Bibb St has some of the best pizza, by far the best in this area. Because of that they are SO busy and cannot handle it. Ordering online is apparently a huge mess from listening to people in the restaurant. Ordering there is still iffy. It is such a shame that a place with such delicious food can't handle their popularity. Only go if you have some serious time on your hands. read more

This is the best Pizza around! Delivery was super fast and it was very hot!!! I order from Bibb Pizza frequently and have always had a perfect order! I love Bibb Pizza the best. read more

Really good pizza in Downtown Montgomery! Ordered two cheese slices and they put them back in the oven for a minute or so...great undercarriage and great crisp. They had about ten beers on draft. I would definitely return for the pizza! read more

I was recently in Montgomery for a work trip, and stopped in one rainy evening with a group of 25 for an early dinner. This place did not disappoint. When our Tour Bus opened its doors, the staff's eyes did not widen with fright, rather twinkle with excitement. For those of you who are old enough, you will understand when I say this place made me feel nostalgic because the wave of aroma that hit me when I walked through the doors was that of pizza in from the 1980s. It was marvelous. In addition to all of the standard pizza treats and options, they had a great lineup of sandwiches, calzones, and salad that made every single person in my group happy. Moreover, they even had great beer on tap. If you like dark beers like me you'll love the Porter that they have in house. You would think with a group our size that we would've been waiting all night for Service, but that food started coming out within five minutes of the first order, and everyone was happy. This is a great place for small groups, large groups, and everything in between. It's worth saying that I was inspired for the first time in my life to eat a meatball sandwich. I could only handle half of the sandwich because it was so large, but the next time I'm in Montgomery I will definitely go back to this place for another. I think they may have ruined me for all meatball sandwiches everywhere else. read more

Bibb St Pizza Company - This meatball sub was phenomenal. Get it. - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, Alabama

The whole time I was in class all we did is a group was wait until we were able to get some authorizations to go have a bite to eat off base. Naturally, asking around paid dividends because word-of-mouth is stronger than any review could be. That being said, when a vast majority of folks got back to the dormitories and said that this was the place to be, it peaked my groups interest. Boy was I pleasantly surprised at the quality of the food and the taste of the ingredients on these handmade hand tossed pizzas. When I tell you that we went back three times in 10 days it is not an exaggeration, but merely a retailing of facts. We sat in very tables and booths and even enjoyed a bit of basketball in a separate side room with big screens On one outing, we were having such a good time just enjoying company and regaling entails a victory that we straight up ordered a round of cannolis for the table. Yes, the cannolis were absolutely delicious and yes, the Godfather was certainly quoted. If you are reading this and on the fence as to whether or not you should go I suggest you minimize the screen and pull up maps so you can make your way there. The owners are great. The establishment is military friendly, and it feels like the perfect place to go as a group. read more

See all

Pizza hit the spot! We were so hungry, and looking for a place near us to eat and found this place! We got the meat lovers, alla romania, and garlic knots. The restaurant wasn't too busy at 2pm on a Saturday. The service was a little slow, but a lot of people were there. The food was so good, so overall great experience! The restaurant definitely have been a little cleaner, especially the bathrooms. But overall, good enough for me! read more

Bibb St Pizza Company - Large 18'' Meat Lover Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, Alabama

See all

Not bad for a basic pizza place in Montgomery. With all of the hype I hear about it, I really expected much better. It's Just plane pizza, no wood fired oven, no bubbly crust, may as well order from one of the big chains. read more

We couldn't resist the glorious smell. We had a slice yesterday while at the brewery next door. Definitely worth the wait, they take their time and the results are wonderful. The crust was house-made, soft and cooked just right. The cheese and sauce were also high quality. They have a nice out door eating and waiting area because it was really busy inside. read more

It seems like they're running a great family business. To make a nice comment, my Pepsi tasted like Pepsi. Sadly, the pizza has absolutely no flavor. The marinara sauce tastes like tap water. They were pleasantly accommodating to my gluten free pizza crust request, however provided the wrong pizza toppings (ordered the cheese pizza from the "specials", yet received a marinara based pizza with only mozzarella as the topping). We were in a rush traveling through town so did not bother to request a remake during the busy lunch rush. The pizza had to be smothered in Parmesan and red pepper flakes to make it edible. The mozzarella sticks had a great cheese pull and crust, however, the accompanying marinara sauce again fell flat. The ranch was very thin and tasteless, which at 50¢ a cup was disappointing. Huge waste of money sadly, as the staff seemed very nice and there was a large crowd of locals following after our order was placed, which should signify a delicious meal. read more

