I have been using Brooklyn Cat sitting for just about 2 years and I can't recommend them enough!!! I am so disappointed in myself for not reviewing them sooner! I find their website to be very user friendly, they keep keys on site and with the sitter and communication is always great! Now the most important part! Their sitters are AMAZING! Carson is a GEM! She takes such good care of my boys and went out of her way for our more nervous new addition! She keeps us up to date with the best photos and messages and I am completely at ease knowing my cats are in the best hands! We return home to report cards for the visit with the cutest drawings! My cats love her and I know if anyone can win over our shy girl it's Carson! Highly recommended Brooklyn Cat Sitting! read more

Snowbird here. Can't stand being in NY for the winter, so I head out west for a few months. My 2 house cats don't travel well so I leave them behind but was considering skipping going away this winter. As my cats age and their health issues increase I didn't feel comfortable leaving them behind. When a neighbor told me about Brooklyn Cat Sitting I went online and found nothing but stellar reviews with so many satisfied customers. I tried them for January and February and can honestly say I didn't have a single concern or worry. Tara, the sitter, not only visited 2xs a day but sent half a dozen photos as well as a little written "news brief" on what they were up to and how they were doing. She clearly not only attended to all their needs, with multiple meds and dietary restrictions, but she hung out awhile with them to keep them company! I won't hesitate to go away again now that I've found these guys. HIGHLY recommend these guys! read more

This is a very belated review, but extremely deserved. We found Brooklyn Cat Sitting and Kaitlin during the pandemic, and she was absolutely wonderful with our older boy Mookie. We had such peace of mind knowing that she was checking in on him while we were gone, especially because he was older and would get very stressed when we left. He also had some kitty IBS issues and so was not always the easiest cat to watch, but she never complained. As the pandemic subsided and her business expanded to include more sitters, we had a few rotating sitters watch Mookie and all were extremely professional and kind. The report cards left after each visit were an adorable touch (we appreciate that he never got anything less than an A, even when he had an accident..lol), and we always looked forward to receiving funny photos of him from our sitter. We even received a photo with "congrats mom and dad!" at the top while we were away getting married :) Our beloved Mookie sadly passed in late September, 2023 after 18.5 wonderful years together, and when we let Kaitlin and our current sitter know, they both expressed heartfelt condolences and sent a beautiful succulent gift in his memory. We have since moved out of the city (and have a new furry companion to love, Ziggy), but we would recommend Brooklyn Cat Sitting to anyone needing excellent and reliable care for their kitty while away. They are a very special company and if they ever expand their services into the Lower Hudson Valley, we would be the first to sign up. Thank you for everything you did for us and for Mookie, it was much appreciated. read more

It was my first time using Brooklyn Cat Sitting, much less leaving my cat behind while I was on vacation. I have to say I was so happy with the services. I love the kitty report card I had waiting for me at home and the daily updates I received while I was away to help put my mind at ease. Communication was great between the company, myself, and my sitter. A big thank you to Clark for everything. Any upcoming travels, I will 100% be using Brooklyn Cat Sitting again! read more

Brooklyn Cat Sitting - My fur baby upon arrival ‍ - Pet Sitting Near Me

There are days that you wake up, when you're certain that there is no hope left for humanity, when you believe that we're all trapped in a never ending supersonic rat race into the very bowels of hell. I awoke on one of those days, just before I was due to go away, with no hope of finding a cat sitter for the weekend. After a friend recommended Brooklyn Cat Sitting to me on a whim, I reached out (Brooklyn Bark never got back to me for what it's worth) and Brooklyn Cat Sitting was quick to respond with a lifeline. The communication from the coordinator was excellent. The warm enveloping cloud-like pillow of comfort I felt when I chatted with my weekend sitter Kris via FaceTime left me feeling carefree. Kris had delivered the knockout punch to my stress. But this was only the beginning. We communicated via the Time to Pet app. As I thought of things I forgot, I messaged Kris and received a quick responses followed by with waves of relief at having made the right decision. I received lovely photos and wonderful updates that made me smile and great little messages (and white lies) about how well-behaved my little cuties were. I know for a fact they're demons, but she did make me feel, for a brief moment, that I was a good cat dad. Thank you Kris and Brooklyn Cat Sitting for a great experience! I look forward to using you again! read more

