Cancel

Open app

Search

Burger Theory

3.3 (44 reviews)
Closed • 6:00 am - 11:00 AM, 5:00 pm - 10:00 PM

Burger Theory Photos

BURGER THEORY ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Quiet
Casual
Good for groups
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Burger Theory

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

InnJoyable
Dan P.

We ate breakfast here while staying at the Holiday Inn. If you pay an extra $10 a night for the room on Hotels.com, you get breakfast for two, which ended up being a good deal because breakfast for two was about $18.50. The eggs and bacon were good, but the waffles were not. The wife calls them "miserable." The best item were the potatoes, which were delicious. Of the eggs, I preferred the scrambled eggs to the omelette. The amount of food you get is quite sufficient. The menu says 3 egg omelette, but it looks like 5 eggs.

Burger theory.  Onion rings(crisps)
Alan S.

Service- maybe 2/10 Staff seemed to be too busy bantering to handle the three tables. Very limited menu. Ordered onion rings, for $3 extra, got onion crisps. Would not recommend.

Farm Fresh Burger
Angel K.

A lot of mixed reviews for this place--either one star or five--but I was on a work trip staying in the the hotel and didn't have too much choice in terms of food immediately nearby. So, I decided to give Burger Theory a shot. It's a hotel restaurant and I went down when it opened at five. Service was good, although it wasn't very crowded either, so I can't speak to the wait time if the place were full. Ordered the Farm Fresh burger w a side salad. The salad was pretty standard (iceberg lettuce, cut tomatoes and red onions). Burger came after the salad exactly as I ordered--medium done with mayo in the side. A decent burger, nothing crazy or mind blowing, but a solid burger nonetheless. A 3.5 ratin would be most accurate, but since I can't give it that, I'll give it the full 4 stars to help up this place a bit. Paducah is a small town and food options are limiting to begin with. Large selection of bourbon. Cheers! Updated: I also got a Cobb salad to-go. It was good!

There is a TV at every booth.
Sarah B.

The Boss burger stuffed with cheddar and bacon, with KGB sauce was juicy. But it didn't pack the punch in flavor I was expecting. But it was a hotel after all. We had one burger, fries, a kids Mack & cheese with a fruit cup. One coke and a draft bud light. The ticked was $26. I personally thought it was high. The burger was $16. Definitely not worth the price. Compared to other local burgers with bold flavor. The hotel is very nice and it was good to try a change. Our server was very nice and a good server. We got full but would not go back. If they wanted to spruce up the food.. I would advise them to get back in contract with PBW. Have the beer Local brewed. The burgers, we could not taste anything but cheese. Salt & pepper that meat & taste what your sending out.

The "Bruben" with rings.
Steven P.

This is a hotel restaurant all the way, I should state that right out front. Compared to other hotel spots that I have visited it is wonderful! Compared to the rest of Paducah's downtown spots, it disappointing. That's how I settled on 4 stars! The beer selection is not bad, I had one from the tap and a bottle. The best part of the meal was the stuffed poblano pepper appetizer. Cheesy & wrapped in bacon! My burger was the Bruben, kind of a take on a Reuben sandwich, but with slaw...not kraut. Except for the soggy bottom of rye, it was good. What did I not like? The price was really high. Appetizer, 4 beers, and 2 burgers were $75! Clearly set up for a traveler using a corporate expense account. Also, the atmosphere is, you know, the inside of a hotel lobby. The service was great, though. I won't go back, but if I was stuck in this hotel on business, I would feel fortunate to have this!

Ni H.

This place knows burgers with their unique blend of meats. I've been here three times in the past month and the food quality is excellent. The service is about average. I have heard the appetizers are really good but never have ordered them. The burgers are massive, you won't leave hungry. The seating/ambiance is nice and you can also eat outside by a fire pit. Extremely happy to have a burger theory here, they definitely beat out all the other chain burgers on quality, taste and uniqueness.

Build Your Own Burger.  Swiss and American Cheese with real bacon.   Parmesan cheese coated fries.

