Cancel

Open app

Search

Bar Madonna

4.4 (43 reviews)
Closed • 3:00 pm - 2:00 am (Next day)
Updated 1 month ago

Bar Madonna Photos

Business Info

BAR MADONNA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Bar Madonna

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Kenneth E.

Came here for a nightcap. The vibes were good, with a good mix of people who seemed like they were on a date, friends having an night out, or people winding down, but it was good fit for all these groups. Tried their Gemma's sauce which I really enjoyed. The service was attentive and friendly. He made sure our waters were refilled and we were happy with what we had. Overall, a great spot in the area.

Interior
Ann S.

A great addition to the Brooklyn bar scene! Bar Madonna offers so many elevated, delicious cocktails that it's hard to choose. The Nonna's Half & Half, Beet Bussdown, and Gemma's Sauce are just a few of our favorites. And they were just ranked No. 36 bar in the world by 50 Best Bars!! So well deserved! A perfect spot for a cozy date night or fun outing with friends. Great service and a fun, lively environment.

Wendy B.

Cute spot. We enjoy the cocktail a lot and the menu is very creative. Had some appetizer bites felt short. Osso Buco Croquettes $20 very meaty, the sauce base was straight kabocha. Fried Artichoke $20 for 3 slices.

Fries, smashed meatball parm
Austin S.

Been sitting on this review for awhile; but dang Bar Madonna was one of the best experiences I had in my recent trip to NYC. I had been seeing this smashed meatball parm burger and knew she would be perfect for me. She was. A light, soft bun beautifully caressed smashed meatball perfection. With the salty Parmesan crisp adding texture and some saltiness. The rich, marinara was seasoned to perfection with just a touch of sweetness to make the acidity in the tomato pop. Do not get me started on the fries. Garlic parm. Crispy. Oh lawd, they remind me of my favorite restaurant back home in stl. The vibes are delicate, in the sexiest way possible. Come here share an intimate celebration with your partner, or come catch up with a friend and drink 1 too many martinis. Either way, you'll receive unparalleled service. The bar tenders are slinging drinks mixed with liquor, camaraderie, and passionate smiles. What an absolute experience. This is added to the "special places in my heart" list

Menu
Sara H.

Stopped by happy hour and loved their oysters! The oysters came with a pickled sauce and I was surprised by how well the combo worked because I've always had oysters with either cocktail or mignonette. Also tried their limoncello milk punch which was very good!

Smashed Meatball Parm Sandwich
Caitlyn F.

Good date spot vibes with the lighting and nice interiors, but the music is pretty loud. Our waiter was kind and always checked in on us, so the service was great. Every item we got was VERY salty minus the Ossobuco Croquettes, which had a sauce that was really good! My friends tried the Limoncello Milk Punch and the Apollonia which they both thought were good. Would come back for the drinks, since that's what they're known for, but would definitely not order food again if it's that salty.

Brussel sprouts & housemade garlic fries
Iyanla M.

Ambience is cozy & dim w 90s r&b/hiphop creating a warm vibe Our waiter Zach was super attentive and helpful! Drinks: Limoncello Milk Punch & Old Fashioned, both were strong and hit the spot Food: Brussel Sprouts & Housemade garlic truffle fries I'm a Brussel sprout lover and I will say they are on the salty side but so addictive. Fries were great!

Oysters
Tristen S.

We just went for cocktails and oysters and had a great time! Tried 6 different cocktails here and a fruity shot and everything tasted great! This is a fun place to do a little happy hour/pre-dinner drinks. We also shared the oysters, which were fresh and great. The bartenders were so kind and easy to talk to. I had a great experience here! The place is a bit small, but clean and comfortable.

Great drinks!
Claire L.

Have been wanting to check this place out and so glad we came! We stopped by on a Wednesday around 6pm and got a seat at the bar. The bar tender was super friendly and walked us through the menu and gave great recs on what to order. We had two really interesting/delicious cocktails, some happy hour oysters ($9 for 6 and had a great sort of seasoning on top), and of course the meatball parm sandwich which came with fries and one of the bar tenders brought us over truffle aioli for them and wow it made a huge difference and was excellent. Def recommend and will be back!

Christopher T.

Reviewing mainly on the food. Tried both sandwiches, very tomato forward. Marinara sauce on the smashed parm was a tad too tart - texture of the patty was good. As for the chicken sandwich, chicken breast was too dry - didn't think the roasted tomato paired well. Entire restaurant also just smells like tart cooked tomatoes if that's your cup of tea ‍ Innovative burger, just not for me.

Cynthia L.