I felt very safe leaving my very nervous cat to their care. They reassured me and committed to spending 30 minutes twice a day. We were updated with pictures and an email. The poop box was well kept she was given treats, fed properly. Came home to a happy cat with a little report card with each day accounted for. My cat Nellie received an A+++. So proud. Crissy was the cat sitter and I was very impressed! Very accommodating! read more

I have used them twice in the past year and absolutely love their services. Being away from your fur babies is always hard and we looked forward to our daily emails with pictures and updates. Love coming home to the report card as well! They are reliable, fairly priced and most importantly I trust them with my baby. read more

Brooklyn Cat Sitting - Our cat Poppy - Pet Sitting Near Me

I went on my first vacation in years, and Brooklyn Cat Sitting's amazing service put my mind at ease. I was impressed by the attention to detail during the intake process to ensure everything was considered from a cat's health & personality to the safety of their sitters. I received daily updates with photos of how my cat was doing. Thank you so much Eleni! When I returned, there was a welcome home note left asking me to text or email that I arrived home safely. I will definitely use their service again and have already recommended them to friends I know with cats. read more

Wonderful A+ cat-sitting service. It was the first time leaving our kitties with a sitter, and we were very nervous about finding someone we could trust to take care of them. Every interaction with BCS was professional and reassuring, and we knew we were in good hands when we filled out the multi-page survey with questions that clearly showed that they understand cats! Carson was exceptional. She was a good communicator and sent us updates with pictures after every visit. Even our shy boy who hides from every visitor loved her. It took a couple days to show himself, but Carson built trust and rapport with him and by the end of the trip was snuggling with her and purring. He's actually more confident now around strangers after Carson. We're thrilled that we now can travel more confidently when we know our kitties will be in good hands. read more

Top-notch service here! Our sweet kitty told us so! My partner and I booked BK Cat Sitters after a not-so-pleasant experience with Brooklyn Bark- we should've called here first! Before the sitting began, our lovely sitter Alyana came by to pick up keys and meet us and our cat. She was super pleasant and likeable and we immediately felt we could trust her (super important when strangers are in your home lol) Alyana arrived on time for feedings, sent photos and videos and gave us a daily update on how things were going. She also left a very cool report card and swag after! Very happy with this business and service overall. Would absolutely recommend!! read more

Amazing company, A+ service. I'd continue using Brooklyn Cat Sitting if we didn't move away to Westchester, but whoever we end up switching to up here has a high bar to meet. We typically had Eleni as our cat sitter, and she was so fantastic with our two cats. So caring and attentive, always sent amazing photos, texted when she had any questions, etc. We didn't once have a single issue in the 3 years we frequented their services. One piece of advice is they book up fast! So if you're looking for last minute care, it's possible they won't be able to accommodate. Not a ding at all, if anything, it's indicative of a well-sought after service. read more

My experience with this company was AMAZING!! This was my first time using a Cat Sitting company so I didn't know what to expect. However, they were very professional and communicated in a timely matter. The first time I meet Michal (My Cat sitter) I got good vibes from her. Which made me feel safe and secure in my decision on having her cat sit, while we were away for 8 days. She texted and communicated with me in the Brooklyn Cat Sitting portal daily with updates along with photos of my Cat. It was such a pleasure in seeing my Cat doing well and enjoying Michal's company. This put me at peace and allowed me to have an enjoyable vacation because I knew my Cat November was in good hands. She feed, cleaned/changed his litter and gave him plenty of petting time (which he loves). She also, used some of her litter when informing me that his litter ran out because he was drinking more water then usual. Furthermore, on the last day of service she left a report card with updates each day of November (he received an A+) :)! Needless to say I will definitely use their services again and I recommend anyone that is looking for a Cat Sitter- Brooklyn Cat Sitter is the company to choose :). read more

Highly recommend Brooklyn Cat Sitting! They have been a godsend for our special needs kitty Chloe. We love their professionalism, thorough policies and procedures that adhere to high ethical standards of animal care, sophisticated client portal that creates ease and accountability in booking and communication, dependability (during the recent wildfire smoke, they continued their scheduled visits), and warmth towards the kitties in their care. Our cat sitter team member Shandi feels like a trusted member of our family. Her visit photos are some of the prettiest we've ever gotten of Chloe! What a joy to see our normally hides from everyone kitty contentedly sitting on Shandi's lap and eating heartily while she's visiting (things she never did for prior sitters). We have always found Brooklyn Cat Sitting A+ and recommend them heartily! read more

