The wings were absolutely fantastic. I mean 5 star good. Never saw that coming. A really cool little pizza joint out in the country that had great service and a great vibe. read more

Jendy's Pizzeria - Hot Wings - Pizza Near Me - Hanover, Indiana

Just moved to this area I called in an order and picked it up at the drive-through. Service was very friendly and the pizza was good. The only thing I can complain about is, I had asked for no sausage on the Jendy's classic pizza which normally does come with sausage and they accidentally put it on there. Other than that everything was fine. I hear they have a lunch buffet, which I will probably try one day. I do recommend you try Jendy's pizzeria in Hanover, Indiana. read more

Madison loves their pizza (as evidenced by the number of pizza parlors here). Jendy'sis one of the most popular for good reason. The pizzas are tasty and cheap. read more

Jendy's Pizzeria - the interior of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Hanover, Indiana

It's not the fanciest place, but the food is pretty darned good. We had a bit of everything - fried cauliflower, cheese sticks, a baked potato, boneless wings, and a pizza. We loved it all. The boneless wings and fried cauliflower in particular were very good. Our server let us know she was brand new - I think we may even have been her first table. She did a great job and checked on us frequently. read more

Has a dive bar feel with well worn decor. Food had great prices and was not bad, but not especially good either. A bit more TLC to the lasagna would have made it great as what i got was cold in the middle and bland with no herbs. Yet the base of it was done excellently and the sauce was chunky. Garlic bread was dried out but bread was tasty. Lots of uncleaned tables and so so service. Just a bit more attention to details would have been appreciated. But the place was busy so obviously popular! read more

Jendy's Pizzeria - Booths - Pizza Near Me - Hanover, Indiana

See all

Food is always undercooked, also never order the mega tater. I've tried to order it multiple times and they're either out of baked potatoes or I get potatoe and broccoli. Nothing with it. I give up on that place. read more

Chose buffet as they only had counter service at the time. Staff was friendly. Seemed clean.

Was visiting my son and he said give this place a try . Amazing pizza for a small college town. Definitely better than anything we have in Florida. And could compare to some in Chicago were we are originally from . Keep up the good work! read more

We visit Clifty Falls State Park every year after Christmas and look forward to eating at Jendy's at least twice. This year we made a third stop as we we were headed home and ordered a large deep dish cheese and a large deep dish sausage and onion. We were enjoying the deliciousness when our waitress came up with another deep dish cheese. The cook had thought the original did not look right and wanted to give us another for free. Not only is the pizza the best in Indiana, but the service is first rate. We love Jendy's! read more

Jendy's Pizzeria - the neon sign - Pizza Near Me - Hanover, Indiana

Stopped here at recommendation of the front desk staff at our nearby hotel. It is a family friendly local pizza place (with Attached ice cream shop). The deep dish pizza is fantastic. Not as thick as a Chicago style deep dish, but the fresh ingredients, flavorful sauce and crispy/ cheesy crust made for one delicious pizza! They have personal pizzas, which is nice when traveling with a picky 4 year old :) Totally recommended if you want to try a great local pizza place. read more

Jendy's Pizzeria - Deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hanover, Indiana

See all

Jendy's pizza is good! The Service is excellent! I definitely will come back to try another thing from the menu! We had the individual mini pizza read more

Jendy's Pizzeria - a person taking a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hanover, Indiana

Found this place on Yelp. Good pizza and the cost was very reasonable. Called head for pick up and was ready in 15mins. Will go back on Thurs. when I am back in town. read more

Excellent pizza! Outstanding service. Really enjoyed time spent there. We will be coming back again soon.

I'm a local and regular who has been going to Jendy's since it opened. Hanover is very lucky to have such a nice pizzeria. The pizza is very good, and the quality is very consistent. Some reviewers fault the service, but my experience is that it is always great, although they can be taxed on busy days. The ambiance is a small college-town pizzeria, and it always clean and comfortable. I really like the deep dish pizza; not exactly Chicago style, but great. read more

In town for a visit to Hanover College and had to check out Jendy's. 100% recommended! The pizza and breadsticks were very good and you can't beat the price! read more

FYI: Never had the pizza. This is a small time pizza joint, kept alive by the locals who love it. Pizza Hut across the street didn't shut this one down. I've only had the appetizers... all great. But the pepperoni sticks are PHENOMENAL, worth stopping for (can't describe the pizza-non-pizza flavor they have)... pep, cheese, crispy and flavorful... it's a deadly combo. read more

Perfection! Our family visits nearby Clifty Falls State Park every Christmas and spends the other 51 weeks of the year talking about Jendy's. For starters, the breadsticks are the best, a combination of soft and chewy. They come six to an order, and our family of four orders two. We always get two large deep dish pies for the main course. The hand tossed is delicious, but the deep dish is jump-up-and-slap-your-mama good! The sausage is our favorite...crumbly and lots of it. The sauce is killer. And the price? Not sure you could put one on something the whole family talks about all year long, yet the Jendy's folks do, and it is very reasonable. All in all, Jendy's is why you patronize local restaurants and wave at the chains as you pass by. read more

This place is the worst. So slow! Service is trash. Food isn't bad, but not worth the wait to get it.

