Aurelio&#x27;s Pizza

I grew up on Villa Pizza, it was my grandfather's favorite. My mother preferred their roast beef…read moresandwiches. Twenty-five years later I am in town for my grandparents memorial, and I picked up roast beef sandwiches for my mom and I last night. The roast beef was every bit as I remember it. LOTS of meat, fantastic fries, and dirt cheap compared to fast food options. My only regret is that I forgot to ask for peppers. It's a rare thing when something from your childhood continues to live up to the memories. I'll definitely be ordering from there again before I leave town.

I arrived on a Wednesday at 4:38 pm to find a handwritten sign saying "Dining room closed." Thank…read moreyou for wasting my time.

February 2019

See all

February 2019

Squigi's Pizza

4.1(45 reviews)

2.0 mi

I was wondering what to eat and came across this joint. I had a good feeling about it…read more My significant other and I walked inside and unfortunately table service wasn't offered. I looked at the menu on the wall. There was a sign that stated 4% Higher with CRedit CArD . I looked at the menu the arrow pointed to. I went to the counter to order. The PIZZA section stated Our Pizzas are Hand Tossed to give you that Personal Touch! We went with a SMALL Cheese Pizza for $10.92. From the FRIED FOODS section, we got Cheese Curds for $6.24. From the same section, we got Mushrooms for $6.24. From the SIDE ORDERS section, we got Garlic Bread for $3.12. We sat at a table while we waited. Our order was ready fast. I was given a free menu, so that was cool. I was excited to try everything. All we had to do was get back to our place. We were given a free red sauce and a free ranch. The Cheese Pizza was beautiful. Every bite was delicious. The Cheese Curds were decent. With the red sauce, they were better. With the ranch, they were awesome. The Mushrooms were okay. With the red sauce, they were a little better. With the ranch, they were tasty. The Garlic Bread had a nice flavor. I enjoyed it. The service was great. I didn't have any issues. Overall, this joint was a successful stop. I'm glad I tried it out. Date of visit: 06/06/2025

Love the Wednesday pizza discount pricing. So much so cheese on their yummy pizza. Always friendly…read moreservice too.

See all

Barton Pizzeria

3.6(38 reviews)

1.0 mi

My favorite pizza and my family's favorite for well over 30 years. I'm not sure what kind of dark…read moremagic they perform on their crust and green peppers, but they are stellar.

Horrible people. Below average food. Got called out on Facebook for a pizza that looked less than…read moredesirable, rather than apologizing or offering to make it right, they decide to blame the customer for his "photo skills". And then they go online and leave 1 star reviews to an establishment they've never been to! Petty owners, bad food. Go literally anywhere else. I suggest Langels or Arrenellos.

Large sausage and pepperoni.

See all

John's Pizzeria

3.2(35 reviews)

2.1 mi

Ordered $50 worth of food which included French Fries and we called to have add some ketchup…read morepackets (they don't have condiments), the delivery driver comes and doesn't have a pen to sign off and tip him. Oh oh.... the order also included a $15 salad and no forks Come on...

Everytime I've been to John's has been amazing for pizza ! Thank you!…read more Chunk sausage and pepperonis !

See all

Lazy shite.

Rico's Pizza

4.1(96 reviews)

5.3 mi

Really good Chicago thin crust/tavern style pizza pie. Nice staff, just across the border from…read moreIndiana. Lady who gave me my pizza called me hun 4 times. What a sweetie!

Ordered a medium sausage and it was delicious. $16.21 and it was actually huge. It was ready in 20…read moreminutes.

