This is one of the most popular breakfast spots on the island, so we obviously had to try it. The food was genuinely very good. My Seasonal Vegetable Scramble was fresh and delicious, and the toast was really good. The hash browns were probably the best part, though. We also got the Blueberry Buttermilk Pancakes, and those might honestly be some of the best pancakes I've ever had. They were SO good. My biggest complaints are the size of the restaurant and the prices. It's incredibly small inside, and because it's so popular, you may have to wait a little bit to get seated. That itself isn't a huge issue, but the bar seating is so incredibly uncomfortable, and it honestly made the experience less enjoyable. The prices are also pretty ridiculous. My vegetable scramble was $26, which is insane to me. I completely understand that you're on an island and things are going to be more expensive, but $26 for a vegetable scramble is kind of crazy. Other than the uncomfortable seating and the prices, the food itself was very good and definitely worth trying if you're visiting the island. read more

Black-Eyed Susan's - Seasonal Veg Scramble - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Great little spot for breakfast in town. They also serve dinner as well although it can't comment on that. I had the avocado toast, my son had a pancake, and my husband had the French Toast and hash browns. Everything was delicious. I even purchased a super cute mug to go. Service was efficient and we only had to wait about 5 minutes to be seated although we came around 10 am on a Monday. Definitely expensive, but the prices almost everywhere on this island seem to be inflated a bit. read more

See all

We got the french toast, spicy thai curry scramble, and a blueberry pancake. The food was all really good, but it was pretty pricey. We went on a Thursday and waited around 25 minutes for a table. They don't have a notification system so you just have to wait around the restaurant for your name to be called. read more

See all

Super enjoyable. Very cute, very cozy. Sunday morning, packed, but the service was calm, efficient, and friendly. I had buttermilk pancakes and they were old school. Real buttermilk taste. I also had a side order of the local sausage, linguiça, delicious. I'm leaving now and there's a line out the door. read more

Black-Eyed Susan's - This is a peak into the back of the building - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

They never let me down. I ak says look forward to a serving of their black eyed peas for breakfast. They open promptly at 7:00 each morning. A definite must every time I hit the island. read more

Black-Eyed Susan's - Logo - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

This is a low four rating. While I wasn't blown away by dinner at Black Eyed Susan's, it was low key, and fine and we were able to snag a last minute reservation. The appetizers were drastically over-priced and very average, but entrees were better. The famed tuna app wasn't as grand as remembered and pretty generic and the salad was also not memorable for a steep price tag. The outdoor patio is charming and inside is so cozy in a diner setting way. They are very much known for their brunch - which does not take rezzies, while dinner does. Brunch is a classic Nantucket choice, as long as you don't mind a wait, dinner is solid. BYOB! read more

Had a great experience here! Went 2x while on the island and highly rec if you're craving eggs and pancakes! I tried both the blueberry and buttermilk pancake and both were light and delicious. The blueberry one was super special with the sweet bitterness of the blueberries really put these over the top! The egg white veggie scramble was perfectly seasoned and just overall very delicious. The scramble also came up with a side + oatmeal toast which is lovely touch. Service was speedy and attentive. Very good wait staff! Loved sitting at the counter too. PS! I do want to mention this breakfast spot is very pricey but the portion sizes are large. Most spots on the island are expensive so it's not surprising but definitely steep. read more

Black-Eyed Susan's - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Although highly recommended, my family waited over 2 hours for a mediocre meal that was very expensive. When the hostess told us she was setting our table, another employee gave our table to another party. They told us they had a reservation. However they didn't take reservations. We waisted a whole morning waiting for a table when we could have been enjoying Nantucket. We were a party of 7 and they sat us at a table for 4. Not worth the wait! read more

Run don't walk to this place if you're on the first morning ferry. Had a passenger who was a part time resident refer this to us on our visit to the island! What an amazing, charming, down home cozy joint this is. It's perfect! Everybody know every body type place! The French toast and omlet was amazing!!!! Great folks working the busy place with friendly service and smiles all day long! Do it! read more

Amazing breakfast! Loved the blueberry pancakes, best I've ever had. Bacon was also delicious. Highly recommend! read more

Really great and affordable brunch on the island with some pretty unique offerings! Surprised by the low ish ratings so hoping to boost. BES was recommended to us by a friend who really enjoyed their spicy thai curry scramble so of course we got it. The curry was definitely on the lighter/subtle side and wasn't all that spicy - could've used a stronger kick but still tasty overall. We also had the breakfast sandwich which came out piping hot but was so good and fresh. The sauce was delicious. The sides of hash brown were so incredibly light, airy and fresh. They didn't leave us feeling heavy and were just perfect. We also had to try a side of linguica as we don't typically see those on brunch menus and they went so well with the hash brown. There was maybe a 15-20 min wait on a Sunday morning but our server was so sweet. We were pleasantly surprised by this meal and would definitely recommend. read more