This is easily the best pizza in Madison/Hanover. It's actually called Jendy's now and there are two locations. The Hanover location is the one I know best. I particularly like the italian sausage and peppers combo. I've just discovered the deep dish, which I recommend. We usually get some breadsticks too. Nothing amazing about Jendy's pizza, but it's well better than the alternatives. The drive-thru pickup at the Hanover location is really, really nice. read more

We usually order here whenever we pass through. Usually 5-6 times a year. We've never been disappointed. The cheesy garlic bread is amazing. The pizza superb. Wish they were closer. read more

Our senior year of college we had a "new" golf coach. We all knew him but since our other one randomly got let go, we acquired a new one. He loved Jendy's pizza and most of us had never been so he decided to take us there to eat. We ordered family style and just got a lot of random things to share. A couple of pizzas and breadsticks. All the food was decent, nothing amazing. Service was alright too but I mean, how fancy schmancy can pizza get? It's better than Pizza Hut but I prefer Papa John's thin crust pizza best. However, for some place to eat with your family, I'd pick here. read more

Pizza here is very good, so we decided to try the mushroom hoagies. The first sandwiches came out cold so they made us two more but they had undercooked mushrooms on them. Couldn't finish the sandwiches. I will mention that has been our only bad experience. read more

Overall impression.....meh. First of all, I rarely leave reviews and my expectations of a restaurant are pretty basic. Feed me good food, be polite, and keep it clean. Feed me good food- pizza was just ok. I'm not complaining about the quality of the pizza but the fact that I couldn't help but feel like I paid WAY too much for it. I could have easily gotten the same quality across the street at Pizza Hut for a cheaper price.....but it's pizza, we're talking just a few dollars here. Oh, the sweet "tea".....more like semi sweet water. It was clear when it came out which was my first clue. It's not like they brew it fresh every day or anything, they by it and it comes out of a multi-selection machine. Maybe it's not their fault but perhaps they should know about it? Be polite- everyone was friendly but not overly eager to interact with customers. Nothing to give a bad review for though. Keep it clean- restaurant was fairly clean, nothing really to write about here. Like I said, not a terrible experience, just meh. If you're hungry for something new, just come to say you tried something new, not to be blown away by the food. read more

Service. The food is good but the service makes it great! This is one of the friendliest places I've been too. I've done many food reviews but have never mentioned the crew. Great people make this a no brainer place to come to. Jendy's is my place to eat when in Scottsburg. I would suggest that you do the same. ENJOY! read more

The food at Jendy's is our family's favorite pizza restaurant ever! The food has always been great! The deep dish pizza is by far our favorite. But there other entrees of sandwiches are good too. I love, love their breadsticks, and dessert pizza too. The Scottsburg location is just as good but they don't have all the items on the menu that the Hanover location does. And, I wasn't too pleased with their lunch buffet. Otherwise than that, I would definitely give them two thumbs up for sure! The Hanover location also has a small play area for kids. My kids, who are older teens still like to go to the window at the play area and watch the employees make the pizza and toss the pizza in the air. Even for adults, its a lot of fun! read more

We had the veggie supreme and the meat supreme, and dessert pizza. The crust was awesome and all the ingredients were very fresh. Very high quality cheese. We ordered all the pizza for pickup. I would definitely return for more! read more

Have been to Jendy's off and on over the last decade. It is locally owned and supported. The service and food selection improves every time I go. Keep that in mind when you read some of the older reviews. I went recently and the menu was expanded again, the food was very good and the service was great. read more

My family LOVES Jendy's!!! They have THE best deep dish pizza around. We always get the bread sticks. The delivery area is small but the times are usually pretty good. The prices are comparable to similar establishments. Dining in is also a plus with this joint. The atmosphere is inviting and the service is excellent! They also have a salad bar. It's a little pricy and you only get one plate but I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

This pace is great! They are always so accommodating and reasonable when doing large events with Hanover College. The pizza is delicious and the employees are super friendly. read more

Decent pizza for a small town. It takes a while to get your food though so I would suggest calling in your order ahead of time if you plan to dine in the restaurant. read more

The pizza here is good but it's not better than any other pizza place like Dominoes and Papa Johns. The thing that makes this restaurant 4 stars for me is the family atmosphere. Every time a local sports does well they always have their name or team on their billboard. Also the people who run this place are town natives and know people here. Also have a lot broader range of foods other than pizza what's nice if you aren't craving it that night! read more

Always friendly, efficient staff. Never disappointed in the food. Great service even during busy times. We eat here regularly and carry-out as well. Nice menu variety, something for everyone. Best breadsticks in town! Love this place. read more

Not terrible pizza... My friends and I hit up the lunch buffet probably a few times a month. For 7 bucks (including drink) you really can't complain. The pizza overall is alright nothing to write home about. Their deep dish meat pizza is quite good however and would definitely recommend that. Oh yeah really good bread sticks, I am not the biggest fan of bread sticks but for some reason their's hit the spot. read more

Excellent pizza and don't miss the cheese sticks! Service is good and price is good for non-chain pizza. I've eaten here on at least a dozen occasions while visiting friends in the area. Solid local choice! read more

Jendy's deep dish pizza rocks! Their prices are great and my family of 4 is stuffed for under $20. My husband is very picky about pizza and he will drive 2 hours just to eat at Jendy's! We love this place. read more

Love Jendy's Pizza and have been a long time customer but I suggest that management send a customer in late on a weekend to see exactly how poor the service is when the teenage girls want to be doing something else. Not only did our drinks not get refilled until we went up to have them refill them for us but we were asked to pay the bill and get our refills in to go cups .... Extremely rude! It was 20 min before closing. Just a suggestion ... Like I said, Great Product but horrible service. read more