I visited Bibb Street Pizza twice during May 2026. After my first visit, I returned a second time because I wanted to be certain that what I experienced the first time was real and not simply a misunderstanding on my part. On both occasions, I was completely ignored. The employees clearly saw me standing there, yet no one acknowledged my presence. No one greeted me, no one said they would be with me shortly, and no one made any effort to assist me. The experience left me feeling not merely unwelcome, but openly disdained. The situation reminded me of what Ralph Ellison described in Invisible Man, the feeling of being unseen despite standing plainly in view. Even growing up in Montgomery during the 1960s, if I accidentally wandered into a "Whites Only" section of a store, such as the upstairs lunch counters at S. H. Kress & Co. or H. L. Green downtown, a clerk would at least tell me I was in the wrong area. As a child, I appreciated being told directly, because I have never wanted to remain where I was not wanted. The employees at Bibb Street Pizza made their feelings known through their actions during my visits in May 2026. I am not angry, nor am I trying to discourage others from patronizing the business. However, I believe the staff should understand how their actions may be perceived by others, whether that was their intention or not. I sincerely wish everyone there well. My purpose in writing this is simply to explain how those experiences came across to me. read more

I went here in July 2021 with some Air Force friends and it was outstanding - the pizza, beer, atmosphere - all amazing. I'll definitely be back next time at Maxwell! read more

The pizza is better than good ... I admire the location in downtown Montgomery something that been missing for 30 years . Friendly fast southern service . I enjoyed the feel of the restaurant . Games on all tvs. Will be back for sure read more

Bibb St Pizza Company - Tasty pizza ..huge slice - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, Alabama

See all

Nestled in an old warehouse, the vibe is that of a hopping college pizza joint. Pizzas are either 12 or 16 inches and are either hand tossed or square pan. I ordered pan the first time we went, but they were out of pan. The crust is flat, thin, and the edge crust is toasted pretty hard. But, the cheese is plentiful and good quality, as are the toppings. They do not have fresh basil, sadly. Service is slow. You walk in, stand at the register to order. We waited about 10 minutes to order the first time. The second was faster (3-4 min). They have 4 ovens and a hefty call in business. So, even though we were the only ones in line, there is a significant wait. On Superbowl Sunday, it took an hour for our pizzas to come out. You can order by the slice, but their slices are pricey. Buying 2 slices (1/4 pizza) is almost as much as a 12 in. Since Mellow Mushroom (my favorite pizza) that was 2 blocks away closed, this is the best pizza around unless you want to go to Prattville. Good beer selection that can be bought by the pitcher (9 beers per pitcher). read more

Great pizza and sandwiches as well as all kinds of Italian foods. Kinda reminds me of a New York pizza place in a hole in the wall ! read more

I ordered a calzone with pepperoni, extra sauce, and NO cheese because I am lactose intolerant. They completely ignored that, put a different kind of cheese in it anyway, and then still charged me for extra cheese. To make it worse, they also charged me for extra sauce that was supposed to be INSIDE the calzone, yet the sauce wasn't even inside--it was dumped on the side instead. That's unacceptable. On top of that, the calzone was made wrong and tasted disgusting. They clearly don't understand what a calzone even is. The size was an absolute joke--this was the smallest "calzone" I've ever had, smaller than a paper plate. A quesadilla is bigger than what they served me. The restaurant itself was also a mess. It was very slow, yet I couldn't find a single clean table to sit at. Between ignoring dietary restrictions, messing up the order, overcharging, serving a tiny portion, and keeping a dirty dining area, this place clearly doesn't care. I will not be back. read more

Bibb St Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, Alabama

See all

We had the calzone & stombolli. Both were freshly made and delicious! A decent selection of local, craft beers too. Staff was friendly and welcoming. read more

Had the Bibb Street special, it was delicious. We are from Birmingham, so if we are ever back we will definitely come here again.

