Love this buffalo! Always has the best stuff and a lot of the times still has tags attached!!

this review is for a selling experience. went by today with a big bag of boots, really nice boots and a few shoes, as well as a big bag of clothes, gently worn. Of course they didn't want any of it which is usually the case with BC, not just for me but for others that bring items to sell, it is a very humbleing experience to have someone go thru your items and refuse them. I will never go back there again to sell or to buy, i sound bitter i know, when i asked the girl what she was looking for given that they were accepting Fall items, she said "different things, nothing that you see often" When she saw my reaction she said "Awh try not to take it personal" i said really, you just insulted me, never again, ever. Charity is a much better option. read more

OH, this place. *cracks knuckles* long story short, I have been going there for years and never had a problem. However, I went there a few months ago and had the worst experience there. So here I am gathering my things, and I see a blonde girl following behind me. I mean every move I made this chick was up under me, so I figured she was an employee who thought I was going to steal. Why? I have no idea. So anyway I got fed up and turned around she asked if I need help with my things.....do I look like I need help with my things lady? I am just fine. But I gave her my stuff anyway to ease her nerves and kept browsing but she still followed behind me. Even when I went to the fitting room and came out she started following me again. By that time I was fed up but I went on line to purchase my items anyway. I don't plan to go back there again after the way I was treated. And quite frankly, this is def a Williamsburg thing as a whole because I went there not too long after and a group of drunk people yelled racial slurs at me. Idk where the heck these people came from (probably the middle of America on a farm) but they need to go back there. Because its 2012 and things like this should not be tolerated. read more

LOVE this location. I found so many great pieces, and the employees are personable and fun! Definitely would recommend :)

inappropriate i have been there several times and the manager jane has refused to buy.. because im middle aged?? i have read several similar reviews .. low level clerks do the buying.refusing often . it won't be long till this co is sued for improper practices.. mostly raggedyy stuff in a dingy rundown store anyway. read more

I really love buffalo exchange fashion and the things they offer but the reason I'm giving this place a 1 star rating is because it's hella fucking expensive for a thrift store. Like I found items there for $30 and $50 . Like it's called a thrift store for a reason so people can buy clothes for cheaper and not close to the same price as the original so such a rip off. And when I came in to sell my clothes which had great designer pieces and "one of a kind " pieces as so called they're looking for , they didn't take ANYTHING! I was so upset and startled! Never again! read more

my first buffalo exchange experience was in southern cali, & i was floored. my friend & i went to two, & they were both amazing, & i didn't find the employees that insulting. boy was in for a treat upon visiting the williamsburg buffalo exchange. not only was the selection less than amazing (i did find some metallic american apparel leggings, so there was some redemption), the staff also apparently believed that my friends and i were hard of hearing. apparently trying on high heels without socks is a disgrace, but when i took off my hat to reveal a head of messy hair, one clerk "ew"ed me. this was particularly hilarious, because i was looking in a mirror at the time, so i made eye contact with her immediately. so. to those of you who don't exactly look put together, i say stay away from the williamsburg buffalo exchange, & go to that pizza shop adjacent to the l, cos the guys in there loved us :D edited feb: we return the next week, & were again insulted, & this time complained to the manager who said, in a patronizing, near mock-apologetic voice that she was "sorry" that we were insulted, but that there was "nothing that she could do". so we told her we'd never shop there again. later, we remarked that we should have defecated in the changing rooms. too bad we didn't. read more

I personally feel like I get a different experience every time I walk in here. One day the employees will be friendly and help you out, the next they'll ignore you. Same goes with the merchandise, there are good days and bad days. Did manage to find a few good items on certain occasions. ($185 jeans bought for $10, ect.) Most of the time I walk out empty handed and itchy. read more

I came here with a bag full of clothes. The cute stoned cashier took only two items, easily worth hundreds of dollars, and gave me the choice of $21 store credit or $12 cash. After browsing their ridiculous selection, I opted for the cash. A different, clownish stoned cashier handed me a soggy ten and two rumpled singles. I can't believe anyone shops at this pathetic vintage store - there are greater places to go if you look further than Bedford/Driggs. Or, just stop looking so sorry-assed and start shopping at JCPenney. read more

