We were excited to support our local bakery and placed an order for a custom two-tier birthday cake. One of the tiers was supposed to have a peanut butter filling, and we were looking forward to something both delicious and memorable for the occasion.
Unfortunately, the experience left us incredibly disappointed. The cake was noticeably dry, almost like cardboard, and the peanut butter filling was so sparse it was barely detectable. For a birthday celebration, it was disheartening to see guests leave their slices unfinished. In fact, most of the cake ended up being thrown away.
While the exterior decor was cute and clearly had care put into it, it was hard to overlook how stale and unappetizing the cake itself tasted especially given the premium price we paid. Sadly, we won't be ordering again. Next time, we'll stick with our tried-and-true favorites, even if it means making a longer drive. read more