Ordered a pizza online for delivery and added mozzarella sticks as well. Im guessing they contracted with Door Dash as the driver called me when she was picking up the order. She stated they were out if mozzarella sticks and asked if I still wanted the pizza. I said "yes" and when she arrived, she said I would have to call door dash to get a refund. Why didn't the restaurant just credit my card? What a disappointment! At least the pizza was good. read more

First time visiting today and my experience was very good. The staff were really friendly, the food was delicious. The lunch deal at $9 for two slices and a drink is a good deal. I went with a pepperoni slice and a slice of mushroom and jalapeños. Parking is not ideal but there is an open lot at a closed business across the street. Definitely recommend. read more

I didn't think I'd find a place that I liked as well as my favorite place in Prattville, but I did. My daughter turned me on to this place, and I love coming here, especially with her! Their pizza is made to order, and it's delicious! They serve Pepsi products, as well as iced tea--all self served. They have some great lunch specials--2 slices & a drink, a slice & salad & drink, and others. They have lots of seating, indoors and outdoors, and several TVs showing sports. They call your name very loudly when your order is up, and you pick it up at the counter from the cook. Parking is at a premium during the lunch hour, so come early or late to get a space. read more

My first time here after many recommendations. The pizza quality, taste and options are amazing. For a dine in pizza spot, pretty much what you can expect as far as atmosphere. The main problem is the wait. They are cooking fresh but the wait time is serious. Some people we came with ordered before us and shared their food. By the time mine came I almost didn't want it but did eat some and enjoyed it. Don't think I will ever go there hungry though. read more

See all

It was a cold rainy night and I decided I wanted to get some pizza. I had not been to Bibb Street in quite some time. When they first opened, I remembered a very thin crispy New York style pizza. Unfortunately, I have not been to Bibb Street in quite some time, and it was not the pizza it used to be. The pizza was floppy, greasy, and not as flavorful as I recalled. I was severely disappointed. The garlic knots were OK but slightly undercooked and the cheese was not fully baked into the knot. The service was quick and the staff was friendly, but it is unlikely that I will return. I think when I want delicious pizza, I will go to Midtown instead. read more

My Husband is a New Yorker he loves there pizza. Staff is friendly. Manger is great. Husband will not eat any other pizza in less we r in St Augustin or Panama City Beach. So they r Number 1 in our book. Also loves the Salads and calazon. read more

This was our first stop in Montgomery, and it was a good one! The place was hopping, so we found it difficult to park, but once we got our food we understood why, and it was at lunch time for everyone. The pizza was delicious, nice and crisp on the bottom. We had to eat outside, and in the pouring rain, we still had a spot. With no flies outside. It looks so fun inside though, and if it was less busy, we would've stay in. The staff were very warm and welcoming. Greeting us immediately, and patient to answer any questions we had. Highly recommend for an interesting spot to stop in when you're wanting a quick bite. read more

We just stopped in Montgomery for the night while traveling and this was very close to our hotel. This is, quite possibly, THE BEST pizza I have ever had! We had cheeseburger pizza, pepperoni pizza, cheese sticks, and zucchini sticks. ALL were delicious! We will come back here ANY time we come to town! read more

When you walk in, you order first before sitting down. We ordered the large supreme pizza, and it's huge! The crust is on the thinner side and it was pretty good. The calzone was an interesting one; it wasn't what I'm used to. You do pay extra to add pepperoni in the calzone. Everything is made in house which is cool, but I wouldn't say that it was the best. The service was on point. Make sure to ask for plates and sauce like ranch if you like to dip your pizza in it. The two employees I interacted with were nice. You do get a number with your order. They give you a taste test for different beers. The empty tables were pretty dirty. They had pretty good traffic on a Saturday night at around 9pm. Glad I got to experience this, not sure if I would be back though. read more

Bibb St Pizza Company - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, Alabama

See all

This review is not for their pizza, it's really great, but it's so popular that they are completely overwhelmed at lunch and service is SLOW. They take orders online that take over an hour to fill and prioritize walk in customers...it's unsatisfactory, please fix this issue. read more

A good slice Stopped and following the graduation for my friend and had a slice and sub. The slice was thin and flavorful crispy and full of cheese and toppings. Definitely a winner. The sandwich was perfectly melted and certainly hit the spot. The music play list was FIRE!! read more

We ordered door dash and everything was fast, hot and delicious even though they were super busy. Excellent flavor for pizzas and sandwiches. Thanks, Bibb St. Pizza Company. read more

The service and food was excellent. I had the meat lovers pizza and it was one of the best pizza I've had in Alabama. I'd highly recommend Bibb St Pizza Company if you find yourself in Montgomery. read more

Yumm!!! This meat lovers pizza was very good. We also got garlic knots and a alla romantic pizza. Delicious!

