This may be our new go-to bagel shop when we're in the mood for a bagel for breakfast! You can BYOB (Build Your Own Bagel) with a variety of bagels and spreads. There are a few unique bagels such as rosemary sea salt and onion garlic and various spreads such as fig and five pepper cream cheeses. There are also a few cold and hot sandwich options such as lox, pastrami swiss (get it on an everything bagel), and BLT. There are also plenty of different drinks in the fridge (different brands of cold brew, juices, etc) along with hot coffee and teas. Service is friendly and there's plentiful seating inside if you choose to dine in. They also have online ordering for convenience as well. read more

Bagel Joy - Pastrami Swiss - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

I've been here twice now and had consistent and great experiences! The service is quick and they even offer an option to pay cash and you get a 5% discount. Additionally, they have accept monetary donations that allows them to give out free meals for those that need it. If someone is in hard times, they can do to the wall and grab a "coupon/ticket" for a free bagel with spread and a coffee. It's incredibly kind and generous system they have for those in need in our community! The food is SO delicious! I have gotten the Lox on an Asiago Bagel twice and they were very consistent with the lox toppings. Weekends are quite busy so expect a wait time but during the week, you can be out in and out quick. Highly recommend! read more

Bagel Joy - Lox on Asiago bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Ordered online for pickup, since I heard such great things. I ordered the egg, cheese, and Taylor Ham (pork roll) on an Everything Bagel. It did not disappoint. Nice hearty, full sized bagel with great Everything seasoning. Could have used a bit more pork roll but that's the only area of improvement. Best NJ bagel and/or bagel breakfast sandwich equivalent I've found here in the area. Definitely will return!! read more

Bagel Joy - Egg, Cheese, Pork Roll on Everything bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Thank you to Bagel Joy for catering a last minute play date for me! I placed my order through Door Dash and less than twenty minutes later, I had a paper bag of piping hot bagels at my door. The bagels had a nice crust with a chew that was not too hard and not too soft. The everthing bagel was a favorite but the rosemary salt was just enough different to make me pause with enjoyment. The accompanying cream cheese was delicious and we I over ordered per usual so all the leftover bagels made a great breakfast the following days afterwards. I would not hesitate to order again. read more

I stopped by to pick up a dozen bagels, and overall, it was a solid experience. I believe this place started as a farmers market vendor and has now grown into a storefront. The moment you walk in, you're greeted by the amazing smell of fresh bread baking. There's a decent amount of seating if you want to sit down for a quick bite. They offer a variety of bagels, though not a huge selection. Everything I tried tasted pretty good. I didn't get a chance to try one of their breakfast sandwiches, but I'll definitely be back for that. If you're in the mood for a bagel, this is a solid choice. read more

See all

The bagels and the staff at this shop are amazing. The place has plenty seating, nice to eat in, but I ordered to go. First, my breakfast sandwich was made with love; and if you visit this place you will see why. The staff appears to be a family of mainly women. You will see them working effortlessly at their respective task. Not rushed, but purposely. I did not see the yellow packs of Splenda so I asked the cashier. She said if they had them they would be in the condiments area which I already searched; and she didn't stop there. When she got a break from customers, she went and got them for me. They were in green packaging that I overlooked. I really appreciated her service. read more

Bagel Joy - A card - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Got around to going to this place and there was a line but there was a digital kiosk. They have this cool thing where they pull a card when you buy something and if it is the same card it is free and you can collect them. I got a everything bagel with cream cheese. The amount of cream cheese was acceptable and the bagel itself was not bad. I would say they are better than Brooklyn bagels in Arlington. I would go again for a bagel. read more

I feel bad but I'm gonna be 100% honest... $4.50 is ridiculous for a bagel with LIGHT butter. Really no way by looking at the menu of knowing butter would cost $2 extra. Absolutely soaked in butter. No longer crispy because it was soggy from butter.. I was going to treat myself with a churro cinnamon bagel. They need to stop calling it that, unfortunately it was quite tasteless. Took a few bites and tossed it... disappointing. 1 star food but they were very nice. read more

Bagel Joy - "Light" butter. Turns out it's $2 extra. Soggy from the amount of butter - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

When I pulled up to Bagel Joy - I was thinking I've been here before... Bagel Joy occupies the physical space that used to house another bagel business. A bagel joint called "Bagel Buddies" used to occupy this space. Apparently the old owners sold the place - and the new owners re-branded. I ordered the Lox on a Rosemary-Sea Salt bagel - toasted. And a bottle of water. My order came up fairly quickly. I noted in the menu description that the menu item included fresh dill - which excited me. Most every place in the area where I've ordered a Lox & Bagel - does not include fresh dill. Fresh dill really makes a Lox & Bagel pop. Lox & Bagel was damn tasty! Service was good. Paid with Apple Pay. #BagelJoy read more