I love this place! I also frequent the East Village location, but I like the layout of this store better for some reason. The selection is always great, and the products are always in great condition. Lots of good steals/finds for great prices. And the staff is friendly. read more

I don't know what this store is looking for when it comes to selling. You would think that they'd want lightly used, trendy, name brand, clean clothes. Instead, they don't. IDK want they want! I came here with at least 10 items, only 2 were chosen. An ugly leopard skirt from Forever 21 and a blue dress from Topshop. I had brought a couple of things (such as cheap, no name jeans) that I figured wouldn't sell, but I DEFINITELY expected my moto jacket (again, from f21 but its still cute and trendy) and my 2 pairs of high waisted Ralph Lauren jeans to sell. I don't understand why neither BE or Crossroads wanted them. It seems as though they are more interested in buying ancient, damaged, and just plain ol' UGLY designer clothes rather than clothes that are actually trendy and will sell! FYI, NOBODY WANTS OLD, TATTERED MARC JACOBS KITTEN HEELS FROM 10 YEARS AGO....WHO EVEN STILL WEARS KITTEN HEELS?! UGH, get it together BE. read more

while it is much easier to find stuff here and the condition of clothing seems for the most part better, i still like beacon's better. if you don't have a lot of time and don't mind items a little more expensive this might be a better option. i always check out both in an afternoon since they're so close! if you're sick of your clothes you can always sell them for some spending money too. read more

Got the most unique dress and jacket. Amazing prices and great finds! Will be back soon!

Although this place is much smaller than Beacon's Closet, I like it more. All the clothes are very clean and hung up in an organized manner. It's easy to go in without much time and flip through everything quickly. I only wish they had chairs in the changing rooms! read more

The trashy employees of this store haven't the slightest understanding of retail. They declined multiple pairs of Stuart Weitzmann shoes and silk for a dumpy peasant top. She contradicted herself and said she wasn't buying for fall but when I presented her a dress she said she was buying fall. They're full of shit. read more

love, love, love buffalo exchange. if you're going to sell items, i suggest you go on a weeknight - preferrably on a monday night - when it's not too busy...that way, the buyers will take the time to look @ your stuff & give you a good amount for selling or trading. read more

eh. more expensive than beacon's, not very good selection, kinda cramped and disorganized. this is one of the very rare occasions when i can say that the one in LA is better. oh well. read more

The prices here are out of control, might as well buy new. Selection not in line with prices, nothing to write home about. Recommend to visit similar resale shops in the immediate area instead. read more

Holy Hipster...I just had a baby and wanted to try and get a few $ for the designer clothes that I had that I will no longer be wearing anymore. I drove out from Long Island on a Monday afternoon and apparently no one works because the store was packed. I had a full trash bag of clothes and got paid for less then half of them. Made a big $27! Thanks for that it just paid my gas but I made more then if I just had a yard sale. Funny thing was there was a big sign that said no donations and the people before me just got there clothes rejected and left but I was asked to donate my stuff! Hell NO! Pay me! Please!! Prob never go back again too far and apparently to hipster cool for me. read more

I have been to your store a few times to sell good jewelry. I was there today and after waiting for one hour on the long line, I showed my jewelry to the tall blond lady manager. She commented "you have been here so many times and your jewelry does not sell at all" showing no interest in what I had to show her. SHE DISMISSED ME in two minutes. I will never return to the Buffalo store on Driggs St. again! read more

Loved it! Staff is super friendly and the clothes were trendy. Like any thrift shop, at a glance its not gonna be like your favorite store. You have to look! I got a Blu Pepper green tank with good buttons and a pair of light wash jeans. Again, this thrift store is not for everyone. Most of their clothes are youthful and some can be on the extreme hipster side. Good for high school kids, college kids and up. My mom was able to find a nice leather blue clutch by kooba. Oh, and I went to beacon's closet afterward and I was not a fan. Even though its bigger, its hard to find cuter stuff. read more

