Order Blue Star Cafe & Pub Takeout or Delivery
Blue Star Cafe & Pub Photos
Business Info
Blue Star Cafe & Pub Popular Desserts
BLUE STAR CAFE & PUB ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
Recommended Reviews - Blue Star Cafe & Pub
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Wish I had discovered this place sooner! Sad to hear they are closing but happy to have been. The potatoes are actually very good. And my scramble was delish. Sometimes scrambles with tomatoes and spinach can be watery but not here!
My family and I came in here for brunch on Sunday. The hostess was very friendly and nice. The interior is beautiful and has an old feel to it. When we got seated, our waitress had not come to our table for 15 minutes. When she finally arrived we asked nicely to place our order. We asked to have the sauce to be removed from a sandwich and on the side for my crab Benedict. When our food arrived, the waitresses quickly threw our plates on the table and ran off. We both looked at our orders and realized it was smothered in sauce, both of which we specifically asked not to have. We waited for our waitress to come by, but she did not show up or even check on us. It took a really long time to flag down another waitress to finally get our waitress. We asked her that the order was incorrect. She rolled her eyes said a half apologetic let me fix that and ran off. We over heard the table next to us also having their drink orders all messed up. When we got our food, the beef dip and the crab Benedict, it tasted pretty good. We only got a refill because we had to flag down the person who bus the tables. We had to get up and walk over to get our own to go boxes. The service was very slow, the waitress had a poor attitude with the eye rolling when she messed up both our orders, we never got refills, had to get our own to go boxes and she messed up the other table's order. I am not sure if this waitress was having a bad day but our experience was definitely not a good one.
Solid 4.5 Just Missed the daily HH which is from 3-6 daily. Ordered market hash with salmon $23 and BF ordered short ribs $23. Generous portions. Host/Servers super friendly and we got seated right away as it was not too busy. Fairly quiet and nice atmosphere. Parking is a challenge. We ended up parking a couple of blocks away on a residential street. Would definitely come back again.
For many, Blue Star Cafe & Pub is this tiny little place that if you blink you may have missed driving by on Stone Way in Wallingford. To me it was a place near and dear to me. You see, it's where me and my now wife had brunch on so many Sundays. When we moved out it to the burbs we'd make a point to try and eat at Blue Star any time we were in the area. As time grew on so did our little family and we took our kids there explaining this is where mom and dad went when we were dating. For. The French toast to the crispy chicken wrap we loved this food. It felt like it was a secret gem hidden at the top of the Wallingford slope. We really couldn't imagine better food. And staff was always welcoming and patrons were always friendly. It has really been a part of the community and the community has been a part of it. So when I heard after 50 years they would be closing their doors I felt obligated to write a review and share the place so many memories were shared. Blue Star Cafe & Pub will be closing in February so please try to make a point to go here one or a few last times before it closes. While it will be closed the memories here will live on forever with me, my family, and so many others both near and far.
Service was quick and friendly. The streak was as good as I remember it. The smaller really helps keep it crispy.
Came here today for lunch and had a great experience. My server, Arianna, came over and greeted me immediately and instantly brought me a water even though I didn't ask for it. I always appreciate that added touch to an experience, even if it is just a water. First off, this place is very charming and clearly has a lot of history to it as it sits in a very hip neighborhood in Wallingford. Really appreciated the decor on the inside. Got the Nashville fried chicken sandwich which was exceptional. Arianna was attentive throughout my entire visit. I will for sure go back here and try other things on their very extensive menu.