See all

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jason K.
122
10
0

8 years ago

It was ok. Service was great and very nice. Burger was just ok. Nothing great but not bad.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Mk Z.
0
62
0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Burger Theory

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Burgers 200 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Driftwood Lounge - Ribeye done right.

Driftwood Lounge

4.7(25 reviews)
3.7 mi

I walked into Driftwood Lounge expecting a full on dive bar experience, and they delivered. This is…read morenot the place to go if you are looking for mood lighting, artisanal coasters, or a bartender who calls you "sir" unironically. And honestly it works. The locals greeted me like I'd just come back from a long trip instead of walking in for the first time. Either they're incredibly friendly or they thought I needed supervision. Either way, solid welcome. Service was minimal in the best possible way. No hovering, life story, or unnecessary check-ins. Just quick, friendly, and efficient, like they understood I came to eat, not start a long term relationship. Now here's where things take a turn: the food has no business being this good. I ordered the Southside Supreme Pizza, and I'm still trying to figure out how a place that looks like it could host a darts league championship is casually putting out world class pizza. I've had pizza from all over the world and this place can hold its own. Thin, perfectly crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and enough cheese to make you question your priorities but not your choices. It's like the pizza didn't get the memo about where it was being served. So yeah, I give it 5 stars. Come for the dive bar charm, stay because the food quietly outperforms half of the "fancy" places that make you wait 45 minutes for a table and then serve you a disappointment on a wooden board. I'll definitely be back. Next time I might even try to look like I belong.

Really high-end bar food. The menu is quite large and everything is good. The servers are all…read morefriendly and attentive.

Photos
Driftwood Lounge - Outdoor patio

Outdoor patio

Driftwood Lounge - Southside Supreme Pizza.

Southside Supreme Pizza.

Driftwood Lounge - Finally a menu II.

See all

Finally a menu II.

Freight House - Spicy beer cheese spread and crudites and crackers

Freight House

4.3(360 reviews)
0.6 mi
•$$$

The way to a man's heart is through his stomach. I'm in…read morelove. My heart Melts when I eat here. ( pass through once a year ) It's the highlight of my culinary year The flavors are earthy simple and complex. All at the same time. Spices never overpower the intended mouth music. I wish I could dine here regularly.

I'm finally having a chance to review our visits to Freight House back in November!…read more My husband and I took a little trip to Paducah, and the main reason we chose this location for our vacation was Sara Bradley's restaurant Freight House. We both are fans of "Top Chef" and since her restaurant is within reasonable distance of home, we planned a trip around it. In fact, we made reservations for two nights in a row, to take in as much of the menu as possible! Between the two different days, we tried a number of appetizers, entrees and desserts. If I were to do this again the same way, I would do one day of apps and dessert and one day of entrees, just to spread things out a bit. What we ate: - Fall pickles: I enjoyed this, with the bit of chili heat, especially the cauliflower - Stuffed Mushrooms: I love mushrooms, and these blended creamy, sweet and hot with a filling of cream cheese, berry BBQ sauce and smoked jalapeno - Pistachio and herb chevre cheeseball: a fresh cheese enhanced by nutty and Herby notes - Smoked bologna: my husband's choice; very meaty and there was a lot of it - Spicy beer cheese spread: a very Midwestern feeling appetizer with tasty veggies and crackers Entrees: -Shrimp and grits: my choice: comforting southern food with lots of flavor - Duck fried rice: his choice: rich rice offset by more delicate vegetables - Sticky ribs: my choice: the pumpkin spice and coffee liqueur glaze worked well for a cozy, wintry meal - Braised pork shoulder: his choice; served with beans and cornbread, this was another hearty, comforting meal with a Southern twist. Desserts: - Winter creme brulee: this was my favorite, flavored with mulling spices, orange and pomegranate We also enjoyed a seasonal sorbet and the fall spice cake. We had the same server both nights, Elizabeth, who was good at making recommendations, and also staggering the small plates on our small table so we wouldn't be overloaded. Chef Sara was in house the second night, bringing dishes to tables. The setting is relaxed, not overly loud, with moody lighting. Overall, we would certainly return to Freight House!

