It was fantastic! Our first time visiting and we will definitely go back when in town. Food! Service! Ambiance! read more

See all

Really good pizza place with that small town feel and charm. I liked how cheesy the pizza was. Waitress told us about the specials so we ordered the pizza/breadsticks special. Would definitely recommend read more

The Red Pepperoni - Large 14" RPD Specialty Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

Came in '25 and had to return in '26! We usually try to go to new places when we visit, but definitely on our list to repeat. Yes, it's that Good! Such friendly staff, team effort waiting tables, offering up great suggestions from the menu. Service was top notch, kept drinks filled & super quick, food was fresh & pizza was hot. Such a happy atmosphere. Super surprised about the price too! 4 adults, 2 apps, drinks, 2 large pizzas, Less than $65! read more

See all

Very good service! Pizza was very good and easy on the stomach. Breadsticks came out extremely fast. Chessy bread was not great, (reason for not getting 5 stars) But very nice loved it read more

I don't know why more restaurants don't use the team method for taking care of tables. What an absolutely efficient crew tonight and it was a half full interior and a nearly full exterior. The food is excellent. I had the meatball pizza (add bacon) and it's fantastic. The lady had the lasagna with a side salad and enjoyed it. She said the salad was fabulous. We split the mozzarella sticks which were absolutely identical to every other restaurant. I cannot get over the level of service. Exceptional the whole time. Thank you read more

The Red Pepperoni - Meatball pizza add bacon. Small. - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

Never met a pizza here that I would pass up.. it's the Staples that bring the family back. But it's the original slash different ones that keep me happy. Little cramped inside and the patio isn't that great because of traffic? But worth sitting out there if you don't mind the weather. Also not impressed with the to go process... you have to wade through the tables and stand awkwardly right in the dining room to get things to go. Kind of wish they would do a pickup up window out the side door but that's near the bathroom, so that's odd too. The food is worth all the complaints. read more

Not sure what to say other than GET HERE AND HAVE SOME ABSOLUTELY AMAZING DELICIOUS PIZZA!! Come back every year for our Anniversary, we will continue to do so as long as we can. The service , the flavors and amount of toppings. read more

The Red Pepperoni - Mac Daddy, Awesome pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

Staying at Clifty Falls State Park in Madison, Indiana and discovering many restaurants in town are closed on Sunday. So we decided to pick up a pizza from The Red Pepperoni. So glad we did!! Got a large RPD (pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green pepper, onion). Delicious crust, flavorful sauce, plenty of toppings. Even better was Sunday is $16 large pizza night. read more

The Red Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

See all

We love the food, from artichoke dip to our Pizza. The servers are nice and very attentive. The ambiance is ok.

I tell everyone I know that it's a must to go to the red pepperoni if ever in Madison ! I have a girlfriend coming in for my birthday this weekend and we absolutely are going ! The RDF pizza is amazing and so is the spinach one !!!! But the wedge salad with blue cheese dressing is amazing and I never go without enjoying one !!! Go go go you will not be sorry ! read more

So F'n Good ! Order Pepperoni on Top ! So Crispy and Good !! Cob salads also Great !!

Delicious! Sauce and cheese were on point , crust was cooked perfectly. Pizza was hot and ready to go in 15 minutes read more

The Red Pepperoni - Ultimate Veggie - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

Delicious pizza place offering both indoor and outdoor seating. The waitstaff proved knowledgeable about the many types of pizza offered here. The pizza arrived at our table hot and tasty . A good beer selection is also available Restrooms are so so. Parking is available in front and along the side street. The ambience is very open. read more

The Red Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

My son and I had dinner here last night. We thought the service was great and the pizza was delicious. Prices are also good. We got the Bonsai Pizza, which was delicious. I also had the Cobb Salad, which was huge and quite good. It's too bad they're closed for Labor Day today or we would've stopped by for lunch. read more

A very cute & quaint pizza joint off of the main strip in downtown Madison. All the staff we interacted with were very nice. This was our first time visiting & we loved it! We got a pepperoni pineapple pizza with garlic sauce. The pizza was delicious - a little too greasy for my liking but I simply dabbed the pizza with a napkin & proceeded to inhale the food. We will definitely be back when the weather is warmer to experience their deck outside. It is decorated with cute market lighting & is sure to be amazing! read more

See all

Super delicious pizza, high quality ingredients and they charge super reasonable prices. we love this place and we don't even live around this area but we make a special trip... a 45-minute drive just for this pizza read more

Quick cook time for a pizza. Really good crust, not greasy and maybe the biggest pepperoni slices ever to land on a thinish crust pizza. Good menu selections. There is inside and outside tables The parking situation is limited and dangerous if a big truck pulls in beside you. Friendly service and TV situation is good for watching games. read more

