Delicious bagels, ever since I moved to Bushwick I've struggled to find a bagel store that I enjoy as much. Seriously miss my old go to Sunday morning breakfast spot. read more

Been patronizing BB since 1998. They are reliable and have catered tons of my company's breakfast events. It's always busy so the bagels are always fresh. The condiments are good, as is the lox. They're the standard for the area and good for Brooklyn. read more

Very good service and a free 12 oz coffee with a bagel/breakfast sandwich purchase. Beware - they use sea salt. My everything bagel was a bit too salty with those large chunks of salt. They get busy so I would be in your best interest to check your order before you leave. Can't wait to go back and try some of their cream cheeses! read more

This place is awesome for a quick bite! It's hard to find many places to get breakfast so early on a weekend in my neighborhood but Bagel Boy is definitely a great contender. The bagels are usually super fresh and they have all the trimmings and spreads you could want. They also have a huge selection of sandwiches and pastas for those looking for non-bagel items. Staff is friendly and ridiculously efficient despite the high volume of people churning through at breakfast hours. read more

Be prepared to wait. And wait. And wait. Six guys behind the counter and with the owner not around only one guy actually seemed to be working - and he had to be as he was doing the work of six guys. The rest of them were puttering around, joking and laughing while we waited and waited. Waited 20 minutes to buy two plain bagels. I was sorry I couldn't walk out like other people were. read more

Not too much to say here...so ill make it short and sweet I live in NY...UES...now Brooklyn....I know bagels. These bagels are the best Ive had yet. Cream Cheese: Im such a brat when it comes to it. Theirs is not only the freshest, but they are very liberal but not sickening. The flavor choices are fantastic- Jalapeno Cheddar- NOM! The staff is fast, courteous and knowledgeable. They have whitefish salad and its to die for. They have a fantastic selection of salads, spreads, drinks and desserts! This all combined with the fantastic prices, Ill be here often.... read more

Best bagels in Brooklyn you never wait more than a few minutes great service clean and friendly I would recommend it to anyone

i came by the place and never have eaten anything like it! WOW i also told my pals in the union in NY

One of the few good bagels in Bay Ridge. There is always a long line here (which always says something about a place). I like the way they keep the line moving. I am a huge fan of Sausage, Egg, and Cheese on croissants. The problem here was that they don't have great croissants and that kind of kills the sandwich. Other than that, they have a great drink selection for whatever you could possibly be in the mood for in the morning (or whenever you stop in). read more

Excellent bagels - chewy enough, not too soft (although no bagelry I know of makes bagels like when I was a kid, when you REALLY had to chew them, their skins were so thick and tough - I kinda miss that!). Plentiful toppings - like ALL OVER the bagels (I HATE it when I order a sesame bagel somewhere and get, like, 8 sesame seeds sprinkled over top!) and all the varieties you'd expect. Points for having light cream cheese as well as regular for a schmeer. Their deli salads are great too - we've gone there at all hours of the morning (open 24 hours! YAY!) for wonderful tangy egg salad and delicious creamy chicken salad, both on everything bagels. The place is often packed (easy to tell why!) but the service is great - they keep the line moving quickly and efficiently. Friends way out in Western NJ near the PA border requested we bring them bagels on a recent trip, saying they can't get any good ones where they live. We brought a couple dozen Bagel Boy bagels with deli salads, and they were extremely pleased, pronouncing them "delicious." And they get special mention for honesty and integrity, too. A few months ago, I was in there on a Saturday morning to get some bagels / sandwiches for the road on our way to a weekend in DC. When we got to the hotel in VA, I found my wallet was missing. Mentally retracing my steps, I realized the last place I'd had it was at Bagel Boy, so I phoned the store, and sure enough, a customer had found my wallet on the floor and given it to the cashier. They locked it up for me until I was able to come in a couple nights later to pick it up, and I had no trouble at all - nothing was missing, my cards had not been used or tampered with. Thank you for that, Bagel Boy management. And most of all, thank you for the BEST bagels in Bay Ridge! Recommend highly. EDIT: Having just had a bagel from Tasty Bagels on 86th St. and 17th Ave. for the first time, I'm upgrading Bagel Boy from 4 to 5 stars. Tasty Bagels's product was good, but if I'm about to rate them 4 stars, Bagel Boy deserves 5. read more

Great little shop, every time I got my bagels are fresh, expedient service & quality pastries, I've been coming here for over 12years! read more

Bagel Boy - Apple crumb croissant - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

SOLID BAGEL Joint in the hood. Wow. I really do like this place... Albeit hubby says bagels are too puffy and big but I think they're great. .90 cents a bagel and they're nice and big. Sometimes I'll get a bagel with avocado comes out to $3.91 but it's huge and they don't skimp on the avocado. Also people in their are very friendly. Cream cheese is also good and fresh read more

