Lunch for 3. Two sandwiches, one salad, two iced teas. $60 including tax and tip. Bill charged 3% for using a CC, which for me deducts at least one star. Food was fine and somewhat overpriced. Quick service as the place had only a few tables dining. read more

Service provided from the moment we walked into Stella's. I enjoy a good Bourbon. Dever, the manager, was very knowledgeableand took the time to give me great advice as to which choices would suit my taste. He was right on. Aaron our waiter was fabulous. He has learned the trade as a professional. engaging, informative, entertaining and very attentive. Both men adapted to support me, as I have a hearing deficit. Speaking directly, articulating clearly and never missed a beat throughout our entire meal. Anyone one who tries Stella's will not be disappointed. Lauragv read more

There are nights when offering a critique feels unpleasantly simple. Diners risk little more than the cost of a meal and the disappointment of an evening gone sideways. Still, it's never enjoyable to recount an experience that falls short at every turn--especially when the failures were preventable. My visit to Stella's, regrettably, was exactly that. From the start, it was clear that the staff lacked even a foundational understanding of Celiac disease. Questions about gluten safety were met with visible uncertainty and no real assurance that the kitchen could confidently prepare a safe meal. That uncertainty became reality when my entrée -- a steak and baked potato -- arrived with gluten on the plate. Not near it. Not questionable cross-contact. On the plate. Naturally, it had to be sent back. This misstep kicked off a cascade of delays that stretched my wait time to nearly an hour, even though we were among the very first guests seated at 5:00 p.m. Meanwhile, my dining companion's meal arrived correctly and on time. I insisted they eat, because by the time my corrected meal showed up, theirs would have gone stone cold if they had waited out of courtesy. The absurdity didn't stop there. The to‑go order I placed after we were seated--intended for someone else--was finished before my actual in‑house entrée ever arrived. Even the wine I ordered to accompany the steak made its way to the table long after the pairing was relevant, arriving more like a begrudging afterthought than part of a well-paced dining experience. When the final bill reached $250, it underscored the frustration even more. At that price point, diners are not paying for mediocrity. They are paying for competence, safety, professionalism, and a level of service that respects their time and their dietary needs. It is not unreasonable to expect top‑notch service when the tab climbs that high. And this incident is not isolated. Increasingly, restaurants in Paducah that position themselves as "quality dining" are missing the mark on training, pacing, and basic hospitality. Yet, as a community, we lack a consistent or constructive way to hold establishments accountable or to encourage them to maintain standards worthy of the prices they charge. If we hope to preserve both the integrity of our dining scene and the value of our wallets, we need better mechanisms for clear, honest critique -- and for restaurants to listen. Stella's, on this visit, offered little more than disappointment and a glaring reminder that good intentions are no substitute for proper training, coordination, and care. read more

One of the best meals I have had in a very long time. Excellent and attentive -- though not overbearing -- service. A wine -- and cocktail list -- of great variety. Delicious desserts. A warm and welcoming ambiance. Definitely worth a visit if you are in the Bluegrass State or if you have a fondness for river towns (we travelled from a river town ourselves -- Peekskill, NY, in the Hudson Valley). read more

See all

Best burger in Paducah! Such a great venue with excellent service and great drinks. My go-to spot when I'm in town.

Five stars aren't enough! From the historical charm to the innovative menu, Stella's is a standout. On the recommendation of our excellent servers, I tried the Ramen. It was a revelation--savory beef and a rich, spicy broth that converted this non-ramen fan instantly! My wife's halibut was cooked to perfection, complemented beautifully by the risotto and earthy grilled beets. We capped off the night with a seasonal pumpkin crème brûlée and a whimsical touch of free cotton candy. Beyond the food, the "haunted" history of the building adds such a unique layer to the evening. Exploring the story of the restaurant and the surrounding Paducah Arts District made for an unforgettable night. Highly recommended! read more

See all

The wait staff and bartenders are amazing. They make any cocktails no matter how strange it may sound for you. They remembered us even though we have only been there twice. They made us feel like we were a part of the family. Matt was the best. He created a special drink for me called the Texas Yellow Rose. It is made with gin. read more

Stella's - Texas Yellow Rose - Seafood Near Me - Paducah, Kentucky

See all

We ordered salads for dinner. After asking twice where was our food, we received it an hour after we ordered it. Items from the salad were missing. We asked for the manager. Excuses and empty apologies were given. We felt unheard. We asked if there would be any compensation, dessert was offered. Because it was late we brought it home. Photo included of what was given. read more

Clean and concise food and drinks. Sometimes simple is best and this is one of those times if you're interested in Simplify, Simplify! Then Stella's is for you! Enjoy- read more

