Everything about this place felt cool and effortlessly vibey. The staff was friendly, stylish, and genuinely great to chat with. I also loved that the artwork on the plates is a tribute to the owners' family--it was such a thoughtful, personal touch. This feels more like a cocktail bar that happens to serve great food, and I mean that in the best way. Every cocktail was expertly crafted and unique. The standouts were the Limoncello Milk Punch (my favorite!), the Mela Tini, and The Bialetti. The food was excellent, too. The Smashed Meatball Parm was a clever twist on the classic sandwich. The grilled romaine salad was next level, with crispy pancetta adding salty little bites of joy. The grilled wings weren't especially meaty, but they more than made up for it with their smoky, flavorful seasoning. Overall, I really enjoyed this spot. It's the kind of place that's perfect for starting the night with drinks and bites or ending the evening with one last great cocktail. read more

See all

Review I'm truly so confused why this spot has so many positive reviews. As a bar that is known for their cocktails, they definitely do not deserve to be in the top 50. Maybe Sunday is not the best night to go for the first time? The two stars are for some of the food and service, as Matt was a dream, but if you're looking for mind-blowingly-delicious cocktails and yummy Italian fare, go elsewhere. Felt like the bartender was in a bad mood and taking it out on the drinks, as anything that was built was over-shaken and flavorless. Everything tasted like watered down booze and the food seemed like an after thought. Puttanesca Martini, was the cocktail I was really looking forward to. Did not get all the flavours they tried to achieve, just tasted like tomato water. Was sincerely disappointing. Don Fanucci should've been an interesting take on a manhattan, but was definitely shaken, not stirred, and tasted like watery bourbon. No hints of thyme or apricot, even think the olive oil was forgotten. Was the least favourite and most undrinkable of the night. Sardinian Nights sounded refreshingly delightful, was excited for the plum and pandan flavours, but again just tasted like a lot of soda with a splash of rye. Beet Busdown actually had some flavour, didn't get any of the beet or balsamic, but was at least drinkable. Gemma's Sauce and the Limoncello Milk Punch were the best of the night, but I'm sure both were batched and 3 oz poured over ice, so saved from being over-done/over-shaken. Was also bummed to not try the Arancino, they were out and didn't have them available until the next day, so we opted for the Ossobuco Croquettes, don't. The charred cipollini was the best part of the dish, the pesto trapanese extremely needed for the VERY dry croquettes. The Grilled Baby Romaine and the Rigatoni all' Amatriciana were the highlights of the night, food-wise, but that's not saying much. I was really looking forward to trying this spot but overall was just too expensive for what it was. Can get much better cocktails and Italian fare elsewhere. read more

Came for cocktails on a Friday night. 4 of us couldn't get a table (1 hour wait) but found some standing room by the bar. My dry vodka martini was SO good! I also ordered an espresso martini and asked for it to not be sweet, it was made perfectly. Great bartenders and vibe. Will come back for drinks! read more

Came here for a nightcap. The vibes were good, with a good mix of people who seemed like they were on a date, friends having an night out, or people winding down, but it was good fit for all these groups. Tried their Gemma's sauce which I really enjoyed. The service was attentive and friendly. He made sure our waters were refilled and we were happy with what we had. Overall, a great spot in the area. read more

Bar Madonna - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

A great addition to the Brooklyn bar scene! Bar Madonna offers so many elevated, delicious cocktails that it's hard to choose. The Nonna's Half & Half, Beet Bussdown, and Gemma's Sauce are just a few of our favorites. And they were just ranked No. 36 bar in the world by 50 Best Bars!! So well deserved! A perfect spot for a cozy date night or fun outing with friends. Great service and a fun, lively environment. read more

See all

Cute spot. We enjoy the cocktail a lot and the menu is very creative. Had some appetizer bites felt short. Osso Buco Croquettes $20 very meaty, the sauce base was straight kabocha. Fried Artichoke $20 for 3 slices. read more