The selection here is geared towards the Williamsburg hipsters, so most of the clothes they choose to buy from you and the clothes they sell are worn, stretched, and "vintage." I brought my designer things there... D&G, Versace, Burberry, Jimmy Choo.. and they rejected every bit of it. And then, I take a walk around the store I find lint-balled, stretched out, over-washed, rhinestone-missing, H&M shirt for $25. WHAT? read more

This is the most amazing vintage store I've shopped at. The staff are so friendly, helpful, & down to earth. They make me feel comfortable when I go in to shop or have any questions. The overall layout of the store is very organized & put together. The clothes are always up to date with the season & there's many different styles to chose from. Every time I go there's different clothes, shoes, bags, etc. Which makes it exciting for me from the moment I walk in. The dressing rooms are very comfortable and clean & you have a mirror in the room. You can take all the time you like & there's no staff member waiting for you in front of the dressing room. Which I love because I hate to feel uncomfortable or like I'm being rushed. I've always went in will intentions of purchasing one or maybe two items & have always left with more than 5 because the prices are too amazing to pass up & I feel like everything is so cute. Lol. By the way they don't have plastic bags to put your purchases in so it's best if you come with your own bag or you can always purchase a cute Buffalo Exchange bag from them for only $2. I purchased one & I use it all the time. I love this place & have told all my friends about it. My mom even came shopping with me for the first time today & she loved it. I will be a loyal customer forever! Lol! :-) read more

Nice staff, good selection, open all the time, but they really need more buyer counters or buyers on staff. I've been in line for 15 minutes and this shit hasn't moved an inch. Wack. read more

Finally had the chance to come by here. Came here with a friend, it was a bit hard to find at first and I walked into 2 stores that were the wrong ones. Once I finally found the place, it was quite crowded. Customers were moving in and out. The line was kind of long for people who were selling things, but it wasn't as hectic compared to Beacon's Closet. Also the way they bought items or traded is much better, they did it right when you were there which I thought was beneficial to the seller. The staff were already dressed up for Halloween. Unfortunately I didn't find anything, but my friend found a cute floral top that was $14.50. The staff were extremely friendly. The place isn't as messy as Beacon's. Clothes are easier to find. They group it according to what the apparel is, for example, all dresses go on one rack, all shirts go on another, tees, and so on and so forth. Would definitely come back here, hopefully I'll find something next time.. read more

This store is alright. Upon entering there was a long line up the stairs of people selling clothes to the store. I've read in other reviews that this is a good place to sell your clothes because they give you a decent price. I guess that rings true judging by the line. They had a nice selection of mens shoes. I found a pair of barely used size 8 Doc Martens. It's a pair I had been thinking about buying and here it was for only $43. Sadly though, trying it on confirmed my suspicion that these shoes are just too stiff and uncomfortable even after being worn in. The store has a nice variety of womens jeans up to size 14, and lots of shirts and shoes. Again, another thrift/vintage store that doesn't have anything for plus size. The mens section is tiny compared to the womens but they do have nice items. They also had some costumes which I thought was a nice addition. The clothing and shoes were all in lightly-used condition. I didn't find anything that was smelly, or had stains or holes. The store is clean, bright and the air is not stale. It was bustling with shoppers and sellers and it had some good but loud music. read more

There was a time when this (and Buffalo Exchange's many other locations around the country) were my favorite stores ever. I can't tell you how many cute dresses and sweet tees I've gotten over the years. And when I started my first real job, a lot of my boring office wear came from Buffalo Exchange, too. Therein lies the problem: as years go by, boring office wear has come to dominate Buffalo Exchange's clothing racks. I don't know if this is a NYC-specific problem or if it's a nationwide epidemic, but all the exciting clothes are going ELSEWHERE. Beacon's Closet, is it you?! Consignment stores, are you to blame? Most of what I end up "scoring" from Buffalo now is a second-hand knock-off top from H&M, which is really too bad: what continues keeps Buffalo a cut above its competition is its keen sense of organization. Clothes are grouped by category and size--unlike Beacon, where clothes are grouped by...color (wtf). But what's the point of finding the exact segment of the rack to search when the pickings are so slim? read more

