Brooklyn Pizza

I'm from a small country town in TX called Anna. Someone from TX came here last month and said I…read moreabsolutely had to try Fortunato's. Well, let me say it was amazing!!! Definitely Will be back. Some of the best pizza I've had since I've left NY.

I've been a big fan of Fortunato's for over 7 years now and usually get take-out several times a…read moremonth. My usual 18-inch pepperoni pizza recently jumped in price from around $20.40 to $24.00! (Their online menu has not yet been updated with the new prices). That's a whopping 17.65% increase! I know times are tough, and I could understand a $2 increase, but seriously? That sort of hefty increase FAR outpaces inflation. See the attached photo... I realize that delivery truck caused a major electrical repair and you had to close for over a week. My apologies, but I'm not going to be able to help you get back to where you once were. Please understand that I can get an equally great 18-inch pepperoni pizza nearby from another Mom-and-Pop joint in the Bay Pines area for around $18.50. That's 22.9% less I have to pay for almost the exact same quality pizza. So I do wish you luck, but that's it for me. Thanks for the 7+ years of excellent pizza!

Supreme Stromboli

Seafood Pasta

See all

Massive, delicious Stromboli's. Fresh tasting marinara.

GulfSide Pizza & Subs

4.5(112 reviews)

4.1 mi

Family-owned & operated

Locally owned & operated

Hands down the best food and service!!…read more The pizza was perfect, the cheese sticks were some of the best we've ever had and the jalapeño poppers were delicious and that's coming from someone who hates jalapeños. Thank you for making our first dinner in Clearwater AMAZING!!

Disappointed in the quality of the food we ordered. Goodie bread was extremely dry, with very…read morelittle cheese. Pepperoni was okay overall, but still lacking in cheese and flavor. Definitely not as advertised in the photos. We've ordered in the past and absolutely loved it. Hoping this was just a one off, and would be willing to try again in the future.

Hurricane Ron Pizza

Garlic Steak Pizza

See all

16" CHEESE PIZZA

DeRussos Pizzeria

4.3(55 reviews)

2.2 mi

This place is amazing. We are at the beach for a week and I already told my husband I can't stop…read morethinking about the pizza or the wings. We must go back a 2nd time before we go home. NY style pizza seems simple but so hard to master. Many places try and fall short. This place is going to leave me longing for their pizza even after we get back home. The thin crust has to have a nice sturdy undercarriage yet with a nice chewy crunch edge. It was perfect!!! The meatballs were superb. While we already ordered alot of food for two people my husband wanted to try their wings. Amazing! Nice and crispy but meaty. Great buffalo sauce. The service was hospitable, friendly and and warm. We aren't locals and I definitely got the impression this is more of a local hangout especially as it's off the beaten path for vacationers here for the beach.

They are almost there, but really really good number one the fries they have crinkle fries and they…read morecooked them very good but they probably cooked them in vegetable oil or seed oil and they need to change to beef tallow so they are all natural. Number two the sauce it probably comes from a can and you have to make sure it's BPA free liner or plastic enters the sauce. Number three is it grated cheese or do they grade it themselves. Are the onions, mushrooms, etc. organic who knows. Overall, their Philly steak cheese Stromboli is incredible mouthwatering but I'm still concerned with the ingredients. I am also concerned whether the dough has bread softeners in it, which are Carcinogenic. Like do they make the dough there or do they source it out?. I will give them a three right now and if they can prove to me, their ingredients are Adequate I'll increase my rating. I'm gonna eat the rest of my Stromboli right now. This is a picture of it at 12:30 AM.

The interior

See all

Coastal Pizza Kitchen

4.4(134 reviews)

2.6 mi•Madeira-Redington

Excellent Customer Service!…read more I had an order for take out. I got home and realized I was missing an item. I called Coastal Pizza Kitchen and they had the missing item delivered immediately! The charcuterie board is impressive and delicious! The pizza is delicious and fairly priced.

Super yummy pizza... light and delicious, right off the beach!…read more We enjoyed dinner at Coastal Pizza Kitchen, with knotty bread and homemade sauce for an appetizer. The knotty bread was overcooked, but the sauce was yummy. They were out of almost all of their draft beer, with no backups, which was very disappointing. The service was pretty slow, especially for drinks, which were just cans of soda. We got our draft beer before the test of our crew got their cans of Diet Coke. We've driven by countless times, tonight was the slowest I've seen it...warm and inviting with pretty lights and it smells delicious when you walk in the door. We tried the On Island Time pasta, with spicy sauce and super yummy. We enjoyed the Margarita pizza, the Coastal pie was the overall favorite...and you can never go wrong with a sausage pizza! A yummy place to stop for food!