As a New Yorker this is indeed excellent pizza. We ordered delivery and it was pretty fast and still hot in the box. Look forward to checking it out in person. read more

Good pizza & good prices. My family did one of the $7 lunch daily specials. Which was 1 side salad, drink & 1 topping pizza. Plenty of booths & long pub table. We'd eat here again. read more

See all

Honestly, I'd return to this establishment over and over and over for three reasons: the food, the staff, and the atmosphere. Walking in I noticed two things, the interior is smaller than what I originally thought and they were blasting a little Blink 182, which was a great sign. immediately, the staff began making small talk with us, gave us great tips on different local restaurants, and told us the amazing set up they have with the brewery next door, Common Bond. Apparently, they allow you to bring beer back and forth between the restaurant and brewery, and there's a little patio area with corn hole and chairs that they share as well. The interior, although small, has a relaxing vibe to it. Like I said, the staff is extremely friendly. I loved making small talk with these guys and learning about their beer selection. Not only do they have a great beer selection, but they allowed us to sample them as well. My favorites were the two sours they have on tap. Also, their coffee stout is fairly tasty. It's made with cold brew so the coffee flavor is more intense then most coffee stouts I've enjoyed. The food is amazing and reasonably priced. We enjoyed the garlic knots with fresh in-house made marinara and a large neopolitano pepperoni pizza. The large, depending on how much your party can eat, feeds about four people (8 slices total). One thing that is really cool is they hand-toss the pizza at the counter right in front of you. I don't think I need to say it again but I will, this place is awesome! It's probably a good thing that I don't like here or I'd be in trouble. Side note: the restaurant has a private room that seats about 8-10 people comfortably. Just FYI, it's on a first-come-first-serve basis. Also, they provide a military discount. Enjoy! read more

See all

Went last night around 7. It was busy but not overly so and there were plenty of staff behind the counter. Party of four, we ordered our food. Thirty minutes later, they finally called my number and when I got to the counter, he hadn't even plated it yet. Fifteen minutes after that, two more at my table got their food. The fourth person never got hers and when she went up to question it, was told "Oh, yeah, we'll start it now." She got a refund. My calzone was overly cooked to the point that the crust could barely be torn with my fingers, let alone a fork. I've been before and the service is always slow, but last night was a cluster#$%^&. read more

I don't mean to be harsh but if you can't get the basics right...your organization is doomed. I ordered a pizza, sub, and garlic knots. My history tells me if you can't get garlic knots right, the rest suffers. These garlic knots were beefy and solid (though could have more garlic) but my problem is...if you make my pay more for marinara or other sauces I EXPECT it be included. The fact that I have to check to confirm is a huge deduction. Standards matter and I should get what I paid for (in this case it wasn't the added sauces). I enjoyed everything minus what I paid for and that's why 3 stars. Follow through and double check orders and this place you be 10/5 stars. read more

In order the Bibb pizza. It was incredibly bland. Almost as if none of the ingredients have flavor. I actually think movie theater pizza has a bit more flavor. Not trying to be rude. The presentation is good, it looks appetizing but it doesn't taste like it looks. The sauce, I don't even taste it (watered down), the cheese.... Not enough added to give flavor or at least a level of saltiness. The pepperoni genuinely tasted like nothing. Like I'm not even kidding. I peeled off the pepperoni and ate it by itself. Nothing. I'm not sure what's going on there. Customer service was average. The place was clean, location is good, the ambiance was also nice. Just no good food. Won't return. read more

Everything was delicious. The service was great - lots of recommendations. They even delivered next door to Common Bond Brewery next door. The veggie pizza was delicious. The pineapple was a great addition! The single slices were huge. The half sandwich was more like a whole! Check them out! read more

See all

My favorite pizza place for eat in. Today travelling through Montgomery ordered ahead and the order was updated with a delivery time about 20 minutes later than the original time, not a problem. My fault for not checking, but he handed over the pizza and we left. It was all wrong. $31 for something that went right into the garbage was not a deal. Yes, I did call and let them know. All he said was sorry. read more

The food is great. The prices are reasonable and the staff is friendly. It's worth it to come downtown.