The food was AMAZING as was the service. Late servers were cheerful and helpful and we were even given free breadsticks. All the pizzas were hot and quality made. Would 100% recommend and come back to. The building was clean and had a wonderful atmosphere. read more

What an amazing spot to grab a pie! My husband and I stopped while traveling through Madison. We both got a side salad and I can't say enough how great the homemade dill ranch dressing was! We got a pizza with sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms and it was DELICIOUS! The service and atmosphere were also great!! if you're in Madison it's a must try!! read more

The Red Pepperoni - Sausage, Pepperoni and Mushroom Pie - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

I'd much rather eat at a place that has not only delicious pizza but also a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Friendly staff makes all the difference. You should feel comfortable and valued while you're there. That's what matters most. I know you all are busy, but you missed today. read more

This is a nice little pizza shop on the west side of town away from the hustle and bustle of downtown. Food is good and cheap. They also have a nice selection of craft beers in bottles/cans. read more

See all

I got breadsticks and a personal cheese pizza at this pizzeria. The breadsticks, again, just like the last 3 or 4 pizza places I went to were just breadsticks sadly. They had no flavor besides being bread. That was disappointing because I've been to this place years ago and I'm almost positive the breadsticks back then were very good unless I maybe got cheese sticks or something back then? I'm not sure. The pizza was just okay. Nothing to write home about. I always go with a plain cheese pizza to judge a pizza place. The inside of the restaurant is nice and the service was excellent. The parking lot is terrible. There's more tables inside the restaurant than there are parking spots outside the restaurant. read more

The Red Pepperoni - Personal cheese pizza from The Red Pepperoni Pizzeria in Madison, Indiana. - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

The staff was very friendly and helpful. The pizza was very average in my opinion. The atmosphere was ok....nothing special. The wait time on a Tuesday was was very good. read more

Comfortable, good pizza, affordable. Can't go wrong.. Good food in a friendly atmosphere

Mr. C and I took a little getaway to Madison to visit Clifty Falls. After we arrived in Madison and checked into our hotel, we were hungry and decided to check out The Red Pepperon. It is a decent spot for a casual pizza night. We found their pizza and breadsticks to be tasty, although not necessarily standout compared to other pizza joints. The atmosphere is nothing special--it's not particularly welcoming or cozy, but it's clean and functional. Overall, The Red Pepperoni is a solid choice if you're looking for a reliable pizza spot without any frills. The food is good, the service is efficient, and you'll leave satisfied, if not blown away. read more

Food was delicious. Very generous size Italiano salad. Cheesy bread hot right out of the oven. Chicken Parm ... yummy and just the right size. Service was friendly and server was knowledgeable about the menu. Refreshing to find a server who knows the menu. Ambiance...basic...however the food was the show stealer. One definitely goes for the food. read more

First time impressions Limited parking as far as I can tell The staff is very friendly and service was really good (I only had to flag my server down one time for extra dressing) but the drink refill was right on time The food... I ordered the lunch special (a personal pizza and salad and a drink. I also ordered the breadsticks to try them The salad looked nice and the portion was good. (The homemade Italian is awesome) The breadsticks were large and nicely done (crunchy outside and soft middle). But it was just plain dough no seasoning that I could tell The pizza was the star of the show I ordered pepperoni and double onion The amount of toppings was good and unlike a lot of places had enough cheese without ordering extra For a personal pizza it was cut into an unusually large amount of small slices which would be great for kids. (and honestly two kids could've shared it.) Overall this is a great place for lunch and I will be back read more

The Red Pepperoni - Pepperoni and double onion personal pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

Always love the food. Service is friendly and quick. Great little place to grab lunch relax and enjoy a quick and quiet meal.

I wish I could give them a higher rating, but the service was just too chaotic. We were honestly not sure which server was ours. We had different people to take our drink order, our food order, and bring the food. No one checked in on us, but they were responsive when we flagged someone down for help. We mentioned that it was our first time eating there, but no one told us they had lunch specials. We only found out when I overheard a server telling another table - AFTER we had put in our order. The food was pretty good. They also had a great beer list. I just wish the service was better. read more

We were starving after a long hike at Clifty Falls, and this place caught my attention easily after driving past it a couple of times. This place seems to get pretty busy. During covid times, they did well with separating the tables and having the staff wear masks. Their main dish is pizza, but you can also get calzones and wings here, too. We started out with some cheese bread (which I highly recommend getting as an app!) and finished with some pizza and wings. It was really good, and a very generous portion too! If you're in Madison and find yourself hungry check out Red Pepperoni. It's a pretty cute spot. read more