I love good ol' diner style restaurants like this. Reminds me of back east with a proliferation of them. Trying to get a feel for the brunch spots in the area I came on a Sunday Morning. Decent crowd but there were some empty booths. There is table, booth and counter seating as well as some outdoor seating, so even on a busy day I wouldn't expect too long of a wait. I was seated quickly dining just myself, bitter sweetness of the large menu hit me. So many tasty sounding options but can only choose one. I decided to take the suggestion of my hostess and opt for the Biscuits and gravy. It didn't turn out to be a good idea. To put it simply I've had far better Biscuits and Gravy. These biscuits were so dense, they may have been stale. Not at all light and fluffy. They had little in the way of taste and the gravy was just alright. Not too much flavor going on with it and some of the best gravy I've had with this dish had little bits of sausage in it. It's supposed to be sausage gravy after all. The eggs were ok, and the potatoes were potatoes, and plenty of them. I'd consider giving it another go here. The menu is huge and the service was decent, but this first go was a bust.
I picked this restaurant because of the location and the wide selection of salad offerings. MB2 and I family-styled the Torrey Pines Salad and the Sweetwater Grilled Clubhouse, subbed truffle shoestring fries. I appreciated the fresh baked turkey breast on the sandwich and the grilled chicken and cornbread croutons for the salad. The food was delicious and the service was friendly and helpful. The decor is a bit dated and could use a refresh. Easy to find street parking on a Monday. I would definitely come back for the food!
Typical diner with a good menu full of staples. My coffee was refilled my fries were hot the food was good. It's clean and has some good pictures of local history in the bathroom. Overall a nice time.
post game brunch on a Saturday they were able to accommodate a large group (12 people including kids). we were split over two tables at first as other tables around us cleared we merged them together and the staff was really great at accommodating it. Onto my food. * cinnamon rolls. so good, warm and HUGE. grab a cup of coffee and some friends because you will need it! * I got the las migas which was so good. think omelet and chips combined topped with meat. The only downside is the potato which was crunchy (not the crispy type of crunch, but the undercooked/raw type of crunch). Overall the food is great, the service is great and we will be back. Note, there is no parking so do give yourself plenty of time to circle around to look for it.
A simple and traditional brunch spot with everything egg dish or sandwich you could want. This restuarant is huge and outdated. The food was just okay, nothing special, and a tad pricier than I'd expect. I've been told that this place is known for their house coffee. Perhaps this was an iconic place decades ago, it doesn't stand out to me compared to its neighboring coffee shops. Overall, it's a little run down and basic, but it's everything you need for a casual day of brunch. Reasons to come back: nostalgic decor and extra nice servers.
I came here for breakfast and absolutely loved it! The menu has so many great options, and the portions are generous without skimping on quality. Everything tasted fresh and comforting, just the kind of breakfast you hope for when you go out.
Classic diner vibes and generally a good time. Ive been here many times and am just now getting around to writing a review. They have a huge menu full of options. Today I got the Hobo eggs (like a frittata), a biscuit, coffee, and a spicy "Chihuahua" bloody Mary. The Bloody was very good (full of garnishes and a nice spice level). The biscuit was amazing, I'd go back just for that. The "hobo" frittata was a bit dry and dense. My friend ordered a cinnamon roll and it was the size of his head (also a winner in my book). The service was friendly but a bit slow. I have this acid-test for classic diners: do they refill your mug of drip coffee without prompting? At Blue Star I had to ask the server for my warm up (as did my friend who had a 'bottomless soda').
