Amazing pizza. Just go. Crust and sauce so good. Fresh ingredients, nice staff. Authentic stuff. The real deal. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Restaurant inside - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

. iLove the food especially the Greek pizza and the zucchini fries they are my favorite so far and the staff was very nice I would recommend to all my ftienfs read more

Amazing thin crust pizza, garlic knots, and blackened wings! Got a hot tip from a local as we were on vacation. We will be back next year. Sorry we didn't post more pics we were too excited to eat! Since posting my original review 2 years ago we've been back to eat at Brooklyn Pizza every family trip to the area. Still five stars for food and service. Here are some pics that were missing from the first review. read more

See all

You definitely want to check this place out if you're in Seminole. Terrible location tucked away in a hidden strip mall off a busy 4 way intersection. But it's worth the effort. They say the pizza is fantastic. I didn't try it. But the meatball sub was truly excellent. Soft tasty meatballs and. marinara sauce on a great roll w melted cheese. Only came w chips. Should be fries. They cheaped out there. But the sandwich is really great, so I'm overlooking it. They throw in a side of the outstanding sauce for dipping. It looks like they make everything fresh. Chef Ramsey would be proud of this one. This place is worth a detour. read more

See all

Very good pizza, staff helpful. On the expensive side for pizza, but crust was excellent.

The service at the bar was good. There were several employees in the place but not all had something to do. The sandwich I ordered was chicken Parmesan and it was dry. I asked for some marinara on the side and I did receive some. When the bill came I was charged $2 for a portion cup of marinara. My opinion is that's not the way to accommodate a potentially new, return client. read more

I haven't enjoyed a pizza in a long time. Always the same large pizza places. It was very refreshing to have an awesome pie. I say yes, give them a chance. $$ on the scale bet you know what they say, you get what you pay for. Way better than 5.99 pick 2. Just saying. As a first time customer, you've got my business. read more

Have heard great reviews for this place so decided to give it a try. First time experience. We got this delivered via Uber Eats. We live around the block so distance isn't an excuse. Our Pizza was LOADED with Tomatoes (part of the recipe but holy crap every inch had tomatoes) which in turn made the dough SO soggy. The flavor was sub par and just not good. So disappointed considering our delivery was over $60 and now most places are closed. Crappy Friday night! read more

Likely the best pizza I have had across many states. For sure the best I have had in the style. Real cheese unlike what chain delivery shops use. Pepperoni and green olives had toppings in every bite read more

Went to Brooklyn Pizza on a Friday and they were unable to serve us but forced me to pay for the whole meal. There was plenty of employees in the kitchen and wait staff. My husbands calzone came out after a long wait so I told him to eat it and we waited another 50 minutes for chicken wings and ceasar salad and then it never came so we asked for the bill. I didn't ask to speak to a manager or for a refund. From my view at the table it looked like the waitress was trying to take the food we didn't get off the bill at the register without me even asking as I didn't get the items. The owners wife came over to the register and pushed the waitress out of the way and it looked like she was arguing with her and then came over to my table with a bill for the entire meal even items I hadn't gotten and started telling me it's too busy on Fridays and I should expect to wait and not bring children if I'm in a hurry and that she has 6 kids. I didn't say anything except to my husband like do you understand what's going on. I never asked for anything off my bill or said I had to leave because of my child to the waitress. I was in total shock. The waitress looked scared. The owners wife moved from the other end of the table and got next to me and just starting yelling in my face. My husband and I sat there completely shocked and so he paid the whole bill as I never ate any food and then the male owner came over and tried to find out what was happening but it had already escalated. It's sad even if they had good food at some point I don't think I'm allowed to go back after being yelled at like this just for going there and not getting the ceasar salad as they produced some wings during the commotion to make me pay the bill. It was not for lack of people working in the restaurant it seemed fully staffed. The owners of this company belong on that show that fixes restaurants/bars. It was like a scene from that show! All of this happened in front of a child as well and is by far the most unprofessional experience I've had in my life! I feel sorry for people who work here can you imagine how they get treated! read more

They have the best chicken wings !!! Who knew ? The pizza was also great. I loved the white pizza with artichoke and spinach and ricotta Of course the garlic knots were perfect as well. Highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Good food and service. I just wish the food was a bit faster coming out. Definitely not the place to go when you're in a hurry. I like the lunch specials. read more