Front door is off Gulf Blvd

Hours!

See all

Menu is one sided as of opening

Two Cousins Pizzeria

3.8(52 reviews)

1.1 mi

Went there this evening with my wife. We split a antipasto appetizer, then ordered a " Two…read moreCousins" calzone for her and a 12inch cheese pizza for me. The food exceeded my expectations. It was great. Our server Patty was friendly, knowledgeable, and promt. Over all outstanding and for sure will return. Having grown up in N.Y.C. in the 40's & 50's this was like a touch of home.

After my Saturday experience, I have to take away one star…read more At 6:45pm I phoned for a take-out order to get only a busy signal. I was right around the corner, so I figured I'd just go there and place my order inside. I was told they are too busy and have all the orders they could handle from now until they closed at 9:00pm. No "I'm really sorry" or "Please try us again." I understand being busy, but I felt like I was not welcome here. If your kitchen gets swamped at 6:45 and you can't take any more orders for the next 2 hours and 15 minutes? You may want to consider getting a 3rd cousin to come here and help out. So I ended up going to Fortunato's on Starkey. They were also slammed, but their kitchen is a well-oiled machine and my pizza was ready in 30 minutes, as always.

Note the new closing time- 8p

See all

Manhattan City Pizza

4.7(27 reviews)

2.5 mi•Tyrone

You know I get it a guy owns a bunch of fast food pizza places and earns a great living this is…read moreAmerica. But if you want to talk to the owner of who exactly made your food, then you can come to this place and support a local businessman. He's from northern Italy and the guy knows how to make Italian cuisine. Really nice man who's very interesting, and just trying to earn a living. His food is some of thee best I've ever had. He is also proud to be an American! God bless him. God bless America.

The works Calzone!! A little light on the toppings. Love the Ricotta…read more Great place though.

Mozzarella sticks

Four Cheese Pizza 16 Inch

See all

The Last Slice

4.7(32 reviews)

2.6 mi•Tyrone

I Just picked up dinner from The Last Slice in the Madeira Beach area and I'm beyond impressed…read more From ordering the food to picking it up everything was fast, smooth, and hassle-free. My order was ready right on time, packaged neatly, and still hot when I got home--can't ask for more from a pickup experience! The staff was friendly and efficient, and the restaurant itself was spotless. Even just waiting a minute or two inside, I noticed how clean and well-kept everything was, which really adds confidence in the quality of the food. Now for the main event: **Pepperoni Pizza**: Absolutely delicious. The crust was crisp, the cheese was perfectly melted, and the pepperoni had that ideal slightly crispy edge. ** Margherita Pizza **: Light, fresh, and flavorful. The basil, tomato, and mozzarella combo was spot-on, and the crust had a perfect chew. **Caesar Salad with Chicken**: Super fresh romaine, creamy dressing, and perfectly grilled chicken. Everything was well-balanced and packed separately to keep it crisp. **Garlic Knots**: Soft, buttery, and full of garlicky flavor. They disappeared fast--should've ordered extra! This was one of the best takeout meals I've had in a while. Everything was made with care, nothing was soggy or rushed, and the flavors were on point. If you are on vacation in this area I recommend stopping in for a pie!

So close but there's no flavor in the sauce Big slice affordable but not for us :(…read more Service is amazing though

Dining area.

Fried cheese ravioli

See all

Entrance.

Gianni's NY Pizza

4.4(498 reviews)

6.1 mi•Tyrone

I'm incredibly picky when it comes to pizza after living in NYC for five years, so my standards are…read morehigh. I have to say, Gianni's is definitely one of the best NY style pizza spots I've found. The slices were fresh, flavorful, and had that perfect New York-style crust. Pazzo Pepperoni was really good too! We also ordered the garlic knots, and they were fresh, buttery, and loaded with garlic. They also have GF crust option. Highly recommend trying Gianni's out!

