You never get a second chance to make a first impression... First impression from the outside was typical hometown bar. Locals all turned to see who was walking in. Greeted by a beautiful soul, Helena, to sit anywhere! Taco Tuesday was the perfect day to visit downtown Madison with $2.50 select Tacos & tasty Margaritas! Also off the menu we selected Bread Sticks with great housemade beer cheese, Burger & Tots, did not disappoint! Definitely a place to checkout when visiting Madison! Don't forget to checkout the restrooms for some beautiful artwork. read more

See all

Seems like a little hole in the wall place, we stumbled upon it walking down main street. Staff was super friendly, lots of variety on the menu, okay ambiance (bar vibes). We enjoyed the food! My Greek wrap was delicious, the pesto sandwich had little to no pesto though, a bummer. We loved the southwest salad! read more

My first time in Madison Indiana and I'm in love with this town. Charming is an understatement. We had so much fun in the short time we were there. I don't believe I've enjoyed walking, especially in the cold, down streets oohing and aahing over the beautiful homes, businesses and atmosphere. I can't believe I've never been. So we walked down Main Street and stopped at Off Broadway Tavern for some bites. There was a wonderful musician playing outside which I absolutely loved. Nothing like being serenaded and getting your belly full. The atmosphere is fun and homey. The staff was helpful and amazing. We ordered the hummus plate for an appetizer, The Wrangler Burger and a Sweet Potato Taco. The hummus was delicious and it was fresh!!!! Served with small pita chips that were the bomb!!!! I couldn't shove them in my piehole fast enough. Also served with carrots, celery and cucumber. The Wrangler Burger was delish as well. Flavorful burger with cheddar cheese, bacon, green, tomato, chipotle bbq aioli and the sprinkles on the cake....Fries Jalapeños. Yummy! Now before you say omg a Sweet Potato Taco....let me tell you this was THE BEST most flavorful sweet potato taco that I've ever had in my life I hate every bit of it. I've never had a sweet potato that tasted that great. Overall I give this place too stars. We will definitely be back. read more

See all

The food and atmosphere here are unmatched in Madison. Service is excellent too. The pretzels are so good and the buffalo chickpea patty is one of the best vegetarian sandwiches I've had in the world. Seriously. Oh and the fries are top notch! We love this place! Don't miss it! read more

If you're in Madison and you want delicious, quality food, and excellent service, you must stop here. Today was our 2nd time here, and we are looking forward to coming back soon. read more

This was a great place to stop in and eat! Lots of options! Very good food and great service! Definitely recommend! read more

Off Broadway Taproom - California Chicken Club - Beer Bar Near Me - Madison, Indiana

See all

The taproom was very much a bar with bar food. The green fried tomatoes were deliciously fried and the salad I ordered was huge. The bartender was busy on a Wednesday night so there wasn't a lot of interaction, but there was just enough seats for us to sit at the bar. The restaurant was small but not claustrophobic. I would come back again, but would try to come before the rush to have a table to sit and talk rather than sitting at the bar. read more

Off Broadway Taproom - Veggie burger - Beer Bar Near Me - Madison, Indiana

See all

This is such a neat establishment, looks like an old saloon inside. They have a lot of great beers on tap from local breweries both from Indiana and Kentucky. I had the fried green tomato BLT and it was so good. I'd highly suggest coming here if you are in the downtown Madison area and looking for friendly service, cold beer and great food. read more

See all

My favorite place to head while staying in Madison /Clifty Falls area. usually after a long day of hiking, we head into town for something to eat and drink. This place might be a little hard to find, but it's on the main road on the side of the river. I've been there when there's music playing The service is excellent, and the food choices are good. Price is reasonable. Of all the restaurants available in the Madison area this is the one that I would choose as a more relaxed atmosphere and good food and service. read more

Stopped here on our way home from an appointment. Such a cool spot. The food was delicious and service was excellent! I always forget how many cool spots Madison has. Will definitely be back! read more

Off Broadway Taproom - Patty melt and Philly cheesesteak with loaded tots and chips. - Beer Bar Near Me - Madison, Indiana

See all

As promised we came back on our anniversary again in December. This place never disappoints, love the ambiance, food is on point. Only one serious complaint, I live in Indy, it's ab2 hour drive!! Win be back this spring when camping near by. read more