See all

I was excited to try this new bagel place. My takeaways are that: -Staff was friendly and warm. -The place was busy and we had to wait around 10-15 minutes for our order. -The prices are pretty steep for the amount you get. -Flavors were good but nothing spectacular. read more

Bagel Joy - Turkey, Bacon, Ranch - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

TL;DR: solid bagels and good sandwiches (hit or miss) Came here on a Saturday morning and there was a decent line, but it moves quickly. The setup is great, staff is cleaning as tables come in and out, and the cashier is nice and informative. It is cutely decorated inside, and there is seating indoor and outside. FOOD: ~Bagel itself was flavorful and had a nice chew to it ~Sausage egg and cheese (5/5) on an onion bagel (5/5): Sausage they use is so good. Egg was cooked well and cheese was nicely melted. Onion bagel was tasty too ~Pastrami Swiss (2.8/5) on everything bagel (5/5): Unfortunately, was not a fan of this sandwich. The pastrami was almost rubbery, and the mustard was a little overpowering. I definitely want to come back here to try some of their bagels with a spread. read more

See all

A local bagel shop has received excellent reviews, prompting me to visit with high expectations for a good bagel. Upon entering, we were greeted with prompt and attentive service. We decided to try their seasonal offering, the apple cinnamon bagel, along with fig cream cheese and their specialty breakfast bagel. The apple cinnamon bagel featured small apple pieces and a generous layer of cream cheese, though the overall flavor was rather subtle, lacking a strong presence of either apple cinnamon or fig. On the other hand, Butcher's Egg bagel was quite flavorful. However, the bagel itself was somewhat average, which was a minor drawback. The shop also provides spreads that appeal to children, such as peanut butter, in addition to their cream cheese options. They offer unique cream cheese flavors, including five pepper, fig, and Kalamata olive. I wanted to give another try for better experience. read more

Bagel Joy - Butcher's Egg on everything bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

I feel bad to leave a 3 star review for a business that has been through so much but I do want to be honest. I was excited to come in today to try them and support their business since they are finally able to open. I do understand they are new but it was only our family and one other person in the shop at the time we went this morning around 8:40. It took a very long time to get our full order. And they were fully staffed. The food was just not good quality. The bagels just did not taste the best and we've tried many bagel places in the area. We were not impressed. Inside was nice and clean and they had very friendly customer service. I would probably go back if we are in a hurry and need to pick up quick breakfast for the kids. read more

Bagel Joy - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

My first visit to the new bagel place at Fair Lakes. The staff were very friendly and helpful. The dough of the bagels was tasty with a good texture. I really enjoyed the bagel sandwich I ordered. The two things I didn't like so much: 1) the Asiago bagel seemed like it was just a plain bagel with some shredded cheese thrown on top at the last minute. The cheese was barely melted and didn't add much of anything to the taste of the bagel. 2) I got a container of strawberry cream cheese to go. The flavor of this cream cheese was really strange. It tasted quite salty with very little flavor of strawberry. I definitely didn't like it and threw out the rest of the container after that first taste. read more

Bagel Joy - Asiago Bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

ough Bagel Joy had to delay their grand opening due to an unfortunate event (you probably saw it on the news, even), they have finally opened. Bagel Joy is known for offering their fresh bagels at farmers markets in the area, and now they have a brick and mortar location. I came during their first day to check them out. I tried a few different things: - Sausage, Egg, and Cheese Bagel on Rosemary Sea Salt bagel - Butcher's Bagel (on an onion bagel) - Everything Bagel with Fig Cream Cheese The fig cream cheese wasn't too sweet that you couldn't taste the cream cheese which was a nice balance. The bagel was also loaded with the cream cheese! Everything here was super fresh -- you could see the bagels in the kitchen being freshly boiled and baked. Everyone was also so nice -- from the person who took the order to picking it up. You could really taste the quality of these bagels. I definitely recommend stopping by Bagel Joy! read more

See all

I bought my first bagel from these guys when they took orders on Facebook and delivered near a shopping mall by my house out of their trunk. I'm impressed with how they went from that to a brick and mortar. Their bagels are sourdough and a good size. I love their onion and garlic bagel but have been underwhelmed by their everything bagel. The proportion of sesame seeds to their ingredients is completely off. They have a sesame bagel in the menu so theirs no need to overwhelm the everything with seedYou can't taste anything apart from the sesame. Their cream cheese options are good and I specially like their chive variety. read more

