My visits at little Italy have always been a great one. The food is good and the service was pleasant. The ambiance is calm and friendly. I love this about the restaurant. My recommendation is for the server to communicate when someone is an up charge. Outside of that I would recommend this restaurant. read more

Little Italy - Chicken Alfredo - Italian Near Me - Dyer, Indiana

Went for Mothers Day and food ( Risotto balls, vodka sauce rigatoni, chicken alfredo ) was really great. Service was the best! Lauren was our server and she was really terrific, very attentive ,knowledgeable and fun. Little Italy was a great choice. read more

Little Italy - chicken alfredo - Italian Near Me - Dyer, Indiana

See all

Best Italian restaurant in town!!! The lasagna and spaghetti and meatballs are my favorites. The fresh bread is delicious and always good with the food. The waitress was really nice I just can't remember her name. The restaurant was very warm and welcoming read more

Little Italy - Italian Near Me - Dyer, Indiana

I hadn't been here in over a year. Was so happy to be back. The bread was delicious although only one loaf was sliced. I came with 2 friends. I ordered the ceasar salad, which came with way too much Parmesan crunch that tasted salty & a bit burnt. Very disappointing. I also ordered the fried shrimp appetizer that came with roasted assorted peppers. I assumed the peppers would be like a slaw or sautéed. It was a plate of fried stuff. The shrimp were great. The rest was greasy & salty. So I only ate half of my food. Our server was sweet, but I had to beg for a water refill. Only got that once. Not very attentive. Maybe it's because it was half off certain wines night. We weren't drinking. My friends enjoyed their food more than me. The place is cute & clean. Not rushing to go back. read more

See all

Very authentic Italian food. A very quaint restaurant with a very wonderful crew. Try their Eggplant parmesian and realize that it is not like other restaurants parmesian. This is authentic and has a different taste and texture. It was wonderful. Our waiter was awesome. It was a wonderful experience. read more

Little Italy - Italian Near Me - Dyer, Indiana

Great authentic Italian food ! Reasonably Priced. All seems to be freshly made no (yesterday left overs ! Worth the visit and easy on the wallet ! read more

Food and service are great took friends there to thank them it was very nice friends love the place

Little Italy is a restaurant that serves great food and provides great service on site. My issue is with a door dash order. Today, I placed an order for fettuccine Alfredo, the site states that the order comes with Alfredo sauce and fettuccine noodles. when the order was delivered, it contained chicken. I spoke with a manager over the phone, and was informed that while she could remake the order, I would have to pick it up as they have no driver's available. I'm unable to pick the order up at this time, and explained that to her. She informed me that there was nothing else that she could do on her end, that if I would like to receive a refund that I would have to negotiate it through door dash. Whole I'm unhappy with this specific incident, I would still recommend the restaurant for the dinner in experience. read more

Food is outstanding. Great sized portions. Service spot on. I have had dinner in Italian restraints in the Little and the row on Oakley Avenue in Chicago and stacks up with the best of them . Highly recommend. read more

tried little italy for the first time with a group of 6 and would definitely come back. the service was incredible. i also loved the family style aspect. the bread was definitely homemade - literally could not stop eating it. the lemon vinaigrette salad dressing was super tasty. everyone else's loved their entrees but my salmon was super small and a bit dry. the pasta being served with every entree was a nice touch. i never want to order a full pasta dish and this gets you the best of both worlds. we ended with the tiramisu which was a HUGE portion. but super tasty. overall, a great experience. i wouldn't order the salmon next time but would love to try the pizza. highly recommend! read more

Little Italy - Maple&Balsamic Glazed Salmon - Italian Near Me - Dyer, Indiana

We are new to Indiana. We tried Little Italy a few weeks ago and have been coming every Friday since. The food is absolutely amazing. The service is top notch and our overall experience is amazing every time. Highly recommended read more

Had our first date at little italy about 4 years ago, and this summer we held our wedding celebration dinner here. This place has fantastic food and their staff went out of their way for our party. I highly recommend this place for any occasion! read more

Little Italy - Wedding Dinner Party - Italian Near Me - Dyer, Indiana

Best lasagna in town only on Wednesday. Arrive early before it sells out. !!!!!!!!!!!!!9 read more

Nuvia was as fabulous as the food! Worth the drive to Dyer for an upbeat atmosphere and excellent food selection. A delightful evening- reservations are suggested. read more

This was my first time and I ordered to go. The bread is really good. They didn't give me oil and parmesan. I will ask for it next time. The picture shows only half of the bread and the bread was warm. The salad was just okay, they make their own ceaser dressing the cheese chips were great on it. They give you a good portion for a small. I ordered the fettuccine alfredo. It has a good flavor. It automatically comes with chicken and broccoli and red peppers. I added the zucchini and squash. They needed to cook the veggies a little longer, I don't like crunchy veggies . Overall, I would go back and try the lasagna. I'm sure if I ate in the restaurant it would be good as well. read more

Little Italy - Ceaser salad and house bread - Italian Near Me - Dyer, Indiana

See all

Came here for the first time for a Saturday lunch. Made reservations just in case and luckily we did because actually filled up for lunch due to the large private parties they were hosting in their spaces. It is located in a strip mall and shares a parking lot with other businesses and parking was hard to come by. In fact, if you cannot find a parking space, you can park on the grass behind the restaurant. Service was super friendly and helpful. Doug really made the lunch enjoyable and made a very good first impression for our first visit. The menu is quite expensive as far as choices especially if you like white sauces, red sauces, meat, or no meat. Portions were very generous, and the food came out very well timed. Needless to say we had lots of leftovers. Ambience was very cute, especially because the entire place was decorated for Christmas. If I'm in the area again, would definitely come back as this is a very good Italian restaurant with solid traditional menu items. read more

See all

If someone tells you the chicken parm here is good, go ahead and remove their number from your phone and move on with your life because you are better off without them. I've tried it two times now to make sure my experiment wasn't a fluke. Terrible taste - almost acidic. Twice I've had it, twice I've had to run to the bathroom afterward to refund. Salad was honestly insulting. Tasted old. Not sure what people love about this place. Tons of good reviews, so it makes me wonder what the hell they usually eat if they enjoy this drool. read more

Had a party of 18 service was fantastic food was amazing! Waitress was very attentive!!!!