Want peace of mind while you're out of town? Brooklyn Cat Sitting is a great choice! Danielle took great care of my 2 cats while I was gone for the week, and I even got daily photos and updates to calm my separation anxiety. I am SO glad I found them, as I now have a go-to crew the next time I go away. Thank you so much for being so loving to my 2 little gray boyz. 100% recommend :) read more

This is a long-overdue review! We have used Brooklyn Cat Sitting on multiple occasions and they're consistently high quality. Once they find a sitter who's a good fit for you and your kitties they try to always book that person. Danielle especially hit it off with our kitties -- and one of them in particular has a very challenging personality, so that's something of a miracle for anyone. She takes care of our kitties like they're her own and sends wonderful photos of them on each visit with great updates so we know how they're actually doing, not just that she came and went. I absolutely recommend Brooklyn Cat Sitting and especially Danielle! read more

I've had very good experiences with Brooklyn Cat Sitting. They send me daily updates with photos while I'm away, and their sitters make a genuine effort to play with my cat, who is very shy. I've found their online portal easy to use. read more

Brooklyn Cat Sitting - Pet Sitting Near Me

We love Sally! Our cat is a special needs cat with serious anxiety and territorial aggression. Sally worked with me to get to know our cat and seems to really understand her. She knows how to act around our kitty to keep her calm and deescalate her if she starts to rumble out of fear. We would definitely recommend Brooklyn cat sitting as well as sally! It was really easy to book and communicate with them and they are very thorough! read more

Brooklyn Cat Sitting cared for my boy for 2 days. Sent daily updates and photos and my cat was happy when I got home. I really liked the touch of leaving a note to text back to confirm you've arrived home. Will definitely use again in the future and would be comfortable to use them for longer trips away too. read more

This was my first time using a professional cat sitting service and I'm totally hooked. I just came home after 5 days away to the happiest cat thanks to Kris at Brooklyn Cat Sitting. While I was gone I got effusive text updates including pictures every time she came to visit and I returned home to a great "report card" of how my cat did while I was away (how much she ate and played, whether she went to the bathroom normally, her behavior, and overall health). It made me feel like they really cared about my cat. Kris even left me a little greeting card and a canvas bag! Brooklyn Cat Sitting is AMAZING! No more asking friends to pop by and check on my cat when I go on vacation. I don't know if you can request a sitter, but if so I highly recommend Kris. I'm sure everyone who works there is just as friendly and professional though. LOVE THEM read more

Brooklyn Cat Sitting - Pet Sitting Near Me

Brooklyn Cat Sitting is amazing! For the 2 years we lived in BK, they watched our cats Elton and Bernie every time we went out of town (even on short notice). The sitters were always sweet with our kitties and very responsive to our texts, emails, and calls. They consistently checked in and were great with communicating the needs of our pets. The portal they use made things very easily bookable, and the "kitty report cards" we got every visit was also a nice touch. Now that we live in NJ we miss using BCS so much! read more

I have never written a reveiw before but I am so grateful for Megan A for watching MJ. It was my first time ever leaving him with a cat sitter and of course, there was an emergency. Megan picked up my call right away and headed straight over to make sure my cat was okay. Once she got there she updated me on the situation and insured me my cat was okay. She even voluntarily waited there until my roommate got there so my cat wasn't alone. Although an unfortunate situation, Megan could not have been better. I really do not know what I would have done without her. I will definitely be using Brooklyn Cat Sitting again! read more

I used Brooklyn Cat Sitting over Christmas and, for the most part, had a great experience. The initial sign up and consult was super easy and went smoothly. We got great updates from the sitter while we were gone and both cats (even the shy one) liked her a lot. There was an emergency with one cat and the sitter took him to the emergency vet and stayed with him until about 3 am. This was huge because I was in Mexico and definitely unable to get back (and he is the love of my life). Now, both cats are happy and healthy. Yesterday, I had an alternate sitter fall through, so I contacted BCS today. They found us a sitter and set up a consult within hours. Just met with the sitter and she was great. Moving to NY from SF meant losing my free, wonderful cat sitting friends, so it has been really great to find a company I can rely on. I will continue using BCS as long as we are living here. read more