See all

Been sitting on this review for awhile; but dang Bar Madonna was one of the best experiences I had in my recent trip to NYC. I had been seeing this smashed meatball parm burger and knew she would be perfect for me. She was. A light, soft bun beautifully caressed smashed meatball perfection. With the salty Parmesan crisp adding texture and some saltiness. The rich, marinara was seasoned to perfection with just a touch of sweetness to make the acidity in the tomato pop. Do not get me started on the fries. Garlic parm. Crispy. Oh lawd, they remind me of my favorite restaurant back home in stl. The vibes are delicate, in the sexiest way possible. Come here share an intimate celebration with your partner, or come catch up with a friend and drink 1 too many martinis. Either way, you'll receive unparalleled service. The bar tenders are slinging drinks mixed with liquor, camaraderie, and passionate smiles. What an absolute experience. This is added to the "special places in my heart" list read more

See all

Stopped by happy hour and loved their oysters! The oysters came with a pickled sauce and I was surprised by how well the combo worked because I've always had oysters with either cocktail or mignonette. Also tried their limoncello milk punch which was very good! read more

Bar Madonna - Menu - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

An amazing place to grab a drink before heading out to dinner in the neighborhood! The Apollonia with the fresh-made prickly pear cordial.... mindblowing! read more

Good date spot vibes with the lighting and nice interiors, but the music is pretty loud. Our waiter was kind and always checked in on us, so the service was great. Every item we got was VERY salty minus the Ossobuco Croquettes, which had a sauce that was really good! My friends tried the Limoncello Milk Punch and the Apollonia which they both thought were good. Would come back for the drinks, since that's what they're known for, but would definitely not order food again if it's that salty. read more

See all

Ambience is cozy & dim w 90s r&b/hiphop creating a warm vibe Our waiter Zach was super attentive and helpful! Drinks: Limoncello Milk Punch & Old Fashioned, both were strong and hit the spot Food: Brussel Sprouts & Housemade garlic truffle fries I'm a Brussel sprout lover and I will say they are on the salty side but so addictive. Fries were great! read more

See all

We just went for cocktails and oysters and had a great time! Tried 6 different cocktails here and a fruity shot and everything tasted great! This is a fun place to do a little happy hour/pre-dinner drinks. We also shared the oysters, which were fresh and great. The bartenders were so kind and easy to talk to. I had a great experience here! The place is a bit small, but clean and comfortable. read more

See all

Have been wanting to check this place out and so glad we came! We stopped by on a Wednesday around 6pm and got a seat at the bar. The bar tender was super friendly and walked us through the menu and gave great recs on what to order. We had two really interesting/delicious cocktails, some happy hour oysters ($9 for 6 and had a great sort of seasoning on top), and of course the meatball parm sandwich which came with fries and one of the bar tenders brought us over truffle aioli for them and wow it made a huge difference and was excellent. Def recommend and will be back! read more

See all

Reviewing mainly on the food. Tried both sandwiches, very tomato forward. Marinara sauce on the smashed parm was a tad too tart - texture of the patty was good. As for the chicken sandwich, chicken breast was too dry - didn't think the roasted tomato paired well. Entire restaurant also just smells like tart cooked tomatoes if that's your cup of tea ‍ Innovative burger, just not for me. read more

Bar Madonna - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I wouldn't have known about Bar Madonna had a friend not told me about his recent visit there, and I'm glad he did. What a gem! I was able to make a last-minute reservation for 2 on an early Friday evening. On the exterior, it's an assuming building with a small sign letting you know you've come to the right place. The interior - sleek and sexy! A perfect venue for a date night, or a cute ladies night out gathering. We were quickly greeted by the host who provided us with several options for seating. We were 2 of 5 people there at the time and chose a small booth table near the front of the restaurant. I'd strongly recommend reservations. There are about a dozen 2-seater tables and the spot quickly filled up shortly after our arrival. The menu features a small handful of options, mostly small bites, but there are enough options to satisfy various palates and preferences. We opted for the arancini (special of the day) and the smashed meatball parm which we shared. The arancini was good though one of the cheeses they included was a little too pungent. The meatball smash was absolutely all delicious and didn't feel too heavy. I'd highly recommend the banana bussdown cocktail. Very dainty, well balanced and packed a punch. Service was excellent; from the host to the bar and wait staff. They were all attentive, friendly and accommodating. I absolutely loved the vibes; and that hip-hop and R&B playlist was sublime. Kudos to the curator! Made me wish there was more room to do a little two- step. It's a fairly new spot, so hoping they're around for a long time to come. read more

