Our second time here. It's a nice quaint little place with maybe a dozen tables. Beautifully decorated like an Italian side street. We ordered a thin crust pizza, spinach, garlic and mushrooms and it was amazing! I can't rave enough about it. We also ordered a bottle of Chianti wine and it was a perfect dinner for two. Service is good, but I have a feeling that if you're a regular, service would match a high end spot downtown! Not saying it's bad, but I think the staff knows how to service the regulars. I kills me to give it such high remarks as I'm afraid that more will find this gem, but I have to give them credit, it's really nice, no other way to say it. ( the pizza was so good, we were craving the leftovers the next night!) read more

Came here on a Saturday night and we really enjoyed the food! The service here was good too and our waitress helped Us out when we needed it. We ordered the shrimp Alfredo which we loved and also the 16inch olive and mushroom pizza which was so great tasting. I highly Recommend coming here! read more

Giuseppe's Restaurant - Olive and mushroom pizza which was excellent - Italian Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

See all

The wood fired grill taste for the napoleon's pizza is great. It's a small business so seating is scarce be prepared to wait for locals that know about this hidden gem. read more

I visited for the first time today. Saying I'll be back is an understatement. Wild horses couldn't keep me away. Everything was fantastic! From the bread and oil to the arancini to the chicken francese to my beautiful gf's pizza. Service was friendly and attentive. Run, don't walk to thus cozy spot. read more

Food was disappointing,thought it was very bland. Not what I was looking forward to.The bread was the only item that had a good Italian garlic flavor. Service wasn't good. It took way to long for our food to come out. Too small and cramped in there and you get cold air blowing on you every time the door opens. First and last time I'll eat there. read more

This is our second time dining at this restaurant. The first time, I had the sausage and peppers with penne pasta and was very disappointed. Very little sausage, even less peppers and too much pasta. Our group shared a large antipasto salad which was very good. My husband had the Italian Beef sandwich- it was fantastic and a few of us had the calzones - delicious! I had the house cab and loved it! Tonight we dined in again. We ordered the Capres salad and I was so disappointed. The tomatoes were hot house, too firm, no taste. It did advertise that it was served with EVO, but I was wanting the basalmic vinegar. The EVO did nothing for this ridiculously bland salad. The price was for 4 pieces of tomato/mozzarella/ Basil. The restaurant itself is very small, and you can hardly negotiate around the tables. I'm not a large person and to get in/ Out the people at the other tables had to move their chairs. Order the Italian Beed sandwich to go and you'll be happy. read more

There pizza are delicious whether it's deep dish to thin, but overall everything they offer is great including there Sangria. Love taking my wife out for dinner!! read more

Visiting from out of state and was recommended this place by a friend.My go to Italian place no longer serves lasagna so I was looking for a place that did.The host John greeted me upon arrival as I was the first customer of the day.Service and Food were excellent.The interior is very cozy.Giuseppis is definitely on my list when back in town. read more

Ambiance, is a 10. Couldn't be better. Make sure to have a reservation, the place is small and fills up. Great pizza. Mild tasting sauce, not too salty. So beautiful to look at I didn't want to eat it. Skip the mozzarella sticks on the appetizer menu. Same mozzarella sticks you would get at a gyros shop. Some confusion with the wait staff, so be patient. Overall, so happy I found this spot. read more

Giuseppe's Restaurant - 12 inch pepperoni pizza. - A cheese pizza with a thick crust, melted cheese, and tomato sauce on a white plate at a restaurant table. - Italian Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

Great food. Pasta is excellent. Specials on Thursday Lasagna is very good Specials most days of the week read more

Ordered pizzas for a 6:40pm delivery....never showed up and they didn't pick up their phone until 8pm...they said they were busy, unfortunately too busy to even let us know that they could no longer deliver. Brutal... read more

Amazing pizza! We had the thin crust pepperoni and the thin crust Canadian bacon & pineapple. My husband is always searching for the best pizza and he loved it! read more

Pizza was horrible, the sauce was sour and the cheese was so cheap it has absolutelyno stretch and tasted like plastic. The delivery driver was extremely rude on the phone and in person. He ordered me to come outside and refused bring the pizza up to my apartment because he said he didn't want to get robbed when I live about 1000 yards from the police station. He was confrontational the whole time and It's the first time in my life I've never left someone a tip before. I will never buy pizza from this establishment again the pizza was terrible and the delivery driver was an absolute D bag! read more

The place was very small inside so it's best to go early on Sundays. I had the rolled eggplant dish in which it was brought to my table burnt on the bottom and for the price, they don't give you enough food. read more

SOOOOO GOOD! I cannot talk about anything without addressing how much love and care goes into their food. I've been here a few times, and you can tell there are frequent regulars. The staff try to really get to know their customers, and their food is so fresh and delicious. I absolutely love it here read more

Adjusted this 5 star review to 3 stars, bc the food is still good here. The service is hit or miss though. I came here over the weekend and brought family there expecting a friendly server like I usually have in the past. Dulce was so pleasant I immediately wrote a review about how good she was. And this time I was instead met with a very rude server. Christina was very unpleasant and made my family feel very uncomfortable. I feel like the service cost on the bill and the tip i left should have been paid back to me for having to deal with such an attitude on a beautiful Sunday afternoon. read more