This is the kind of place I'd be a regular at. It was small but super-clean and well-organized, offering a big variety of beverages (both hot and cold), other snacks, and a full deli/bagel selection. My bagel with lox and cream cheese was very good. The staff was very friendly. read more

Truly an excellent deli. I ended up going almost every day on my last NYC visit, and was more and more impressed each time. Bagels are large but solid and seasoned well, both in the dough and on top. The cream cheeses were intensely flavorful. Everything seemed fresh, whether it was morning or 9pm. The workers were very accommodating with our orders and were both fast and accurate. read more

Best bagels, hands down, ever ever ever ever. The everything bagel is so chewy on the inside, so crispy on the outside. It's love. A little bummed that there's no seating, but it's close enough to walk home and eat it up. read more

Bagel Boy is my absolute favorite bagel place in the universe. I moved to the west coast for seven years and Bagel Boy was always one of my first stops when I came home for a visit. I'm a pretty easy customer - plain bagel with butter - and it's perfect every time. I've been going to Bagel Boy since it opened and it just keeps getting better. I've had their sandwiches and salads and they're all amazing but the bagels are what gets me. I wouldn't buy cold cuts from them - the folded paper packaging doesn't seem to keep things as fresh as the plastic bags from the supermarket down the street - but the sandwiches are awesome, especially on a bagel. I love these bagels so much I had an ex-boyfriend overnight me a box of bagels across the country. The store is really crowded in the mornings but the guys behind the counter work quickly and get you in and out as quickly as possible. The other bagel stores in Bay Ridge can't compare to Bagel Boy - I'd recommend it even if I didn't live a block away. read more

Stay away from this place.. Refusing to take Orders by phone anymore a worker named Moe with a horrible attitude said no we don't do phone orders really after a decade ??? Terrible customer service Forcing customers to order online and figure out your app.. Making your wait more than an hour for delivery......!!!! Theyve gotten stingy giving you less meat than they used to.. only Spanish speaking workers who you can barely understand and have terrible attitudes when you want a custom order they are very unfriendly sometimes even burning your bagel if you ask for toasted.. No low sodium options..... Stay away from this place bad service.. Go To Sunset Bagels or Sams Bagels in Bayridge either one is a better option than Bagel Boy read more

I ordered online - big mistake. My son begged me to order because he loves their bacon. Whatever. I ordered an OMELET. The system makes you choose an option for bread which one would think was for TOAST. No - they put my OMELET on BREAD. It wasn't even an omelet. They put all of the ingredients of the omelet separately on the bread. I am so disappointed. read more

Holy moly on the options! Although it's a zoo inside, the line seems to move along nicely. The bagels are giant, but they are not as soft on the inside as I would like. You have to gnaw on them for a while, like a dog on a rawhide bone. Why do they sell loaves of white Wonder Bread? Very odd. read more

Great Bagels. Something about having a NYC bagel and there is something about having a Bagel Boy Bagel. They are made daily and are good even by themselves. Every time I bite into a Bagel Boy Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese I can feel the happiness it brings to my taste buds (along with a nice cup of Joe which just cements its) The only draw back is the price and over time the chewing of the Bagels make my jaws hurt. If I could I would go everyday. Unfortunately, I treat myself probably once in a while. If you haven't, then you should try. read more

I just picked up a dozen bagels and end up with 15! With $1.00 each it is a bargain. The bagels are fresh and big. The place was packed on a Saturday morning but the service is fast. I was in and out in less than 3 min. I love bagels and from Out of town. I will be back if I am in the area. read more

You can't go wrong with Bagel Boy. A Bay Ridge fave. No matter what time you go it is busy, but on the weekends it's really hopping. No matter what they keep everything moving and everything fresh. Their bagels are great and the cream cheese spreads are tasty. Plus they will cook your eggs sunny side up for your sandwiches. Which gets my thumbs up. read more

Their bagels used to be chewier. Today I went and ordered my Usual, an everything bagel Toasted medium with cream cheese. It had poppy seeds, sesame seeds and dried onion flakes but it was mostly poppy so I didn't have that everything flavor. It was barely toasted and so Got cold Quickly. It was like eating room temperature bread. The inside was gummy. It's getting hard to find a really good NY bagel anymore. They should be crunchy on the outside and really chewy inside. This wasn't. Disappointed. read more

Bagel boy has been my go-to breakfast spot for years. They have a great selection and I've never had anything un-fresh. My only warning, check your order carefully, folks. I don't know if they're overwhelemed or just ADD, but I've had them screw up my order many many times, whether placed in person or on the phone. read more

$8.5 for a bagel??? I got the scallion cream cheese with lox and I did not like the way that scallion tasted with that bagel. Not going to go back again. It was interesting how they put together the lox and the cream.cheese but 8 dollars is asking too much for that experience. read more

