It's been 9 months since my previous visit even though they are only 2 blocks away. On this snowy Friday, I was their only customer for Happy Hour. I got a Italian chopped salad which was huge. I added a glass of Gascon Malbec. It paired well with the 10in New York New York pizza with a gluten free crust. Lots of pepperoni, sausage and mozzarella cheese. I enhanced it with bacon & jalapeno. I ate the 4 slices of pizza with a 2nd glass of the Malbec and plowed thru the entire salad. All good. I was able to use accumulated rewards and with the Happy Hour discount, my great dinner was cheaper than expected. I was served by Gia L. She was friendly and paced my order so that the pizza arrived after eating some of the salad. No automatic service charges. read more

See all

Great pies here. Ordered for pickup ahead, the order was brought out right on time. The pizza travels well. I was surprised to find the wings were breaded and fried, with sauce on the side. read more

See all

The pizza was enjoyable and well prepared. The crust was soft, and the ingredients tasted good together. It would be even better with a little more toppings. read more

It was getting late on a weeknight and I was dying for a good pizza, but my first choice was inexplicably closed. I sat in a pitch black parking lot, trying to find an alternative before closing time. I had just talked about Brooklyn's Finest with a friend, so I decided to give it a try. Their Web site said they could produce my pie just before closing time, so I placed my order and headed south on Broadway. Even in the evening, trying to find parking was difficult. I went around the block twice before finding a spot on Lincoln. Another customer parked right behind me and we headed west on Cedar Avenue to retrieve our pies. Brooklyn's is right on the northeast corner of Cedar and Broadway. The patio and side of the business face Broadway with the entrance on Cedar. The space is warm and welcoming with an expansive bar and two sections of seating with overhead doors, one opening to the patio. The staff was friendly and efficient and quickly brought out my order. It smelled great, so I hurried home. The smell was not deceiving, the pie looked great and was perfectly cooked. I ordered a small New York, New York: red sauce with pepperoni, sausage, bell peppers, red onion, mushrooms, black olives, and mozzarella. The ingredients all tasted very fresh and generously covered the pizza. I have had some real pizza disasters lately, so I was thrilled to get a pie that was perfectly cooked to a golden brown. The crust had a great chew and held up well to the ingredients. The sauce had a nice, spicy bite. Everything went really well together. I just had the leftovers for lunch and they tasted even better. I'm not a native New Yorker or even a frequent visitor to Brooklyn, so I can't speak to authenticity, but this was a delicious, well-made pizza and I enjoyed it a lot. It really hit the spot. This place should definitely be on your pizza rotation. read more

See all

Meh! I ordered an Italian Chopped salad which was huge although it was 99% lettuce, there were a few remnants of pepperoni, didn't notice the salami, a few pieces of tomato- have to admit it was pretty lame as I felt like I was eating a bag of lettuce. My two friends ordered a NY Style pizza one person ordered the 10" and the other ordered a 12". The 12" pizza was exactly the same size as the 10" pizza, my friend pointed it out to the server and she responded no it's actually a 12" pizza but we use the 10" pan?????? Excuse me but we aren't stupid, then she laughed it off by saying that the person that ordered to 10" pizza got a better deal!! My friend said the pizza was good but the crust wasn't the best, probably use American enriched bleach flour. Ambiance typical pizza joint! Oh and BTW, they added a credit card surcharge to bill which I think it illegal because there is no disclosure about up charges on the menu or informed by the server. read more

Food and service was amazing . Ambiance was warm . I would definitely recommend this place if you're looking for some good comfort food .

Despise shitty online ordering. I'm the "search engine" tried wings. Chicken wings. Spicy chicken wings. Copied it directly out of the menu "1lb spicy chicken wings". Nothing. Off to a different restaurant. And it may be ToastTab's issue but why would any business not correct that? Sobo 151 has great wings. New China has good wings. Fire on the Mountain - same. AND you get on their order site and they have the items I'm looking for. Easy choice. read more

Overall good experience. Meatballs and manicotti were excellent. Meatballs were very tinder. Very good marinara sauce. Some of the better garlic knots around. Pizza was just kind of average. Nothing really special about it. Pizza could use some more sauce. A lot of pizza places seem to be skimpy on the sauce these days. Crust was just average. read more

