I've been to Blue Moon once before about a 1to 1-1/2 years ago and nothing stood out so I must not have had any issue at that time. I went in again on 9/2, however, and was very disappointed. First, the good: Their bagels are very good and they don't skimp on the lox, as the other bagel shop I frequent tends to do. Now, the bad: I ordered a sesame seed bagel with scallion cream cheese and lox. Obviously, because I just mentioned it, this isn't my first time in a bagel shop. In fact, I frequent an excellent one just 2 towns over, so when I placed that order what I expected to get was an untoasted bagel with cream cheese topped with lox on both halves. What I got was a toasted bagel sandwich with cream cheese on one half and lox on the other. First, they should ALWAYS ask if the customer wants the bagel toasted. I didn't want it toasted and wasn't expecting to get it that way. A good bagel stands on its own and doesn't need toasting (the exception, of course, is for those who prefer butter in their bagels). I may return. I'm not sure, but I'll definitely make sure I specify it remain untoasted if I do. PS - if they're making pumpernickel bagels (the other bagel shop no longer does, because of poor sales) maybe some could be made without raisins? read more

We got sandwiches delivered from Blue Moon and my Hot Honey Chicken Salad sandwich hit the spot. Normally I'm a bit let down by chicken salad because mayo can be a bit boring. However, throw in some hot sauce and hot honey and that changes the game up. Portions were generous so I was pretty stuffed. Solid lunch choice. read more

Blue Moon Bagel Cafe - Hot Honey Buffalo Chicken Salad - Bagels Near Me - Medfield, Massachusetts

I think I am invisible to the staff their except when they are taking my money. I went in twice, and both times they took my order, took my money, and then ignored me completely. I was not nasty about it either time (I mean, stuff happens), and the first time I waited while they made my order....the second time I just asked for my money back and you would think I insulted the Karen working their like I had disparaged her entire family. It was actually so weird to me it was funny, and the woman next to me joked that she would walk me to my car if I was worried angry woman would follow me. I mean, talk about DEATH STARE. LOL If they do mess up, I promise you, you will get no apology at all, just snippy people returning your money and acting like it was all your fault. It was bizarre....and it happened both times I visited. I get that the owner thinks his choices of products and ingredients is so superior ( if you read through the comments on this place, he has chimed in several times on bad reviews with a hilarious sales pitch, which does little to change anyone's mind when they don't like the food or service, but I'm sure it makes him feel better---turn lemons into lemon aid, am I right ? Ha ha ha ) Anyhow, I did manage to get the overpriced chicken salad tub that they sell the first time I went (I picked it up myself from the cooler, so they couldn't forget to get it for me, LOL) and I have to tell you...the amount of tarragon in it would curl your hair. They aren't into subtlety, are these people? Totally inedible. Don't bother. There is a Brother's Market up the street that has great lunch and breakfast options. read more

The Chicken Pesto Panini at Blue Moon Bagel Cafe is incredible! The panini was perfectly grilled with melted mozzarella cheese stretching with each bite. The pesto sauce adds the perfect amount of fresh basil flavor that complements the chicken. The portions are quite generous and definitely filling. Pro tip: Worth every penny, but go during off-peak hours to avoid the rush/wait. read more

Blue Moon Bagel Cafe - Chicken Pesto Panini - Bagels Near Me - Medfield, Massachusetts

Wow! Blue moon is quite exquisite. One of the workers, Finn, was very pleasant to talk to. Very nice local spot.

They sure have a lot of choices.. But this is a rip offplace!!! Many items are literrally double of what other caffess near y charge! Watch what they charge you! read more

New business, we went an hour ago. Today was still a soft opening, tomorrow it is fully opened. We got bagels and a blueberry loaf. I highly recommend the sesame bagel. Located on 109 next to Marshall's. Well worth the visit. Everyone was nice and professional. I see this place a regular visit. Good luck to the owners. read more

See all

Popular spot in the area. Friendly staff, comfortable, most items good quality, and a ample variety of goodies/lunch items. Nice interior but getting to the point of being a little worn. A bit pricey too. read more

See all

Seriously! I ordered a Raisin bagel with butter NO cream cheese! And You charged me for butter?? No Thanks! read more

Been coming here for years but have noticed some of the pastries are not up to par lately, specifically the cheese danish I bought today. It was exceedingly dry and I couldn't find any cheese. The outside had a dark dry appearance more like a crust, which should have tipped me off. Ended up giving it to the birds. Not just anyone can make good pastries and it makes me wonder if the new owner takes on unskilled bakers. No qualified, experienced baker would produce such a low grade product. Hope they get better in the future. read more

Very busy, which is a great sign. But generally thought the breakfast sandwich was skimpy for the price. Bagels are fine.