Photos
Freight House - Large Bottle of Sparkling Water

Large Bottle of Sparkling Water

Freight House - Deviled egg

Deviled egg

Freight House - Fish dip app

See all

Fish dip app

Grill 211 - Thai noodles with pork loin

Grill 211

3.8(105 reviews)
0.4 mi

235$ The most expensive bill I've ever had. Anywhere. In…read morethe entire u.s.a. Overpriced!! I typically am perfectly happy to pay whatever it takes to get a good meal and usually don't pay attention to the bill But this bill easily exceeded by 50% What you typically pay for a high-quality meal And while the meal was quite good, it wasn't a five star meal The service was five stars The salad was good The coconut clam appetizer was good My branzino was quite the small portion and lacked flavor Our salmon was overcooked to dry The best part was the service it was impeccable I rarely say this But I'll never go back it's just not worth it It's a 150$ meal. Not a 235$ meal. Other patrons voiced the only reason they were there was because it's the only place open on Monday.

Went for dinner, very cool atmosphere. Lights could be a little dimmer. Service was excellent…read more Food is where the price doesn't meet the road. Truffle fries; don't use crinkle cut, you're not Culver's. Seriously, you have to figure out how to make fresh cut fries Or get creative w/ another spud. Chilean Sea bass; you have to give us a bigger piece for $62, It shouldn't be 1" x 3" morsel. Again, do better, It should be twice as big. If you're worried about running out, oh well, at least match the size for the value. Salmon seemed fairly big enough for the $$. You're a good spot fr dinner, but have to do better. Hope you take to heart.

Photos
Grill 211
Grill 211 - Dry  salmon.

Dry salmon.

Grill 211 - 63$ Branzino. Lacked flavor  Small portion

See all

63$ Branzino. Lacked flavor Small portion

Strickland’s Seafood Restaurant - Blackened chicken breast with Cajun Red Beans & Rice and hush puppies

Strickland’s Seafood Restaurant

4.1(194 reviews)
2.6 mi
•$$

Came on the recommendation from a friend (04/25/2026), I'd heard mixed reviews so I was curious…read moreabout this place. I'll give them 4.75 stars, but they did fantastic so I'll round up for this place. First, we walk in the door and Zack walked past and complimented the boss on her snazzy shirt and a few other staff were friendly too so the vibe was nice to start off. We were then led to our table to discover Zack is our server for the night. Another compliment on the bosses glasses, okay she did look great - Thanks Zack! Drinks come out super fast and we get our food ordered. Zack was great helping with Alpha Gal and later following up with the kitchen staff that they had in fact not put butter on my fish - another win. I ordered the red fish special (I think) with a baked potato and the boss got the Harris Platter. Zack recommended blackened and was so right, delicious! I tried her fired catfish and that was delicious too, but would have dipped it in hot sauce, but the cocktail sauce was so yummy with a nice horseradish bite - delicious and maybe better than hot sauce (slander I know). That 0.25 off - well the hushpuppies were kinda gross and bland. This is the south so quality hushpuppies are a must. Ask for Zack, you will not be dissapointed.

My friend and I were in Paducah shopping and decided to have dinner at Stricklands. It was a…read morebeautiful afternoon so we sat outside. The waitress was very kind and helpful. We ordered drinks. I ordered a double Basil Hayden sour and my friend Tanqueray and tonic. We had shrimp, crab cakes, mahi and Ahi. All were delicious. Half way through the meal we ordered another drink. When the check came my 2 drinks were $56. $28 each. I understand that a double is 2ce the price as a single but in a place where 95% of the menu items are $20ish or less and the restaurant is NOT high end one would not expect to pay this much for a drink. If you are going to charge above average prices they should be disclosed. No prices are on the menu.

Photos
Strickland’s Seafood Restaurant - Indoor dining

Indoor dining

Strickland’s Seafood Restaurant - Harris Platter

Harris Platter

Strickland’s Seafood Restaurant - Oysters-half a dozen

See all

Oysters-half a dozen

Texas Roadhouse

Texas Roadhouse

3.4(99 reviews)
4.7 mi
•$$

It's kind of wild for a chain that is pretty mediocre to be packed 7 days a week. Then again,…read moregiven the competition from Outback and the like, this place comes out on top. On a Wed night, place is packed, but I found one of two empty spots at the bar. The food was decent, on a high protein/low carb diet this is a solid choice. The shrimp was overcooked and overseasoned, but edible. The filet was ordered medium, arrived as med-rare: more rare than med. Taste was good, but should have been left on the grill for another 3 minutes. Overall: Against completion and at this price point, this chain and location are a good option.