HIDDEN UPCHARGE FOR CREDIT CARD - once I'm at the very end of the online order you see there's a fee for using cc. This is online - how else do I pay? Junk fees should be in the menu prices! read more

Service was good, seated right away. Lots of TVs to watch college football on a Saturday evening. Our starter came after our entrees were served but the eggplant was fresh out of the oven when it finally arrived. The pizza was good but not exceptional. The crust was a little floppy and not exactly crisp. read more

See all

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is top tier. The pizza is flavorful, perfectly cooked, and hits that classic New York-style vibe. Great quality and definitely worth it easy five stars. read more

I want to give a big shout-out to the owner, Carlo, and his entire staff! We held our daughter's high school graduation party at the South Broadway location, and it was a total success. I first called Carlo to inquire about hosting the celebration. We met in person, talked through all the details, and planned everything together. Once I sent out the RSVP to our family and friends, I followed up with the final guest count, and Carlo offered some great suggestions for the party. The food was amazing--everything was made fresh! We had pepperoni, cheese, and veggie pies, homemade garlic knots, and penne pasta. The drinks were flowing, and the vibe was just right. All of our guests were super happy and impressed--it was the first time many of them had been to Brooklyn's Finest Pizza on South Broadway, and they loved it! They also have a really nice patio setup outside, which added to the atmosphere. If you're looking for a great place to host an event, I definitely recommend checking this place out. Carlo and his staff did an amazing job--thank y'all so much! read more

So excited they are open! I ate at the one downtown before we closed our office and have been waiting for this location to open. The food is soo good here. Their sauce isn't sugary and their garlic knots are better than Benny Blanco used to be. RIP Benny's XOXO. The chopped salad is delightful. The meats and cheese are cut in small squares so the salad has a nice consistency and the bites are all flavorful. The service was so friendly. Al and Chad were attentive social and fun. They play sports and have lots of tvs. The restaurant was designed so no matter your seat, you can see a tv. This will be a fun place on Sundays. They have live DJ's starting at 9:45 on the weekends. They also have nightly deals during the week.Their Stromboli is like no other. They have a fulll bar too. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - chopped salad nice portion! YUM - Italian Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Came on a Saturday around 12:30. Delicious food. Good drinks. Watched Harry Potter Will definitely come back read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Italian Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Poor service, no one picks up calls for to-go orders either. Dirty place don't even think about using the bathroom here is you're a woman

This is my 2nd time eating here and they never and I mean never disappoint. The pizza is always so freaking delicious and the staff is always so friendly. I got two pizzas and a drink for under 15 bucks o believe. The pizzas I got was an everything pizza and the other one I honestly can't remember it has white sauce with chicken and I think bacon and that by far was my favorite. Next time I will get two slices. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Italian Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

They have really good gluten and dairy free pizza and it's fairly priced too! The service is always attentive and the ambiance is relaxing and fun. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Gluten and dairy free beef pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - Denver, Colorado

I'm very glad this place became Brooklyn's Finest! We needed a good pizza place on broadway. I love what they did to the place, it's very NY and also just like a cool place to chill. The bar is huge and overall the place is big. You can have a party here! The food was delicious. Started off with their famous garlic knots and knish. We also had their Monday Special, it's buy one get one free spaghetti and meatballs. The food was just so delicious and fresh. We also drank Malibu Rum frozen pina coladas that our waitress recommended. They were refreshing and tasty. Our waitress was very down to earth and friendly. I'll be coming back again soon. read more

See all

First off this place was popping line out the door and a private party. They got us right in, and for how busy it was on a Friday night we got our food faster than I could finish my beer. Now for the good part. I got the Hell's Kitchen pizza was so good I burned my mouth and went in for more. But then I tasted a bite of the manicotti it was so freaking good. My wife (100% Italian from NYC) said she usually doesn't like other people's sauce and she loved it. Our waitress was super accommodating and kind. I mean look at this pie only wish she was a lil hotter but I'm a gluten for punishment. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - 10" Hell's Kitchen - Italian Near Me - Denver, Colorado

I always love some good New York style pizza and the owner of the restaurant is using his family recipes from when he moved to Denver from over 30 years ago and you can really tell in the flavor and how the pizza tastes. This is also some of the best garlic nuts I have ever had and the flavor is bursting through on them, and the tiramisu was excellent. read more

See all

Try the pepperoni Pinwheel and the Times Square Pizza awesome nice atmosphere.Tons of menu items hard to choose. I'll be back to sample more items. Service was good as well. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Pizza sgin - Italian Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

They were amazing the service was amazing and the environment was very clean the workers are nice

Best pizza in Denver! Don't forgot those deep fried salt and pepper wings! You will go back for more!

