New to the area and decided to give the pizza place a try. Friendly staff. Great bar area. Garlic knots are top notch. Husband had the Manhattan BBQ Special Pie. Comes with BBQ sauce base, flame-grilled Chicken, bacon, red peppers, & caramelized onions. Delicious. I had the Build Your Own Pie with bacon, black olives, and caramelized onions. It was amazing. The onions were tender and sweet and perfectly complemented the bacon and olives. Can't wait to go back and try the calzone. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

See all

In town on vacation for the week and have eaten here twice. The pizza was so delicious and the pasta was amazing! The desserts were great also! Brad is courteous and cares about his customers. He also refilled our drinks both times to help out his staff when he was visiting the tables! He also gave us a recommendation to try another night! Would definitely recommend making a trip here for pizza! We will definitely be back!! read more

Service was great! Cheese very good. Sauce very good. Crust is meh, thus the three star. Got a large cheese with x-cheese. Maybe a brushing of olive oil before the cook? read more

Pizza is awesome and I will be ordering again but cheesesteaks are not good. Sandwich meat is in chunks and spiced weird. Get a pizza skip the cheesesteak, Pizza it delicious. read more

Went for the first time and what an awesome experience. Great atmosphere, staff is super friendly, and the Hawaiian Pizza we had was amazing. Definitely will be a go to place for our family. Food: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Ambiance: 4/5 read more

While on a beach vacation, a few locals took us here. Great Thin Pizza and great service. If you're ever in the area, be sure to stop by! And the Bruschetta is one of the best I have ever had. The balsamic was a true thick balsamic that complimented the meal! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Bruschetta - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

Hi. This pizza is outstanding. I didn't realize how far away it is and I ordered for delivery. Sorry. I grew up in North Jersey now I live inFlorida. Craving NYC pizza. This pizza reminds me of that. read more

When we wanted pizza during quarantine, but our go-to was temporarily closed, we went on UberEats looking for alternatives and decided to try Brooklyn Pizza. They have a lot of good toppings, and tons of tasty flavor options. The sauce is delicious and fresh-tasting, and not pasty at all. The mama's meatball and the veg out were both tasty, and so was a plain-old pepperoni. My only complaint is that while the crust has a good flavor, but not a ton of structural integrity, so toppings-heavy pizzas are prone to falling apart. My husband has had the calzone a couple of times and vouches for it. We've also liked the Caesar salad and the lemon cake. They also have a lot of sandwiches and pasta options, but we haven't tried those yet. It turns out they have their own delivery as well! It's on the expensive side for pizza, but it's still a good choice for the area. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - 10" Mama's Meatball Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

Flavor was ok but tasted burnt because the bottom was BLACK!!! Either cooked to long or oven stones black!!! Sausage was slices!!!!

Real New York style pizza. Great service and well run restaurant. We loved being able to watch the pizza tossing guy. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

The best pizza in the USA, and thats coming from a New Yorker! If you only get to get here one time be sure to get the monster calzone! A+++. Great food. Great service. Super friendly! read more

This is our go to pizza joint. Yum and amazing staff! My guy is a New Yorker and I am a midwesterner, our pizza expectation are light years apart! The first time we went for pizza he ordered a pie . I ordered mine. When his came to the table I asked why he ordered a kids pizza (it only had cheese ) we converted now thanks to BP, I enjoy our "pie" extra crispy! read more

There is never a time to stop exploring. When we decided we ~neeeeeeded~ a simple plain cheese pizza, we took it as an opportunity to try something new! A little Yelp search for New York style Pizza followed by a few swipes through some pictures (being careful to zoom in on that ratio of cheese to crust), the decision to order from Brooklyn Pizza in Seminole was made. To comply with safety standards at this time they have a station set up out front of the store. We ordered AND paid over the phone to mitigate contact, however you can order outside in person. The gal met us out front, asked for an order number, and then returned with our huge, delicious box of cheesy dreams come true. The pizza was massive, did I mention that? The amount of cheese on our pizza was perfect and the tang of the red sauce was nice. It was exactly what our hearts needed. Grateful for leftovers today. PS They are selling sangria to-go right now ;) (locally sourced: The Florida Winery sangria is served on draft daily) read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

See all

I really enjoyed my stop at Brooklyn Pizza this week. I found their pizzas to be a very much authentic to New York style pizza. The prices were moderate to good. We are looking forward to our next visit to try some of their Italian pastas. Overall, I say it was a good experience. read more

Hate to say it but it was the worst pizza , soggy and very droopy ...The limoncello cake was awesome ...