Stella's - Gin and soda - Seafood Near Me - Paducah, Kentucky

Fantastic find! Our server Enetria made it extra special. Had the filet with garlic butter and cut it with a butter knife , hubby had the steak salad and the tuna app. I think the cornbread pre-meal was the icing on the cake. The Pace Car cocktail was also exceptional with Green River bourbon. Really cool backstory on the building of the Cohen family too and Stella Cohen who passed in 1980. read more

Waiting an hour fir our food. Server said, kids chicken tenders are almost ready. When finally can out they were dry chicken nuggests. My spouse and I ordered fish and chips. Thick chewy batter, greasy and reheated greasy, drowned in salt fries. Our tables final order showed up 10 min later. A salad with shimp must take alot of time. Arrived around 6pm on a Wednesday so not busy restaurant. When mentioning issyes to sever was told, "I'll let the kitchen know". We will never be back. With such a small menu they should be able to do all the item well. Instead it appeared all pre made and fried or reheated. Management should be embarrassed. read more

When you are traveling across the country, it's best to take your time and not always be in a hurry to get home! We came from Asheville on our way home to Colorado Springs and decided to cut our day early and stay in Paducah. We decided to walk into downtown from our hotel and ended up at Stella for dinner! Best decision ever! Not only is it a cool little town but the food and hospitality at Stella was so worth the evening! The folks there were awesome....felt like everything was provided just for us! We started with drinks and then moved into starters. The shrimp was amazing and we were even treated to the tuna after saying I just never liked tuna before. Oh my word, so so good!!!! Our main dishes were delightful! I had the delicious Scallops and grits (something I never get in Colorado....whats up with that?). My husband had the Moqueca (Brazillian Fish Stew). Equally amazing! Our server was so kind and friendly. "E" made us feel at home and like we were part of the community. She then ended our meal with a signature cotton candy finisher. Over all...i would highly recommend spending an evening at Stella! Thank you all! read more

See all

We went for a date night. It was so loud, it was hard to hear. The food wasn't impressive for the cost. The service was not impressive. She was super nice, but often forgot about us. It took 30 minutes just to get a drink, but apparently there's 4 bartenders. At this point I don't even remember what we got to eat, that's how unimpressed I was. Oh but for some reason we got cotton candy with our bill. The cotton candy was the best part. read more

See all

The service, the food and the charm of a very old building - where to begin. This little gem is amazing. Our waitstaff was wonderful, very knowledgeable & friendly. Lareisha and Chantelle are so amazing- their recommendations showed awareness of their kitchen and they actually listen to the diner and will ask the chef if a diner's question is beyond the norm. The warm corn muffins with soft butter could be a meal they are that good! My daughter is Vegan and a plate of fresh veggies was roasted for her with perfect seasoning. The willingness to accommodate is so appreciated. I went with the fish & chips which should be the gold standard - for fish and chips. The broccoli slaw was yummy, so fresh and crunchy. The portions are huge! So appreciate when you ask for a container to take the left overs home the staff insists on boxing it up for you. So looking forward to returning and dining through the menu. Please give this lovely venue a try- you will be so glad you did! read more

Service was excellent, but I must point out. That I am a fan of New Orleans style gumbo, and I have to tell you that this was the beet gumbo I've ever had in my entire life, including all the restaurants in the French Quarter in New Orleans! read more

Love it! We dine here alone at the bar as a couple, with friends at a table or our family in a section.

worse place ive ever ate at before wayy to expensive for a steak and it's no better then an Applebee's steaks they truly do rob you Absolutely cold and nasty and the waiter was rude and high smelling like straight dope absolutely not ok since I cant breath around the smell of that stuff read more

Ambiance was good but the food was over priced. I ordered the steak special that was a New York strip. The sauce was good but was a bad cut of meat. One drink, Ceaser salad, and my meal was +$150 read more

We made a reservation for two online. There was no choice of tables. When we arrived, we were asked if a high top was okay. It isn't as we seniors with various artificial parts. There was a booth available, but we were told because they had a reservation for 6 people in a half hour we couldn't have it. When we told the manager that obviously they weren't interested in our business, we were asked to leave because we were "rude." BTW we thought we would try this place in spite of hearing that the food was overpriced for what you get. And several friends have said the food isn't very good. read more

Classic bar. Kitchen wasn't open but they had an amazing gumbo and basil in the drink perfect starter. Silver big screens to watch the game will have to come back for dinner but for now I need to scoot and go pick up something for Peggy. I would recommend checking Stella out if you have some time. read more