Came in yesterday got a ribeye. Half the steak was fat and over cooked. You would expect some fat…read moreon a ribeye. But half was the steak was unable to be eaten. I called and the manager and she offered to fix and replace the steak. Today went to get the fixed steak, even tried a different cut of meat. Ordered the steak medium rare and received it medium well almost well done. Called back again to inform the manager and she said nothing she can do. So you mess my food up on two separate occasions and act like there's not a problem. Will not return here. I will also advice family and friends to not here as well since there customer comes after that pockets are full. If I pay for something I expect it to be the way I pay for it to be. As you can see by previous reviews they do not even read the reviews. Most show inconsistent cooking of steaks. There big selling point.

Photos
Texas Roadhouse - Hostess stand

Hostess stand

Texas Roadhouse - Not bad for a fast food steak house

Not bad for a fast food steak house

Texas Roadhouse - ISLAND COOLER

See all

ISLAND COOLER

Stella's

Stella's

3.7(46 reviews)
0.4 mi

Service provided from the moment we walked into Stella's. I enjoy a good Bourbon. Dever, the…read moremanager, was very knowledgeableand took the time to give me great advice as to which choices would suit my taste. He was right on. Aaron our waiter was fabulous. He has learned the trade as a professional. engaging, informative, entertaining and very attentive. Both men adapted to support me, as I have a hearing deficit. Speaking directly, articulating clearly and never missed a beat throughout our entire meal. Anyone one who tries Stella's will not be disappointed. Lauragv

There are nights when offering a critique feels unpleasantly simple. Diners risk little more than…read morethe cost of a meal and the disappointment of an evening gone sideways. Still, it's never enjoyable to recount an experience that falls short at every turn--especially when the failures were preventable. My visit to Stella's, regrettably, was exactly that. From the start, it was clear that the staff lacked even a foundational understanding of Celiac disease. Questions about gluten safety were met with visible uncertainty and no real assurance that the kitchen could confidently prepare a safe meal. That uncertainty became reality when my entrée -- a steak and baked potato -- arrived with gluten on the plate. Not near it. Not questionable cross-contact. On the plate. Naturally, it had to be sent back. This misstep kicked off a cascade of delays that stretched my wait time to nearly an hour, even though we were among the very first guests seated at 5:00 p.m. Meanwhile, my dining companion's meal arrived correctly and on time. I insisted they eat, because by the time my corrected meal showed up, theirs would have gone stone cold if they had waited out of courtesy. The absurdity didn't stop there. The to‑go order I placed after we were seated--intended for someone else--was finished before my actual in‑house entrée ever arrived. Even the wine I ordered to accompany the steak made its way to the table long after the pairing was relevant, arriving more like a begrudging afterthought than part of a well-paced dining experience. When the final bill reached $250, it underscored the frustration even more. At that price point, diners are not paying for mediocrity. They are paying for competence, safety, professionalism, and a level of service that respects their time and their dietary needs. It is not unreasonable to expect top‑notch service when the tab climbs that high. And this incident is not isolated. Increasingly, restaurants in Paducah that position themselves as "quality dining" are missing the mark on training, pacing, and basic hospitality. Yet, as a community, we lack a consistent or constructive way to hold establishments accountable or to encourage them to maintain standards worthy of the prices they charge. If we hope to preserve both the integrity of our dining scene and the value of our wallets, we need better mechanisms for clear, honest critique -- and for restaurants to listen. Stella's, on this visit, offered little more than disappointment and a glaring reminder that good intentions are no substitute for proper training, coordination, and care.

Photos
Stella's - Bar

Bar

Stella's - Parmesan Potato Gratin

Parmesan Potato Gratin

Stella's - Smoked old fashioned

See all

Smoked old fashioned

Burger Theory - burgers - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...