See all

Judging from the lines to get into this place, we figured it had to be good. We lucked out when we got there because we got to go in immediately. We went for breakfast, and it was delicious. Every place in Nantucket seems to be small, that is how Black Eyed Susan's is. You get close. But the food is worth it. I would've loved to have seen what their dinner menu was. read more

Great little place for a home cooked vibe. Attentive staff, tastey meal! There can be a wait sometimes, but India street is not a bad place to if one has to wait. read more

See all

Fantastic breakfast! Wonderful menu and excellent service. Comfort food in diner style. Maryellen was a wonderful waitress and added to our great experience! Worth the wait (if line is long) read more

See all

A very cute spot but unfortunately my food left little to be desired. I ordered the avocado toast and it was more like Sabra guacamole bread. For the price I was very unimpressed. The other diners got the breakfast sand which was much better. read more

Our Server Jo was a sweetie and very patient with our group of 6. It was restaurant week in Nantucket and we made reservations for outside since COVID is now making a comeback. There were about 5 appetizers to choose from and about 6 entrees and then 1 dessert choice. I went with my sisters - two of whom are VERY picky eaters, one of them could not find any appetizer she would eat, and only one entree. But again she eats like a toddler, and no onions, no cheese, no ingredient she has never heard of, etc, etc. She did find an entree she liked (thank goodness). I had the squash hushpuppies which were delish, served nice and hot outta the fryer. My entree was the pork served over lentils..the Pork was fall apart tender - and there was a little but of spice to it. The portion was huge and I got to take 1/2 of it home. I do wish there was more than one dessert option, though the one they had was indeed tasty - it was like a chess pie. What I really loved about it was that they really had the salt to sweet ratio on point! read more

See all

A wonderful breakfast find near downtown. While on a business trip my colleague and I read good reviews on Yelp about the wonderful experience of Yelpers at this establishment. I'm pleased to report that we are adding our experience to the growing list. While we waited a long time (45 minutes) after being told it would be thirty minutes we finally were seated inside at a two person table. The serving staff was prompt and quickly brought us water while we reviewed the menu. Megan ordered the huevos rancheros and I got the vegetable scramble with tofu. We heard about their delicious pancakes so we ordered one with whipped butter and maple syrup on the side. I'm so glad that we did. It's was a perfect compliment to an excellent meal. I do highly recommend adding the pico de gallo to the tofu scramble meal. It makes it extra yummy. read more

See all

Best hangover cure. Cured my chicken box blues. Thank god for these pancakes... EVEN MORE... thank god for the hash browns, they were a godsend. Dousing the pancakes in syrup and the melted butter is actually heaven on earth and everyone must eat here. Currently mouth watering thinking about it. read more

See all

Been wanting to try this spot for a while right now because it's considered an island staple. Went on a whim and was wildly disappointed, overpriced and tasteless. Even the delivery was very unappetizing. Special looked good when delivered but didn't have much taste either, the risotto was good from the special. Hopefully breakfast is better. Service was great, just disappointed by the food. read more

Black-Eyed Susan's - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Worth the wait. The grits are especially yummy. Everything on their menu is good. Don't miss this place for breakfast!

Ordered all the apps. Amazing tuna tar tar. The chefs were amazing and friendly- we at the counter and chatted them up a bit. The decor and mood, the lighting, all top notch. Excellent food! read more

Black-Eyed Susan's - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

We had breakfast at Black Eyed Susan's, and as always it was charming and yummy. I had the Portuguese scramble, while my had the French toast, made from actual French bread. read more

Sat at the counter and we were mesmerized by the chefs preparing breakfast for the patrons. I got the egg scramble special with asparagus, roasted red peppers and basil, with extra crispy hash browns and an English muffin. My husband got blueberry pancakes. Food was excellent, well prepared, and quick. All the ingredients were fresh, and our server Mariah was friendly and attentive. The place is cozy with a fun and relaxed atmosphere, great music selection. We are here for the weekend and will return tomorrow for sure! read more

The best dinner on Nantucket. Hands down. Todd is an unbelievable chef, and I am so happy he is back on island. Gone are the days of cash only and lining up for reservations- snag a seat at the counter to watch the cooks work their magic!!! read more

Black-Eyed Susan's - Tuna Tartare - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Another local favorite tucked away in the upper part of town! The food is really good. Better than diner food but feels like home cooking. It is very small inside, they now have outside seating in the back too. There is usually a wait, but trust me its worth it. It can get a little warm inside though. HIGHLY recommend for breakfast. Their Huevos Rancheros are amazing and a bit different than your usual. We also love their blueberry pancakes! Parking is street parking. Casual attire. read more