Terrific company. Kaitlin is a pleasure to work with and has excellent communication. Danielle and Alyssa have taken care of our cat several times and each time sent multiple pictures and a detailed, enthusiastic description of the visit. I feel very comfortable leaving our cat in their care. Prices are a little bit higher than I've seen with individual cat sitters, but the quality of the service is far superior, in our experience. Thank you! read more

My sitter was nice, but didn't show up on one of the days I paid for. Their site also gives you the option to book longer visits for more money, but my sitter never actually stayed for the amount of time I paid for (verified by building security camera). That said, when my sitter DID take care of my cat, it was very nice. I got nice pictures of my cat and a description of what the sitter and my cat did every day. I just wish they followed through on some of their commitments. read more

Similar to another review, after waiting a few days after my initial web submission I heard from Kaitlin to schedule the meet and greet. After multiple follow-up emails from me, I never heard from her again. Maybe she does a great job if she decides to follow through on her commitments, but due to her lack of professionalism my search for a cat sitter over the holidays has now been delayed another two weeks while Kaitlin was busy not knowing how to run a business. If you're too busy for new customers, just say it, don't string people along. Bye! read more

We went from reaching out to them (via email) to having Kat sit for us for a week and would absolutely use them again. Loved getting the daily updates. Our sitter was very on-time every day, and clearly followed our guidance on food, litter, water, playtime, and even watered our plants. She sent us daily texts with a few photos & what they did that day. Those texts keep us comfortable, knowing that our babies were being loved and taken care of. These guys have a clear and straightforward system set up, so that nothing falls through the cracks. Highly recommend giving them a chance to sit your cat! read more

As a return customer, while dealing with a major family crisis abroad, waited days to hear back if they could take care of my cats, while my partner joins me in dealing with family crisis. Only after I booked someone else, and asked for my keys back, they got back to me within minutes, trying to squeeze me in for the 2 week period. Pet care should reduce stress, not augment it. read more

We could not have had a better experience with Brooklyn Cat Sitting and our catsitter, Dylan. He was completely professional and conscientious from the first moment of the consultation to the final note we had waiting for us when we returned home. We loved getting texts with his photos and very charming writeups of his visits with our cat, Choppy. She loves to play and it's clear he spent a lot of time with her and her favorite toys. This was the first time we've left Choppy for more than an overnight trip, and we were a little nervous about being gone for 5 days. We booked two 30-minute visits per day and it was completely worth the cost for the peace of mind and great service. We found BCS on the recommendation of a friend who uses the service. I highly recommend Brooklyn Cat Sitting and we'll definitely be using them again in the future. read more

We've been extremely happy with the level of care Brooklyn Cat Sitting provides for our cat Hemingway. Sally treats our cat as if he were her own and sends us pictures at each visit, giving lots of playtime and cuddles. She is a true cat whisperer. Kaitlin is also wonderful making sure Hemingway gets his playtime in and treats! You can tell these sitters really love cats. We've had other sitters from this service and they are all wonderful but Sally & Kaitlin happen to be our more regular sitters. I just came home from a 10 day trip and my kitty was super content when I got home. I could tell he's had all the company and attention he needed! Can't recommend Sally and Kaitlin enough. Their service and piece of mind it provides are worth every penny! read more

Brooklyn Cat Sitting - Pet Sitting Near Me

My anxiety level about leaving our cat for the first time in 2 years was ~high. Brooklyn Cat Sitting was amazing and gave us peace of mind that our cat was in good hands. Their (easy, electronic) intake process is thorough and really sends a message that they know what they're doing! So many good questions were asked so we knew they were doing right by our cat's routine and needs. Eleni was amazing, attentive, and sent daily updates with the best photos and overview of her day. Great experience. read more

Highly recommend this service. We've used BK cat sitting about 5 times now and there's no one else I would trust my kitties to! Each day we get a detailed account of how our cats are and some pictures as well. Booking is super easy on the portal and Kaitlin is very responsive. We've only had Kat as our sitter and she's been excellent- I don't worry at all when we go away! read more