See all

Pepperoni and green olive

Squigi's Pizza of Highland

4.2(50 reviews)

1.9 mi

I was hungry and wanted to go somewhere close. This ended up being my stop…read more My significant other and I walked inside and unfortunately table service wasn't offered. I looked at the menu on the wall and then was offered a free menu, so that was cool. I went to the counter to order. From the CALZONE section, we got a Small - 10" Cheese for 12.00. The PIZZA section stated Hand -Tossed* Thin Crust*Thick Crust*Deep Dish. We got a Thin Crust Small - 10" Cheese for 12.00. We were told our order would be brought to us outside. We sat outside to wait for our order. It was brought out to us fast. I was excited to get back to our place to get started. The CALZONE was tasty. There was a red sauce in the box with it that amplified the flavor. The PIZZA was greasy, but I enjoyed it. The service was great. I didn't have any issues. Overall, I had a successful visit. I'm glad this place was close. Date of visit: 06/13/2025

Ordered delivery from the Hampton. From start to finish top notch experience. The man who took our…read moreorder was polite and thorough. The pizza came piping hot. And delicious. Well worth the mouth burns for such a great pizza. The only downside I'd say is that I had to share with my kids

See all

Capri's Pizza

3.6(136 reviews)

3.2 mi

Went in and asked if they do slices,an employee said only on weekends. I was trying to see the menu…read morebut it was very dark in the restaurant (early afternoon). It was my first time in the restaurant and I could see at least 5 people working(3 of which were right near the front counter). Not one person offered to help me,I stood there for over 5 minutes before leaving.Not a good first impression.

Driving through we wanted Chicago style pizza and stumbled on Capris. It was delicious. The sauce…read moreis sweet. Friendly service. Dated interior but didn't impact our food! Didn't take too long either.

Address: 837 Main St, Schererville, IN 46375 Phone: (219) 865‑9100

See all

Address: 837 Main St, Schererville, IN 46375 Phone: (219) 865‑9100

TD's Express Pizza

3.0(34 reviews)

1.8 mi

I used my debit card over the phone and my debit card information was completed. According to my…read morebank the charges began not long after we ordered food from there. I have had 43 charges attempted on my card since the. I now have no way to pull out money or make purchases during a state of emergency.

Over the years this place has gotten so much better for customer service. The pizza is really good…read moreBUT THE FRIED CHICKEN IS SO GOOD! It actually makes the pizza taste better ‍. The prices have changed over the years but you can get 8 pieces of fried chicken and an xl pizza with fries and buffalo sauce for about $35. Such a good deal and glad this place is in our town.

Front door, festive for Christmas.

See all

Storefront picture.

Amici Grill & Pizzeria

3.8(105 reviews)

0.5 mi

Got lunch here today while working. I've been here a couple times before over the years and have…read morealways been pretty happy with my experiences. Food is good, wide menu variety. Service is always friendly and efficient too. Got the Gyro pizza calzone which was way bigger than I expected, definitely worth at least two meals for me. Inside is clean and comfortable. I'd definitely go back to try other things they offer.

Great food, I've never had a bad meal when I've been here. Highly recommend this place.read more

Outside

Thin crust pizza. Sausage, onion and green pepper

See all

Signage outside

Jet's Pizza

3.9(7 reviews)

2.8 mi

Jet's Pizza -- Hammond, IN (7943 Indianapolis Blvd)…read more Jet's Pizza hits the spot... LET ME TELL YOU! The pizza was absolutely delicious -- perfectly baked crust, rich sauce, and generous toppings that make every bite worth it. The shop itself was spotless, and the staff worked fast and efficiently. Ordering online was a breeze; the site made customization simple and pickup timing accurate. If I had one small note, the price was just a tad high -- but honestly, the quality and speed make it easy to justify. You can tell they care about doing things right. If you're craving great pizza and smooth service, Jet's on Indianapolis Blvd is a solid choice.

I tried Jet's again since I saw a review of someone eating the 4 corner pizza and the CRUNCH I…read moreheard made me crave pizza. I did the order through TEXT message again and this time I did the 4 corner pizza with hamburger, mushroom and onion. It was GREAT - in fact, so much better than the last time. Cooked perfectly with a great crunch. I didn't realize you can also flavor your crust if you wish. I did the TURBO crust which was a mix of several seasonings and it's definitely recommended! I also ordered the medium size antipasta salad - which was okay. not the freshest salad, but it was full and definitely good for 2-3 people. I added a few additional toppings I had at home, but next time I will try their wings. I went inside the very small establishment in Hammond to pick it up this time. The gentleman working at the counter was super friendly, everything was on time and ready for pickup. I also added a 16 oz bottle of sugar free soda. That was like $2.50 for the soda, so it's not the cheapeast. I WILL come again...I thought I wouldn't be back, but I'm glad I tried it again!