Some of the better bar food in the area. Good ambiance for drinks and service was fast/friendly. Would come back for the chicken sandwich. The fries needed just a tad more crisp/salt.

Octopus alla griglia
Allison C.

I raved about this place the first time around but this time was a total flop. Our main dish was missing for the better part of an hour, and every time we asked about it, they said it would only be a few more minutes. The smashed meatball parm sandwich was missing a lot of sauce and tomato flavor, and the Caesar salad was incredibly underdressed. It was also so loud the server couldn't hear us without shouting, and having a conversation was a mission. Wouldn't come back after this experience

Banana Bussdown Cocktail
LaToya Y.

I wouldn't have known about Bar Madonna had a friend not told me about his recent visit there, and I'm glad he did. What a gem! I was able to make a last-minute reservation for 2 on an early Friday evening. On the exterior, it's an assuming building with a small sign letting you know you've come to the right place. The interior - sleek and sexy! A perfect venue for a date night, or a cute ladies night out gathering. We were quickly greeted by the host who provided us with several options for seating. We were 2 of 5 people there at the time and chose a small booth table near the front of the restaurant. I'd strongly recommend reservations. There are about a dozen 2-seater tables and the spot quickly filled up shortly after our arrival. The menu features a small handful of options, mostly small bites, but there are enough options to satisfy various palates and preferences. We opted for the arancini (special of the day) and the smashed meatball parm which we shared. The arancini was good though one of the cheeses they included was a little too pungent. The meatball smash was absolutely all delicious and didn't feel too heavy. I'd highly recommend the banana bussdown cocktail. Very dainty, well balanced and packed a punch. Service was excellent; from the host to the bar and wait staff. They were all attentive, friendly and accommodating. I absolutely loved the vibes; and that hip-hop and R&B playlist was sublime. Kudos to the curator! Made me wish there was more room to do a little two- step. It's a fairly new spot, so hoping they're around for a long time to come.

Bar area

See all

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Bar Madonna

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Cocktail Bars 21,017 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Tora

Tora

4.5(69 reviews)
2.1 mi•Bushwick

I'm so happy that this restaurant is just a 2 min walk from my apartment. The food here is amazing…read moreand the ambiance is nice and peaceful. Food and alcohol is fairly priced and food is flavorful/well seasoned which is hard to find in a Japanese restaurant. The service is quick and food didn't take a while to come out. We ordered shishito peppers, corn ribs, beef sukiyaki, pork belly wrapped enoki mushrooms, and Miyazaki a5 Wagyu hot stone grill. * Shishito peppers 5/5 My favorite out of everything we ordered. It's a MUST TRY! The sauce it's in has yuzu so it's nice, savory, a lil sweet, a lil sour, and a little citrusy - it's perfect for my tastebuds. Literally could not get over how good the sauce was. It also tasted good to dip the corn ribs in that sauce!! * Corn ribs 5/5 Grilled corn ribs with seasoning and cheese, super simple but super tasty. Can never go wrong with corn ribs! * Beef Sukiyaki 5/5 Nice and flavorful broth, the meat is tender, there's also a knot of clear noodles at the bottom of the bowl. * Pork Belly Wrapped enoki 5/5 GOOD. Who doesn't love pork belly AND mushrooms (only crazy people) ?! Amazing flavor, nice and smokey, with crunchy enoki mushrooms * Miyazaki A5 Wagyu 5/5 Good, nice to order once just to try since it is a little on the pricier side bc it's A5 Wagyu, personally I'd rather go to an A5 Wagyu restaurant if I want A5 Wagyu. Nonetheless, it was nice to try! This was enough food to share between my sister and I, without feeling overly full and bloated. Definitely will be coming back regularly since it's so close to home.

I'm going to give Tora some extra points because it's SO hard to find good asian food in this area…read moreof Brooklyn. Tora I think is a true jack of all trades, while many restaurants try to excel in one area I think Tora does amazing at multiple. It's good for sushi, ramen, noodles, etc. Just an overall really well-rounded japanese spot. I think their serving sizes are also very good. Though I'll say I don't think Tora particularly excels in one thing it's not going to be the best ramen or sushi you've had in your life but, for something that's close? Affordable? Has no line? It's definitely the best. Very above average in every regard. Haven't eaten here in person so can't speak on their service but at least their food? Great get pick-up/delivery all the time

Photos
Tora - Dining Area

Dining Area

Tora - Salmon Don

Salmon Don

Tora - Zaru Soba Chashudon Katsu Curry

See all

Zaru Soba Chashudon Katsu Curry

Bar Madonna - cocktailbars - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...