Gianni's New York Pizza is exactly what you want when you're craving simple, solid, no-frills pizza…read moredone right. We ordered the garlic knots, cheese triangles, and a large cheese pizza, and everything was genuinely delicious. The garlic knots were soft and flavorful, the cheese triangles were a fun twist and really good, and the pizza itself hit that classic New York-style mark--great crust, good sauce, and plenty of cheese. It's a casual setup--you order at the counter, grab your drinks from the self-serve station, and they bring your food out when it's ready. Easy and efficient. The staff was friendly and the whole experience felt relaxed and welcoming. If you're looking for a laid-back spot with consistently good pizza, this is a great choice.

The counter where the order is taken.

The Cosa Nostra Pizza

See all

Kitchen view & ordering area

Pizzitalia's

3.8(41 reviews)

2.7 mi

This restaurant had very good Italian cuisine as well as huge portions. Everyone in our party…read morereally enjoyed their meals

Great pizza and they switched over to the '00 flour! We had their version of supreme, village salad…read moreand side of meatballs. The lemon vinaigrette for the salad was very good. The meatballs were subpar - would t order those again. Very chewy. The pizza's crust was crisp and not soggy from the toppings.

Half Mushroom Half cheese pie

See all

Tuscan slice and pepperoni

Slyce Madeira Beach

4.0(342 reviews)

2.2 mi

My favorite pizza in Tampa Bay. Best location for me was Indian Rocks Beach (for sentimental…read morereasons), but it permanently closed after Hurricane Helene. Thankfully Madeira has it covered. Not only have they mastered the art of perfectly cooked gluten-free crust, the pies are wealthy in fresh, flavorful toppings. I'm super picky when it comes to pizza. I've never ordered my own creation because Slyce offers so many craveable specialty pies. In my top three: Truffle Shuffle (for the mushroom lover in me), French Dip (comes with a savory au jus for dipping), and the Beach Bird (bbq chicken w/caramelized onions). Runners up: Roasted Veggie, Pear-a-dice (w/chicken) and Margherita. This location has a big patio on the gulf, full bar, sports on TVs, ample parking in a private lot, and the staff always provides amazing service. If they were in Tampa, I'd have a dangerous pizza addiction.

Stopped in Slyce Madeira Beach location last night for dinner and as always was a great…read moreexperience!! We were seated upon arrival which was very nice!! Our server, Isabela, was very attentive, friendly and helpful with menu suggestions as well!! Pizza was excellent, full of flavor and brought out hot!! We sat inside which also is a great atmosphere for dining. They also have covered outdoor seating which is also a good option!! Great job to the kitchen staff for doing an excellent job on the pizza!!

Bar

Classic White Pizza (no red sauce) and excellent

See all

Bar view

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

15 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

John R.

10 years ago

Interesting that the few negative comments are all 1 stars.. no 4's, 3's or 2's. That means that a few people have a personal grudge and are trying to sabotage the ratings. Specifically, Antoinette's comments about her delivery indicate that she is too lazy to drive a mile to get to the place, she doesn't have a credit nor debit card (since she was bitching about change), and obviously she didn't tip. While it is conceivable that the her cheese may not have been melted, it is not possible that it was "ice cold". She's a liar. Another negative nellie claims that are not from New York (as if that matters). In fact, the main guy there, who I assume is the owner, is from.. wait for it.. drumroll.. BROOKLYN! A third bozo complained that there were no menus. Apparently they could not raise their eyes and look at the board on the wall. They had menus when I went.. and they have not even had their grand opening yet. Hopefully this person who complained will discover what is on the menu of a pizzeria. Hmm.. pizza? perhaps soft drinks? I bet they have pepperoni, black olives, sausage, and meatballs too. Ya think? If these complainers went to the restroom, they would probably complain that there were no instructions on how to wipe their ass! I don't think the fake 1 star reviewers will matter though... because when I went, the place was packed full of people. read more

Steve T.

170

10 years ago

Awesome Pizza with homemade sauce, not like the cookie cutter restaurants. Can't wait to go back. Service was excellent, as were prices. Dessert was delicious too. A bit loud, but not too bad. Very homey restaurant. read more

Kirsten C.

8 years ago

https://iontb.com/local-chiropractor-and-seminole-restaurateur-arrested-for-felony-child-abuse/ This sways my opinion on this establishment. Support local businesses ran by good people. read more

Stacie N.