See all

Legit ass NY pizza. This place is tucked away in a nice strip plaza with a tiny sign on the marquee. Only reason I noticed it was because I was stuck at a traffic light. Otherwise, I would have driven right by. The interior decor is modern and fun, not what you'd typically see in a little NY pizzeria. Honestly, I was in and out. I had a fantastic slice of cheese pizza and would be a serious regular customer if I lived in the Seminole area. They got the right ovens, the sauce is good and the cheese was up there with the likes of Grande. I'm a fan and look forward to returning. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

See all

I don't even know where to begin! I love this place! Food is great, atmosphere is calm and relaxing! They have great pizza and other foods HOWEVER their Burgers are AMAZING! This is my go to place for a burger and fries!! I wish I could give 10,000 stars! read more

Best pizza around. Everyplace else around does the usual, pepperoni cheese, etc. blah blah. This place has super combinations and flavors in pies like the Godfather, idk what they've got on there, a little of everything, it's fantastic. It's a super clean friendly fun atmosphere with attentive service, fresh ingredients and fantastic pizza. The pizzas here have new combination of flavors and tastes and it may cost a little more but it's better and it's worth it. Treat yourself! All I ate was the Godfather pizza and coke to drink it was great. read more

Hubby and I have heard great things about this place and it did NOT DISAPPOINT! The Caprese Salad was probably the best I've ever had, and that side order of meatballs topped with ricotta, EXTRAORDINARY!!! We will definitely be back to try more of their food. Our server was also a cut above read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

See all

Didn't live up to my expectations both delivery and food. Looking for another place to get pizza from in the future.

Best pizza around. This is our local pick for takeout. Can't go wrong w Bronx Bomber or Godfather pizzas. Proper caprese & Italian antipasti salads. read more

Second time here and took kids Yo! Their wings are fire! Delicious. Zucchini fries were also on point. Mozzarella sticks were fire. Honestly this place is ridiculously good. And prices are pretty decent as well. read more

Best Spagetti and meatballs! A friend and I have been in search of good spaghetti and meatballs. We have tried a few places and this is what we found. The place on the beach (Mario's), the food was ok but prices were high $24 for the meal and $4 for a can of coke. Another place ( Two cousins) the food was good and meal was reasonable but when my friend asked to order one more meatball to take home for her son to try, she was charged $8 for one golf ball sized meatball. Finally we tried Brooklyn Pizza Co. I wish we had started here and saved time and gas. The spaghetti and meatballs was delicious and the portions were huge, and all pasta dishes come with a side salad and garlic knot. The meatballs were the size of tennis balls, I included a picture of a meatball appetizer. Our server Anastasia was so attentive and the owner even stopped by the table to see how our meal was. The prices were very reasonable especially given how much food you get. I made the mistake of sitting at a table near where the food comes out so now I want to order everything because it all looked so amazing. Definitely our new place. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Mama's meatballs. Homemade and served with fresh ricotta and marinara. - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

I've wanted to try this place for awhile (live 5 miles away) and I'm kinda pissed at myself for not doing it sooner. I could've stayed all night; very clean, great friendly service, good food and Beatles/Lennon satellite radio. The staff is BEYOND awesome (Amber intercepted my boring beer choice & suggested sangria- Holy Crap it was GREAT...and I'm not a wine drinker AT ALL!). Thank you again What is in the house dressing?? I can bathe in it- friggin delicious. Well done guys. I found NOTHING wrong with every aspect of this place....and nothing makes me happier then to pick apart & roast a business. read more

See all

So glad they made it through 2020! This is where we take everyone when they visit! Everything is so fresh, the owners take great pride in what they serve, Mamas Meatballs, zucchini fries, the hamburger is unbelievable, and the pizza is the best. read more

This place has not only the best food hands-down (it doesn't matter what you order), but the best staff! The pizza crust is the closest I've found to authentic Italian, and I've truly never found a more helpful and professional staff anywhere else. I've worked in the gourmet food industry, and, although small-town, the food quality here is unsurpassed. read more

Yet again another Brooklyn pizza made to perfection! Boys get the pepperoni mushroom, I get vegging out - gluten free. Best gluten free pizza anywhere!!! These boys know how to run shop! Continue the brilliance of a perfect pie. My husband can't wait to try the Cheesesteak. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

See all

Would be a five star review if better service. Closes at 9pm every night. Don't show up after 8pm Ordered an appetizer and specifically said we would like it first and all food came together Told owner who came to ask how service was and told him and he could care less. Didn't even address the situation. Food was great. Despite an extremely limited Menu due to chef shortages, pizza and wings great!Recommend the mamas meatball pizza and the wings. read more

