Best Pizza in South Bend. Have been coming here since I could walk and it never disappoints. Always go with the supreme (Green Pep, Onion, Mushroom, Pepperoni, Sausage). Mug Club Membership $5 for life for $5 pitchers. Also have Newcastle and Fat Tire on tap. Only place for pizza and beer. East Jefferson is the spot don't even waste your time with the Grape Road location. read more

The best pizza in town. Better than anywhere else. My favorite pizza place in town. It take about an hour but it is good. I recommend you to go here read more

To whomever said they were writing for travelers, and gave an abysmal review: All time fav pizza... Its Chicago thin crust. Which is similar to St Louis with a cracker crust. Sausage with extra cheese is traditional. Many ppl don't even know Chi thin crust exists. If you thought this was a NY slice, yea, you'd prob be disappointed. But this is where SB eats their pizza. Its amazing. And so is the addictive parm/herb topping. Pizzas are slow to come, arrive boiling, and are worth a wait read more

Not only is there pizza amazing but their employees are just plain awesome. The customer service is off the chain they really make you feel like family here without even knowing your name. Tara went above and beyond tonight and even though I only spoke to her over the phone I could tell she was smiling and and she was extremely helpful! :) Thank you down town Barnaby's for making our night! read more

Best pizza in Michiana area! Delicious crust and sausage. Employees often give discount even if you don't have a coupon. I love the order and serve yourself style. It's a laid back place great for long dinners with friends. Call ahead to order your pizza if you need it quick. Jefferson Road location is SIGNIFIGANTLY better than Grape road location. I'm not sure if they are owned/run by the same people, but the food and service are superior at the Jefferson Road location. The extra drive is worth it. read more

This place is not good for kids, the food is not special, and the cashier couldn't bother to tell us it was going to be 40 minutes for pizza. Which is not good when you have toddlers. Our fries were cold by the time we got our burgers. Worst experience ever. I will never return. read more

The atmosphere can be a little dank and the place itself a little quaint but the pizza is second to none. With a crust as good as Barnaby's you could easily get away with second-rate toppings on top, but Barnaby's doesn't shortchange you anywhere. With a huge variety of toppings, a bar, salad bar and full array of appetizers it's a great place to grab a beer with friends or grab a pizza to take home for the family. read more

I've lived in this neighborhood for many years, and I was looking forward to a new experience when this restaurant closed for remodeling a couple months ago. Unfortunately I was disappointed when I went today. The same boring dull ceilings and walls and very uncomfortable booths. The food was OK, but all in all there's not enough here to bring me back. read more

I have friends who swear by Barnaby's. I think it is good to great but not amazing. Tastes like beer in the crust. Not a fan of the ordering system when dining in. I do get carryout once in a while. read more

One of our favorite places to get pizza in dtsb! Great local joint not to be missed if your in South Bend.

Everybody goes to Barnabys, I just don't know why. No service, good but not great expensive pizza. Not enough TV's to be a sports bar, enough TV's to be distracting and its usually way to noisy. read more

Big, open, fun atmosphere! Seat yourself and order at the counter. TV's to watch any current sports. Pizza and garlic bread are great! I will definitely go back anytime I want a sit-down pizza place. read more

Cheap beer good tastin pizza

My first thought upon leaving Barnaby's was: "Meh." The pizza was average at best. I wasn't a huge fan of the crust or the sauce, sort of agreeing with the previous review that said the crust was like a saltine cracker. As far as pizza goes it is really goddamn expensive, especially since they don't even have waiters serving you. For the best pizza in South Bend, skip Barnaby's and check out Rocco's. read more

Ate here growing up in the late 80s and early 90s. Its my favorite pizza place and I always eat here when I come back and visit.

Order took over an hour and a half to be delivered, and arrived over 35 minutes after scheduled delivery time. Called Barnaby's after scheduled delivery time had lapsed to calmly and respectfully asked about the status of my delivery order. Lady who answered was extremely rude as she yelled to hold on, only to be outdone by the man who then picked up and very rudely stated the order was already out before hanging up on me before I could get a word in. The order arrived ~30 minutes later. No apologies from anyone for my order being so late. Barnaby's considers the customer to come second to themselves. Very sorry for annoying you with my business, Barnaby's. Won't happen again. Two stars instead of one because the food was decent, albeit a bit cold by the time it finally arrived. read more

The ordering process doesn't make much sense, it was our first time there and there wasn't anyone up front to tell us that we had to stand in line to order food stand in a different line to order drinks. Then hope there was a seat to sit at. No servers, no host, no seats, and a line 10 deep. We left and went somewhere to get service. read more

Unique pizza crust, substantial but not doughy. We have consistently good pizza whether we dine in or carry out. Coupons keep the price reasonable. Tonight's pizza was great! read more

For over 20 years this place has been one of my favorites. Great pizza, burgers, and shrimp.