9 years ago

Recently picked up a pizza from here for the first time. Good service, took a little longer than was told at ordering but not much. The pizza was good but the crust was pretty blah. read more

Barb T.

10 years ago

We have been there several times since they opened. Have enjoyed everything we tried. Love the pizza, great salads have tried the chicken. Great atmosphere and service. read more

Calvin M.

149

9 years ago

When I'm in Seminole this is where I get Pizza. IT IS AWESOME ! The meatballs are pretty great as well. Kinda of hidden off the road but, worth it! read more

Wu K.

8 years ago

This is my favorite pizza and my style great staff nice people a lot of beers on taps it's a great for Seminole love this place I'll be back read more

Amy G.

254

8 years ago

Delicious food! Amazing pizza! Very clean place and friendly staff! Family friendly also! Check it out if you're in the area! Great place!

Kalynn J.

8 years ago

My new favorite go to pizza place! It's so nice inside. Very clean and fresh. Staff very nice and service always great. Love it

Eerb G.

2 years ago

They have an F rating here due to violations!! Used to love this place. Surprised they are still in business

Scott B.

9 years ago

Hands down the best pizza in town. Great atmosphere and service. You won't be disappointed.

Kelly A.

9 years ago

Best pizza and service bar none. Amazing atmosphere too. It's a weekly must for my family.

Cesar B.

6 years ago

Super friendly staff and the pizza is probably the best in town.

Debra G.

4 years ago

The people are so nice...Pizza was so good.

Kimberly J.

8 years ago

Love

Brooklyn Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Seminole, Florida Coffee near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Seminole, Florida Restaurants near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Seminole, Florida Breakfast near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Seminole, Florida Things to Do near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Seminole, Florida Desserts near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Seminole, Florida Parking near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Seminole, Florida Dinner near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Seminole, Florida Burgers near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Seminole, Florida Shopping near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Seminole, Florida Movie Theatre near Brooklyn Pizza

Best of Seminole

Things to do in Seminole

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Brooklyn Pizza also viewed

The Last Slice

4.7

(32 reviews)

So close but there's no flavor in the sauce Big slice affordable but not for us :(…read more Service is amazing though

Beach Pizza Plus

3.4

(74 reviews)

I've lived in Seminole for over 20 years and never tried Beach Pizza until the Seminole location…read moreopened. I have tried The beach pizza, a cup pepperoni pizza, a sausage pizza and the cheese pizza. They have all been very good! I love they offer different styles of crusts and cooking types. We are from Ohio and love a good super thin crust that is crispy. Whenever I order a pizza with toppings from Beach Pizza I always order it thin crust, crispy,and well done. It's the closest to Ohio style pizza I've had since living here. That said, this place made me a fan of a good old fashioned cheese pizza! I order it regular crust, extra oregano. Man, this pizza is solid!!! I've never had a cheese pizza from anywhere that I was willing to try it a second time, until now! Today was our fourth regular cheese! My son has had the Stromboli and liked it but did say it wasn't as much filling as Fortunato's, which is the best we have found in the area. If you haven't been to Beach Pizza give it a try! The prices are good, it has been very clean everytime we have gone. The service is always friendly and orders have been accurate.

Ordered a calzone to go for lunch. I ordered mine with black olives. Very good! Perfect amount of…read morericotta, mozzarella cheese, and olives. Huge portion and enough for 2 people or leftovers!

Paulo's Pizza

4.1

(88 reviews)

We walked in thinking this is going to be really good pizza or really bad pizza! But we are happy…read moreto say it was DELICIOUS! From the moment we walked in, the 2 guys at the service counter was friendly, and they gave great recommendations for our first time here! We went on a Tuesday night so the ambiance was what you would expect from a pizza joint on a slow Tuesday night! Also NOTE TO WHOEVER READS THIS: splurge on the bread sticks, they are divine!

Paulo's pizza is a hidden gem on Central Ave. Their pizza is second to none and always the best. I…read morealways do take out so I can't comment on the ambiance and service.

Bruno’s Pizzeria

4.7

(13 reviews)

Bruno's is a new pizzeria close to my home in west St. Petersburg. I think their pizza is the best…read morein St. Petersburg, their ingredients always taste fresh and service is very friendly. Please try this hidden gem, you can order online and try their garlic knots, they are delicious!