The Red Pepperoni - Get some cheesy bread to start! - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

Had their lunch special today. I got the white pizza and hubs got a chicken barbecue pizza. Both were delicious... and the salad that came with was excellent!! Servers were friendly and good at their job. Will definitely go there again when back in town! read more

Good flavored pizza and reasonably priced, the customer service was also exceptional. I always had a full Coke and was greeted hello and goodbye. I drove there an hour and 10 minutes to try this location. read more

Super good pizza!! Our preference is GF pizza crust and Red Pepperoni has 2 options for that! Cauliflower or GF flour pizza crusts. We ordered the ultimate veggie and the roasted artichoke and both were sooo delicious!! The service was as amazing As the pizza! Fast, happy and the wait (even though restaurant was busy and full) was very short. Great experience! Thanks Red Pepperoni! read more

The Red Pepperoni - Ultimate Veggie and Roasted Artichoke-both on GF cauliflower crusts. Yum!!! - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

Ran across this restaurant on my way back from visiting Clifty Falls and am so glad I found it! They have excellent gluten free options, including a basic gluten free crust as well as a cauliflower gluten free crust. I got a half greek half cheese pizza with the cauliflower crust (it was one of the best cauliflower crusts I have ever had). The ranch with the salad had a lot of dill and seemed homemade. Staff was a little cold but some were friendlier than others. If I am in the area again I will definitely come back! read more

The Red Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

See all

Service was great. I've been here a few times and never had any issues. Food was also great, pizza is on the top of my food groups so it never disappoints. read more

Had pizza & breadsticks while in town for the weekend. Cheese/sauce ratio was good. Good quality cheese, flavorful sauce. Breadsticks were homemade, fresh, hot & came with a choice of dipping sauce. Friendly service, well paced. If I'm ever back in the area, this will be a stop for sure! read more

I called in my order and went to pick it up. There aren't a ton of places to park here, so try to beat the rush if you go at lunch time. The girls at the counter were super friendly! I had no idea that stopping here would make such an impression on me. I got the RPD Special calzone and not only was it delicious, but the marinara sauce was the best I've ever had in my life! I usually don't use marinara for my cheesesticks or calzones, but I will never get one from Red Pepperoni without it. Food was sooo good and a pleasant surprise. read more

The Red Pepperoni - RPD Special Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

This spot has great beer selections (no tap) and some great smothered pizza varieties. Dough is flat NYC like but small like crafty pizza place, heavy cap of mozzarella over premium ingredients. Service was good. We started our dinner with beers and spinach artichoke dip that comes in a boat and heated to perfection in a salamander with layer of... cheese of course. Solid choice for dine in or carry-out. read more

See all

This corner pizza joint serves a great lunch special Monday through Friday that includes any of their specialty pizzas, a drink and your choice of a salad or breadsticks. You can also do a build your own small pizza without the other stuff but we were pulled in by the loooong list of specialties and knew we wouldn't agree on one to share so it was perfect for my sis and I. The exterior appears newly remodeled and I was expecting a more upscale interior but appreciated the super casual atmosphere being the sweaty messes we already were by lunch. Service is fast! We had a couple of different people pop by to help us, which I don't mind. Drink refills were there before we needed to ask. I love that. I had the salad, my sister had the breadsticks. She preferred a more spicy nacho cheese than what they serve but really liked the texture of the breadsticks. My salad had green olives and pepperoncini in piles and I really liked the herby homemade Italian dressing. She got the veggie pizza, thrilled to have toppings she hasn't had on a pizza in years because her family won't eat them or anything they touch. I decided on a chicken bacon ranch pizza-the CBR. Both of our pizzas were loaded with toppings. Her veggies were fresh and the right color. My ranch sauce was not too salty and had a nice hint of dill. We thoroughly enjoyed our food and our time there. This place earns its ratings. A extra bit of nice for me-being asked if I wanted a drink to go on a humid 90+ degree day. read more

The Red Pepperoni - CBR-chicken bacon ranch. Hard to see but yes, this was piled with chicken and bacon. No sad slices here. - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

See all

F Minus!!! I got the worst service, rude waitress, no plates or silverware until 10 minutes after food was served. Then I told the waitress hey no service means no tip. She gave a very rude attitude. This was at The Red Pepperoni in Madison ind. I emailed them thru Facebook. Response sorry this happened. It wasn't that busy either I notice other bad reviews on google reviews as well and each response from them seem Scripted.... The best apology is Changed Behavior.... It doesn't seem to be changing much.... Just totally Utterly Disgusted with how I was treated. I think it was deliberate. read more