7943 Indianapolis Blvd, Hammond, IN 46324 · (219) 339-5387

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Maria M.

0

1

0

3 years ago

Excellent service. Would recommend. I got my food earlier than told, but it was fresh, hot, and delicious!!!

Maria W.

0

7

0

8 years ago

The pizza tasted great, but for $84.00 I can get three large great tasting pizzas elsewhere.

David M.

0

4

0

13 years ago

Good lunch buffet!

Aurelio's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Aurelio's Pizza also viewed

Villa Pizza

4.2

(66 reviews)

I grew up on Villa Pizza, it was my grandfather's favorite. My mother preferred their roast beef…read moresandwiches. Twenty-five years later I am in town for my grandparents memorial, and I picked up roast beef sandwiches for my mom and I last night. The roast beef was every bit as I remember it. LOTS of meat, fantastic fries, and dirt cheap compared to fast food options. My only regret is that I forgot to ask for peppers. It's a rare thing when something from your childhood continues to live up to the memories. I'll definitely be ordering from there again before I leave town.

I arrived on a Wednesday at 4:38 pm to find a handwritten sign saying "Dining room closed." Thank…read moreyou for wasting my time.

State Line Pizza

3.9

(31 reviews)

This was our first time trying this spot. We did a pick up order . The pizza was hot and delicious…read more The sausage was tasty and so was the sauce . I loved the cheese in the crust on the deep dish . I would order again from here .

The most recent SLP was over the top! We live 3 miles from the Dyer location. The delivery was…read morepretty fast and hot. We get light sauce and our 14" pie was crispy. I just tried the new guy in town and it confirmeqd that State Line is my go to local.

Marco's Pizza

3.1

(28 reviews)

Did not care for their online ordering website but what I ordered I was pleasantly surprised by…read more Very tasty!! Unfortunately I was craving anchovies (I know I'm gross lol) but this location doesn't have them even though advertised. The staff quickly called to replace it or offer a refund. I will definitely be returning.

I ordered a pizza for pickup today as there was a promotion for half off so I ordered a sausage…read morepizza and picked it up and drove home and I opened up the box and had sausage, pepperoni and had so much Parmesan cheese that it was way too much I tried to scrape it off but it was no use I had to force myself to try and eat some because I'm diabetic and hadn't eaten anything I was disappointed because don't have money to throw away so I have pizza to throw away.

Miller Pizza Company

4.0

(160 reviews)

1.Best Pizza 2.Drive there from Mishawaka…read more3. The way Pizza should be 4.Wife is from Maine says Miller Pizza is the best she has ever had 5.

Miller's is a community GEM! They hit the spot after a long day at the beach. This is a walk in…read moreonly spot but they do have some outdoor seating for those beautiful summer days. The food was good. We ordered a supreme pizza with a side of wings. All of it was tasty. Service was good, nothing to complain about.

Arrenello's Pizza

3.7

(92 reviews)

Given the St John location isn't on here yet, I'll put it here. Highland location, fantastic. St…read more John, horrible. All young kids who don't know how to multitask which tells me management isn't training properly and just hiring cheap labor. They turn the phones off because they're "swamped," which seems to be the only word they were trained to use. A very rehearsed response. I went in and there were 6-7 of us in line and 3 waiting. 3 kids working the front taking orders (one main girl and one going back and forth and another STANDING by the phone). Multiple kids throwing pizzas in the back (as you can see through the glass showcase). Turning their phones off isn't about being "swamped" it's about trying to manipulate consumers into thinking they're swamped if a consumer goes there in person. Shady business tactics to use on consumers in today's economy. Their prices are obscenely high. $17 for a small pizza with one topping is a joke. The son should not be running this business. Not worth it, take your money elsewhere. People only think it's good now because it's someplace new to try. There are four other pizza joints within 2-3 min from this place.

