Made a stop to get some coffee & something to eat before heading to the park . The guy At the register was pretty rude , I asked him for a plain croissant , he then comes and grabs a cheese one & when I told him I asked him for a plain one , he had an attitude! I'm paying for what I want not for you want to give me ! Then my partner asked for a sandwich & guy tells him well if you want it with everything we charge extra for everything ! Like if we couldn't afford it ! I found it pretty rude ! Won't be going buying from this place again ! read more

The bagels are good, and on weekend occasionally make the trip in to pick one up. This establishment suffers from something many NYC places have: an unknown organization system. Yes, there does appear to be a "flow" to where you should order... but how much you should order from that guy? Do I order my coffee at the register? If I just want a drink, do I have to wait in the line, or can I just go to the register? I'm sure to anyone who's lived here forever these might sound like crazy questions. Maybe they are, but that time I tried testing one of my theories on the line that woman gave me one hell of a dirty look. read more

I had forgotten about Bagel Boy until just this morning when I went to see a Doctor located right next door. Upon coming out of the Doctor's office, I saw Bagel Boy and thought "YES YES YES. An everything bagel will melt my sorrows away right now" and I made a beeline for the door. They changed the layout a bit since the last time I came in, and I like it. They are like a well-oiled machine. Great service. I ordered an everything bagel with egg whites, turkey bacon, swiss cheese and tomato and it was ready in under 3 minutes. As for the bagel itself, all I can say is that I've lived in NYC for most of my life, and I have had many a good bagel, but nothing, I mean NOTHING, compares to Bagel Boy on 3rd. NOTHING. Understand? N-O-T-H-I-N-G! The bagel is perfection, moist on the inside, crispy on the outside, puffy, the "everything" on both sides of the bagel. Effin YUM! So, thank YOU Bagel Boy for reminding me of your awesomeness, and thank you for making a sick girl smile if even for a single moment this entire week. I love you. Will you marry me? read more

There is so much hype about this place and I'm really not sure why. Every time I come here there is a serious mistake with my order. I think they are just too busy and therefore make too many careless mistakes. read more

Never ordering from here again. I ordered a toasted BLT with cheese (I paid EXTRA for the cheese), my order took over an hour to get to me (I am 5 minutes away from them). When my order got here it was not toasted, it was actually cold and there was no cheese. I called and told them my order was not correct. The guy took my order again and said they would send out a new one. Once my order got here, it was a little warm not toasted and there was still no cheese. AND on top of that the delivery guy was rude. Not the first time they mess up an order but it will be my last time ordering with them. read more

I don't care what anyone says, Brooklyn bagels are the best. This is my go to bagel shop since forever. If you ever come around during the weekend, you'll see a bunch of cars double parked outside waiting to pick up some bagels and coffee. As much as I love them, they do have their off days and there may be less cream cheese or whatever, but the bagel is always good. Quick and friendly service for the most part and the prices are reasonable. If you've never been, they are worth a try. read more

Bagel Boy - French toast bagel w/cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

'Bagel Boy' has some pretty good selection and quality. Well, of course everything in it is typical Boar's Head; but I mean the salads and entrees and prepared spreads are decent and creamy and the bagels themselves, are okay. Its a chain, they generally keep up their chain standard. This location is no exception. Its also a clean, well-lit store in a great location for a late-nite feeding frenzy. The one weak aspect to their bagels is that they're not 'crusty'. I like a bagel crusty outside, soft inside. These bagels are same-texture-throughout: soft and chewy. My real complaint is the prices. I bought 1 lb of roast beef and 1 lb of Pepper jack cheese, and maybe a small container of cole slaw? And a 20 oz. Coke? The price was $20! Outrageous. Live and learn. I'll never buy anything but a single bagel/cream cheese here. Its not where I will go to spend any serious cash. read more

Love Bagel Boy...a coworker of mine brought some in one day and just from looking at them I knew they were Brooklyn bagels. I was so excited since I'm a Brooklynite living in NJ and I haven't had a decent bagel in years since moving there. I basically stopped eating them since they're subpar. I have since been going to the Bagel Boy location in Bay Ridge. I know about the location in NJ but for some reason they don't taste as good as the Brooklyn location. Must be that NY water that makes a difference. Service is always efficient and everyone is so friendly. I order my bagels online and they're ready to go when I pick up. Cant beat that. So happy I made this discovery. I used to see it all the time when visiting friends that lived in that area years ago but never stopped to try them out. Bagels are always fresh and delicious. read more

I was treated exceptionally well by the staff. The breakfast sandwiches are fantastic--I had an egg and muenster cheese on a roll with hot sauce. Impeccable. Thank you to James and Jessica for your warm welcome! Carlo - Hidden Grounds Coffee read more