Although I'm from Chicago the pizza was good. Not what I'm used to but good. The meatball sandwich was excellent. All the meals were piping hot and the service was excellent. The dining are is clean and well groomed. All food is prepped and cooked in the open so no surprises or wondering what goes on!! read more

This place is a MUST try in our area! Fabulous customer service! I think these people must have worked or trained at Publix! As we all know in the Tampa Bay Area , Publix excels at customer service. The food is made to order with fresh ingredients. Family friendly, lots of food options to please everyone. Good for large groups. A very attentive happy staff! What more could you ask for?? Thank you Brooklyn Pizza for making Seminole your new home! I appreciate it! read more

See all

Love it here. The pizza is legitimately amazing and I've come in often enough that I've made friends with the staff. I don't deviate much from my staple order (Stella and pepperoni/pineapple/jalapeño). It's 100% worth it to swing in or order pick up. You'll thank me later. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

Pizza was delicious but they got my order wrong. Rick took my order and I asked for the 10 piece chicken wings in mild sauce. My order arrived and I had 6 piece chicken tenders. I called to let them know and Spenser answered and pulled up my ticket. It was rung up for chicken tenders but I'm 100% sure I ordered wings because I've been craving buffalo wings for days. I'm not too upset because I was charged the price for the tenders and not the wings (about $5 difference). I would have them repeat your order back before paying and hanging up. *update: do not order the chicken tenders. Over cooked, dry and chewy. read more

See all

Amazing NY Pizza here in Florida!!! It's true! Delishhhh!! We live 50 minutes from them and we do not mind the drive it's worth it!!! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Cheese Pizza. Moody Teenager. - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

See all

Amazing service. Came from out of town and Luis treated us with nothing but respect. The pizza was amazing. As a guest of the town, I highly recommend this establishment. read more

Cold draft beer. Great service. Cool interior. I loved this place when I first visited back in February and had their Greek pizza. I returned this time with my mom and we had The Godfather. The pizza wasn't anything special. I think the difference was that this time I had a meat pizza and their meat is very sub par. The meatballs were mushy and flavorless, and the sausage wasn't your typical tasty, spicy Italian sausage, but instead limp slices of gyro like meat. The pizza was totally edible, but not worth the price. That being said: loved the Greek veggie pizza from my first trip. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Inside bar and dining room - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

See all

Loved it! godfather pizza was fantastic and the lasagna was the best I ever had best full of it. The cannoli was huge. Great service and felt like I got to experience real New York Pizza. The dough recipe is 150 years old! read more

I called ahead and when I arrived I felt like I was family. Greeted warmly. We decided to eat there. Service was on point. Our pizza was delicious. Crust was just right. We ate the whole pie normally hard to do but it was a combination of deliciousness and hunger. I ordered a cannoli and the flavor was more like I remembered as a child in NJ. I loved it! I highly recommend Brooklyn's I think you would enjoy this place. read more

If I could give 0 stars I would. We went and ate in Brooklyn's a couple weeks ago and they had the absolute best mozzarella sticks we have ever had. So tonight we ordered them for delivery, along with 2 pizzas. When we received our food, the mozzarella sticks were awful. First of all there was only 5, not 6 as listed, and one of the sticks were completely empty. On top of that they were burnt, practically inedible. Then to make matters worse our cheese pizza wreaked of some sort of ammonia or something along those lines. Both the pizza and the mozzarella sticks went in the garbage. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Burnt mozzarella sticks; missing one whole stick and missing one with cheese - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

See all

Found this place last year on vacation and positively loved it. Came back this year, still incredibly delicious; everything! We started with the fabulous Mamas Meatball appetizer, then Margherita pizza and dinner salad. Absolutely had to try the "To Die For" Lemincello Cake...wow did it live up to its billing. Chloe, our server was amazing and attentive. This us now a regular stop on our yearly vacation. Advice, don't share the cake, get your own. I will next time. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Limoncello Cake - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

Good pizza, very friendly staff, but I gotta say, their salads and pasta dishes are amazing! Huge salads, great toppings. They're next to Vampire Penguin, try that place too! read more

The food is exceptional! We ordered The Godfather pizza, The White Out pizza and the Lasagna. Extremely large portions. Undoubtedly, the best lasagna we had ever eaten and in my opinion, the best pizza. The crust is amazing! The service was great. Our server was very friendly and answered all of our menu questions. The owner even visited our table. We will definitely return on our next visit to this area. You can't go wrong taking a trip to the Brooklyn Pizza Co. Lasagna, White Pizza, Godfather Pizza, Zucchini Fries, Cannoli read more

