My food is always fresh and the garlic pickles are my favorite. Only reason why I gave a 4 is because they run out of pickles a lot.

I've enjoyed the BP since it began in 1975. Always have been pleased with the quality and quantity of its sandwiches. Love that they are locally owned. But today I had a problem. First on their website site they say drop us a line but only provide phone or fax numbers. Email tends to work these days. The problem im trying to report is pricing. I ordered 1 large roast beef sandwich and 1 large Brooklyn Pickle sandwich. The price sign says: $9.25 for each sandwich. When told the amount, it was $21.01. In the past it was $19.98 as it should have been today. So your very pregnant cashier is either skimming or she failed math. $1.02 isn't the point. When you post a price that's what you charge. Ken and Craig, not what i would have expected. Richard Butler read more

Giant sandwiches are huge, they could easily feed two people. The homemade soups are out of this world!! Easily the best sandwich shop in Syracuse!! read more

I have to stop at Brooklyn pickle whenever I'm in Syracuse. It's just too good to miss. Half sandwich actually equals a whole sandwich here. They are huge. Huge. Huge. I love a simple turkey, American, lettuce, tomato on white or wheat. We like to take it to go and enjoy it outside before a visit to the local zoo. read more

Our first visit and the sandwiches are amazing! The bread was great and the meat was real- not just lunch meat. The cheese cake was excellent. We paid $30 for two sandwiches, two desserts, 2 sodas and of course a Brooklyn pickle. Could not eat it all if we tried in one Setting. So $30 for two people but will easily make 2 meals each for a phenomenal sandwich - I think that is an amazing deal. Staff were very pleasant and appropriately wearing masks. Could not ask for more. Thank you so much. read more

So I have a confession. I've seen a lot of thingies. Boys' thingies I mean. How can I not have, I mean, I'm a young guy who's been to NYC a lot. And I can say that NYC peepees can be categorized by borough. A Bronx Pickle, wow. Raw and intense. A Manhattan Pickle... well those are a little crazy. And expensive. A Queens Pickle... very interesting and exotic. A Staten Island Pickle... the smallest and least adventurous. But as for the Brooklyn Pickle. My word. Have you ever heard the term "Italian Stallion." Well, yes. What to get: Half order of Corned Beef or whatever you fancy on brown bread. BP is easily Syracuse's best sandwich option (out of the ones I've tried). It's a little chain-y, but there are only two locations. They are fresh, delicious, good value for money and friendly. They're a little like Subway, but way, way, way better. They have nothing on the delis in NYC and some of the delis in Buffalo, but in Syracuse terms this is an excellent sandwich, and you will thoroughly enjoy it, the way I enjoyed your moth... oh crap that's totally inappropriate. Nm. A half order is more than enough for you, my dear. Take my wood for it. I haven't been to the more-oft-frequented downtown location (yet), but this leafy one out in the west burbs is lovely, and clean, and well-lit and cute and has plenty of space. The parking lot is a bit tricky and it's on a bendy part of the road, but come here and get a high-piled sandwich on brown bread and have wichgasms. Not to be confused with the cries of passion in Salem, MA a couple of hundred years ago when guys with big Italian Brooklyn Pickles would come to town. read more

Try the originl Brooklyn pickle- Pastrami. Oh my this is one delicious sandwich. Like the style & ease of ordering. read more

This is my favorite sandwich shop of all time. The meats are great, desserts are homemade and it's a family owned place. I love this location, I've been going here since I was a baby. Why not 5 stars? Because sometimes the bread isn't as fresh as other places. Anyone who lives in upstate New York knows that wegmans makes some mean subs. Anyway get the Italian when you come here and make sure you put on the marinated tomatoes....oh and a cream cheese brownie. read more

Brooklyn Pickle is not just a name. The owners mother grew up in Brooklyn, and the family made regular downstate visits to his grandmother. On every trip, they never missed an opportunity to bring back their favorite "Brooklyn Pickles." When he opened the deli, he wanted to give his sandwiches an extra special touch, and these famous pickles were the obvious choice. It quickly became the shop's signature garnish, and the unforgettable name was born. To this day, every sandwich is accompanied by one of these family favorites. BP is a local sandwich shop with two locations that boasts overstuffed deli sandwiches, huge subs, award-winning homemade soups, convenient catering, and a fun, friendly, fast-paced atmosphere. They are a Syracuse staple and a favorite among locals. So here's the thing...I've personally never understood the hype. BP has never really impressed me. While I've never had a bad sandwich here, I've never had one that knocked my socks off either. At the end of the day, BP is a simple sandwich shop...meat on bread with some veggies and cheese. Nothing separates them really from a sandwich someone could make at home. They boast their giant deli sandwiches, but I've never personally had a HUGE sandwich here. They're normal sized. Normal condiments. Normal everything. Why the city loves them so much is beyond me. Prices are a tad high, in my opinion, for what you get. Service can be so so. The place definitely gets busy during lunch hours and it can become confusing. Again, not that it's bad food...if you want a simple sandwich, it'll fill that void. But don't come here expecting the best sandwich you've ever had. They get three stars from me simply because it's not BAD food. The things that are best, in my opinion, about BP are three things...their pickles, their Italian style tomatoes, and their pudding. There's just something about that damn pudding... read more