BEST Bagels EVER. Whenever I visit west coast relatives, I'm asked to bring a big bag full Bagel Boy bagels. I can't find a bagel I like better, I couldn't live without Bagel Boy. The staff is really friendly, and they're open 24 hours on Friday and Saturday, so its great for a late night snack. read more

Let me start off by saying do not be fooled by other reviews. I had been a faithful costumer of bagel boy for three years. I would go to bagel boy almost daily for either breakfast lunch or sometimes both. I have even got free wraps and sandwiches because of how many I bought on my rewards card. The place has completely gone downhill. Apparently they hire anyone to work there nowadays. The other day I waited a HALF HOUR for a quarter pound of turkey and a half pound of swiss. Now I'm not saying I walked in and waited for my order.. The new deli man literally took my order and then took a half hour to cut my cold cuts.. No exaggerating I had to check on my meter to avoid a ticket.. Whatever.. The iced cappuccino. I used to come to bagel boy daily with my girlfriend and get iced cappuccinos because of how good they were. I went in recently with my brother (who also gets them) and we both agreed something tasted funky about them.. Whatever.. Then I go in last week it was disgusting to the point where I couldnt even finish half.. Don't be fooled by this place it has had its better days. Never mind the fact that bagel boy is a complete rip off.. Bet you never knew that they actually charge you for lettuce or tomato on your sandwich as separate charges. Who does that? As someone who knows food in bay ridge.. There's better bagel stores in bay ridge, trust me read more

I recently moved to Bay Ridge and this awesome spot is right downstairs from my apartment. The minute I saw it, I became excited at the prospect of being able to get my coffee right before I get onto the train to head into work.... I have not yet found anything to fault the lovely people who run this operation. The variety of bagels this place offers is mind-blowing, all of which that I have tried so far are near-perfection. The service here is fantastic. The people here have always been friendly, inviting and accommodating to me, as each time I have gone I have tried something else...they have the patience to actually let me ask questions, even when they're extremely slam med, which it has been every time I have been so far. The only small thing I would have to say is that the breakfast sandwich, which I tried this morning, was lukewarm...but that is something that can easily be fixed if I was to ask. I look forward to coming here more often and trying more of what they have to offer. read more

I bought an egg salad bagel here yesterday. I asked for the bagel to be scooped and toasted which they forgot to do. That's ok however the everything bagel with egg salad and a small amount of turkey cost 8.25. I also asked for some onion which I didn't receive. The workers here were talking amongst themselves and not very welcoming. The egg salad did taste nice so that's why I am giving 2 stars but it was way over priced and with so many other bagel spots in the neighborhood I won't be rushing back here. I work in a bar in the area and asked my customers if that seemed expensive and they said it was ridiculous. read more

Fellow Yelpers: We talk about social distancing. There's a place in Bay Ridge' ~ that you should stay a faraway distance from! Bagel Boy' on 3rd avenue. Based on Coronavirus' and staying home in lockdown.. I decided to place an order with this lowlife business. However, I paid with a credit card on the phone, and then the delivery person contacted me, thereafter to advise he's unable to come inside my apt. bldg." Finally, I called Bagel Boy' and they said the driver will be at my door soon! When the food arrived it was inedible. Especially the stale bagels. Which also, were molded! The Salmon Lox' was very old and like - rubber. Nevertheless, once again, I spoke with the merchant' who laughed and enjoyed the abuse he gave me. I asked for a credit to no avail for the molded stale bagels! Henceforth, I then called 311 NYC and reported the incident concerning the old lox and bagels." Stay clear from this business, and distance yourself, clearly, u could get food poisoning if they continue to sell old food!!! Fortunately, there's some other great food deli's in our area! Best of luck! Stay Safe - God Bless All" read more

Delicious bagels and always fun, innovative, and delicious cream cheese flavor choices. The deli choices are just as good and you can't go wrong with their grilled chicken, mozz, and balsamic on a fresh roll. Open 24 hours on the weekends? You can't beat that. read more

THIS PLACE IS A HIDDEN GEM PEOPLE! Look. I am probably the last person to have wound up in this area. Long story, but I ended up having to go to Bay Ridge to pick up something I had lost, on a rainy summer day in New York on a Sunday. Awful. Simply worst timing possible. However, Bagel Boy was the best thing that ever happened to me. I walked in and was concerned but all I had been thinking about my entire time in New York was how I wanted to try the Brooklyn bagel that I had been hearing about for so long (I have an avid Brooklyn native friend who raves nonstop about Brooklyn--honestly though, what he says is generally true). I got a plain bagel--I'm a purist. Eating it on my way out I was blown away. After I got two blocks out and one bagel down, I turned around to go back to the store. I bought 6 for my friend (who is a carb-lover) and 6 for myself. Couldn't hold back. Simply amazing bagels. Was worth the 3 hour detour I took from Manhattan to get here. read more

