Service is decent food could be better. $1 per slice of bacon side order is pretty step. Restaurant cleanliness is lacking as well. Looks like stuff that's been on the floor for the last few days. Most likely won't be going back unless I hear things have improved. read more

Just what you expect, it's a diner. We were seated quickly, in a shabby but comfortable booth, at 11am on a Sunday. The service was good, our coffee cups were never empty. Our breakfasts were solid, what you'd expect of the classic 'diner' experience. The waitress did lose points for forgetting to have the peppers and onions left off my hash, but otherwise it was a nice find in Carnegie. read more

Had breakfast here for the first time... Granted it's New Year's Day so it was pretty busy. The service was not that good our orders were wrong and the waitress acted like she didn't know what to do when we told her it was wrong..age actually said "do u just want what's missing on the side Idk what else to do". We also then waited 20 minutes for our check. read more

This is my second review of Bob's which I've always been a fan of but I think this is it for me. Dinner was good, service was great until I got home and wanted to eat my leftover chipped ham sandwich. It was then that I realized that the kind waitress who offered to box my leftovers also gave me the wrong food. So I will be returning to Bob's in the morning to pick up my complimentary replacement meal and a sincere apology for another disappointment courtesy of Bob's. Never again. read more

I'm a regular, so this may not apply to newbies. Treated well. Take good care of me. Food is always well-prepared and fresh. Jodi is a good server! read more

This place is always busy, you might have a long wait, but totally worth it! Food is really good! Ordered the kids breakfast and they ate it for 4 days there was so much! read more

If you like diner food and aren't uptight about ambiance, you'll love to eat at Bob's. All of the food is good. I have never had a bad meal there. A lot of the portions are large, and the service is quick. For having such a small kitchen, the cooks do a remarkable job. They are very busy during the breakfast hours, especially on weekends, but the wait is worth it. Bobs has several locations, but Bob, the owner, can usually be found at the Carnegie location, and he likes to spend time talking to the customers. Don't be surprised to see him sitting at a table chatting with customers as they eat. read more

Food pretty good breakfast served all day...which is great.dining room area dirty though could definitely use a good cleaning twice a week

The food was very good. I got the eggs bendict and my husband had the sausage biscuits and sausage. Everything tasted great and fresh. The sausage patty was huge, homemade and delicious! We went Saturday morning so it was crowded but we were seated immediately by a very overworked gentleman. The host clearly needed some help and another waitress would really improve the time waiting. We got our food quickly and thankfully everything was fine as it was because we had to wait a long time to get our check. This is probably my biggest pet peeve when it comes to service. They had run out of silverware and our waitress was either making toast or on her phone for 5 minutes while we waited for the check. I would probably go back again but at off peak times. Great food but the service isn't the best. read more

Tried Bob's for the first time today. The food was good-- we got eggs and pancakes- and our service was friendly. However, I was very put-off by the lack of cleanliness. I eat out a lot, and I think the floor in this place was the dirtiest I have ever seen. Also, the upholstered chairs looked downright grimy. Sorry to say that I won't be back and can't recommend it. When the basics aren't taken care of out front, I can only imagine what is happening back in the kitchen... read more

I'm in here all the time for lunch as it's convenient to my office. The food is reliably good, soups are excellent and the service never lets me down. Cup of soup and a half grilled cheese is my go-to, but the patty melt is also great. It's clear from watching the waitstaff all like each other and work together as a team. Highly recommended! read more

Went in for breakfast today and there were a handful of other customers and plenty of dirty tables. After receiving our food we were not acknowledged by our waitress or any waitress for over 20 minutes. But they had enough time to talk about the blueberry bread for French toast and how the cook did it so creatively. Which must be where his main focus was on cooking because the "fresh" fruit cup had barely any fruit and definitely was NOT fresh. The sausage gravy wouldn't have been bad had they not drowned it in salt. Definitely not going back or recommending it to anyone. Don't waste your time. read more

We've tried Bobs a few times, wanting so much to like it. It's just not good. Greasy, undercooked food. And it's dirty. Dirty tables, dirty chairs, dirty menus. Yuck. read more

This is a diner in a rundown area of Pittsburgh. If you are expecting five star quality then you had better go to a five star establishment. I wish I could give it more than two stars but the inconsistency in the preparation of the food (same item prepared different every time) and the Walmart type atmosphere make it hard to do so. The food, service and price is exactly as what should be expected. The food is decent but nothing remarkable. The service is what it is. Overall there is no reason to cross this place off your list. You will find something you can live with. The food arrives fairly fast. The price is not out of line with other restaurants of this caliber. The bottom line is Bob's will not be your " go to" place but it is a place you can go to. For me it will be an every few months experience. read more

First time at Bob's dinner today for breakfast. Best home fries I've had at a restaurant, bacon was nice and crispy and of course the Mancini's bread! If you are looking for ambiance, go someplace else, if you want a great breakfast, come here! read more

Today was our first visit to Bob's diner. The food was excellent, the service was very friendly and our food came out quickly. The owner even came out to introduce himself to us and seemed genuinely attentive to our experience. We hope to be new regulars!! We highly recommend! read more

Worst Diner Experience I've had in 67 years. My hot beef sandwich was inedible. I took 2 bites and had to ask the waitress to take it away. The deli sliced beef was like rubber and had no flavor whatsoever. Eat here at your OWN RISK. The table next to me had to send their meals back because they were cold and I saw the cooks put them in a microwave rather than make a fresh/hot order. It was my first & last time visiting this DUMP! read more

This is my 4th trip to this diner. Food has always been good but the service isn't worth it! My husband and I went on a Saturday a little after lunch. There were probably 10 other people in the place and quite a few employees. With the amount of employees at the time there is no reason we shouldn't have had refills or things done in a timely manner! No one seemed to want to be there and it showed. We won't be going back! Gab and eat is right around the corner with great food and service! read more

Stopped at Bob's in Castle Shannon on Saturday and won't be back. My very small BLT had only 2 pieces of bacon on only 1 half of the sandwich! Cold side of frozen french fries for $2 extra? My husband's breakfast came out with burnt black rye toast (he ordered white), over easy eggs that were runny and cold hash browns. We waited almost 20 minutes for this mess too. read more

I was visiting my family last in June . They suggested we have lunch at Bob's Dine in Carnegie . I had never been there , but it will be a must in future visits. Their food plates are freshly made when ordered. I had a huge Chefs salad with piles of thin sliced turkey,ham and roast beef. The lettuce was actually all green leaves, with little or no RIBS. It was so big I took half home for lunch the next day and it was still fresh. The next visit I had an omelet which was huge too. It was served with fried potato wedges which were delicious. Our waitress on both visits was very friendly and happy to help me sort out the present forbidden foods in my diet.They serve the BIGGEST fish sandwiches I have ever saw. Not sure if ALL 5 locations are as good, but the one in Carnegie is a great place to dine read more

found a hair, food wasn't hot, menus splattered with food. lots of other places to eat in carnegie, go there....anywhere.

My husband and I have been eating at Bobs since they opened. However the last three times we were in there the service was terrible, The first time we over looked it because the waitress was new. Her name is Tonya, she runs around like a chicken with her head cut off doing so many thing that she forgets to take care of her customers. the second time we was in she was her waitress again we ask her for napkins 3 times and she never brought them to us, another server got them for us the first time we ask her. the third time we was in Tonya waited on us again we was going to leave, but like I said we have been eating there since they opened. The last time she brought us the wrong omelet, she never came back to check only to bring us the check.WE love Bobs food but if he going to hire wait staff with no experience we will not be back. I will say that in the last year the wait staff has been amazing there, we are those girls at??????????? read more