Giuseppe's Restaurant - Margherita pizza- needs fresh basil though - A cheese pizza with melted cheese and a slightly burnt crust, served in a pizza box with some basil leaves. - Italian Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

See all

We've been looking for a local place with Neapolitan pizza and I'm happy to say that we finally found one! This pizza was fantastic and exactly what we were looking for. Golden bubbles on the tender chewy crust with fresh ingredient who could as for more?! We ordered the PRIMAVERA ($18): E.V.O.O., fior di latte mozzarella, fresh arugula, fresh chopped tomatoes, prosciutto crudo and shaved parmigiano. This is my new favorite. It is perfectly balanced salty, creamy, crispy with a little chew and is comparable to much more expensive pizzas that I've had. We also tried the MARGHERITA WITH BUFALA ($17): Imported San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh Italian buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and E.V.O.O.. Also delicious - a delicate classic what's not to like. The Neapolitan pizzas only come in one size (I'd guess 12") and you will eat more than you think. I'd recommend trying a variety depending on your party. I'd like to say I'll be back to try their regular pizza, but honestly, I'm not sure that I can get anything other than the Primavera lol! If I try anything new, I will update the review. I ordered take out so I cannot speak to the table service. The take out/pick up window is an old-school walk-up window in the rear of the building. Luckily someone else informed me of this because there was no signage to direct you to the back. *Fun tip * There's a cupcake place in the same strip mall with tasty desserts read more

See all

Forget all the positive reviews from the past because they don't apply to whatever is going on now. The food was terrible , we were told they had no bread and my party was there within an hour of opening -we were still charged a service fee for their nonexistent bread. The red sauce was of a very dark color and tasted burnt. I told the waitress the sauce tasted off and her reply was " nobody has ever complained about it". The party seated to our right spoke up for us and said that was not the look or smell of dishes they had in the past - waitress said " well that's the way we make it as of a month ago". read more

Always a lovely time at Giuseppe's. Have been many times. Sometimes, there is a wait (but it is well worth it!) I am a bit picky, so my favorites are pretty basic, but their tortellini and their margherita pizza are heavenly. The restaurant is themed to look like you are actually in a small town in Italy, with the walls resembling facades of buildings and the wallpaper, a mural of an Italian town. I appreciate the effort they put into aesthetics. (Although the effort they put into their food is much greater.) Very cozy, no obnoxious music. Waiters and waitresses are always very kind and accommodating to making suggestions and notes when guests have any dietary restrictions. Can't wait to visit again. I miss their cannolis! read more

Food and service was amazing. Small cozy restaurant but would go back. Definitely recommend.

I've reviewed before, but I felt the need to add yet another review for the amazing lasagna. My husband and I order two lasagna dinners to go--we eat one and save or freeze the other for another day. It is absolutely delicious! Seriously, if you freeze it, it bakes up perfectly. I will never make lasagna again, because Giuseppe's is the best! Everything on their menu is delicious (at least what we have had), and our friends brag about the pizza. We also love the antipasto platter. Thank you, and Happy New Year! read more

Consistently tasty food. The minestrone soup is delicious. The free, warm, homemade (I assume) bread is a nice warmup for your main dish. I won't list the particular menu items as there are many. Try 'em all. I haven't found one I wouldn't have again. read more

Been on a mission to find Neapolitan pizza in NWI that was worth anything. And I think I finally have in Giuseppe's! I had the margherita and they nailed it. My husband got a thin crust supreme and we both loved their regular (non-neopolitan) pizza too. We're pretty snobby when it comes to pizza so this was a great surprise. Picked up pizzas to go so nothing to report on ambience/service. But we will for sure be back! read more

It's small inside, but the food is always good and servers polite. Tonight we had the pizza delivered. It was very good.

Really good Italian food,fresh..small place ,very small,may have to wait for table Very large portion read more

This is a hidden gem that combines authentic flavors with impeccable service. The pizza the pasta! Everything season well! The ambiance is cozy and inviting, making every dining experience memorable. From the perfectly cooked pasta dishes to the delectable desserts, every bite is a culinary delight. A must-visit for any food lover! Come Wednesday nights for 1/2 bottle of wine! read more

Cute place tucked behind Overstock store. My husband had the pizza and I ordered the linguine with white clam sauce. The pizza was very good, chewy crust tasty sauce. More than enough for one person. Now onto the linguine. I had not had it in a long time and it sounded really delicious. However it had a weird smell, like something was burnt. Not sure if the clams were bad or they used too much alcohol in it. I ate some of it and kindly took the rest home and then discarded it. The other thing I didn't care for was the canned and bottled drinks. You have a sit down restaurant that takes reservations but you serve drinks like it's a fast food place. I only gave it 3 stars for this reason. If we go back gonna stick to the pizza and they can keep the clammy linguini. read more

Great food horrible service. If you're going to be open until 9, don't stop serving customers at 8. If you run out of bread at 7:30 BAKE MORE!!!! read more