Love the ambience but it's expensive. Also, they ask for a tip at the register....which is annoying for a cafe where you stand in line and order. Hate the tipping screens. I don't mind tipping at a full table service restaurant but this just seems like a money grab for already pricey bakery items read more

sorry, but the bagels we bought were really dry, as if they were a few days old. Sorry I bought a dozen without trying first!

There has been an enormous drop off in the quality of their bagels in the past few years. The bagels have devolved from crisp outside crusts and chewy, not bready, interiors to dense, often inedible, doughy lumps. The lack of care can even be seen in the shape of the bagels - last batch I got had some bagels that looked like skinny stretched out rubber bands while others were mudpie shaped with no semblance of a hole in the middle. At this point, the bagels at Shaw's supermarket next door are just as good if not better at a quarter of the price. The only reason Blue Moon gets two stars not one is that their pecan rolls are still delicious and the sandwiches not bad albeit overpriced. read more

Ok this is a tiny sample size so maybe I should wait to give 5 stars. Took a drive to check out foliage and looked up sandwiches in the area. Got a BLT on an everything bagel for about $6.50 and it was delish. Fresh bagel, good veggies and lots of bacon. People working there were very sweet (I think half of Medfield High works here and at Brothers) and the baked goods look amazing. Stupid of me not to take one to go. Will have to drive back out again. read more

just scrolling Yelp and shocked this place anything other than 5 stars. Been eating there for 20 years always great read more

First off, you notice the tastefully designed restaurant including the lighting, artwork and its spacing, as well as a section to showcase local artists. Then you are hit by the delicious aromas of freshly baked breads and bagels and you're greeted by an amazing and friendly staff working hard to get your order prepared quickly. The place is always filled, especially on the weekends, with regulars and families but there is ample seating inside and out so you never have to wait to sit down. I've only had the rye bread and a bagel, so far, but I know I'll be back to this neighborhood gem. Thank you all! read more

Nice atmo. Cool Food. Good People. lovely ambi. Awesome cooks. Mag Price$. No Mice. And Love. Love from the MBTA Green Line. 〰

I just don't see the value here. The food is great but two bagels with cream cheese are almost 9 dollars while half a dozen bagels are also about nine or $10 so I kind of shake my head at what's actually happening there. A roast beef sandwich is $10 and I literally can walk 50 feet in one direction and get a sandwich three times the size for $10. read more

I like blue moon, it has a good amount of vegan options and the food is always dependable and good. My only qualm and reason for 4 stars is the amount of times that my order has been made wrong. Overall a yummy place with a nice vibe read more

Quick stop here for a coffee with a friend after shopping at Marshalls next door. Got a hot coffee and a bagel. Both were delicious. Bagel was soft and chewy. Staff was friendly and looked family owned. Will be back the next time I'm in the area. read more

Blue Moon Bagel Cafe - California crunch bagel - Bagels Near Me - Medfield, Massachusetts

So far, 2 orders delivered= 2 orders all wrong! Leaves me wondering who got what I offered? The bagels are great! So is the cream cheese. So, subsequently, we went to the cafe, got bagels & cream cheese to go. Bad customer service, too. We called to voice our concerns, without any satisfaction. It cost us over $30.00 to get food we couldn't even eat!?! read more

Blue Moon has the best chicken salad sandwich ever. Food came out quickly, and great portion. Lots of options for both breakfast and lunch. It can get super busy so you may have to wait in a long line, but they move it along and always worth the wait. read more

This place has it all!!!! From bagels to egg sandwiches to danishes to muffins to pastries and everything else in between. We got an oatmeal chocolate raisin scone which was so kick ass good. We ordered egg and cheese sandwiches, all super fresh and delicious. Service is also helpful, friendly and patient. Tons and TONS of options. You cannot get bored with this place. It's always clean. Didnt love the coffee. But I won't deduct a point for that because everything else is absolutely superb! There is an option for everyone. read more

Blue Moon is local Bagel shop! Going there for many years--But, they also do a wonderful catering job! Salads, sandwiches are fantastic as well as the GREAT staff helping to decide what works. Just recently we had a office lunch and I was blown away by the service and my staff was blown away by the food! Desserts to die for too! Thanks so much Blue Moon for the local vibe, the city style and the outstanding service--See you soon! read more

The service was great they were helpful and patient. The bagels sandwiches where delicious and the cream cheese was amazing. They have cream cheese for sale by the container in a bunch of different flavors. read more

Blue Moon Bagel Cafe - Sausage egg and cheese with cream cheese. - Bagels Near Me - Medfield, Massachusetts