I am in love with Brooklyn Pizza. I am on a low carb diet and have missed pizza. I sometimes have some alternatives, but nothing has come close to the gluten free cauliflower pizza crust that I can order here. It tastes like regular pizza crust! It is SO good. It is only available in 10 inch size and they sometimes run out of them, so keep those things in mind. I have also had the buffalo wings, antipasto salad, and the zucchini rolls (they're stuffed with ricotta and baked with red sauce). EVERYTHING has been amazing. I love the buffalo sauce and the crunchiness of the wings. The salad is huge and has large chunks of tomatoes, artichokes, lunch meat and more. The inside of the restaurant is spacious and very modern looking. They have been quite busy on my recent visits. Service has been great as well on my visits. I really love Brooklyn Pizza and with my restrictive diet and the joy I get from my visits, it is now in the regular rotation. If you are into carbs, the lasagna was brought out for the table beside us and it looked amazing. I highly recommend! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Antipasto salad - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

See all

We have ordered from this location before but this time was honestly atrocious. We ordered a Bronx bomber, 20 wings, and a vegan pizza. The Bronx bomber was just okay. We got medium and bbq wings which were so soggy I had to put them in my air fryer. The vegan pizza was just a veggie pizza with no cheese and it was so soggy my friends could not pick it up. We even attempted to put it in the oven and even that didn't help. That was all $70. Next up, have y'all ever heard of the pizza guy coming in your house and then NOT leaving? First of all, we are in the middle of a pandemic. He asked me if I had anywhere to put the pizza and then proceeded to enter my home. Then when he saw what video game we were playing, he would not leave and kept talking to us about it. It was so awkward and made us all really uncomfortable. Also, he dropped our wings on the floor. It was very unprofessional. Overall a very bad experience and it cost me way more than it was worth. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Soggy pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

Great family-like atmosphere. A handful of regulars were in as well. One couple suggested my bf and I share the zucchini fries - wow they were amazing!! They come with a fire horseradish sauce too. Service was good considering they were short-staffed the evening we came in. Looking forward to trying more of the menu The Hawaiian pizza was the main course and phenomenal. Perfect thin crust that wasn't too crusty. The toppings tasted super fresh!! It's hard to find quality pizza here in Florida and they definitely nailed it. read more

Overall pretty good. I believe a Delivery delay made the crust soggy. Otherwise had reasonabley good flavor etc.

We have always had a great experience with take out from Brooklyn's! Dinning in was even better! The pizza is great as always. I also loved the antipasta salad! I'm almost positive we ate everything we ordered that night. The owner or GM was amazing and took great care of my little guy! Gave him some dough to make a pie with. A coloring book and lots of crayons! Experiences like this are so rare! This is one of the many reasons we will continue to support Brooklyn's. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - A little dough for our little pizza maker - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

See all

It took us almost 2 years to finally find a pizza that could even close to what we experienced in New York. The crust is light and crispy baked to perfection. You can taste the fresh ingredients in every bite. They're service is top notch! I'm so glad we found this place!! Excellent! A++ read more

We wanted good pizza and that's exactly what we received. If you can't tell by picture I took and posted, we didn't let our eyes eat first this time. I'm a huge pineapple on pizza fan so this was right up my alley. I don't usually like thin crust, but I really liked this one as my ingredients didn't slip off of the dough whatsoever! We finished the entire pizza and the onion rings (which passed the test!!) in a span of an hour and half with no regrets.The restaurant is really spacious and nicely decorated with a bar and TV's, which are necessities for the average sports fan. Additionally, service was attentive despite having a soccer team come in that day. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Totally Hawaiian Brah - Pizza Near Me - Seminole, Florida

We tried out Brooklyn Pizza for the first time tonight and it did not disappoint. I had pizza and the hubby had pasta with meatballs. Our waitress was wonderful. We will be back. read more

I really am not one to leave reviews. When I do though it is worth it. I just absolutely love this place, I've grown so close with the staff and they have truly made me feel like family. I live down the street and after work when I want to get out but not do anything crazy I come here and have some wine and talk about my day as a way to decompress. I am always bringing new people in to experience the joy this place offers and they leave loving the food and service provided. Well done Brad and family, Sarah read more

After last years review we decided to give it a try again. Tonights food was on point. Thank you for the great customer service and making it right read more

See all

This is our go to pizza place. I have no pics to share because we always down the pizza. Our favorite is the coney island with double pepperoni no ham. We also got their Buffalo wings fried crispy and they were so good. This is a place we are willing to go to for some good pizza. You have to order from here as it's worth it. read more

Brad, just want to thank you for taking care of me pies are always great. Appreciate you. Been coming here since the day you opened.