Stella's - The bar. - Seafood Near Me - Paducah, Kentucky

My wife and I stopped by on December the 26 after a few drinks at Barrel and Bond, and I must say, wow, everything was so fantastic, from the food to the Old Fashions and not to mention the amazing staff!! My wife and I look forward to the next time!! read more

One of our favorite places to eat. We make it a point to spend the night in Paducah just to go to dinner at Stella's. The servers go above and beyond to make the experience great. The food is always creative and equally delicious. It isn't often when a favorite restaurant is part of a road trip. read more

Requires reservation although they had plenty of tables empty, through out the two hours we were there. So we sat at the bar. Bartender nice and friendly. Food was not as great as we were told would be. I think hostess and some waiters were uptight. read more

First let me state this is my impression and review , so please try the restaurant yourself, you may really enjoy it. The decor was nice, the waitstaff was nice and attentive. The menu had a nice variety. I really really wanted to love this place only because the owners of another restaurant owned it that we absolutely love. I was looking forward to an awesome meal. Walk in, seated at a bar high top ( big negative for me) I'm old, my feet need to be touching the ground . I made the best of it. We Ordered the Charcuterie board(small) 18.00 Believe me it was small, on the micro size pieces. Made the best of it, ate what it had but wished it had a little more on the board. All the entrees to me were a little overpriced. I ended up just getting a bowl of French onion soup (delicious) and a small house salad 8.00. Husband got the pasta dish which sounded good. Came in a cute bowl, but the portion was small and Way way way over salted. Onto dessert, looked over the menu and ordered the creme Brule, the highlight of the meal, delicious!! As for the drink menu, again way over priced. Will we return? Probably not, we were not impress for the money they charge. read more

Stella's - Seafood Near Me - Paducah, Kentucky

We stopped in on a Friday night and wanted to order charcuterie and a few drinks 20 minutes before 9pm - we were told no - so we left - I so wanted to try this out on our layover - would have been the EASIEST to provide to us! Your bartender recommended a dive bar that was less than appealing -we found an amazing meal with ambience at Mi Lindo Michoacán read more

UNBELIEVABLE. What a rip off!! I had the peach & country ham salad. There was a single very thin slice of ham and four small chunks of lettuce. Where there should have been peaches there was about 1/4 of an apple sliced very thin. It cost $14 and I needed a burger when I was done read more

Wow so many things wrong with this food I don't know how to explain. Too many flavors for something so simple. The flatbread was hard and crumbly and just fell apart. The sauce tasted really bad and sausage flavored. Very off putting as if bacon which was hard and burnt tasting, fresh pineapple had a weird wang, ham was flavorless and jalapeño should have been easy enough to get down. Neither of us could eat it. The iced tea was not good southern sweet tea. We were NOT told that the tea wasn't sweetened or that it wasn't orange pekoe which is what we use. Sure I have lots of teas from pipers but I don't use them to make my iced tea with. Such a weird flavor. Needless to say we didn't like or drink it but why weren't we told that they don't make sweet tea and that it was an odd flavor one when we placed our order? The burger meat was good enough but the whole taste of a creamy pesto and a ton of mozzarella with a paper thin tomato was a fail. Hand cut fries ok but don't get them unless you're in love with lots of salt. Hmm I would say for a Thursday afternoon lunch you wouldn't expect that the booth next to you would have people so loud it seemed like they had a few way to many drinks and we couldn't even enjoy the food if it was good not to mention having to step around liquor and laundry delivery people to be seat on hard wood benches that looked as they did 20 years ago. The place was a huge disappointment for a $100 lunch that went uneaten read more

Stella's - Hawaiian flatbread - Seafood Near Me - Paducah, Kentucky

See all

Excellent food, with a good selection. Nice ambiance and great service. I would go back again.

This was my first time at this restaurant as it is new. The atmosphere is nice, but nothing crazy. There is a bar seating option which is more casual than sitting at one of the tables. The food is reasonable, but I feel like the steak may be a little higher. Our waitress wasn't overly friendly, it felt like she was rushing us. I had the pasta and the pasta was very good. read more

Stella's - Seafood Near Me - Paducah, Kentucky

Amazing place, amazing food, amazing staff. The ambiance is perfect for any time of the day. You can tell everyone who works here really cares about the place. read more

See all

Stella's is the best restaurant in Paducah! Innovative, ever-changing menu, excellent cocktails, warm ambiance, and great service. Go go go! You will not be disappointed!!! read more

This place is a see it to believe it kind of establishment. Got excellent energy, nice decor, great service, and the food is outstanding. The menu seems to rotate frequently which keeps things fresh. Never had a bad meal here. Also, ran into Alice Cooper eating here before his show at the Carson Center. Awesome place. read more

