After my Saturday experience, I have to take away one star. At 6:45pm I phoned for a take-out order to get only a busy signal. I was right around the corner, so I figured I'd just go there and place my order inside. I was told they are too busy and have all the orders they could handle from now until they closed at 9:00pm. No "I'm really sorry" or "Please try us again." I understand being busy, but I felt like I was not welcome here. If your kitchen gets swamped at 6:45 and you can't take any more orders for the next 2 hours and 15 minutes? You may want to consider getting a 3rd cousin to come here and help out. So I ended up going to Fortunato's on Starkey. They were also slammed, but their kitchen is a well-oiled machine and my pizza was ready in 30 minutes, as always. read more

I guess they had ownership turnover last year. We waited WAYYY too long for our food in this tiny restaurant. This food is absolutely terrible. I got the Chicken Marsala and the chicken looked boiled. Like with the pasta. And then chopped uncooked mushrooms on top. Someone got lasagna and most of it was still cold. Horrible. They saw we hated our food and did nothing. Don't waste your belly, time, or money. It's not good at all. read more

Hidden gem! I highly recommend this place for true authentic delicious Italian food. We ordered a pizza with 1/2 cheese and 1/2 meat lovers. We also got the chicken piccata which was delicious! Not much of a wine selection but that's ok. The food is so delicious and so worth the wait. It's a very small place. There is quite a bit of a wait so be prepared ...this is not fast food. Enjoy the experience and tip well as the server deserves every bit! Such a sweet lady! read more

See all

Our new favorite pizza place- hands down! This little gem has been right around the corner for a long time and we just didn't try it. Recently we decided to give new places a go. Well, the buck stops here! Two Cousins Pizza is our go to from here on! Always cooked perfect and hot! Great customer service! Fantastic carry out deal! Give them a go! You won't be disappointed! read more

Two Cousins Pizzeria - Fantastic!!! The crust is crispy, the perfect amount sauce and cheese. Our new favorite!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

Heard this place is horrible .Someone said they got bad pasta & the portions were small New owners probably won't be around long if they continue read more

Not the same pizza as before price when up and quality has gone down. Not the same place as before.

We've been there twice and it was fantastic! The lunch buffet was great. Tonight we got a calzone and small pizza. Wonderful. I've only had crust like that in Italy. I don't usually care for calzones because they're too ' bread-y'. This was light but stayed firm. All the ingredients were fresh. And the owner is a class act. I hope you'll try it sometime. read more

Service was wonderful. But when you serve sour pasta not so great. She took it back and said he was remaking it. Well the noodles were still sour. I hope I don't get sick. However the fettuccine Alfredo was nice. But not enough for me to EVER go back or recommend. read more

Excellent! My favorite pizzeria locally. Service was impeccable - I think her name was Claudia. So efficient and friendly. It was one friendly man in the kitchen and truly some of the best pizza I've had in ages - the apps were delicious to boot! My favorite was the antipasto dish. Highly recommend and I live in NYC; I know my pizza! read more

GREAT pizza... I will be back for more than the pizza. Sharree the owner is so interesting. world traveler. also makes own sauce and other things ... I will call before and tell him what my wife and I would like ,,, he said he would get it and prepare it.... love this place... a real diamond in the rough read more

Best Pizza! Good service! Definitely reccomend!! Everything is fresh and made to order.!

This place just opened a few weeks ago and it is about time we had an exceptional Italian restaurant in out area. They have a decent menu and the pizza is out of this world. This time we had the homemade lasagna, and it tasted homemade. Large portion with bread. Wished they would have offered a salad with it though. It was more than I could eat in one sitting. The people running it are very nice and the restaurant is clean. I have a new favorite. Watch out Bellas. read more

Two Cousins Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

If you are lucky enough to get it, the food is GREAT.... but, unless you arrive at 4:00 when they open, don't expect to be seated. We had the good fortune of ordering pizza for take out ONCE in March 2022. Since then we have tried three times to eat in the restaurant or order carry out with no success. The first time we called and received a constant busy signal. Someone posted online they were IN the restaurant and the phone was left off the hook. Our second in-person visit was to take family there, and were told there would not be a table ready for an hour. It's a VERY small place, but they didn't seem to mind turning away customers. Our final attempt was at 7:00 last night . We saw there were only two tables occupied, and both looked like the check had already been paid. We waited patiently at the door for 5+minutes before anyone who worked there ever saw/greeted us. A man from the kitchen poked his head out to ask if we were there to pick up carry out. I explained no, we wanted a table to eat in the restaurant, and his response was that they closed in 15 minutes (they advertise they're open until 8:00 pm), but we could seat ourselves if we liked. We chose a booth, but after a few more minutes were still never greeted with menus or anything. We decided to leave and on the way out, a woman came out of the kitchen and asked if we wanted to order.... at the counter.. on the way out the door. I said, no, and the man from the kitchen said they were closing in 15 minutes. She tried to explain that just meant we needed to get our order IN by that time. For a business that has wonderful food, that is clearly in demand, they need to work on their customer service skills. Making a customer feel like they are a bother or an inconvenience by arriving an HOUR before the advertised closing time (when they are only open 4 hours a day!) is not how you build clientele. I get the vibe the man in the kitchen is the cook and owner, who cares about his food and HIS time, but clearly not about his customers or growing his business. He may not even care about a bad review, so I post it as a cautionary tale for those who are interested. read more