I've been meaning to try this spot for a while so when I heard they were closing soon, I had to bump it to the top of my list. I really liked the food - my scramble was AMAZING. I got the Top Gun but subbed Morningstar sausage for the bacon. The side of potatoes plus (also ordered no bacon) was really good too. They have lots of vegan and vegetarian options or mods too! My partner just thought his breakfast burrito was ok and could have used more seasoning or perhaps less potatoes, but overall he did like it. My mimosa was just kinda ok and honestly I probably would have liked the OJ on its own better. The service was mixed. Our server was great - the kitchen put bacon in my first side of potatoes and she apologized and fixed it right away. The front hostess however ignored us and 4 other people who were waiting for tables for almost 10 minutes when we walked in and answered the phone and walked off several times, only for us to find out we could just go seat ourselves immediately at the bar. All the other staff seemed great, though perhaps overwhelmed and harried (understaffing?). The ambiance at the bar was chill - we got to watch the game on the tv and there wasn't too much activity aside from servers grabbing drinks nearby from the very friendly bartender. Overall, I'm sad this spot is closing soon because I would definitely go back. read more
9 months ago
Saying goodbye to the Blue Star feels like saying goodbye to an old friend. I've been coming here for decades - with colleagues, friends, and out-of-town guests (including one who saw the Blue Star on The Food Channel). Cozy, warm & welcoming - with wooden booths and back bar - old world charm that can't be matched by today's cool contemporary restaurants. Vintage photos on the walls, and an old-fashioned community bulletin board in the back. It had a private room in the back - I reserved it a few times for larger gatherings. Yes, spaces like this are disappearing. On my last visit to the Blue Star - today- I met a kind man (Tracey Outlaw) who shared more Blue Star history with me. Thank you to Wendy Morales for many years of community service while running this wonderful institution. It will be missed~ read more
Being just a few blocks from my office, we decided to pop in on a Sunday afternoon. Right away, the interaction with the hostess put us off. We were told to seat ourselves at the bar, and honestly, I should've taken that first interaction as a sign to go somewhere else. Several minutes later our cold, disengaged waitress came by to take our order. I went with the BLTA, which the menu said came on a ciabatta roll but it arrived on a hamburger bun instead. I wouldn't have ordered it had I known. The coated fries were cold, and the sandwich just wasn't good. The barely toasted hamburger bun really ruined the whole thing. My dining partner ordered the garden omelette, which he said was fantastic. It certainly looked good. It came with a side of red-potato home fries that were fine but definitely under-seasoned. Overall, the service was pretty mediocre--except for one gentleman with a fabulous mustache, who was genuinely great. The food, at least for me, was just okay. Not sure we'll be back anytime soon. read more
9 months ago
Wish I had discovered this place sooner! Sad to hear they are closing but happy to have been. The potatoes are actually very good. And my scramble was delish. Sometimes scrambles with tomatoes and spinach can be watery but not here! read more
My family and I came in here for brunch on Sunday. The hostess was very friendly and nice. The interior is beautiful and has an old feel to it. When we got seated, our waitress had not come to our table for 15 minutes. When she finally arrived we asked nicely to place our order. We asked to have the sauce to be removed from a sandwich and on the side for my crab Benedict. When our food arrived, the waitresses quickly threw our plates on the table and ran off. We both looked at our orders and realized it was smothered in sauce, both of which we specifically asked not to have. We waited for our waitress to come by, but she did not show up or even check on us. It took a really long time to flag down another waitress to finally get our waitress. We asked her that the order was incorrect. She rolled her eyes said a half apologetic let me fix that and ran off. We over heard the table next to us also having their drink orders all messed up. When we got our food, the beef dip and the crab Benedict, it tasted pretty good. We only got a refill because we had to flag down the person who bus the tables. We had to get up and walk over to get our own to go boxes. The service was very slow, the waitress had a poor attitude with the eye rolling when she messed up both our orders, we never got refills, had to get our own to go boxes and she messed up the other table's order. I am not sure if this waitress was having a bad day but our experience was definitely not a good one. read more