See all

I've lived in Walpole for about 15 years and driven by the Blue Moon hundreds of times and always said to myself, I have to try them one of the times. I finally did in October 2020, and regret not having tried it waaaay sooner. Actually if I did, I would probably weigh 20 lbs more! They are a full blown bakery with breads, bagels, pastries, sandwiches and so much more. My favorite pastry is, for me, one of the hardest to find let alone a good one: pecan rolls. Some call it a sticky bun. OMG! These are to die for if you like pecan rolls. I used to live in Waltham and there was bakery in Newton about 30 years ago (can't remember the name) that made pecan rolls only on Sunday. You had to wait in line for about an hour to get these and I did! The Blue Moon's are also this good. So far, in addition to the pecan rolls, we've tried the biscotti, apple strudel, cinnamon rolls, and of course the bagels. All fresh and amazing. My wife chooses do to do Gluten Free and gets their GF bagel. She loves it. I tried it and for GF, it's not bad. If you're on a GF diet, you will likely enjoy it. She tried "Twist" in Medfield, which is all GF and this is waaaaaay better. They have lots of outdoor seating but if you go on a weekend, it's a very long line. If you call it in, you can skip the line. read more

Good service, delicious goods, great location and a very nice indoor and outdoor seating area. Love the varied loafs of bread as well! My only complaint is that everything is just a little too pricy, especially post 2022, but the quality of all their goods has been great. read more

I have never stepped foot in the door here, so I've got no vote on service or facilities. But my CFO lives nearby and brings these in for us every two weeks. And we fight over them. Well, *I* don't fight over them because I'm in the office early enough for dibs, but favorites are definitely fought over. Our office is right above a Dunks, so bagels, of the inferior variety of bagels is readily available. People will come in with one of those in hand, and just throw it out because there's Blue Moon. These bagels are dense and chewy and delicious. They are everything a bagel should be. Speaking of everything, that's my preference. Everything. With their scallion cream cheese and then my own tomato slices and come salt and pepper. Breakfast of Champions. read more

Great Bagels, Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches, Coffee and Soups. The Bagels are Fresh and Delicious. We really like the Sausage and the Bacon Egg and Cheese sandwiches on a everything bagel. The coffee and soups are also really good. If you like this kind of thing you can't go wrong with Blue Moon, they are the best we have found. read more

True Artesian bakery, you can tell everything made from scratch; Challah bread is unbelievable. Been going here since they arrived, best place anywhere; have morphed into full blown deli Mikey T read more

Blue Moon is one of the best Bagel Shops in the Region. Their Bagels and Breads and other baked goods are outstanding.

So disappointed by the way the new owners are running this business. The hot chocolate was cold, the extremely greasy spinach and cheese croissant had just a small amount of filling at the bottom, and the service was a disaster. No one including the manager seemed to know what they were doing. So sad. read more

I grew up in the area and used to love going to Blue Moon Café. I have to say, I was in there earlier today and received horrible customer service. The woman checking me out was extremely rude and yelled at me when I went to check and see if the bag they put on the take-out container was mine. She then slammed a sign (which had been out of sight behind the counter) in front of me and glared, asking "Can I help you??" Super rude. They have never had a system before for takeout, so how was I supposed to know? It's too bad because I love supporting small businesses, but if I'm going to be treated like a criminal/thief for simply checking to see if my order is ready, then they will not be getting my business again. read more

Five for their pastries, both on choice and quality. But, at least for me, good pastries go with good coffee. Their coffee is a One... Not because they can't make good coffee, I think they simply don't care. Sometimes I feel like I want to show them how to make better coffee... Well, average is Three. If they only improve their coffee attitude, I would give them a 10! read more

Best sandwich I have had in a long time. I told them what I loved and they made this custom sandwich for me... I had them write down the ingredients for me so I can order it again lol Wonderful caring staff! read more

Blue Moon Bagel Cafe - a bagel sandwich on a table - Bagels Near Me - Medfield, Massachusetts

I love this place! I came here for breakfast with my mom and neither of us had bad to say about it. The bagels are delicious and so is their coffee. The cakes and pastries on display are beautiful and they have free samples out for you to try while you're in line. Full review on my blog: http://luggageandalatte.blogspot.com/2013/12/saturday-morning-coffee-date.html read more

See all

fresh food made in house and served fast by really great staff. family owned small business

Stopped here for lunch with a friend. I had the chicken pesto. Fantastic sandwich! It was made fresh to order. My friend had the Reuben, which I had to try too. It was delicious! Nice family friendly place. Nice for sitting & relaxing on their comfy couch. Nice town hang out spot. read more

Bakery, sandwiches, and coffee oh my. Blue Moon succeeds where so many others fail; they actually have a good product! They just do things right all around ... great breads and bakery items fresh everyday, delicious sandwiches (esp. Cuban), and good tasting coffees on the stronger side. Free WiFi, nice staff, pretty quick service. Only things are that I hate the fluorescent lights, and it's a on the pricier side for cafes (I think the quality is worth it here). read more