Why I have not been here sooner is a mistake!!! Service was over and above; friendly and helpful servers. Great music was playing, which is always nice. Food!!!!! Best boneless chicken wings I have EVER had and I am very picky. I totally forgot pics because it was so upbeat and engaging...apologies!!! The chips and queso was good and tasted very fresh but could use a little more spice/flavor. I'll definitely be back!!! read more

Should you find yourself in Madison, Indiana, on the banks of the Ohio River strolling the town's historic main street in need of a bite and brew, you really should stop in at the Off Broadway Taproom. It's one of those places that could have been featured by Guy Fieri as a 5-star "Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives." The vibe is laid-back funky, the taps include an excellent velvet-soft amber ale, but the star is the sweet potato taco with local hot sauce-- the chef's special creation. You can't miss her-- striking as she is with her multiple tats! Her signature creation blends roasted sweet potato, shredded cabbage, pico de gallo, black beans and corn salsa with vegan sour cream. I was not there long enough to test the menu including the blackened crawfish. Next time.... read more

See all

We had the best service and lunch at this cute establishment. We passed by it twice before we found it because the outside street sign was missing. We had a wonderful server who was very familiar with the menu and made recommendations. Everything is homemade in their kitchen. Thomas enjoyed wings and two tacos. I had the VEGAN black bean and mushroom burger with a side salad. The burger and salad were excellent and filled me up as the portions were generous. I was so thrilled to see at least 4 vegan options on the menu. The restaurant is older but clean and well maintained. The bathrooms are as well. I would definitely return and I highly recommend it. read more

Off Broadway Taproom - Inside - Beer Bar Near Me - Madison, Indiana

Had a bit of a party here once, with a big group on the patio and it was very nice... the food was a little lackluster, but the historic building, location and the service was good enough to get to 4 stars. read more

We had an all around wonderful experience at Off Broadway Taproom! My husband and I came here after dinner in celebration of his 42nd birthday. We had been here before and I was looking forward to the live music and tacos. He was looking forward to the drinks. As our luck would have it right when we got there the band was beginning to perform. I ordered steak and shrimp tacos. The steak tacos were the best tacos I'd ever had. They were superb! The live music was fun and created a great ambience. The staff were very friendly with cool vibes. We will definitely be back! read more

Food was amazing. I'm now craving the Thai chili shredded chicken taco. The cauliflower bites were good - I think they would have been better if they weren't battered. The homemade chips were crunchy just like we like them. Cool building. Typical bar scenery. Wasn't expecting the cool mural read more

See all

Fast service. The food was very flavorful. They were several tvs for us a watch sports and not too loud. Get the Cuban! No regrets. read more

Off Broadway Taproom - Cuban with loaded house chips - Beer Bar Near Me - Madison, Indiana

Stoped in for lunch on 7/17/25 after a visit to the Falls. This place was hopping for a Thursday lunch but got seats at the bar as soon as we walked in. Service was AMAZING considering how busy they were. The decor was really cool with a mix of music murals and regatta memorabilia. The food was incredible. That was one of the BEST Nashville Hot Chicken sandwiches I've ever had and my wife's tacos looked amazing as well. Lunch for the 2 of us right at $30 is just a bonus because I would gave gladly paid more. read more

Off Broadway Taproom - Fish Taco & Sweet Potato Taco - Beer Bar Near Me - Madison, Indiana

See all

Not bad for Madison. I got some ridiculous burger that tasted good but was just a mess.

Open for lunch but not child/teen friendly. Darn, thought it was a restaurant but couldn't bring our teen. Won't let me leave a review without stars. read more

Service was great , all the staff is really friendly and kind. The food on the other hand was just kind of OK. I will say the fries are excellent! The veggie burger is super mushy with too much bean and the Caprese was good but just average. Would come back to drink and skip the food next time read more

Off Broadway Taproom - Veggie burger - Beer Bar Near Me - Madison, Indiana

See all

Great location and ambiance!! The ribeye was not worth the price. I've had great ribeyes Al over the country and this lacked something. Parts of it tasted gamely , which was not pleasant. The bartender was awesome and the drinks were on point! read more

Food was delish and service was friendly and timely. Look forward to checking it out again when I return in the warmer weather.

