restaurant was pretty busy, but the hostess confirmed we were able to sit at the bar (we were a party of 4). We ordered a few rounds of cocktails and a few appetizers while we were here. The Whipped Feta and Charcuterie were two of our favorites. Well balanced in flavor and overall, very fresh! The cocktails were refreshing, light and flavorful- just what we needed. My personal favorite was the Red Lantern; featuring tequila, pomegranate, lemon, egg white, and bitters - YUM! I'm not sure what it is, but the frothy-ness of the egg white is just so delicious in a cocktail. While we didn't have a table, we didn't mind and really enjoyed sitting at the bar so we could engage with the bartender (super friendly) and watch her hand-craft our drinks. The overall ambience of Amali is great. It's cozy, not super loud, and seems like a great spot to meet friends for a delicious brunch. We got lucky, but I'd recommend booking a reservation (or coming in a small party and hope for a seat at the bar). They have so many other menu items that we all were drooling over, but had dinner plans elsewhere that evening. Definitely looking forward to our next visit to NYC to visit Amali! read more

See all

Had a chill dinner here with a friend and was in for a fun surprise. The service is excellent and food was above average. We ordered a few apps and and one entree the whipped feta was probably my favorite. the bread it came with however was very hard the burrata was also quite savory. the vegetable it came with (snap peas but cut up) added an interesting texture that in wasn't a fan of together with the burrata but separate it was a party! also ordered the potato based spread which by the way its described we expected cut up potatoes but we got a puree which was good just surprising the pasta was really nothing special but the serving was so big i couldnt finish it would definitely recommend but probably would not return :) read more

Amali - Spaghetti alla Chitarra - Mediterranean Near Me - New York, New York

See all

While it pains me to write this review, Its necessary to expose the illegal conduct this restaurant is engaged in (18% admin fee). Surcharges like this are illegal in the state of new york When walking in we were greeted by a friendly host. We were seated in a timely manner and service throughout the meal was consistent. Although pricey the quality of the food justified the cost. Things took a turn south when the bill arrived. We were uncomfortable to bring it up to our excellent server but when we got home found out the owner acknowledges this is an illegal practice on a news report. We understand his good intention to pay his employees well with the fee. However the fee and his internal compensation are two distinctly separate matters the establishment is trying to tie together. Simply paying your employees well does not grant someone a free pass to break the law as they see fit. I recommend victims chargeback the illegal amount taken from them with their credit card companies. https://www.ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/news/2021/05/05/restaurant-adds-administrative-fee-in-attempt-to-retain-staff--city-says-it-s-against-guidelines# read more

See all

Classsy Mediterranean restaurant with high quality food and service, but also rather high prices. I came for dinner and ordered the Beau Soleil Oysters, which tasted very fresh and came with an apple mignonette sauce, which added a bit of sweetness. For my main course, I ordered the Filet Mignon. I understand that some people might have considered this perfectly cooked, but personally, I found it to be a bit too rare on one side and the crust on the other side to be a bit too burned. It was very tender though, which is a result of this prized cut of meat. I loved the maitake mushrooms and cippolini onions that came with the dish, as they were unique and tasty. For dessert, I ordered the Tiramisu, which was a classic recipe. It was creamy with a nice coffee kind of flavor. Although my three courses all tasted great, I have to say that the prices were a bit high: $4 per oyster (I got 6), $54 for the filet mignon (granted this cut of meat is always expensive but there wasn't much meat on the plate), and $16 for the tiramisu (seems overpriced for the portion size). I suppose it can be argued that what I ordered is always pricey, but at the very least Amali should be $$$ instead of $$ on Yelp. The interior of the restaurant is beautifully decorated with a sort of fusion between a bright Greek island style and a more cozy, wooden (and festive for the holidays) style. There is both a nice indoor and outdoor seating area. The staff were super friendly and attentive- you can tell they really care about making it a pleasant dining experience for you. The service speed was decent. Overall, you can be sure to get high quality Mediterranean food at Amali in a beautiful setting, with friendly staff. Just be aware that it can get a bit pricey depending on what you order. read more