First time there. I was very impressed with the food. True italian sauce. Great pizza. Large portions. Dinners were priced right. Very good set ice. Debbie was exceptionally attentive. We will be back. read more

So I like to give praise where it is due, but also bring to light places that seem to not go through the effort. It used to be amazing before it was sold. We have been going there for about seven years or so. It was an Italian family owned joint before and like I said, it WAS amazing. We went there a couple of days ago and it no longer amazing. Much smaller portions for one thing. The marinara has changed and it not even close. The owner raves about his own food, but the Lasagna was barley ok and a tiny portion. The meatballs in the Spaghetti and meatballs were tasty, but much smaller and dry and also a much smaller portion. The garlic knots were tiny and mot much flavor also. The dress code is as if there is none for the employees and owner. The server was good though is all it really had going for it. It tasted as though most everything was microwaved also. What a shame. We now no longer have a true Italian restaurant less than a mile from us. We wont be eating there again. read more

Their pizza is excellent. I got a large pie and a Sicilian, both delicious. My mother-in-law moved so, unfortunately we won't frequent the place like we had planned, but they definitely deserve your business! Try them! read more

What a fantastic find! We tried: the chicken Marsala, baked ziti, garlic knots, meatballs, eggplant parm, homemade tiramisu and cheesecake. All the food is made to order and I quote (from my mother in law) "best chicken Marsala I've had in 68 years!" Inside is super cozy, with Italian decor. They have italian music playing that wasn't too loud, which is great because we were able to hear each other from across the booth. Marlena is a doll and we can't wait to bring other guest to this great place. read more

Came here and picked up a carry out order. Everyone was very friendly and it seemed like a nice family-owned restaurant. I ordered garlic knots and a pepperoni pizza. Garlic knots were ok but didn't have too much flavor. And they were loaded with butter, like sitting in a pool of butter. Decent but not spectacular. The pizza was extremely bland and they skimped a little on the pepperoni. It may have been one of the most flavorless pizzas I've ever had. Almost as if somebody took a branding iron to my tongue and burnt off my taste buds. It wasn't disgusting, just boring. Sauce had absolutely no kick. I do, however, want to go back and try the lasagna, but that was the first and last time I'll ever order the pizza. I'll let you know how the lasagna is! read more

Tucked away little gem... Cute place. Awesome Italian food! Great spot for locals to enjoy.

Wow, what an outstanding experience. If you want real Italian stop here at two cousins pizzeria. It's just a little joint on Seminole Boulevard in Seminole Florida. Either call ahead 15 minutes before your arrival or plan on having a glass of wine or two. .... libations while you wait for your fresh cooked Italian food that has not been pre made sitting in a freezer and/or refrigerator. The owner, his name is Carlo unbelievable as he's had several restaurants. It's a family affair and those that are not family "staff members" are outstanding service providers. I'm a restaurant owner, however, not in town but would be proud to say that this food came from my kitchen. FROM specialty pizzas two salads this place is top notch some of their specialties: Fettuccine Alfredo, chicken alfredo, chicken marsala, eggplant ala Siciliano, chicken parmesan. The picture shows is left over from a chicken parmesan, the portions are huge. Don't miss this opportunity. Also the only place that I've ever been able to run into fried ice cream. If you've never had it give it a try outstanding for $3.95 read more

One of the best pizza places, we have every been in. Both garlic knots, and Parmesan wings. Pizza is very good. It might not to fancy outside, but it is one of the best tasting pizza ever! read more

This is the best Italian food we have found in the area. I haven't tried the pizza, but the pasta dishes are out of this world. Huge portions, piping hot, fresh out of the oven! The antipasto salad is a must every time we go, and it's bit enough for the table to share. The red/tomato sauce on the pasta dishes is so delicious and flavorful. The bread is freshly made - crusty on the outside and soft on the inside like it should be, and is served with a dish of oil for dipping. The aroma of garlic hits you in the face (in a good way) as soon as you walk in the door. Claudia is amazing. She treats you like family! It's a small place, so if you have more than 4 in your party, expect a wait for a table, especially on the weekend. But it is SO worth the wait. read more

Went there this evening with my wife. We split a antipasto appetizer, then ordered a " Two Cousins" calzone for her and a 12inch cheese pizza for me. The food exceeded my expectations. It was great. Our server Patty was friendly, knowledgeable, and promt. Over all outstanding and for sure will return. Having grown up in N.Y.C. in the 40's & 50's this was like a touch of home. read more