See all

Some of the better bar food in the area. Good ambiance for drinks and service was fast/friendly. Would come back for the chicken sandwich. The fries needed just a tad more crisp/salt. read more

See all

I raved about this place the first time around but this time was a total flop. Our main dish was missing for the better part of an hour, and every time we asked about it, they said it would only be a few more minutes. The smashed meatball parm sandwich was missing a lot of sauce and tomato flavor, and the Caesar salad was incredibly underdressed. It was also so loud the server couldn't hear us without shouting, and having a conversation was a mission. Wouldn't come back after this experience read more

See all

This is a great spot with a great vibe. Highly recommend checking it out if you're in the area, delicious food & cocktails read more

See all

My 2nd time here and I don't even live in NY Great service + vibes and that orange wine they have knocked my socks off. Love to drink and bill, good eh not so much but I only tried the chicken sandwich - needs more seasoning in the breading IMO. read more

Incredible food and drinks! The Meatball Parm Burger is to die for and the Apple Martini is a must-try. Great vibes and awesome service!

Solid meal with good service! Restaurant was a vibe and had great music playing. Favorite was the smashed meatball parm -- MUST get this!! Steak with fries was good as well but overly salty. And unfortunately I wasn't a big fan of the caesar salad. read more

See all

Bar Madonna is gorgeous and the vibes are spectacular. The drinks are strong and delicious. The staff is kind, beautiful and perfectly Brooklyn. But the food is not there yet. We came in for date night dinner and shared the fluke crudo, grilled baby romaine, octopus and the smashed meatball parm. The smashed meatball parm was great but everything else left more to be desired. To be blantly honest, the octopus should be avoided, it was salty and the presentation kind of gross. We love octopus and it's a must order for us when we see it on the menu so it was sad that it was such a miss for us. Look, we will be back for drinks at the bar and to stare at the pretty people but it might be some time before we are back for a full meal. read more

Bar Madonna - Gemma's Sauce and Fluke Crudo - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Bar Madonna feels like a piece of the Garden District in Nola broke off and started to grow in Montrose. Think untried elegance with delicious libations. This is a cocktail & wine-forward spot. Focus there. The service is un intruding and prompt. The courtyard is opulently cool. Enjoy! read more

Loved this place. Came for happy hour quick food and drinks. Delicious. Loved the artichoke app and the fries. Old fashion was spot on and service was on top of it. Atmosphere is moody and romantic. Will be back! read more

Bar Madonna - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Love the chill vibes of this place!! And the drink the bartender made for me on the spot with just a small recommendation was sooooo tasty!!!! Literally perfect spot for after work!! read more

Bar Madonna - I had to remember which whiskey the bartender used! So good!! - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Delicious appletini cocktail and small bites to share. Great spot to start the night!

WOW!! What an absolutely fantastic experience. Sitting at the bar, we had dinner and a show as we watched Rob and Ricky show off their bartending finesse. Started with some oysters, no hot sauce or mignonette but tbh didn't need it. Juicy Oxtail croquettes to follow. Meatball smash sandwiches, which were the mention in Infatuation that caught my eye (a tiny bit dry on first bite, but it's because I'm a red sauce ADDICT and my partner debated that I'm delusional). Straccietalla which made the PERFECT dessert but of course we needed the cannolis to follow. The cannoli shells were so fresh and crunchy. You can't go wrong with a single cocktail here and I foresee them being booked out VERY soon. This was their first Sunday open and quickly a neighborhood favorite. Also their dishes are adorable and apparently hold stories as well (pics of the owner, owner and partner, etc). Perfection to the most minute detail. read more