This is my favorite pizza of all time. The crust has great flavor and is soft and crunchy at the same time. I usually get takeout but the atmosphere inside the restaurant is pretty fun. It's very dark and loud and friendly. They have great specials on beer read more

Been going here every year or so since the 1970s. Yeah, its dark, its a bit pricey for what you get, but, hey, they serve beer and its open on Sundays. Whattdayawant!?!?! read more

What happened to Barnaby's on Jefferson? Their pizza was always better than Barnaby's on Grape Rd. and they consistently had one of the better pizzas in this area but now they are on par with the Grape location. BLAND crust, relatively bland pizza. Very disappointing. There is little to no reason to return especially when there is an excellent pizza location less that 1/4 mile north on South Bend Av. read more

I read some great reviews... but being honest I found NOTHING special about this place. It has a nice atmosphere, but I had the pizza and again, nothing special. It tasted like most Midwest pizzas really. There was simply nothing that stood out with this pizza. I also didn't like the fact you had to go to another line to get your drinks. They had ONE person there on a Saturday night.... the line at times was 10 people deep. For soft drinks, it could be a lot easier if you just had self service! Perhaps Barnaby's is the best South Bend pizza. If so.... I wouldn't get pizza in South Bend at all! read more

Excellent Pizza. A little dark in the building but food was excellent. Great breadsticks and sauce.

Delicious pizza. Maybe the best I've ever had. For 2 of us I ordered a 10" pizza and it was just the right size. Sausage, pepperoni, green pepper, onion & mushroom. Took about 20 minutes to cook. While we waited we enjoyed a couple tap beers. I recommend ordering beer by the pitcher even if there are just 2 in your party, because it is a much better deal. read more

I grew up on the pizza with pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms and have since tried many other topping combinations. All good! When I crave a pizza or when I was living out of town for a few yeas I always think of Barnaby's first. read more

The pizza was good, but, but we weren't a fan of the atmosphere and the number calling for food being ready. It was hard to have a conversation. Beer we were served was very old. And 2 Employees bussing the tables were complaining beside us while clearing tables about a coworker or boss. It was very unprofessional. read more

HANDS DOWN BEST PIZZA IN TOWN. It has the old school feel to it. You need 30 bucks for a large pizza with beer!

Awesome Pizza! I have not ate inside but I have ordered delivery a number of times. They have never gotten the order wrong and the order is always ready on time. I love the pizza crust and the toppings are always tasty. Awesome place. read more

Absolutely, hands down, my favorite pizza in South Bend. It's bar style (thin and cut into squares), cheesy, and delicious. The other food there isn't the awesome, but the fries, breadsitcks, and garlic bread are all great to accompany the pizza. Beer is cheap and they often have a few craft brews on tap. It's a fun place to take large groups. I cannot emphasize enough how great the pizza is here. read more

My Mom, Dad, sister & brother recently went here & were very disappointed. Pizza was NOT good. Too thick, way too much cheese, etc. My Mom got sick on it. This is no where near the taste of original Barnaby's from Park Forest, IL. I suggest if you want to taste something closer to the original, make the trip to the Barnaby's in Elmhurst, IL. read more

The pizza is always excellent, and the staff was friendly. No better place in South Bend for pizza.

Love, love, love this pizza!!!!!! The crunchy crust, bubbly cheese, and generous toppings make Barnaby's a lifetime favorite,

Sweet potato fries were a huge disappointment! Very burnt and cold. Loaded fries should just he called cheese and bacon fries. Pizza was ok, not great. Delivery girl was super friendly but we won't be ordering again... read more

Barnaby's - BURNT sweet potato fires, very disappointed. - Pizza Near Me - South Bend, Indiana

Let me just say, this location is a lot better than the other one. Better quality, friendlier staff and cleaner atmosphere. My family took me to Barnaby's as a kid and I always keep coming back. The food is excellent and the way the cut the pizza makes it to where if you don't like the outer crust chances are you won't get the other crust. read more

I like this place but I haven't been there in awhile because I really have to be craving their food. It's sometimes just easier and more convenient to get pizza from Pizza Hut. They do have more than just pizza which is another reason why I like this place. read more

Always a great taste! The front cashier has a bit of an attitude, but you get over her as soon as you eat their yummy pizza

Unacceptable service today, but I'm giving a 2 because the food was good, even though the pizza was barely warm. Called in a carry out order, was told it would be ready at 8:45. Arrived at 8:44, paid and was given our two pizzas, but told the breadsticks and garlic bread would be "a couple of minutes". After waiting ten minutes I went up to the counter and was told they're about to start the order. I then spoke with a manager and he said they're making it now and it would only be a few minutes. At 9:05, 20 minutes after I received my pizzas (still no garlic bread and breadsticks) I went back up to the manager and asked how he feels an apology is acceptable for waiting on sides for twenty minutes. He apologized again, said "we're doing the best we can". Not once was I offered a pop while I waited, a coupon for next time, an extra order of sticks, fresh pizzas...nothing. If the employees had been honest with me from the beginning, and told me it would be another 20 minutes before my sides were ready, rather than lying about the "few minutes", I would have simply cancelled the order of garlic bread and breadsticks and left happily with my pizzas. Very disappointed in the way management handled it. In the end after I had to speak with him twice, he refunded me a whole $4. $4 for an extra 20 minute wait and nearly cold pizza. read more

Barnabys on Jefferson has the best pizza in South Bend. Do not be confused..Grape Rd in Mishawaka is not the same.

My favoritte pizza place. I love the chewy thin crust and the really balanced sauce. This is a must visit when I come home.