I've been three times now, and every time I'm both impressed and let down. The decor is lovely; the size is intimate; the music is usually good; the food, however, is iffy.
Today I had brunch. Before my meal arrived, I was served two small muffins, which were cute and fine. One is usually bran in nature, and the other is a surprise. Today's was just a standard corn muffin, but they were both good. On to the meal, the scrambled eggs were standard but fine. The biscuit, as always, was well-done, which I prefer. It was warm, crunchy, and thick...but lacking in flavor, so I requested some strawberry jam. The crunch on top and bottom really was quite good though, so overall it was a win. The bacon, which they cure there, was burnt but somehow still not crispy; I don't care for chewy bacon, but I ate it. The home fries were decent - nothing to write home about; shoestring in nature, presented in one of those tall bucket-things with lots of added herbs. The sauces that came with the home fries were, I believe: a homemade ketchup with bacon infusion, a garlic aioli, and a srirachi concoction. The ketchup was the best one, but that might have been because it was actually cold; the temperature really added a nice refreshing kick. The garlic aioli was bland, unappetizing, and warm. My olfactory senses indicated the srirachi sauce was not for me. I also had the grits, which honestly just weren't very good at all. They advertise that their grits are "aged," but if that's aged, they need new. Good grits can really set a place apart from the hoi polloi (see Mama's Boy in Athens). I also had coffee, water, and a sangria. You can get the sangria in white or red, and I've had both. They are good, but they do not have fruit in them, which is a real disappointment. Good authentic sangria should have fruit, which soak up the wine and are delicious(ly boozy) to eat when finished with the drink. I will also add that I was nowhere near buzzed. The coffee and water were fine.
The last time I went I had the biscuits and gravy, and it was unappetizing in both appearance and taste. I expect sausage gravy to be white, not beige. It also shouldn't be greasy. If I'm being honest, I gave most of that to my dog when I got home.
Look. I'm still going to eat there. It's the best restaurant Winder has to offer, and I REALLY want this place to succeed. I just need for them to hone some of their details. Add some milk or something to the eggs for added fluffiness. Get the bacon crispy. Find some creamier grits. Add some fruit to the sangria. Leave the biscuit alone unless you're adding some herbs for flavor (maybe garlic?). Get your sausage gravy in order; it's not called "white gravy" for nothing.
3 out of 5 stars read more