Great food and wonderful service. Always a great atmosphere. Staff is very attentive and friendly.

We have become regulars since moving to NWI last summer. Food is always delicious, and service is always on point.

Addison was a FANTASTIC waitress. Attentive & friendly in helping me celebrate my birthday. Food was outstanding as always. Prime Rib was excellent ! Love this restaurant. Christmas lights everywhere inside read more

Little Italy - Red sangria pitcher - Italian Near Me - Dyer, Indiana

See all

Top notch classy. The food tastes like you made it at home. Good taste, good seasonings, fresh, delicious. Service is fast courteous professional friendly. Reasonably priced for the amount of food you get. read more

Dinner | $20-30 Everything was perfect. The place was full and they had no problem keeping up. We only get in the area twice a year and you can bet we will make this a regular stop on those visits. read more

Great food, enough for two. Service was excellent never was ignored. Pricing is very reasonable.

Best Italian in the region that I've tried by far. Portions are generous af as well. The chicken Alfredo (I know it's basic) is specifically sooooo good. Great for dates too. Highly recommend this to anyone in the region. read more

What a N Indiana gem. Great home made itialian food, great service, super affordable. This is our Go-To for itialian food. Let's not forget the generous portions. Take a friend - you will not be disappointed. read more

It's so rare to get a server of the quality of Doug and it's to the point nowadays, where the service is as important, if not more so than the food quality. Kuddos to Doug on being such a great waiter and the food is the best in Northwest Indiana. We love the ambience of the music also. Great place! read more

Food is out of this world. The employees are very personable. Haven't tried their pizza yet, but heard it is good. Their salads are large and fresh. read more

Good food, good drinks and good service!our waitress was very attentive. We had everything we needed before we even asked.

This place is GREAT! The food is fantastic, the service is great, ambiance is wonderful! My wife and I came to dinner here and other than a little wait( very busy!) everything was perfect! Keep up the great job! read more

The service is always a 10 ! The food is always a 10! One of the best places to dine in Indiana .

The food here was delicious. The atmosphere was wonderful. The staff was great. Five stars.

The food and cocktails are excellent. Portions are large. Service is great. High marks.

Wonderful family style Italian restaurant that is not overly priced. Generous portions, food was excellent, and the server was also very friendly and attentive. Family friendly as well read more

The food is excellent and the service was very good. The ambiance is awesome - warm and inviting.

Food was great! Perfect for date nights! Very pleased! No matter what I order, it's top shelf!

First time won't be the last. Holy shit, what a gem of a restaurant! If you love family style Italian this place should be on the top of your list. Started with crispy mozzarella in a parmesan coating with a very complimentary marinara, a simple but this case an enticing appetizer of things to come.. Chicken parm in a light crunch coating and a flavorful homemade marinara. Sausage and peppers a staple, consisted of 2 sausage links consisting of a savory blend of meat, fennel, and select spices was a masterpiece. Fennel can be overpowering if heavy handed but this blend was just enough. Pepperonata and again the marinara were great. Fresh tasty, hot bread, tableside bowl of zitti and salad were a great complement to our meal. Top it off with a nicely trained and friendly server and seating hostess and you have a fairly priced meal that is delicious. I recently reviewed an Italian restaurant on Calumet and this place blows their doors off. Keep up the good work chef and staff, it was a pleasure dining with you. read more

I found this place because of a random google search and I am SO HAPPY that Google came through with this gem! I ordered the risotto balls, meatballs, and spinach Alfredo. Everything is seasoned well and generally flavorful. The Alfredo was not overly sauced and the portion sizes are HUGE! I'm glad my instinct was to get the "Little Italy," because I would have been eating this for days I'll definitely be back! Kudos to the proprietor! read more

Little Italy - This is AFTER I've eaten half! I'm stuffed! - Italian Near Me - Dyer, Indiana

Tried Little Italy for the first time today and to cut to the chase I will be back. The service was 10/10, Doug was very friendly and easygoing. He explained the menu and had recommendations. Really great guy. The food was also 10/10. We started with Calamari, it was fresh, the breading was perfect and well seasoned. We had a house salad with vinaigrette. I was happy to see spring mix. For entrees we had the rigatoni without the peas. Very good and filling. The sausage was good too. We also had the sausage and peppers, there was a slight kick to it which I liked. For dessert we had tiramisu. I didn't think I had much room left but we cleared the plate! For cocktails we had the shaken lemonade, very close to a lemon drop. Also very good. All in all, I'm glad we decided to try a new restaurant today. read more

See all

This place is amazing. The food is excellent. The wine is great. The service is fantastic. Shout out to Sam who brought my package I left on the table to the our car. Love the music, the ambiance just everything. read more

Little Italy - Chicken parmigiana. - Italian Near Me - Dyer, Indiana