Every time I stop by Brooklyn, my belly knows she needs a bagel boy's everything bagel. By far my favorite bagel place with the freshest non-fishy tasting lox. They have a bunch of different cream cheese flavors but any one of them on a nicely toasted bagel is just perfect. It's a shame that there's no seating area in the place but there's a park bench right outside that's always great for chowing down your bagel. read more

It's good, bagels are great, everything bagel was on the salty side. The girl at the register charged me wrong but I didn't realize until I got home and it was too late. I'm a bit annoyed about that but I can't say the bagel was bad. It gets very crowded- I wish they made it into a line with signs- people seem to all gather by the cash register and it feels congested. They should also consider getting paper bags with handles because I made a large order one morning and I had to figure out how to maneuver 3 paper bags with no handles- I don't have enough hands for that. They said they would find a plastic bag but it was taking a very long time and luckily I had a bag in my car read more

Live everyone there. Helpful and sweet. Already know my order. I go there veery morning..

I've been going to Bagel Boy for a few years now. The bagels and cream cheese are great and on the few occasions when I've had a cold cut sandwich for lunch, it has been one of the best around. I love the very thinly shredded lettuce! The thing I can't get over is their coffee! I am a self-professed coffee snob, having taught myself how to make a great cup a few years ago, and this is some of the best coffee I've tasted outside of a real coffee shop. I don't know what they do to it to make it so good, but I'd about 80% of the time it is just amazing! The other 20% it's decent enough. Does anyone know if they put Chickory or something else into the brew to make it so good? read more

I have always received great food from this place. Fantastic bagels - always fresh. Their bagel wheels make everyone happy. Great service - they know they are great and have a lot of people working there so they can get us our sandwiches and coffee! read more

The Bagel Boys work hard to give customers great bagels and coffee, but Unfortunately, I paid almost $8 for a salad that had a rusty NAIL on the bottom and inside the lettuce, it wasn't clean. I wasn't feeling well later on that day afterwards. I felt like I ate rusty food, then I saw a NAIL in my salad. I took it back to the manager who replaced my salad with a wrap, but the wrap wasn't very good either. Who's preparing the salads and wraps? Was it a carpenter? read more

Probably my favorite bagel place in all of NYC. Wide array of choices, speedy service, and delicious food. Not much else needs to be said. read more

Bagel Boy - Everything bagel with olive and pimento cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Hands down best bagel store around. The line is consistent so you know everything is as fresh as possible. Don't sleep on their coffee either! I hate sugar in my coffee so I can never enjoy flavors since most places flavor their coffee by syrup but, bagel boy has coffee with flavored beans their hazlenut coffee is my fave cup in bay ridge! read more

I drove by the place at 2 A.M. Saturday morning as a way to stop my nodding out at the wheel, deciding that a coffee and bagel were just the ticket and, boy, was I surprised at the outcome. There was that all-too-rare sense of all your bagel fantasies coming true AND confidence that stomach cramps and worse (I won't even mention the "D" word) would NOT rear (no pun intended) its ugly head. Not only was the food arranged neatly, cleanly and in seemingly unlimited supply, but three gorgeous, happy and friendly Brooklyn babes came in and made it seem as if they were making their usual rounds and checking in to partake in a gathering of those seeking the hot breathy coming-together over lusty, tasty....oops, did I fall in love again? read more

Like users mentioned before, used to be a great place. Now it's a hit or miss. Recently got a poppy seed bagel that was stale as sh*t. Needless to say I couldn't even eat it. Sandwiches don't even taste good anymore. Their portions have gotten smaller, even their bagels are smaller too. The price is different every time. I suggest getting the cashiers on board with pricing. WHO CHARGES FOR LETTUCE AND TOMATO ? .50 cents a piece. PLEASE CHANGE THIS, it's WRONG. Could be a great place, like it once was if they just go back to serving quality instead of quantity. Oh, and bring back the Krispy Cream donuts you guys used to sell ;) read more

Disclaimer: I'm not writing on behalf of my hospital, just as an individual. I work for a local hospital that has several early conferences a week. I cannot tell you how many times I've called BB at 5:30-6:00am to have something delivered for 8am and they come though with not only a delicious spread but with a very nice presentation. Thank you BB for saving my ass on more than one occasion; because a hungry doctor is an unbearable doctor! read more

The bagels have become hit and miss. The everything bagel have been lacking what used to be great, overwhelmingly seasoned. The counter help is less than eager to help and often get the order wrong. read more