Solid 4.5 Just Missed the daily HH which is from 3-6 daily. Ordered market hash with salmon $23 and BF ordered short ribs $23. Generous portions. Host/Servers super friendly and we got seated right away as it was not too busy. Fairly quiet and nice atmosphere. Parking is a challenge. We ended up parking a couple of blocks away on a residential street. Would definitely come back again. read more
For many, Blue Star Cafe & Pub is this tiny little place that if you blink you may have missed driving by on Stone Way in Wallingford. To me it was a place near and dear to me. You see, it's where me and my now wife had brunch on so many Sundays. When we moved out it to the burbs we'd make a point to try and eat at Blue Star any time we were in the area. As time grew on so did our little family and we took our kids there explaining this is where mom and dad went when we were dating. For. The French toast to the crispy chicken wrap we loved this food. It felt like it was a secret gem hidden at the top of the Wallingford slope. We really couldn't imagine better food. And staff was always welcoming and patrons were always friendly. It has really been a part of the community and the community has been a part of it. So when I heard after 50 years they would be closing their doors I felt obligated to write a review and share the place so many memories were shared. Blue Star Cafe & Pub will be closing in February so please try to make a point to go here one or a few last times before it closes. While it will be closed the memories here will live on forever with me, my family, and so many others both near and far. read more
9 months ago
8 months ago
Service was quick and friendly. The streak was as good as I remember it. The smaller really helps keep it crispy. read more
Came here today for lunch and had a great experience. My server, Arianna, came over and greeted me immediately and instantly brought me a water even though I didn't ask for it. I always appreciate that added touch to an experience, even if it is just a water. First off, this place is very charming and clearly has a lot of history to it as it sits in a very hip neighborhood in Wallingford. Really appreciated the decor on the inside. Got the Nashville fried chicken sandwich which was exceptional. Arianna was attentive throughout my entire visit. I will for sure go back here and try other things on their very extensive menu. read more
11 months ago
I love good ol' diner style restaurants like this. Reminds me of back east with a proliferation of them. Trying to get a feel for the brunch spots in the area I came on a Sunday Morning. Decent crowd but there were some empty booths. There is table, booth and counter seating as well as some outdoor seating, so even on a busy day I wouldn't expect too long of a wait. I was seated quickly dining just myself, bitter sweetness of the large menu hit me. So many tasty sounding options but can only choose one. I decided to take the suggestion of my hostess and opt for the Biscuits and gravy. It didn't turn out to be a good idea. To put it simply I've had far better Biscuits and Gravy. These biscuits were so dense, they may have been stale. Not at all light and fluffy. They had little in the way of taste and the gravy was just alright. Not too much flavor going on with it and some of the best gravy I've had with this dish had little bits of sausage in it. It's supposed to be sausage gravy after all. The eggs were ok, and the potatoes were potatoes, and plenty of them. I'd consider giving it another go here. The menu is huge and the service was decent, but this first go was a bust. read more
I picked this restaurant because of the location and the wide selection of salad offerings. MB2 and I family-styled the Torrey Pines Salad and the Sweetwater Grilled Clubhouse, subbed truffle shoestring fries. I appreciated the fresh baked turkey breast on the sandwich and the grilled chicken and cornbread croutons for the salad. The food was delicious and the service was friendly and helpful. The decor is a bit dated and could use a refresh. Easy to find street parking on a Monday. I would definitely come back for the food! read more
11 months ago
post game brunch on a Saturday they were able to accommodate a large group (12 people including kids). we were split over two tables at first as other tables around us cleared we merged them together and the staff was really great at accommodating it. Onto my food. * cinnamon rolls. so good, warm and HUGE. grab a cup of coffee and some friends because you will need it! * I got the las migas which was so good. think omelet and chips combined topped with meat. The only downside is the potato which was crunchy (not the crispy type of crunch, but the undercooked/raw type of crunch). Overall the food is great, the service is great and we will be back. Note, there is no parking so do give yourself plenty of time to circle around to look for it. read more
3 years ago