Went with some friends as part of a nice night on the town. First and last visit to Stella's. Reservations for 7:00pm and we were seated right away with no waiting. The restaurant and building has a ton of history so no surprise that the environment inside was really nice. Our waiter was super friendly and helped with meal suggestions. I elected for their nightly special of ribeye, potato wedges, and green beans. Meal presentation was wonderful! The potato wedge was similar in texture to a hash brown and had a really nice taste, the best part of the meal. Green beans were good too. I ordered the steak medium and got it closer to rare, but elected to not send it back, I like rare steak too. The cut was just awful, filled with too much gristle to enjoy and tasted a bit burnt. I'd rather have a McDonalds hamburger then go back to Stella's and I loathe McDonalds. read more

One of the best restaurants we have been to in the south. Absolutely amazing chef & staff! Come here and be stunned!!!

Only reason to give this 3 stars is the atmosphere. We thought the food was average and best and it was pricey. The bill was $120 with a $40 bottle of wine, 2 entrees and dessert. They also charge you 3% for using a credit card. Sorry, but that's the cost of doing business and not having to handle cash. read more

Good and drink were fine, but for the price the service style needs an upgrade. Maybe 10 or 15 minutes after the entree the server came and squeezed a dessert onto our table that we didn't ask for. 5 minutes after that she drops the check. The table was full. We were still eating our butter soaked entree. Terrible practice. read more

Châteaubriand was PHENOMINAL. Love the ambiance & all the delicious drinks! Will be back for sure.

We went to Stella's tonight for our anniversary dinner. We had a reservation for 6:30 pm. We were seated promptly upon our arrival by the very nice gentleman host. We started off with some old fashioned cocktails from the bar and the ham and potato croquettes. The drinks were good and bar service was prompt given how busy they were. The appetizer was very good and we were honestly shocked at the great flavor. They use Broadbent's ham to make these, a locally owned smokehouse that has been making exceptional pork products for over 100 years. My husband and I love that this restaurant uses products from several local businesses in their food! We saw on Facebook earlier in the day that they had a special on Chateaubriand and only had four available. We were lucky enough to get one of them! It took a while for it to come out, but it was worth the wait. It was $120 for 25-30 ounces of beef with a bourbon mushroom demi-glace and parmesan potato gratin. The beef was cooked just how we ordered it and the the jus served with the beef was excellent - wonderful flavor. The potatoes gratin were very good also - excellent texture and flavor. Nice and crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. My husband doesn't usually like this kind of potato, but he really enjoyed these. There was so much beef, we couldn't eat it all! Our server was very good - prompt and attentive. We ended the night with the chocolate lava cake, served warm, and vanilla ice cream. It was good but had a salty taste and the portion is very small for $13. Other desserts on the menu include crème brûlée, chocolate chip cookies, and a new blueberry cake. Other menu items include a bone-in pork chop, onion ring tower appetizer, onion soup, wedge salad, burger, steaks, charcuterie, fish, pasta carbonara - there's really something for everyone. They have a nice cocktail menu, beer selection, and wine list. There's a nice, centrally-located bar in the restaurant that's busy and lively. There are televisions at the bar and bar snacks on the menu. The tables are very pretty and the booths have high backs, which I really like, because it makes seating more intimate and allows for more private conversation. This restaurant is located on a corner of a busy two-lane one-way; there isn't much street parking, so be prepared to park in the large free public parking lot across the street. Hours are Tuesday - Saturday from 3pm to 10pm. They're closed on Sunday and Monday. This made for a really good anniversary dinner and we are glad we came! read more

See all

Looking for somewhere for lunch on our day trip. Read about Stella's and it sounded good. Nice outdoor dining off the main drag on a tree shaded sidewalk. Jake, our server, was working the entire outside area. The bartender had called off, and he and the manager were doing most everything. He apologized that our drinks took a couple extra minutes! No problem, no hurry. The lunch menu is brief but amazingly well constructed. My wife had the French dip burger, I had the pork schnitzel. Very good, with a side of warm potato salad, but very different than the usual German salad. It was a gorgeous day, there was great instrumental music playing from somewhere across the street, and we really enjoyed ourselves. A tad pricey, but this is the touristy area so not a big deal. Would definitely return next time in town. read more

First time eating here since it became Stella's. Start out by saying the staff was wonderful. Very polite and stayed on top of things. I had fish and chips and substituted the chips for fries. Fish was very good. Fries were small and overcooked and way over salted for my taste. Definitely not worth $32 IMO. Decor is about the same as it has always been. Clean, tight booths. I gave it 3 stars because there's not an option for 2.5. read more