Simply the best subs in all of Syracuse in my opinion. Very nice staff works here. Very fast service. Incredible place. A must visit. Prices are very great. Thank you. read more

The people who work here are so nice! They helped me navigate the menu my first time here, and I can't wait to go back! The sandwiches here are made with care, you can taste it. You watch the construction of the food in front of you, and it is rewarding. The meat and bread are fresh, and the pickles are a highlight! read more

If you are looking for a good old fashioned deli sandwich, this is the place for you. I had the special and it exceeded my expectations. Portions are large and all of the ingredients were fresh. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Brooklyn Pickle Special Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

I love this place so much! The staff is so sweet and friendly, always saying hi to us when we come in!- which is at least once or twice a week. The sandwiches are HUGE and I love trying the different soups. I always see the same staff working super hard in there, it doesn't go unnoticed. The food is so good and the people who work here make it even better! Thank you! read more

As sandwich shops go, this one is consistent. Soups are ok, hot dishes are ok, sandwiches have fresh bread and quality sandwich meats. Prices are a bit high, but so is the hype. Don;t go at lunchtime, unless you have time. Looking for a good fresh sandwich, then this is a good place. Pickles are pickles, a cucumber marinated and you get a couple slices, not the half a pickle they started out with. read more

This is a must stop spot for lunch! I do not live in the Cuse region anymore. But anytime we visit, there is a trip to the Brooklyn Pickle. I have seen others get large and small sandwiches but I have never tried anything else than the Brooklyn Pickle sandwich. Heck, I am not even sure if I have purchased chips or baked goods. Everyone raves about their brownies and cookies but I have always focused on getting something I know I like. So, let me describe the sandwich: Its soggy, fattening, and full of everything you want for a deli sandwich. It is made up of corned beef and pastrami. Add some of the thousand island sauce and it is a party! There are usually a few slices of pickles on the sandwich wrap and it comes in two sizes. The half is usually good for one person with a decent appetite. The full is good for someone that hasn't eaten in a while or two normal people. Stop in to enjoy a good sandwich for takeout or eat in. PS: They also sell 5 gallon buckets. The buckets are packaging from some of the pickles they receive. read more

I was so disappointed. I had put off going here because I figured the servings would be huge, or at least as big as Jersey Mike's or a Wegmans sub. They were not even close. **Not enough** meat. More bread than anything. The person who made it definitely slapped it together. I found myself thinking how a subway sandwich is made with more love. Ha, I don't usually find myself thinking like that, but I was definitely impressed with how little she cared about what she quickly wrapped in paper. I won't go here again. When I told someone how disappointed I was in Brooklyn Pickle, they said I should go to Vince's Gourmet Imports in North Syracuse instead next time. read more

Giant portions for dirt cheap. Food is good quality and the place is clean. The workers were slow and not super friendly, but I'd still recommend this place. read more

I have always heard good things about this place but never experienced it for myself. I got the liverwurst sandwich which is generally my favorite. It was pretty great. I didn't even realize they have other meats that most places don't like pastrami. I will definitely try that next time. I got a sandwich for myself and my girlfriend and we split a bag of chips. Our total was less than it was at Subway the week prior for the same amount and better food. It was pretty busy around lunch time, but that's to be expected for a place that is so good. Can't wait to return. read more

Best sandwich in Syracuse by far. Huge portions and extremely delicious!! Staff was friendly and helpful.

This place has the best sandwiches in town. They have every kind of deli meat you can imagine. Whenever I come home I visit this place for lunch. Their soups are pretty good as well. Clam chowder, chicken noodle and steak soup are a few of my favorites. The best part are their homemade pickles. I will buy a jar for myself and won't last long because they are so good. Service is always quick and efficient. I highly recommend this sandwich place! read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

Fantastic large Deli sandwiches! Nothing too fancy, but they never disappoint! Been going here for years, and They will continue to have my wallet! If you are looking for special sandwiches like buffalo chicken salad, or Cajun turkey, call ahead to make sure they offer it that day! And if you are feeling extra hungry, be sure to pick up a pasta on the side... may I recommend chicken riggies? read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Buffalo chicken salad sandwich on rye! Not sure if they have this every day. But definitely one of my favorites. - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

Totally amazing sandwich! There half sandwich is probably size of most places "full size" . The meat bread was fresh and tasty , the Cole slaw was ok, only knock I the Russian dressing was more like mayonnaise ,I would go with the mustard next time . But all in all you can't go wrong read more