This place is a winner for the following reasons: 1. The menu is small enough to hold yoiur focus and not be exhausting. Everything I've tried, from the sandwiches to the smaller plates, has been delicious. The cocktails are all superb. 2. The hunter green loungey interior invites one to linger. It is handsome and staid, dreamy and lush. 3. The staff are fantastic. The hostess on every occaison has been sweet and accommodating and while the servers seem very busy, you never feel you're not a priority. They are friendly and super-focused. The vibe is playful, festive, with a welcome streak of good humor. The second I finished a drink of water, the glass was re-filled. I like that this place is brand new but knows what it's doing. It is obviously from a very experienced team, and the team is good at what they do. I feel like I keep going to places lately that are buzzy and new but the funding came from *somewhere* and everything feels dizzy, even inept. Not so with Bar Madonna, there isn't a second where I didn't feel like I was in good hands, on every visit. Highly recommended. read more

I cannot recommend Bar Madonna enough! It was an incredible dining experience from start to finish. The cocktails were so unique and tasty that my party tried almost every drink on the menu. The Limoncello Milk Punch, the Apollonia, and the Zia's Lychee Martini were our 3 favorites. The Grilled Baby Romaine is a must; it's their take on a Caesar salad. If you like spice, you must try the Calabrese Hot Wings. The Smashed Meatball Parm melts in your mouth and the Strip Steak was perfectly cooked! The ambiance is cozy, the staff is approachable, and a DJ came out late night and played all the hits. I will be returning very soon! read more

Bar Madonna - The Apollonia cocktail - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Incredible spot. The smashed meatball sandwich was amazing. Immaculate vibes, great drinks, excellent staff. Highly recommend read more

Bar Madonna - Outside - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Perfect date night spot with amazing food, great wait staff, and phenomenal drinks. Pictured is the arancini with vodka sauce, 10/10. Also pictured is the smashed meatball sandwich, 100/10. Can't wait to come back and try more of this amazing menu. read more

Bar Madonna - Smashed Meatball Parm - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Croquettes Lacks flavor in the filling, the verde sauce was lethal in terms of parsley, I can still taste it, and the marmalade was unbearably bitter Wings No flavor other than burnt charcoal, vile Parm burger Salty meatball sub, a for effort Chicken sandwhich VILE, Soggy, dry The kitchen needs a new team. This place was gross, I'd say there's room for improvement but I doubt management would bother to make a change that LARGE. read more

One of my favorite new bars in Brooklyn. Amazing cocktails, bites, and ambience. Service was impeccable. They have DJs on the weekends which brings the vibes to a new level. Ask for Ricky at the bar! One of the best drinkslingers in the business read more

Bar Madonna - Wings - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We recently ate at Bar Madonna and we were really blown away by the food and service! We loved the smashed meatball Parmesan and the Lamb Chops. The Caesar Salad was spot on and very flavorful. On top of that the drinks were excellent. We will be back and will bring friends. read more

The Godfather doesn't normally give a review for a place that is not on my collections list. My daughter went for a visit and said I would be impressed, snazzy interior, Kid Super artwork, great bartenders, and food that won't give you agita. Maybe we can move the captains meeting there. Can't wait to visit myself. read more

this place was incredible from start to finish. our server Aaron was amazing and the owner Eric helped us so much choosing out the best dishes and cocktails!! you MUST get the oxtail croquettes and then meatball parm. unlike anything i've ever eaten in NY get the cannolis to finish. 10/10 ambiance!! read more

Bar Madonna - Cannolis - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

by far my absolute favorite space. I had a birthday party here and was blown away by the courtesy, hospitality, incredible service by all the wait staff and bartenders. Everyone went above and beyond to make sure everyone was taken care of. Absolutely incredible vibe, music, drinks, food. Couldn't possibly recommend more. read more

Always consistent!!! The service is amazing and the food and drinks are always off the chart delicious. Love going back!

incredible new spot! highly recommend the Calabrian wings. Great atmosphere and staff

very good for drinks but the food was only so so. we got the parm sandwich honey wings and croquettes. definitely a good date spot though it's super cute inside read more

Bar Madonna - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York