This is amazing !! Glad we found Bruno's pizza. Pizza is awesome. The perfect crisp on the crust…read more Great lunch special too. Two slices and a fountain soda. Inside has about 30 seats and is super clean. Absolutely worth checking out!

DeLosa's Pizza

3.3

(402 reviews)

The moment you grab the handle to walk through the front door, you're greeted by the most amazing…read morepizza aroma! If you love a thin pizza with a crispy bottom and perfectly crisp crust, you're going to love this place. They also offer wings, salads, and even a cauliflower crust, although we didn't get a chance to try those. We ordered a medium cheese pizza, and it smelled so good that I completely forgot to take a picture until I was already halfway through eating it! The staff was friendly and attentive, the tables were clean, and the restaurant had a quaint, welcoming atmosphere. They also have a great selection of bourbon and tequila, along with a nice variety of beers near the register. Overall, it's a charming spot in a great area. If you haven't been yet, definitely add this place to your list, you won't regret it!

Tony and I had Calliope at John's Pass Boardwalk and we enjoyed walking around. It was sunny, not…read morebusy and we'll the best time to explore in my book. We went into a few shops, nothing truly catching my eye. We decided to eat at DeLosa Pizzeria New York Style Pizza. We ordered a bottle of Ice Water, Budweiser and 3 slices of Pepperoni Pizza for $24 w taxes and tip! The pizza was Great and Pepperoni Greazy which we like and expect. It had very heavy Italian seasoning which Calliope didn't like. But she's 2!! She doesn't truly know real pizza yet!! She thinks all pizza should be in a orange pizza box. Definitely would eat again if in the area! Highly recommend to anyone in the area.

Pajano's Pizza & Taphouse

4.3

(70 reviews)

When visiting family nearby the best Pizza is high on the list for a dinner out. We've been here…read moreseveral times and Mom always insists we get a white pie with PineApple. The service is outstanding and we get to sample some adult beverages before landing on our favorite. My wife and I selected the FiestBier and my Mom chose the Root Beer. We also enjoyed the garlic bread with Marinara for dipping while the pizza was being prepared. The Pie came out fresh from the oven so I warned our party to take their time with that first slice! Leftovers in a box to go for another round the next day. All in $75

One of our favorite go to restaurants! We absolutely love their house steak and cheese and pizza…read more They're so good that we haven't tried anything else. We usually sit at the bar, where the service is always great and friendly, and the other customers are too. They also have a nice selection of beers on tap. Definitely recommend giving them a try!

Amy's Pizza

3.9

(31 reviews)

Best Pizza I have had all year! Also, super friendly service! I highly recommend this local place…read moreto everyone.

We had more great pizza slices at Amy's for lunch today. The slices aren't really aren't…read moreadvertised anywhere (it'd be great if they offered a special and posted it on the wall), but definitely ask for them as they are a wonderful way to satisfy your lunch cravings with some good, freshly made food. There's plenty of seating inside and out front, which gets nice shade from the Florida sun. Good location for beach goers.

Original Pizza Treasure Island

3.8

(124 reviews)

Ordered a medium pepperoni and mushroom pizza for carryout Saturday night. They were slammed with…read moreonly 2-3 people working and quoted about 45 minutes. It took around 40, but definitely worth the wait. The pizza was delicious--perfectly crisp crust, fresh ingredients, and plenty of cheese. The real garlic butter and marinara were $1.50 each and absolutely worth adding. The medium was perfect for two, and our total was only $24. It's a tiny carryout spot with just a couple of tables and a casual, no-frills neighborhood pizza-shop vibe. Everyone was super friendly despite how busy they were. Best pizza I've had in Florida so far. Of note: They usually sell pizza by the slice in the afternoon, but evenings are full pies only. Cheers

I'm pretty sure this is the best pizza in Treasure Island! They not only do pizza but also some…read moreamazing sandwiches! Their location is perfect, since it is so close to the beach. We had a vegetarian pizza one evening--lots of toppings--and another time we stopped for an Italian roast beef sandwich (a hot sub) on a delicious garlic-buttered roll that is accompanied with marinara sauce for the sandwich dip. Excellent, and it was big enough to split the sandwich comfortably. This establishment was closed last year due to the hurricane damage, but they are back! Under new management, but as good as it has always been!

Joto's Pizza - Seminole

3.7

(140 reviews)