A good eatery open for breakfast and dinner . We had delicious corned beef hash with eggs over easy and a Portuguese scramble fir breakfast ...The pancakes and French toast looked good on our neighbors plates. A couple of things to note-, cash only, tight quarters and the kitchen grille is directly across from the tables...also no a/c was on when we visited so it was a bit warm . Service was good., Joe Bob gives it a thumbs up for breakfast read more

I know it's an island but one type of bread is a little odd, hash browns are the frozen patties from the grocery store. Prices for homemade food but diner quality. read more

Awesome breakfast spot! Huevos rancheros we're amazing. Haven't had good huevos in years. Place was packed but they know how to get you in and out without feeling rushed. read more

Black-Eyed Susan's - Huervos rancheros - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

This place was always an island favorite but under the new ownership... not so much. Food quality is the same as it's the same chef but prices went WAY up and portions went WAY down. Left hungry. Sad but won't be returning. read more

Tiny breakfast Cafe with lots of local ambiance. Opens early (7am) when nothing else around is open. Food is good & portions are generous. $$$ ($50+ for 2), but that is typical for the island. read more

Some of the best omelettes, pancakes, eggs benedicts, and other breakfast items on Nantucket. A cool, small location with friendly staff.

Please re-open!!! We miss your amazing breakfast! Hope that things get sorted out soon what ever it is.

Not sure what the fuss is. Dinner is ok, if you like to stand in line to make reservations and eat yummy food in 110*. That's right. NO AIR CON and an open kitchen! Not for the menepausal .... breakfast is average only & lord knows you'll be lined up like cattle to the slaughter for scrambled eggs and stringy linquica sausage. It's an ACK landmark... resting on its laurels it seems. Enjoy & go home & take a cold shower. ( trust me you'll need it) Ps: no liquor license so byob. read more

An oval potato hash brown like the one at McDonald's but they don't deep fry them they griddle them with oil and it literally was like a sponge ... McDonald's are better ... also had a side of corn beef hash and it was off it had a sour smell and sour taste our waiter literally told us to go to the Downey flake ... $50 For 2 breakfast that we did not even eat or enjoy. Pre-cooked thin bacon like at Subway and toast was not even toasted such a shame. read more

Be advised, there is always a wait for a table. (Longer at peak vacation breakfast times.) So naturally, the question comes: Is it worth the wait for a diner? The food at this old style diner is always great. Favorites among our family are the Portuguese scramble and the pancakes. It can get hot inside, so if you have the option to sit outside in back do that. FYI...Cash Only. read more

See all

Food was good although very limited menu. Very small cosy restaurant. Pleasing to some, cramped to others. BYOB. Felt rushed due to the 2 nightly seatings. Just not the good experience I expected., read more

It's a nice little restaurant but boy oh boy does it cramped inside. It's small. It's tiny. Eh, it's located inside a former house. There is table seating inside but a very long counter dominates half of the space. The cook(s) work in front of the counter so the counter patrons receive a slight show while dining. This restaurant is known for its breakfasts and brunches. I tried visiting for dinner at night but the restaurant was completely filled. Plus, I learned the dinner prices were kinda high. So I was happy to just eat breakfast there on the following day. Prices were much more reasonable for breakfast. During my visit, it contained a mix of locals and tourists. Cash only. read more

See all

Just had a fabulous breakfast at Black-Eyed Susan's. Huevos Rancheros were the best I've had on the east coast. And to top it off, a mystery benefactor came by and told our waiter he'd pay for our breakfast! Thank you to whoever you are! read more

Delicious food but not much space. Definitely better for small groups or counter seating. The hostess does a great job getting parties in to be seated. The waitress and guysanning the kitchen do a great job. I got the eggs Benedict and was very happy with it. The English muffin was well griddled and the ham was thick and eggs cooked perfectly. We got a side of corn beef hash for the table. This is not your canned red corn beef hah, it was Crenshaw made and from gray corn beef instead of red. So smooth, almost as if mixed with mashed potatoes instead of chunks of crisp home fries. The edges were crispy from the griddle and it was absolutely delicious. Highly recommend ordering the hash! read more

Can a hostess torpedo an experience? My gosh. The attitude and off-putting miserableness is gross. Hey owner! Step up and fix this. "Can I put my name in for a table? No, wait outside, I'll get to you when I get to you". Too bad because the cooks are working hard and the food is decent, but it's overshadowed by the shit attitude of the hostess. Go elsewhere. Ps. All the people waiting outside are shaking their heads in disbelief. PPS. You're welcome for 2 stars. read more