See all

It's the last week of Winter Restaurant Week in NYC! This place has delicious Mediterranean food, but the price is pretty high. We love the appetizers. Both dishes come with this tasty fried flat bread. The hummus is smooth and tastes great. The mushroom is cut into small pieces and is well-seasoned. The scallop main dish is okay; the portion is kinda small for the price we pay. Duck sausage pasta portion is pretty big compared to the scallop dish. There is no dessert included in RW menu, which is kinda a bummer. Overall, food is amazing, I just don't think it is worth the price we paid. So if you don't have a budget, or want to do something fancy, highly recommend. read more

See all

Amali was amazing! I went there for a late lunch, and the restaurant was not very full. The servers were very friendly and helpful with anything we needed. They have both indoor and outdoor seating. I wanted to sit outside because it looked so cute, but we ended up sitting inside to enjoy the AC. The food was delicious. We started off with oysters - they were pretty small for the price ($4 each), but came with a great Apple Mignonette. The Spanish Octopus was cooked very very well and was super flavorful. It came with a red sauce/mash that was on the saltier side for me, so I asked for a lemon to balance the taste. I always respect a chef's dish design, but I would really recommend getting a bit of lemon for the lobster. The cavatelli was perfect. Super creamy and chewy - it's become my favorite kind of pasta. Overall, would definitely recommend coming here on a date, with friends, or family! The restaurant is more on the fancy side, so you can definitely look forward to a nice dinner. read more

See all

Had such a delicious meal here last week!!! The dishes aren't cheap, but you're paying for exceptional service, nice ambience, and some tasty food. I almost missed the place when I was walking outside because it's a bit hidden away, but the interior is gorgeous as you can see from the pictures. Our server, Roberto, was so attentive and friendly from the moment we walked in. My friends hyped up the branzino at this restaurant so much that I came here solely to try it, and I was not disappointed. The fish was so buttery and soft, and I loved how crispy the skin was. The frascatelli was similarly delicious and had that deep seafood flavor you can't get in all seafood pastas. You MUST try the mushroom caponata. Also loved the drinks here!! Shoutout to our friend Brian P. (who is a regular here) for introducing us to this place! Will definitely be coming back to try the other entrees. read more

See all

Weeknight experience with a big party of 12 people. We were an hour early but still our reservation was honored. Superb service, prompt and made nice recommendations. Food was fresh, flavorful and well portion size. The Mediterranean dips and freshly baked bread was phenomenal. You could taste best ingredients and freshness through and through. Desert selection was great - we tried crème brûlée and tiramisu- both were good. Must try if in the area !! read more

See all

Classy and thoughtful dishes served by attentive waiters in a lovely environment. Our favorite dish by far was the Dayboat Scallops ($37). The scallops were perfectly caramelized and still tender. The real kicker was the sauce it came with, which was packed full of umami pleasantness. The cauliflower artichoke dip with warm, delicate cuts of pita was a welcome appetizer ($12). The Spanish Octopus a la Plancha ($23) was a slight disappointment. The flavors and the fingerling potatoes were terrific. Unfortunately the large octopus tendrils were tough and overcooked. I had one medium-sized tendril that was cooked perfectly, so it could've just been an error for the larger pieces. The Lamb Burger ($19) was very nicely done, and actually medium rare, like I ordered. The tzatziki and whipped feta were really nice touches and balanced out the salty richness of the lamb. Would definitely come back just for the scallops! read more

See all

I love the mushroom appetizer, clam appetizer, and the linguine. The clams app has an excellent crispy finish. Mushrooms are flavorful with a perfect texture as well. The linguine vongole is one of the best I've had. I also tried the agnolotti, which had a nice amount of lobster and a tasty brown gravy. Finally, if you're not feeling pasta, I recommend the filet read more

See all

Gem lettuces w radish garnish with vinaigrette is very fresh followed an appetizer course autumn squash & grilled Brussels pistachio feta , burnt honey amazing Entree spice grilled chicken very juicy Halibut seafood confit potato is okay For dessert chocolate mouse The servers are very attentive read more

Super delicious Mediterranean food but please note it says $$ but it's really $$$. I must say this review is many months late but nevertheless the outdoor seat up was nice and I'm sure it still is too. Side streets are always a win as opposed to being on a busy Avenue. We had a very special meal, very refined with exceptional service. Highlight was the fish. read more

See all