No complaints here. There are many sandwiches to choose from. My husband had a hard time, me?? not at all. All I did was look at the menu and saw egg and olive and thats what I had on wheat. It was great! My husband got the pastrami and he liked it. Service was fast, lots of people working on that Saturday. I would love to go back for another egg and olive, yum! read more

Looking for a quick lunch and craving a good sandwich? This is the place to go! The sandwiches here are HUGE and very tasty. They put an overly generous amount of meat on the sandwich and you've got to try their Italian tomatoes. They have the perfect spices to compliment a sandwich. I always get the light rye bread. The side dishes, located in the coolers, are also worth the extra money. I highly recommend the anti pasta salad. Lots and lots of toppings and the lettuce is always fresh and crisp: never soggy. And the pickles. You get slices of pickles with you sandwich, but can ask for more or while pickles. They have amazing spices and are just right. No generic mass produced pickles here. If you're in Syracuse this place is a must! read more

Never had a bad sandwich. They are huge. Soups are delicious and no matter how packed they get you will not wait in line more than a minute or two. read more

See all

This place has decent sandwiches with fresh meats and produce. Better subs and sandwiches than your chain sub shop, but the name of the place must be an inside joke because their pickles are absolutely awful. They are limp and offputting. Nothing like an artesinal pickle from Brooklyn. Compared to a NYC deli, overall it falls short, but for Syracuse it's a good alternative. Do people really like your pickles??? read more

Currently we live in Texas but everyone we go home to visit family we always end up at BP, I love this place. It's a taste of home for me. Lots of options for different flavors but I always go with the turkey. read more

To be honest, I had a hard time understanding what all the fuss was about this place. The sandwiches were just really basic and nothing special. I tried a variety of different ones each time I went back since the entire city rants and raves about the sandwiches are amazing, but I didn't find anything worth returning for besides the pickles! The staff, however, were always welcoming, friendly, and on the ball with how they run the place! read more

The pickles tasted terrible. The center of one was hollow. Cannot get the taste out of my kouth. Wilted, brown lettuce, hardly any chicken in salad. Didn't have grilled chicken which is what I originally wanted. Asked for extra dressing, did not get it. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

We eat here all the time! They load the sandwiches so they are bursting with the best ingredients.

Delicious! Half sandwich was teaming with meat and toppings. A must! Loved the Italian sandwich. Pickles were a little mushy-my preference is for crispy. Coleslaw was sweet, but good. Yes!!!! read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Italian sandwich (half) - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

I drive "near" Syracuse about 6-8X/Year, can't be anywhere remotely close without stopping! You can't get better than this place! read more

Obsessed! As a former employee many moons ago, I am very familiar with the cleanliness and orderly perfection of the Pickle. And the food? So fresh, so abundant, so yummy. I dream of these sandwiches when it has been too long! I am disabled now, and the Pickle is very accessible. LOVE. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Hands down best sandwich in Syracuse. If you're in town, you must stop here for lunch. Try a sandwich with their sub sauce, try their awesome pickles (the garlic ones are my fave) and get a yummy peanut butter cup cookie for dessert. They also have Pepsi products and a wide variety of soups, drinks, chips, and salads. You will not be disappointed if you're in the mood for a sandwich! Note: Most people will only need to order a half sandwich. They are very large. read more

If you are looking for a great sandwich, this is the place! Just like the delis in New York City, quick line, plenty of options and good food. I got the turkey on rye which was awesome, but my father tells me the hot pastrami is to die for. Also told the Reuben is yummy but really messy. You really only need to order a half a sandwich though as the sandwiches are so big. read more

Rolled through CuseTown and looked for a sandwich shop near me. Well im glad i found this place. Meat was quality and fresh. Sandwich was delicious. Cool new spot for me. read more

I cant possibly love the Brooklyn pickle more. Its our first stop everytime we come into Cuse (6-8 times a year). My favorite sandwich is its namesake and i always make sure we get pasta salad and neptune stew! The mac and cheese and the hungarian goulash are MUSTS if theyre on the specials menu! So delicious. I cant have the pickles since im allergic to garlic, but my bf loves them (and he grew up here!) read more

The lady who rang me up was so helpful, she explained all the sandwiches and subs, showed us the bread. We split a whole Brooklyn special and it was still huge! It doesn't say it on the menu but it had corned beef pastrami lettuce tomato mayo and pickles- so delicious. Everyone knows each other by name, and the employees are so warm and welcoming. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Brooklyn pickle special. Yummmm - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

In town on business and local folks suggested I try this place out. Got the Brooklyn Pickle special. Great sandwich! Super huge sandwich. I ate half for lunch and half for dinner. Tons of meat and fresh vegetables. Definitely a place to enjoy a great deli sandwich. Glad I stopped in. read more

My favorite place to get food when I'm back home. Always love the corned beef. Ask for extra pickles! They recently expanded and its very nice in there now. (Was cozy before) Many choices for hot or cold food. They are always friendly there. Next time I'm home, I plan on buying a shirt! Bas F. - please go back to Brooklyn at any time... read more