I went to the Buffalo Exchange in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. I found it to be a nice change of environment from my usual F21 addiction. However, very similar to Forever this place happens to be a little crazy looking in just about every location. You could potentially come out with some really good finds but you have to know your personal style in advance and more importantly you really, really, REALLY have to dig. This staff is okay, relatively friendly and certainly more helpful than the sales associates that you may run into at the more commercial retail outlets. This location in particular carried some nice apparel selections, but let's be serious. Paying ten, fifteen, and in some cases twenty dollars is a bit steep for secondhand threads. But I won't because how many stores is there really that sell gently used top designer bags, clothes, and shoes? There were a lot of Ralph Lauren items which I found to my liking. This place is certainly the Barney's of thrift stores. It was a more upscale than any other thrift store that I have ever seen. read more

its an okay store. everything is a bit pricey for a thrift store but ig thats how the surrounding area is im terms of prices.

We did a thrift shopping day and this place was by far our daughters' favorite. Good prices and selection.

Sold twice in one day where the person actually examined the clothes the first visit and a different person on the second visit just went through the motions; barely examining the items. Needless to say, I rather donate to Goodwill than to be near this place again. Forgetting this Hipster area unless I really need to come back one day. I hope the demographics by, then have, changed for the better. read more

You can always trust that you'll find what you're looking for... And some stuff you're not! I also rely on doing annual closet dumps here and getting a little bit of cash back! read more

Very sketchy people at the front desk. Very suspicious and judgemental. Definitely pay out less than your clothing is worth. Beacon's Closet is much more normal and pays better read more

Pretty cool. Great prices. A little cramped, but that's a good thing. It'd be cool if they were open later, but overall you should definitely go because you can find awesome brands at a fraction of a fraction of the cost. I'm a dude and I found some Ben Sherman, rad oxfords and boots, and some H&M, etc. Good stuff! read more

Had a few great experiences buying here. Once bought shoes but ended up getting two rights. Was able to get credit even the shoes were still in London. Unlike Beacon's Closet, staff was busy being too cool to answer questions and help find things. I almost never buy new clothes and am glad to have one of these stores in my neighborhood. I find great deals every time I go here. read more

Friendly, helpful staff. Unfortunately, the men's selection isn't very large. It's a shame because I'm sure they get so many good clothes from all the people who try to sell there, they just don't have the space. read more

Took a small bag of items here - one of the items was a pair of black patent leather Ralph Lauren Collection high-heeled ankle boots that had been worn only a few times. After the 18 year old "fashion savvy" buyer deliberated for a few minutes because he was nervous that these may not be in style (ankle boots aren't in style right now? Someone should alert Net-A-Porter, they're really off-trend right now...) He came back and said they could maybe sell them for $28. (should have taken them straight to a consignment shop on the UES). He rejected a jacket that had a snag - ok fine. I shopped for a few dresses and went in to the fitting room only to find every item I was trying on either had a tear or a snag. Looked through their shoe selection - choices were destroyed,chunky-heeled, cheap, or fake leather - nothing of quality. Obviously, I should have taken the bag I had set aside for the Salvation Army here and kept my designer items for consignment. *****Oh, and by the way - The girl that let me into the fitting room was in front of me in line at Beacons Closet two days earlier cashing in her drop off for cash. Do I detect a scam here?***** read more

I went here not expecting much and was EXTREMELY surprised! Great stylish pieces and great value for my trades. BONUS the staff is extremely friendly and super helpful. I will definitely be back, one of my new fav spots! read more

They are friendly, but their eyes say different. You get the feeling that they buy your clothes based on something arbitrary that's actually related to you and not what you are selling. I've heard tales of people going on different days to buyers and they take what the previous person wouldn't. Plus, the selection is gritty. read more

Me and my boyfriend came to this buffalo exchange strode with two heavy bags with shows clothing items in perfect condition only worn once I went to sell they debt take no items bc the brand wasn't "known" enough wtf shit u sell is not brand name or vintage n if it is it's crappy looking and overpriced. The lady that attended me was rude she explained to me why she couldn't buy my clothes n just tossed them aside in the counter and walked away dint even say have a nice day I was left to fold all the clothes by an empty counter as she stood justbin space read more