A simple and traditional brunch spot with everything egg dish or sandwich you could want. This restuarant is huge and outdated. The food was just okay, nothing special, and a tad pricier than I'd expect. I've been told that this place is known for their house coffee. Perhaps this was an iconic place decades ago, it doesn't stand out to me compared to its neighboring coffee shops. Overall, it's a little run down and basic, but it's everything you need for a casual day of brunch. Reasons to come back: nostalgic decor and extra nice servers. read more
1 year ago
I came here for breakfast and absolutely loved it! The menu has so many great options, and the portions are generous without skimping on quality. Everything tasted fresh and comforting, just the kind of breakfast you hope for when you go out. read more
3 years ago
Classic diner vibes and generally a good time. Ive been here many times and am just now getting around to writing a review. They have a huge menu full of options. Today I got the Hobo eggs (like a frittata), a biscuit, coffee, and a spicy "Chihuahua" bloody Mary. The Bloody was very good (full of garnishes and a nice spice level). The biscuit was amazing, I'd go back just for that. The "hobo" frittata was a bit dry and dense. My friend ordered a cinnamon roll and it was the size of his head (also a winner in my book). The service was friendly but a bit slow. I have this acid-test for classic diners: do they refill your mug of drip coffee without prompting? At Blue Star I had to ask the server for my warm up (as did my friend who had a 'bottomless soda'). read more
1 year ago
The food here is good. The service needed a little help. Granted they were a bit busy, the servers need to pay more attention to their tables and make sure they don't give off an attitude towards their customers. The building this was in was cool and had an old western feel to it. I'm sure this place is haunted. read more
Fave local brunch spot! Hangover heaven - not super bright or loud, good breakfast booze for hair of the dog, hearty portions, casual feel, and overall just good food Biscuits are my fave and come with a homemade raspberry jam! Potatoes are also stellar and well seasoned. Good vegetarian options too. read more
10 months ago
The food and service was excellent! The prime rib sandwich was fresh and super tasty. The fries were extra crispy and the service was prompt and friendly. We really need to support these neighborhood restaurants that are locally owned. And for those entitled customers that complain about the smallest things on these reviews, they really need to stop comparing them to expensive restaurants. The sandwiches cost less than $20 so if you're expecting service from an expensive steakhouse, you need to go to a steakhouse and pay hundreds of dollars for a meal. read more
1 year ago
1 year ago
I enjoyed the chicken and waffles and my husband really enjoyed the smash burger. The menu has a ton of options to choose from. There is definitely something for everyone. The service was friendly and there is a lot of seating. I was surprised to be able to get seated right away. read more
Great solid brunch option! Came on a Sunday at around 11am and was seated right away. Food was great - the omelet was huge, and each dish comes with a side of biscuit or scone and they're HUGE. The jam that comes with it is AMAZING. I recommend saving some so you can take it to go and get an additional to-go jam. I'd say the scone was my favorite. Service is a little slow, but other than that a great option for weekend brunch! read more
11 months ago
Came here for my birthday brunch. We sat at the bar. Fun atmosphere. Cool to see the old photos and how long the establishment has been open. Had the perfect savory sweet combo with the Norwegian pancakes. My boyfriend had the Market Hash and he really enjoyed it. Found out that they make their bread IN HOUSE! It was super delish! The staff is so friendly. It was hard to decide what to get bc they had so many yummy looking options! read more
Parking is a bit difficult, our friends had to park about 6 blocks away. There is plenty of seating inside and some outside for a beautiful day. As we arrived we waited a minute or two to be greeted and sat down but the staff looked to have been keeping busy and our servers who helped us were nice. There is a large menu with gluten and vegan options. They have specials on weekdays. We ordered for drinks 3 of the breakfast shots. Breakfast in Bed, Oatmeal Cookie, and Cinnamon Roll. They are each pretty sweet and come in the Circleware scorcher shot glass; so are pretty big. My friend really liked the oatmeal cookie and said it tasted exactly like one. I ordered the Cinnamon Roll and it comes with Whipped Cream sprinkled with cinnamon that was not called out on the menu so I did not get to try the full shot. My friends did say it tasted like a cinnamon roll though with the whipped cream. Along with those we ordered a