So sad to leave a negative review..trying to find a good pizza place in our area, feeling like we'll never find it. We ordered delivery, had no problem with the wait time or our delivery server, he was very polite. Opening our food, our stromboli and boneless wings were so black, they were burnt to a crisp. I'm sure the food is fine when it's not black and over cooked, but whoever looked at our blackened order and sent it out should be ashamed of themselves. Sorry to say we will not order again. Good luck and hope you improve the problems. read more

Two Cousins Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

See all

This place is AWSOME and I never say that for any food place in Florida. Its Italian food, great pizza. The desserts oh man sooo good. The chocolate cake oh was soo silky smooth and good. The canoli so yummy. We ate the desserts so fast I didn't take a pic of them. I eat like a pig every time we go. Just found the place 1 month ago been there 5 times. Eat there if you can hot and fresh oh I'd go right now if I could. Service is so friendly and nice. Sit relax enjoy. I honostly can say this place is great I really enjoy the food. Tried meals for 1st time last night. Unreal. My son loved the huge bowl of food he had. Large plates of food dripping of love. Please check it out. People in Florida dont know what good Italian food is. read more

Two Cousins Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

See all

First time trying this place. The food was delicious. We had cheesy bread and a pepperoni pizza. It's small and cute on the inside. Service was good- Very friendly. I'd def come back. read more

Two Cousins Pizzeria - Cheesy bread-- so good! - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

the pizza, pasta, and desserts are great. I would recommend this place to every local nearby if they want great Italian food!

The cheesy garlic bread did not look like the picture when I got it, it was undercooked. The pizza is ok. I think the crust is not scratch in house, it always looks like a pre-made shell. Maybe this place is better for dine in than carry out because I always carry out and though I live 3 min away, it still seems that things cooled down too fast. Either way, westshore and mamas is probably a better bet for me as far as quality goes. read more

Great very small place Great pizza and all Italian dishes Friendly Only opens at 4 pm Has delivery Around the corner from me Very convenient when open read more

Tried it once and that is enough. I love pizza NY style but this was a little too thick for me and VERY well done. The bottom of the pizza was black. Enough said. read more

Very friendly and nice. Food was not to my liking at all though. I hate to write a poor review, but I think the current rating is misleading. Sorry. read more

Sorry to say, but the pizza was bland and boring. I love NY style, thin crust pizza, but this one failed to please my tastebuds. I do not think that I will be back. The restaurant itself was nicely Italian inspired with its decorations and smelled great when we walked in. I do wish them best of luck with the place, but the pizza didn't do it for me. read more

NY style pizza . Garlic knots to die for. Someone criticized the garlic butter sauce which is beyond me, because that's what gives those hot, crispy nuggets their awesome flavor. I've also enjoyed their meatballs, eggplant rollatini, stromboli, baked ziti, and spaghetti. A mountain of food every time, enough to share or to take home leftovers. If you order wine they fill up your glass all the way to the top - even more reason to go back for more. read more

Such an awesome restaurant! You want authentic Italian food? This is your new Italian restaurant. The food was outstanding. My Dad got a massive stromboli that was so full of excellent ingredients, out if this world! Mom gets this bubbling lasagna that is like a party in your mouth. My aunt gets this dish called Chicken Riggi that is so creamy, you've got to try it!! And my wings were superb. They were baked and juicy and just wow. You've really got to get here!!! read more

I don't know if this place is still open. Called for a lunch delivery and no one answered. Thought I might have misdialed, so called back and let it ring. Voicemail finally picked up and said they would be closed for July 4th! read more

Very simply put, this is a solid spot for pie. It's not insane , but it's really solid. The dough has a nice light flakiness to it, and they are consistent with the food they put out. The wings are clearly baked , and really fall off the bone because of that. The hot and mild are both great. The wings her really do kill it as far as how they are prepared. It's really all about what you are looking for, and knowing what to order and where to order it from. Here I would say get a large pep and hot wings. It's not a gourmet Italian spot, it's just a super solid family establishment that has the nicest people and the same food consistently day in and day out. If you live in Seminole , go show some support to our local businesses and get a pizza. read more

Pizza was very good. Garlic knots are delicious and different. Loved their antipasto! Looking forward to returning to try the Italian dinners. Patty is a wonderful server, you can tell she love the owners and everything they put out. Forgot to take pictures., next time. I am so happy we have a neighborhood real italian restaurant, small but comfortable. As I said, can't wait to return. read more

We are so in love with this place. The food is delicious and the staff is unbelievably personable and friendly.

Tremendous food and huge portions! We got spaghetti and meatballs and chicken parm. Both were amazing, and big enough for at least 2 meals! Also ordered a salad, but they messed up and accidentally gave me someone else's cannolis. I have never been so happy to have my order messed up! Best cannoli I have EVER had. Will definitely go back again! read more

Excellent New York style pizza! Garlic knots are amazing as well! Ordered carry out but noticed they have 6-7 very comfortable looking booths for dining in. Over all I'm very satisfied! Will return. read more