My dad and I stopped here while passing through on a motorcycle trip. Very friendly service and many beer taps from Illinois breweries. We had the smoked wings, which were very good. The taco salad was very good but the spring greens got lost in the ground beef. I would suggest Romain lettuce instead of spring greens. I highly recommend.! read more

Off Broadway Taproom - Beer Bar Near Me - Madison, Indiana

Some of the best food in Madison with gluten free options! Casual/bar atmosphere but don't let it fool you, I go for the food not the drinks. read more

We were Received warmly. As a former publican of a spirited pub in Fort Wayne, this taproom was absolutely phenomenal! It is a well-oiled machine working gracefully to meet the customers needs. Gabby, a bartender, graced the bar with such finesse and energy. She has a incredible memory. The gentleman too working with her was exceptional. The food and beverages were excellent and the price. This is a five star joint! read more

Stopped in Off Broadway Taproom on a rainy day to get a little lunch. They were pretty busy at noon on Saturday. My hubby had the Wee Mac in a can for his drink and I chose a Coke. They waited on us pretty quickly and checked on us a couple of time during the meal. I ordered fried green tomatoes and the Philly cheesesteak sandwich, the hubby ordered wings with two different sauces. I chose the house-made chips for my side with the Philly. Pretty cool bar area and it was busy as well. We enjoyed our meal and appreciated the quick service. I would order the Philly again as it was a good amount of food and tasty. read more

See all

This is a local bar catering to locals. We took a weekend trip to Madison, IN. This bar was recommended to grab a bite to eat. First impression was good when we walked in. There are about 9 tables along the wall and only one table available at the end. Everyone looked at us when we walked in and the conversations got louder. We sat down and staff walked by us several times not even glancing our way or offering service. I asked for menus. They continued walking by us not offering service. All this time, the bartender just stood there watching us. We were never offered service in this bar. It became very obvious this is a local bar and outsiders are not welcome. We have never had an experience such as this. On the positive side this place was very clean. Can't comment on the food as we were not served. We were cheered as we left. read more

Off Broadway Taproom - Taken from the back of the bar - Beer Bar Near Me - Madison, Indiana

Went for lunch on a HOT day! So pleasantly surprised! Had a spinach chicken wrap with pasta salad! Very large portions! Look forward to eating here again read more

What an unexpected surprise! The food was amazing we had tacos-- buffalo cauliflower (9/10), fish taco (10/10), shrimp taco (9/10), carnitas (10/10), steak (7/10). Fish taco was the best one! Service was great, beers were excellent. Atmosphere was awesome. read more

We went on taco Tuesday. The tacos are unbelievably delicious and huge. They were all great. I liked the Carnitas best. Violet took care of us. She really hustled. I like the hydro racer on the back wall. Cool decoration. Definitely deserves 5 stars. They need more tables. read more

See all

We had the shrimp, fish and chicken tacos. All three were great, but if I had to choose one it would be the shrimp. The 1/2 loaded tater tots was too much for the two of us. Very good and plenty if you are very hungry. They have a big selection of beers. Our waitress was very nice, sadly I forgot her name. read more

Stopped in for dinner here one night while in town. They have bar seating and regular tables too. Inside was cozy. Our waitress was friendly and knowledgeable. Food was wonderful and our orders were correct. My burger was well seasoned, and the homemade chips were fresh and crisp. Would eat here again if ever in town. Even though it was getting busy (fri night) we were never rushed. Small town goodness! read more

I had the sweetest server! Kennedy was so awesome! She is a good asset to your team! We will continue to come back, because of her!

The best tacos I've ever had! My husband is from Louisiana and he got the shrimp,fish, and crawfish tacos and he absolutely loved them! Everything was great! read more

Great food and service! Cute little bar that seems like a popular spot for locals and visitors like us. Food was tasty - especially the California club with homemade chipotle mayo. Enjoyed a margarita and an old fashioned to complete our meal. Beer list is extensive! read more

Off Broadway Taproom - California Club - delish! - Beer Bar Near Me - Madison, Indiana

See all

Can't really describe this as pub food because it's soooo good! Had the Rosemary chicken sandwich and it was delicious! The service is great, even on a high traffic day like Hanover Homecoming. We are going back the very next day bvuz we heard from other patrons that the brunch is fantastic. read more

My boyfriend and I came into your restaurant early September for a quick bite. I got the Po Boy sandwich and he got a burger. Both of our main courses were amazing, however the Crawfish taco we split was not. Taste was good, however we woke up in the middle of the night with food poisoning; throwing up with stomach cramps. We really enjoyed our main meals and may give it a second try-- minus the Crawfish taco. read more

DAMN good tacos! Fish and shrimp tacos were incredible. Ordered a second helping. Nice staff and great vibe.