Just not what I hoped. We got there ordered the garlic bread and the arrechini as appetizers. The garlic bread was oil and garlic powder. The arrechini was the best part of the meal. My nephew ordered the linguine with clam sauce and I got the chicken Francesa. They both were screaming for flavor. The service was really slow too. Maybe their pizza is better. But the pasta was a hot mess. I won't be back. read more

Love the eggplant dishes, the arancini, and any of the Pizza Napoletana. Excellent sauce! We live close by and pick up pretty regularly. Dining room is tiny. Service can be spotty slow, but the food makes up for it. read more

Ordered takeout from here tonight. Ravioli was delicious! Pizza and pasta tasted fresh. The meatballs were a bit too salty. The dining area was an intimate setting. I look forward to going on a date with hubby here! Pick up is in the back! read more

Ordered pizza delivery 2 separate times less than 2 miles away both times took forever to actually receive the food and it was received cold the delivery guy was rude the first time the second delivery girl was nicer then the last guy but still ridiculous how I have given this place multiple Chances and they continue to disappoint the pizza itself isn't bad I've had it a previous time to these two but a friend picked it up and it was pretty good. So if you are going to go here just don't get delivery. read more

Service was below average, waiter did not check on us once, tiramisu was frozen solid, but pizza was very good Ambiance was nice read more

Went here today on a whim with a girlfriend, because our favorite Italian place (Livio's) was closed on Tuesdays. The place was cute and cozy and smelled good. It was also empty. Our server brought us a basket of nice looking little knotted bread....warm, but awful. Hard and tasteless. I ordered the linguine Alfredo with chicken, and my friend ordered the chicken franchese. The Alfredo sauce was awful, possibly the worst I ever had. Lumpy and gritty and chewy. The chicken was grilled (over grilled) with black charring. I took a few bites and when our server came to ask how everything was, I told him my dish was awful. He asked if I'd like something else, and I really didn't. My friends dish was okay. It had a nice lemon sauce. He took my dish off the bill. Very disappointing meal. Too bad, it was a cute place. I will say, they had nice clean bathrooms. Sometimes you find a gem.....sometimes not so much. read more

Giuseppe's Restaurant - Dining area - A dining area featuring tables with white tablecloths, wooden chairs, and a large mural of an Italian canal scene on the wall. - Italian Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

This is the best Italian sausage I have ever had. I tried the Italian sausage & green peppers on my first visit and have gone back several times since. I added a piece of Italian sausage to their Gnocchi and meatballs dinner loved it even more! great, friendly service and atmosphere. Only ten tables, so call for reservations if you're having dinner. read more

This used to be a gem, we would go there a couple times a month, we support them through Covid. Within the last 6 months things have changed. Food is not as good and the quality of the food seems to have declined. I'm not sure what the issue is but we have decided not to return after several disappointing meals. read more

Great food. A cozy place to dine and the decor is cool too. Every time I've gone the service is great.

"NY guy seeks real pizza in Chicagoland" The headline says it all. I know I cannot find real NY pizza in places other the the NY, NJ, Philly, Poconos and Southern Florida where old time Italian pizza makers moved and passed on the craft, but I thought I'd try in Chicago. My friends warned me not to even mention NY pizza in the Chicago area as people would get mad. Ahhh, I did anyway. I figured what's the worst that can happen? I get into a heart pumping (aerobics) first fight? Luckily, the folks in Guiesippie's contained themselves when I asked they make my pizza with thin crust and make it crispy like a NY pizza. They did a good job! The only thing missing is the anchovy. The sauce is not NY style but good. Overall, pretty good. There are about 20 people eating in this little gem as I write this. I also had the garlic bread. It too was good. One person told me this is the best pizza in the area. Humm, I guess I'll have to try other places to find out. The staff here is very nice. The dining area is comfortable. I have no complaints about this place at all. read more

Giuseppe's Restaurant - My special request pizza - Italian Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

See all

I walked in here to dine inside and it was a really small space. The tables were very close to each other, so that's one thing that turned me off in the beginning. I ordered a diet soda and it was served in a can, which also turned me off early on. I shrugged it off and browsed the menu. They served us a few rolls along with a jug of oil. The rolls were a bit hard, but they were free, so it's hard to complain about free items. I ordered the Margherita Pizza and a Chicken Dumpling Soup. The Soup was unique with an array of spices flowing through the broth. The chicken and dumplings were both plentiful throughout the soup. It was a great shot at redemption for them after the few first calls of judgement. I made a plate of my significant other's House Salad. It had flavors flowing throughout, especially from their dressing. The vegetables were very fresh tasting. The Margherita Pizza was a great size for the price. It was a bit thin, but I love how there wasn't really grease on the bottom. It seems like a healthier alternative to a standard pizza. The service was fast and everything we needed was handled nicely. We didn't have any issues at all with the service. Overall, I enjoyed the food, but to me it's not a great place to sit down and eat. Next time, I'd probably pick up my order. read more

First time here and love it! Great food and atmosphere. Highly recommend! Serve is a pleasant experience. read more