Came for a snack. Was not expecting the best pizza I've ever eaten in my life. Everyone inside was friendly as well!

After all the advertisements, it looks like a really good restaurant. Maybe my taster was off that day, but I didn't think it was that great. Nice environment, friendly weight staff though read more

Food as always was great. Being from NY and growing up with great Italian food, this place is great. The service was quick and polite. The ambience is the standard pizza place right off of a college campus. Made me nostalgic for pizza in my dorm. read more

Very nice guys working there They got very busy while i was waiting for takeout and i could see how efficient they were I had spaghetti and meatballs and it was very good Most people were getting pizza and it looked very good Next time I will try their pizza read more

Owner Carlos has the best service. We came in just after the kitchen closed and made sure we had our pizza made. Will come again. The food was just like NYC. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Bar inside - Italian Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Brooklyns is fantastic the food choices are simply amazing. They have a great assortment of food to choose from. Service is very good, staff is attentive. The restaurant itself has a New York vibe. As for parking horrible unless you like paying for it. Give the Calzones a try . Fantastic read more

Glad this location is finally open after a fire forced some construction delays. It's on a great corner of South Broadway right near Alameda, and there's a huge outdoor patio plus plenty of seating inside. This is a much bigger location than you'd expect from the street, and although parking is a nightmare in this area, once you get here you're good. Service was friendly and welcoming. As you'd hope, they have legit NY-style pizza, with a crispy crust, plenty of cheese and foldable slices. My only issue with my pizza was the high amount of olive oil on top, but the flavor was excellent. They have a million pizza toppings and combinations, and you can always make your own too, in addition to sandwiches, calzones and a few pasta dishes. They have daily and lunch specials as well. I'd had pizza from one of their other locations before but I'm glad this one is here since it's closer to me. Hopefully they have a good run in this spot. read more

Brooklyn's finest is fantastic, truly a gem in a sea of mediocre pizza in Colorado! 5/5 highly suggested from a former NJ resident!

I am from NY and this is really good pizza. I love the Mulberry slice when I am walking on 16th Street and need a snack. I was disappointed the sode / ice machine was broken the last few times I was there but they make a good slice. I haven't tried anything else yet.... read more

The pizza was great, and our server Jenny was the best. I'll be coming back to this spot.

Music was SO loud we couldn't even hear ourselves. Not sure whose bright idea that was. Food was nothing to write home about.

Stopped by and had a slice with meatball. Yummy! Service was friendly, crowd was friendly. I'll be visiting again.

We had incredible service at this pizza place! Even with a fully swamped staff, Kayla provided excellent customer service. We think she deserves a raise! 11/10 would recommend the mango frozen drinks! read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Mango frozen drink - Italian Near Me - Denver, Colorado

We sat down and waited. A server finally showed up and took our drink order. We waited, she came back two times and asked if we were ok. On the third run, we asked for our beer, no bartender in sight. Waited. Finally beer arrived. Ordered an appetizer and lunch and both arrived at the same time. Beer gone. No server. Went to the bar to order another beer, still no server. Did I mention the server, manager type and bartender all on their phones the entire time. Yeah. And the pizza was soggy. I will give it one more try. Gary Lee is rolling over in his grave read more

I got a flier and went in for the $11.95 special. They charged me almost double. I corrected them and they reluctantly offered it to me, but still upcharged me an additional $8. I didn't argue anymore because at that point I knew I wasn't going back. read more

Service was a little spotty, missed some drinks and food we ordered. Pizza was a little soggy, but not the worst. They had really good happy hour prices though! read more

If you're a person of color this is not the place for you!!Someone named Rasheed the owner of the establishment. He was belligerently drunk and yelling at me because I brushed past him. I said "I said excuse me multiple times." I asked if he was drunk he then began to change his tone. I asked to be seated to eat. He said he would assist me in the manner Waiting standing for about 10 minutes. Then began to realize he was never coming back or finding assistance. No one of color worked there or was in there but myself and the bouncer. That's never been a problem. However they made it KNOWN that I was not welcomed. read more