Surprisingly large menu of items. We started with the cheese bread- really good & the marinara was…read moretasty and not too sweet (yay!) All of the good is freshly prepared. I do think it could stay in the oven just a bit longer for a better melt, but it's still hit and good. Portions are really big, so be prepared for leftovers. We enjoyed everything we had- the pizza in particular was tasty & huge for the price. Service was great- around enough to be helpful, not so much to be annoying. I did think it was a bit odd to have drinks in to go cups, though. The tables are packed in pretty tight, so you're going to have to be friendly with your neighbors when you get up to leave from the booth side. The acoustics are also not great, and added with close tables, it's hard to carry on a conversation.

Nice sandwich shop, nice service and food fresh so I would recommend it, appreciated the server…read morechecking on us

Am in town for the weekend and came in Friday night for dinner…read more Pros - GREAT music and AMAZING atmosphere! - Food was good and portions were nice! - Great location with plenty of street parking nearby. Cons - Watch hour as they are only open for a few hours for both lunch and dinner, with a break in between

Good food and service. Server was helpful with selections from menu too. Would go back if in the…read morearea.

This place was adorable! They have coffee, tea, smoothies, baked goods, all kinds of stuff to get…read more You can also buy bags of coffee and tea, books, cups, and little tea plates and cups. It is adorable. There is plenty of seating + the staff was SO friendly.

Coffee time at The Attic & Coffee Mill was perfect!!!!! That place has so much charm and character…read more I had a smile on my face from the moment I stepped inside. They had so many goodies to choose...cinnamon rolls to special specialty toast to muffins, different flavors of coffee and specialty coffee. We got there in perfect time because by the end of our coffee time this place was packed. So this must definitely be the place to be in Madison. The staff was so nice. We ordered biscuits and gravy, a piece of toast and the Berry Good Toast with an iced coffee and a cup of house coffee. The gravy was a spicy milk gravy that would make any granny proud. My Berry Good Toast was so delicious. It was multigrain toast with a thin layer of strawberry cream cheese, a drizzle of honey strawberries, and blueberries with a angel kiss of powdered sugar. It was perfection. My coffee was robust and the much needed pick-me-up. My friend purchased a coffee mug to remember our time in Madison. I will cherish it always. I love this place!

"Brick Oven", I instantly know it'll be delicious. We got three separate personal pies, all…read moredelicious. Tons of toppings with the perfect crisp. And only $8-10 a pie! The breadsticks were okay, kinda plain but we still finished them! They have different featured desserts, and like 8 options. We struggled to decide but we got a chocolate cake (OMG YUM) and a peanut butter pie that was huge. Super cheap desserts, too! Small little place, but the staff were overly friendly. Just what we wanted and were looking for! Highly recommend. We were traveling through, but if I was local I would be here weekly.

Some of the best pizza I have ever had. I appreciated the proportion size of the individual small…read morepizza. The waitstaff was excellent and made our dining experience even better. P.S. don't skip the pie for dessert. They had coconut cream pie on tap and it was definitely in my top 5 favorite all time pie. So good

The young lady working the counter was very sweet and courteous. The coffee and food was very good…read more We had black coffee, my husband had a blueberry muffin and I had the Santa Fe bagel. If you can, sit outside on the quaint street and enjoy the small town vibes.

Stopped in here for breakfast on a weekend trip to Madison. It was crowded, which to me was a great…read moresign that it's well loved. It did not disappoint. My iced pumpkin spice was the best iced PSL I've ever had (and I've had many). My bacon cheddar bagel sandwich was incredible too, toasted perfectly. The shop itself is cute and rustic with hardwood floors and plenty of seating. The vibes are great!

Higher-end restaurant in Madison. We went out to celebrate my birthday and were able to get a…read morereservation for 3 just a few hours before we wanted to go. The place is a good size, volume was nice, they have both indoor and outdoor seating along with the bar, too. Our waitress was super nice, allowed us to modify our drinks a little and our meal. The only downfall was the food took forever to come. We were there for about an hour and a half from start to finish. Drinks were good, strong. The "grilled" Caesar salad was not grilled but honestly i preferred it that way. We got the chicken meal and it was phenomenal. The chicken, the potatoes, and the sauce were so good. The salmon presentation was beautiful and delicious!

I was in the Madison area on business and by accident found this restaurant, and boy am I glad I…read moredid. I had the Shrimp and Grits, and I can honestly say it was the best I ever had, hands down, and I order that dish a lot. The ambiance was great and the service even better. I also had the oysters as an appetizer, very tasty, and a great value. If you're in the area, don't miss this one; it was so worth it.

Not good.. Use to be awesome and has really went downhill…read more Waitress was good just seems dirty inside..maybe invest in a duster and vacuum.

DO NOT FREQUENT THIS ESTABLISHMENT!! They serve instant mashed potatoes and are proud of it. The…read moremanager was argumentative and told me I was mistaken that many restaurants serve instant mashed potatoes. I eat out frequently and love my potatoes. I have never been served instant mashed potatoes, maybe some cheap buffet. But never a 'nice restaurant'. I am disgusted at the treatment and food. The manager then raised his voice and said well what do you want to do about it. I did not pay for it. Good luck.

Absolutely LOVE this deli !!! Great sandwiches, cozy atmosphere, and happy attentive staff makes it…read morea GEM! Drove the wife up this past weekend and she now loves it too!! Now if we could get one down southern Indiana across from Louisville. I can hope! Go get something good!

Interesting menu, good quality. Good for something fresh and real. I used to stop and get a chef…read moresalad to go for lunch.