This is such a trustworthy, thoughtful and thorough business. Kaitlin took care of my 5 year old cat Oscar and I felt completely at ease the entire time. I love her updates that come with each visit, including photos - she's honest, she's encouraging, and Oscar likes her very much (he doesn't always love new people). She obviously has a way with animals. The service is very responsive, a good value, and goes to great lengths to provide updates and make the owners and pets both feel safe and confident. I can't say enough good things! read more

We always use BCS when we go out of town so that our kitty Meemer's friend Danielle can come take care of him. The online booking and payment system is easy to work with. We also love receiving daily reports. More than that, we have peace of mind. I know the kitty is in good hands while we're gone. We typically book two visits per day, which can get pricey, but it's totally worth it. read more

I am a passionate cat lover and doting cat mom, and I cannot imagine a more thorough or professional service to care for my cat than Brooklyn Cat Sitting. Kaitlin is a one-woman operation, but somehow manages to run an amazing business. She has a deep knowledge of cat behavior and health (as she is a vet school student), and is truly an animal lover through and through. She sends daily updates and photos, so you can see your pet is dong well each day, and even leaves behind a daily checklist showing that everything you're paying for has been attended to. She is super nice, and very responsive via email. I will be hiring Kaitlin for all future out of town needs! I think my cat likes her better than she likes me, haha! I can't recommend her services more highly. read more

After a recent death in the family, we needed to find a cat sitter on short notice. We were already happy Brooklyn Cat Sitting customers, but the team went above and beyond for us under difficult circumstances. They even sent us a lovely condolence card, which was greatly appreciated. Also, frequent updates with pics of our cats (one of whom has health issues) was extremely helpful. But aside from those personal touches, I can say that Brooklyn Cat Sitting is the best pet service I have ever used. They stayed late after one of our cats vomited just to make sure he got some food down, and they even fixed one of our broken food dishes. I cannot recommend Brooklyn Cat Sitting highly enough. read more

I have used Brooklyn Cat sitting for some years now and they are so amazing. My main cat sitter Kat is just amazing but there have been times I have been away and others have filled in from Brooklyn Cat Sitting and they also have been great. The portal makes it so easy. Even when we have had a fill in they transfer all the information so I have to do very little. They send constant updates and make me my two cats are safe while I am gone. I cannot recommend them enough! read more

So utterly and completely happy with Brooklyn Catsitting. I did a Google search and found a few services, but I the info on the Brooklyn Catsitting site was so impressive that I decided to go with them. Kaitlin came over with Liesl who would be sitting the cats. The intake interview was thorough and I immediately felt at ease. We were away three days and once I got the first email update, I was totally relaxed. We came home to two obviously happy cats, report cards, and a personal note from the sitter. In addition to excellent general care, all sitters come with first aid kits, so they are prepared. In our case, one of the cats scratched herself to the point of a little bleeding. This was reported to us and the cut was attended to. Amazing! I am typically reluctant to go away for a number of reasons, including worrying about the cats. Now I have fewer reasons to refuse to go away. I cannot recommend these people more highly. Very impressed! read more

Filled out an online form and NEVER heard a peep. I called more than 5 times at different times of day and never got a response. Will never try again! read more

I have been using Brooklyn cat sitting since we got our cat back in March 2017 for vacations. I have been really pleased with the service and responsiveness - even last minute requests can usually be accommodated. My roommates are always excited to see our daily report with cute pictures and updates. I would not use anyone else. read more

We hired Kaitlin to take care of our sweet 1.5 year old cat back in December. I don't know why it has taken me so long to write a review. Before finding Brooklyn Cat Sitting we had hired a different sitter through another cat sitting service. But the sitter had a dog and I think that the smell she carried made our cat feel a little uneasy, I love dogs as well, but I appreciate that Kaitlin is a cat-centric sitter. Kaitlin is very professional and I felt secure leaving our cat child in her hands. She came over and met her and us. She asked the obvious questions about where all of our cat's food, treats, and litter, etc was. But what I appreciated, is that she also asked about favorite toys, activities, her habits, hiding places etc. Kaitlin is very thorough and took notes for our cat's record. While we were away (for a week) she made sure to text me daily updates along with a photo of our cat. This made me feel so much more secure. I would recommend Brooklyn Cat Sitting to anyone. I don't know how Kaitlin does it, she runs the business by herself and has just recently hired two sitters. I hope that they are as amazing as Kaitlin, but I am sure they are! read more