The rainbow bagels are just a plain bagel but like it's really fun to eat. They also have a great variety of cream cheeses. I ordered one with a rainbow sprinkle cream cheese. They had Nutella and a Birthday Cake one that looked good too but I didn't try it yet. Definitely coming back! read more

Bagel Boy - Rainbow Bagel with rainbow cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I ordered a sesame seed bagel toasted with cream cheese and tomatoes , corn muffin toasted with butter a Snapple Apple and a reg coffee at 8:00 Am because my breakfast break starts at that time. The delivery Guy shows up at 9:30 Am with a cold bagel and muffin and ice cold coffee and they didn't even get the Snapple Apple rite they gave me apple nectar a brand I never heard of, the worse part is I work 4 blocks away from their store but it took him an Hour and a half to DRIVE 4 blocks? Smh I will never order from this place again ! A complete waste of my time and money , Ice cold coffee and a Rock hard bagel that No human being would bite because of fear of breaking a tooth and digesting Metal that will cutt up your A hole if u ish it out. Do your self a favor and call mikes Deli , doesn't matter if your twenty blocks away the guy will show up on bike with hot food read more

I've lived nearby for 10 years and have loved coming in regularly. The staff is great. During COVID, the place is packed and staff doesn't control how packed it is. Customers often don't wear masks and become verbally aggressive when asked. The line is tight and customers become verbally aggressive when asked to space out. I know there's not a great solution for a busy business, but this place has lost me as a customer as a result. read more

Every time I come back to Brooklyn I make an effort to grab bagels at Bagel Boy. Their bagels are delicious and amazing. I highly recommend you give this place a shot. read more

Best bagels in Bay Ridge. A little on the pricey side, but worth it. My favorite order: Everything bagel with egg whites, avocado, lettuce and tomato. read more

Bagel Boy in Bay Ridge is absolutely fantastic. The food items? Phenomenal and fresh. The display? Very nice, and so is the atmosphere. But the best thing of all is the excellent customer service and staff. You're always made to feel welcome, the staff are always accommodating, and they are extremely friendly and welcoming. I would highly recommend their business to anyone reading this review. read more

I don't know who the Bagel Boy is but I'm guessing he lives somewhere in Brooklyn or New Jersey. There are three locations. This one happens to be in Bay Ridge. Small chain bagel places seem to be becoming the norm and I have no problem with that as long as they are good and consistent. It's working for Brooklyn Bagel Co. and La Bagel Delight, so why not Bagel Boy? The bagels here are very good and the selection of cream cheeses are an added bonus. I had an everything bagel with jalapeno cream cheese and it was pretty delicious. The bagel was fresh and fluffy which is what I come to expect from an above average bagel place. Seating and a bathroom would have been nice, but can't have everything I guess. Yeah. It's one of those bagel places. If I'm ever in this part of Brooklyn again, I can see myself making another quick pit stop here one morning. Don't let the iconic Bagel Boy character deter you. This isn't the Bob's Big Boy of bagel places. There's decent bagels to be had here. read more

There are bagel stores everywhere in NY but whenever I'm in the Bay Ridge area, this is my go-to. Never have I ever come into Bagel Boy and there isn't a line wrapped around the counter. Their bagels are fresh and the employees are quick. You are also able to pay with their app which makes things so much easier. One thing I wish they had was tofu cream cheese, then I would be here every day! read more

It's so awesome that I almost shed a tear every time when I walk in. Please open up more locations in bay ridge. You obviously have more customers than you can handle. Please just open one next to my apartment. I'll eat there everyday, I promise. I love places that can provide you with the simplest things (bagel/sandwich and coffee) and completely excel in quality. You'll understand why there's always a line here once you've had a try. read more

Absolutely love this place. The coffee is great the food is always fresh. Their bagels have the perfect amount of soft doughiness on the inside and crisp outer layer. This is my go to spot for bagels, they have a nice big selection of bagels and cream cheese. read more

Bagel Boy has the best Bagels in Brooklyn. Terrace Bagels is a close second, Dyker Park Bagels 3rd and La Bagel Delight 4th. Midwood Deli & Cropsey Bagels used to be up there too but have fallen on hard times. There's also a great runner up called Brooklyn Bagels (5th & 87th) which deserves an honorable mention. Back to the topic, these bagels are perfectly dense and chewy but still light and crispy. A bit small but well-made. If they were 24/7 like Dyker I'd camp out here semi-permanently, as Bagel Boy has better bagels and faster service. it's worth a trip out if you're picking up weight; parking in Bay Ridge is bad on weekends but it's still a breeze compared to Park Slope anytime. read more

I've lived in bay ridge my whole life and me and my family have been going to bagel boy for as long as I can remember. I have to say they never disappoint me , always fast, nice kind group of people , best place to get your day started with a good meal read more