Bagel Joy - Everything bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

I'm writing this review with some genuine disappointment, because the bagels themselves were pretty good. My positive experience ended at the counter as I was charged an additional 50 cents to have my bagel toasted, and when I asked about the charge, the employee explained it was their policy because "they have to slice and put it in the toaster, and that is additional time and labor." This explanation, coupled with the large neon sign right at the entrance that reads "hot, fresh bagels," left me feeling disconnected and frustrated. This isn't about the 50 cents. It's about a small, customer-unfriendly policy that feels like a "nickel and diming" approach. It creates a barrier rather than a welcoming path for a local business to connect with its customers. The feeling of being charged for a basic service, one that seems implied by a sign advertising "hot" bagels, is a turn-off. Ultimately, on principle, I won't be returning. It's a shame, as the quality of the food is very good, but little irritations like this are why I find myself feeling so disconnected from local shops these days. read more

Overall the place was clean and ordering was easy. I wasn't a fan of the bagels themselves and my cinnamon raisin bagel tasted like whatever savory flavor came before me on the toaster however I know that is personal preference :) I wish they had more of a coffee shop presence as their coffee was lacking with a side station of DIY syrups and creamer. The service was quick and kind. read more

Bagel Joy - Cinnamon raisin bagel, plain bagel, and cream cheese, iced latte - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Bagel joy was a great bagel addition we rotate through. There is usually a line on weekends but moves quickly. The amount of cream cheese is a guilty pleasure because it's over an inch thick! read more

Bagel Joy - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Pleasant breakfast experience reasonable close to the hotel we were staying at ( Fairfax Hilton). Bagels are very fresh and our everything bagels had lots of toppings. I had an egg and cheese sandwich and Mrs NMD had a very tasty ( I had a bite) veggie cream cheese spread. They have La Columbe coffee products- our favorite brand. Prices are reasonable. Very friendly staff. Basic, clean store with well detailed descriptions of food options and prices. Tons of free parking as it's in a corner of a large outdoor shopping area. I'm grateful to other Yelpers whose reviews lead us here for breakfast. read more

Overall: 3 stars Average bagel sandwich with a long wait. I may try their bagel and spreads in the future but don't plan on trying their sandwiches. Bit overpriced for the quality/quantity of food. Food Quality: 3 stars Ordered the Lox sandwich on the Salt bagel. The Salt bagel was way too salty (overwhelmed the taste of the whole sandwich). Not as much filling as I was expecting for the price and bagel was average. Not bad but not great. Bit overpriced for the quality/quantity of food. Service/Experience: 3.5 stars The staff was friendly. Plenty of parking in front (part of a shopping complex). No major issues/concerns but did have to wait a bit long for the food. read more

Bagel Joy - Lox - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Ordered two bagels toasted with spread - they came cold, untoasted and stale. The everything bagel tastes like nothing - covered in sesame and poppy seeds but no taste of garlic, onion, and definitely no salt. Just bland and seedy. The Asiago bagel is just a plain bagel with a single slice of "Asiago" cheese that was so cold/hard it fell off the bagel in a single layer before I even bit into it. Again, bland. I might've overlooked the taste if the bagels were worthwhile texture wise, but they were clearly made at least a day prior - and I ordered mid-morning. I also ordered a muffin on the side that was not included in the pickup order. To be fair, the bagels are a generous size and they don't skimp with the cream cheese. But that's all I've got. I hardly ever write reviews but this was just sad for a bagel place. I miss bagel buddies. read more

Obsessed with their rosemary sea salt bagels. I've had their veggie sandwich and egg/meat sandwich on this bagel and it's so flavorful! Staff is friendly and location is clean and open. Coffee is self-serve. They have 7 tables inside and 2 outside. A rack for online pickup orders is conveniently located near the entrance so you don't need to shimmy up to the register. I hope they open more locations near us in Loudoun County. read more

Bagel Joy - Veggies on a Rosemary Sea Salt Bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Great bagel shop! The bagels are big and fluffy inside but with the perfect chew. Not bready feeling at all. Staff were friendly and service was good! It's rare that we find a bagel shop with Taylor ham/pork roll, so we were delighted to see it on the menu and done well! I appreciate they have a create your own bagel sandwich option so I could add a schmear of cream cheese to my sandwich. read more