Horrible take out service.. waited almost 2 hours for a pizza after calling in. No explanation but appears they gave away 3 pizzas to people who ordered after me. But ... the owner apologized and gave a gift voucher for my next visit. The pizza was delicious. read more

Pizza was 40 mins late, undercooked and cold. Have ordered from before many times with no problems. Asked for a refund as pizza was inedible and was denied. Will not go back. read more

Ordered 2 chicken parm subs for delivery. Delivery guy had no mask on. Subs were awful. Chicken was burnt to the point where it was at least half black. Very little cheese. Very little sauce. Very expensive subs. Over $28 to deliver 2 awful subs. Subs came with potato chips which were packed in the styrofoam container with the subs. Completely soggy chips. I won't order again. read more

Ordered a pizza for delivery and it was one of the best pizzas I've ever had! The flavors of the crust, sauce and cheese all stand out which tells me they use high quality ingredients. Excellent pizza! read more

Every time I call the most friendly person answers. It's the realist NY style pizza I've had and I'm from NJ/NY. Food is always delicious, fair pricing and the quality you're looking for when you want a good pie. read more

So it was pretty good, not running back again but if in the area and hungry, I would stop again but not enough to make a special trip. Wings were good too, blue cheese was good. Really all very good just not overwhelmed. Would probably try something different next time. read more

Took my kids for a quick bite on a Wednesday night in the early evening. Service was fabulous! We ordered two pizzas because my son wanted the cheeseburger pizza and my daughter wanted pepperoni. My son enjoyed his pizza so much he ate the entire pie. My daughter and I were satisfied with ours but nothing extraordinary. The crust was extremely thin and crispy. The cheese was melted perfectly, maybe not quite as much cheese as I normally like. The sauce was very flavorful. If you like super thin, crispy crust, then you will love this pizza. read more

See all

Just ordered pizza and wings again. I thought this place was great when we first started coming here. Now it tastes like all other ok pizza places. Crust tastes different not much to it. You don't taste good dough. The sauce seems sweat. Just not same. Sorry. Don't get much in a fry order. Not crazy about skins on fries. Love the wings, got good spice to it. read more

During this time of COVID, the manager stands behind his pizza maker to "blow under the pizza dough" to release from the paddle! I observed this person holding up the dough and actually blowing the extra flour off the board! Flour being dispersed throughout the oven over multiple pizzas! The manager was not concerned. " That's the way pizza is made". Anyone agree?! read more

Awesome pizza can't wait to come back and try the rest of the menu. Justin our server was freaking awesome. Great place great atmosphere.

Good pizza, especially for the south where I've found that the crust just isn't very good usually. A little pricey, like everything else in the area. read more

The food is great-always prepared fresh and to the perfect specifications. While to-go is easy, the service is amazing (especially Justin). . His attention to detail and positive attitude makes dining a real treat. We'll even drive over from south Tampa. Outstanding overall. read more

Wow I am truly amazed by this place. Awesome staff. And also can I add that the owner comes up to you and talks to you. This was the best cauliflower crust pizza I have ever had. I have had many pizzas but I have never seen one like this. If you are ever in the Seminole area you should go and try this amazing Brooklyn pizza. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Cauliflower pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

Absolutely great New York style pizza. Also salads, pastas, calzones and the like but all I can speak for is the pizza. Outstanding. If this place delivered to my house my physique would rival the "sloth" guy in the movie Seven. As an added bonus the sangria is one to rival the Columbia restaurants. read more

First visit and WE will be back (The 4 beautiful, silly, bothersome gently-old ladies in the corner booth!) Had a great time, service wonderful and even better food. Staff are friendly, patient, helpful and just plain AWESOME. Thanks Tyler and Brad for making our visit memorable. Great Service, Great Food, Great Atmosphere. Definitely a 'go to' place for our monthly Ladies Outing... you poor things. Ciao Dang so busy chatting with my friends and tasting the beautiful dishes we forgot to take pics. Everything was delicious, not one complaint shared between 4 picky old ladies. Had: Zucchini rolls, garlic knots, amazing HUGE Calzone, and 2 pizzas. Stella in a nice cold Stella goblet, loved this! Also tasted the Zepolis and had to stop myself from shoving them in my mouth. Just a simple native girl from Treasure Island, Fl. Big THANKS all read more