Bagel Boy - Poppy bagel with lox and scallion cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

It's a nice little cute store on the corner of Main Ave. You can find fresh baked, hot, soft bagel here. There was a long line when we walked in but it went very quick. Prices are reasonable. Store is clean. The only con is (kinda surprised me) they are still not environment friendly. Their coffee is a little bit bitter. I wish they use paper cups considering they have 3 busy locations. read more

Good spot. This place must have gone through a face lift since the last time I went in here 5+ years ago, but it's really nice inside. The Cinnamon raisin bagel with butter was very good. But the large coffee, was a bitter. That, plus the bitter coffee holds this at 3 stars, but could easily be a 4. Total for those 2 items was just under $3, not stellar, but reasonable. What I really like about this place was the quickness and efficiency of the checkout line. I was bumped to the front of the line, since the people in front of me, were waiting on egg/bagel orders. That stuff speeds my day, and I like the efficiency. read more

Not as good as the one in sheepshead bay, bagels aren't as chewy and tastier as the one in sheepshead. Especially their french toast bagel. Someone should tell them to take a tip from sheepshead. read more

Food is great bagels are fresh delivery took a little long I asked for 2 turkey bacon egg and cheese sandwiches and one lox with scallion cream cheese I don't eat pork I'm Muslim and the other egg and cheese I got lettuce and mayo on it had pork bacon but it's ok I threw it out but other than that food was delicious fresh cooked and eggs well done and bagels are so soft and fresh lemonade is a total blastttt love the lemonade read more

Bagel Boy - Scallion lox everything bagel is to die for - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

For the past month I've been trying different bagel stores throughout Dyker Heights and Bay Ridge. I haven't been to Bagel Boy since I was a kid and figured I'd give it a try. My server, James, fulfilled all of my needs! I was in shock with the friendly staff and customers waiting in line. You don't see people holding doors for one another often in Brooklyn. After today's experience, I will always recommend Bagel Boy! read more

Everyone, and I mean everyone, comes here for the bagels. A great local joint that attracts people from all over. We had to see what the hype was all about. The bagel was "plump" and chewy and had a ton of lox on it. The price was steep for a bagel and lox, but the quality of the bagel and lox were very good. Would definitely come back for a good bagel. read more

If you just want a dozen bagel or a bacon egg & cheese bagel it's great but anything else they don't get the order right. Was told 45 min wait for pancakes. Why so long for 3 pancakes? Are they ordering the pancakes from somewhere else? Also I got egg whites with avocado on a wrap & they gave me 2 small slices of it. I get this all the time at different places & always get a few pieces of avocado. Also We got a plate with bacon eggs & home fries when we got home to eat, no bacon & they didn't toast the bread. If you want a dozen bagels they are good but that's about it. read more

Easy to say best bagels in Brooklyn.the staff is always so nice and take care of you.always fresh bagels and fresh coffee.i used to go to there first store years ago in Dyker heights.it's a little drive to Bayridge but it's worth the trip every time. Ps just a heads up do not park in front of store the traffic cops are like vultures waiting to give tickets.its hard to eat bagel that just cost you 115.00 lmaooooo. read more

Bagel boy is the best bagel shop in Bayridge! They have the freshest most delicious bagels daily! Their custom hero's are to die for! Make sure to use them for your next party! The staff is always very welcoming and helpful! They know your name and order as soon as you walk in the door! Highly recommend Bagel Boy! read more

This is hands down my favorite bagel place in Bay Ridge. They have giant bagels that are fresh and there's good coffee. Plus there are the other deli options for sandwiches, salads, and some baked goods. read more

Not just a great bagel but so much more to offer ... wide variety of breakfasts and lunches . Very satisfied with their staff who always are so friendly and accommodating. read more

Bagel Boy bagels are to the cream of the crop. Simple the best there is! They have a huge variety and other deli sandwiches which are amazing too. Haven't had one I suggest you do. When ever I get back home first thing I do is go there in the morning and get huge bag for the family. read more

Lots of good options including breakfast sandwiches, paninis, and bagels for a quick bite in the morning. I got an onion bagel with jalapeno and cheddar cream cheese. There were actually large chunks of jalapeno and cheddar in my cream cheese. It sure was tasty. Nice and quick service, too. Check them out! read more

Well, My experience at this bay ridge bagel shop was unbelievable the staff was very friendly and the bagels are mouth watering. They offer a great selection of sandwiches and wraps. The muffins are sooooo good. The coffee is top shelf. You should give it a try and see for yourself. read more

Great food, come in, grab it and come out. Quick and easy. Many custom sandwiches or create your own. Recommend this place to anyone in bay ridge trying to grab a quick bite to eat. EDIT: Just placed a $200 order and it been over an hour and I am 6 blocks away. Not sure whats going on but it should be here by now. Hope the food is as good as usual read more