Just the bagel itself is excellent! Much better than Panera and Manhattan bagels and slightly better than Main Street Bagels (my usual go-to). However, size wise, they are slightly smaller, which is okay to me since the flavor and taste makes up for it. I actually give it 4.5 stars because I like my bagels scooped and the owner (?) came out and told me they dont do scooped bagels (but made a one time exception for me). I'll be back again for sure! read more

Bagel Joy - Bacon egg cheese on everything - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Soft opening start and are hitting on all cylinders. They have perfected their NY style bagels with a crunch on the outside and soft and chewy on the inside. The Asiago cheese was freshly made you can taste the hint of salt. The blueberry was also fresh. We got their bagels with sausage, egg and cheese. We will be back to their store front. read more

Bagel Joy - Blueberry bagel with sausage, and cheese - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Love coming here. They have great service. I like to order ahead and just grab my bag and go. I love the salmon lox bagel. If I lived closer I would be in so much trouble. read more

They will put 500lbs of cream cheese on your bagel even if you ask for 'light' spread-- but at least you get your money's worth. The everything bagel is decent, but the rosemary sea salt is read more

Great staff everyone is very friendly. I had a bacon egg and cheese bagel and purchased a few bagels to bring home, all tasted ok. The fig cream cheese is very good. Spacious restaurant lots of seating available. The coffee was very good. read more

Great bagels. Probably the best in northern Virginia. I was a huge fan of the previous tenet, Bagel Buddies, and I still miss their huge selection. However, Bagel Joy is about as close as it gets in terms of quality. I also like that they updated the decor so things feel modern. The self-serve coffee is a nice upgrade and the La Columbe coffee is a pretty solid choice. Things are very focused on the bagel experience: bagels, spreads, and bagel sandwiches are what make up the menu. It's nice to see them keep things simple and it's probably what keeps the line moving. read more

1454 bagel with cream cheese, eggs, and bacon. This place is a rip off not worth it. Bagels are OK.

If you enjoy half baked super dense bagels, this place is for you. Had to discard the bagels purchased after trying to toast these monstrosities. I baked bagels as a teen 45 years ago and they would have fired me on the spot if I had served anything as hideous as these hockey pucks. read more

Extremely long lines and slow service on the weekends. Got a bacon egg cheese bagel sandwich and my friend got a sausage cheese egg with avocado. Bagel could have been toasted more. Had a nice chew but too doughy and thick for me. read more

Great bagels! Maybe the best in NOVA! Service is welcoming and friendly and there's plenty of places to sit indoors and out.

The bagels are delicious! They have a huge variety of bagels to choose from! The place looks clean . read more

Bagel Joy - Rosemary' sea salt with eggs and cheese! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

We wanted to check out what all the rage was but you know ... it was just ok. Let me share why. 1) they got my order wrong, which made me disappointed from the start. They piled on the cream cheese so it was the same size as the bagel ... so may think this is a good thing. 2) the egg sandwich bagel was big but soggy.. so you need to eat that quick. 3) plain bagel - nothing special. And dare I say the grocery store bagels taste better! Overall - not sure why people are raving about this place.. there are much better bagel places that keep portion sizes nice and get the orders right. I didn't go back as the line was long but make sure you check to make sure you get the bagel you ordered before you leave. read more

Pretty good bagels! The best bagel place in the area that I've tried. It's a cute spot and great selection

Bagel Joy is finally open after all they've been through! We came on opening day and it was packed! Since the line was so long and most of the bagels were sold out by the time we arrived, we left and came back on day #4 of opening! Service was very friendly, warm, and inviting. They have a variety of bagels, spreads, drinks, and bagel sandwiches. I like how they sell their bagels from the previous day for a discounted price. This prevents wasting food and I would totally get that. I purchased a half dozen of onion, everything, and asiago bagels and they were good. I like how the onion bagels have pieces of onion inside the dough. The pastrami and swiss cheese sandwich was also good. We are just excited for a new neighborhood bagel spot! read more

This place is so great! I got the everything bagel with cream cheese and it was exactly what I expected/wanted. I also got the Avril and daaaaang, it was everything I didn't KNOW I wanted. So tasty and messy and really blew my mind. I want to try the rest of the menu but can't ever imagine passing that up haha. Service does take a bit, but they are made to order, and it's worth the wait. The staff is super friendly and seem to genuinely appreciate people coming in. 10/10! read more

Glacial pace of service despite 10 employees. $11 for a breakfast sandwich is absurd. No advantage to human interaction, business focused on online orders except for the VIP who walked in and was served ahead of all of us. read more