As classic New York City as it gets…read more
Despite having lived in NYC, I never made it here to see & hear Woody Allen play horn. I've always lamented that. So when we were planning our most recent trip back to the Big Apple, I serendipitously discovered that Tony Danza was going to be performing. I'm a lot of things, but a person that's going to pass on the opportunity to see Tony Micelli live is not one of them.
Tony Micelli!!!
The show was called "Sinatra & Stories." Hubs supported my enthusiasm & excitement. He's a very wise man. Cause even if he hadn't, I might have gone by myself!
Kidding, not kidding.
The Cafe Carlyle is a supper club, & for performances there are rules. One, if you book a show, you are required to reserve dinner as well, which of course is a separate fee. Two, there's a dress code. Men are required to be in a suit, blazer, or sports coat, & women "a cocktail dress, elegant skirt, or dress pants are recommended." Done & done.
The space.
It's intimate & elegant, but not at all pretentious. The murals, the bar, there's a lot of history here.
Dinner.
I ordered a "Jackie-O" cocktail, because, Jackie-O. I just had to.
We both ordered the steak for dinner. I wasn't expecting anything more than mediocre food as per the previous reviews. And that was ok; I'm here for the show, dinner was secondary. But, surprisingly, our meal was better than mediocre. We sincerely enjoyed everything. Service was professional yet easygoing; & that was very much appreciated. Nothing can sour an experience faster than pretentious service. Our waiter even (politely) laughed when, after perusing the dessert menu, I opted for a glass of Pinot Noir instead. When he brought the wine & I told him "this is my dessert," he smiled & nodded in amusement.
The show.
Tony was fabulous. He sang. He told stories about NY, his mom, & of course Frank Sinatra. He succeeded in captivating us for an hour & a half.
We had booked this well over a month in advance, & we were given a great table. But, the best table (right next to ours)...we were told it was reserved for regulars. Fair enough. But the "regulars" (a mother & daughter just out of high school) not only got the waiter's birthday completely wrong, which was pretty hilarious, but they were both wearing jeans as well. So, not really regulars, & not dressed to code.
FYI, we flew in from San Francisco, we're dressed appropriately, & had I been privy of your birthday, I wouldn't have gotten it so wrong. Just sayin.
Dinner & a show, for the 2 of us, was $1000. Worth it.
4 stars.