Famous House Bloody mary, Espresso Martini and a Michelada. Bloody was decent but think I missed out in adding the habanero vodka. The espresso Martini was smooth and not too harsh, and the Michelada was bloody mix heavy. For food I ordered a build your own scrabble with the vegan sliced potatoes upon request. It was a good size meal, I ate everything except the toast. The potatoes were soft and had a good seasoning to them. They are unlike another potato that I have had before and were good. The scrabble was filled with sausage, bacon, black olive, avocado, and fresh mushrooms. There are many options available on the menu that you could come back many times to try something new. A good place to get a good morning meal with friends and then a much needed walk back to your car to walk it all off! read more
8 months ago
8 months ago
One of my favorite brunch spots in Seattle. It can get busy on the weekends but I've never had to wait for a table for 2. They have plenty of seating and the space itself is awesome, feels very old school Seattle with lots of old pictures on the wall. Highly recommend the Top Gun Scramble, and make sure to get it with the potatoes! The toast comes with delicious raspberry jam too. I also love the strawberry waffle with whipped cream. read more
1 year ago
2 years ago
4 years ago
We had a group of 7 on a Tuesday night, and the place was basically empty. However, our service was still very slow and at one point we were asked to give up our menus so that another group could have them. (Do they only have 8 menus??) I'm vegan and clarified with the server that the pistachio pasta could be made vegan, as it was marked that way on the online menu but not the paper menu. They assured me yes, it could be made vegan. When we ordered, I asked for the pistachio pasta made vegan. When it arrived, it had cheese on it. The service was already slow and I didn't want to cause a scene (and I'm not allergic to cheese or anything), so I just ate it. And it wasn't eve good. It was lukewarm with globs of melted shaved Parmesan that had re-coagulated. It wasn't very much food, but it was priced at $17. Really truly not worth it. Like, a waste of money. One of my friends ordered the fish tacos and they didn't come out with everyone else's food. The server said "it'll be 2 minutes" but it was literally at least 15 minutes later when he got his food, everyone else was almost done eating. The rest of my non-vegan friends said the food was basically fine. Seems like mediocre food quality for a pretty steep price and the service is very lacking. I will not be back. Also this Yelp page says that they require masks and the staff wears masks--that is not true. The staff was not wearing masks (maybe one person) and they did not require patrons to wear masks. read more
9 months ago
5 years ago
So I was a bit worried about trying this place because it only had 3 stars, but the hangover that I had didn't really care were I ate. Now after eating there, I think the lack of stars might be because they get super busy and food can take a long long time. But service is great, and the food actually taste so good. The restaurant is a cool diner vibe but different from others, and it's pretty big. I got the fruity waffle, which was so delicious. So much whip cream. It had the perfect crisp to it. And then i got the Nashville hot chicken sandwich. This was surprisingly really great! It wasn't very spicy, but it tasted so seasoned, crispy, and fresh. The bread was a soft, and everything inside it complimented it. read more
10 months ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
Page 1 of 19
More info about Blue Star Cafe & Pub
4512 Stone Way N
Seattle, WA 98103
Wallingford
Directions
(206) 548-0345
Call Now
Order Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://bluestarcafeandpub.com/
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
More Info
Health Score
Blue Star Cafe & Pub Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - Blue Star Cafe & Pub
I would love to get your recipe for hollandaise sauce? You have one of the best I've ever tasted! It's so buttery and silky with just the right amount of lemon.
Hi Sarah, So wonderful to hear you enjoy our hollandaise sauce! We've been following our tried and true recipe since 1975, here you are: 1/2lb butter, 8 egg yolks, 1/2 lemon juiced, pinch of salt, pinch of cayenne, dash of tabasco & lemon zest…
What brand of mustard to do they serve with their sweet potato fries?
Thank you for your question, we serve our sweet potato fries with either chipotle aioli, ranch or garlic aioli.
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
42 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
4 years ago
16 years ago
2 years ago
13 years ago
17 years ago
13 years ago
13 years ago
14 years ago
13 years ago
15 years ago
10 years ago
11 years ago
16 years ago
17 years ago
13 years ago
13 years ago
10 years ago
4 years ago
9 months ago
16 years ago