Grew up eating this pizza. Though I prefer the Glenwood location you can't go wrong at any of the…read morethree. Kevin and his team serve great pies and props to his father for creating this legendary pizza.

Toni's Pizza

3.4

(11 reviews)

I knew it would happen sometime and it did yesterday. I ordered a medium pizza and received a small…read moreone instead, plus, it was a "re-heat" one! Yep, I know a re-heat pizza when I see one, hence I won't order from this place anymore; shame I've ordered from there a lot over the years.

Love the hot wings and pizza. Been going here for about 3 years and the service is always good.read more

Venice Pizza

4.0

(22 reviews)

I only have had their pizza. Pizza is good! Crust is perfect. Well done is the way to go! The lady…read morethat takes order is always wonderful! Price is great! Cute place on the inside!

Contrary to what some others have written, I found my experience with the order taker as well as…read morebeing rung up and greeted once inside went very well. It was a pleasant experience. Very friendly and professional. The Yelp menu did not match the correct menu and items were markedly higher than posted on Yelp.com. Get it together! I pizza was very good. I have never had a pizza using red Spanish onions before today which gave the pizza sweeter, more unusual taste. Visually the colors used on the pizza made it look very appetizing. This pizza stood out from that of their competitors and had a different, more unique flavor which was pleasing. Try it! The crust was too cracker-like and could use some improvements. I like a very thin crust and this wasn't it. Enjoy!

Giuseppe's Restaurant

3.9

(241 reviews)

This review is long overdue as my husband and I have been coming here for a few years--not…read moreregularly--but enough times to let people know to support this small, family-owned business. The ambiance is cozy and inviting with only 14 tables. Yes, only 14. Instead of expanding to the masses, this restaurant chooses to keep its vision to retain dining as the experience it should be. The murals on the wall, and the feeling of being in an outdoor cafe while remaining inside, is something you don't see much in the area. The food is always fresh and delicious. We've enjoyed lasagna, manicotti, carbonara, fettuccine, piccata (chicken with capers), Marsala, salad and desserts. The wine is served in large glasses so you get a nice serving to enjoy some Chianti or choose another nice Italian wine on the list. The restaurant serves wine and beer only, and coffee drinks. I've heard the pizza is great but haven't tried it yet. It always looks good when another table orders it. Carry out is available in the back of the building. The owner is very nice and will talk about his Italian heritage with a warm smile. This restaurant is truly a little gem hidden behind big box stores. It makes a nice date night too. Make a reservation on Friday or Saturday.

Hello, the food is good. Service by Anna was TERRIBLE! I have never experienced bad service like…read morethis. I sat and watched how Anna treated the other customers. She only checked on me once, was very dry. What is worse after waiting about 20 minutes for her to take my payment, well that never happened. I went up to the counter to pay my bill. She picked up all of the other customers bills at their table.This was my 4th time dinning in, first time ever receiving this type of service. I felt HURT and VERY sad leaving. I never intentionally treat people bad. The other young ladies that waited on me in the past were very kind and attentive. She was clearly having a good day by the way she interacted with the other customers. Lastly after taking my payment she never stayed to see the transaction through. Immediately I took my receipt and left. No excuse for this type of behavior. I will never return to this establishment. Cafe Borgia, service is Top of the line. The owners greet you and talk to you. Servers are OUTSTANDING! Anna should go there for training!

Pizza Mex

3.2

(13 reviews)

Food is good and prices are low but as far as delivery well that's the only down fallread more

Poor customer service. I first issued a complaint on fb through . I sent my photo. I then called…read morethe next day and was told that that was not their fb page. I asked for a manager and I was told that since I had complained on yelp that I would not be given another pizza. They lost a new customer.

Wana Pizza

3.9

(20 reviews)