Had the ham sub with hot peppers on the side!! Omg! It was nice and hot and great! Had it built on garlic bread which was delicious. Service was excellent. Food came out quickly. I definitely will be back to try the beef and also the chicken sandwich!! Very happy I tried this restaurant. read more

Good food great beef sandwich. But my large shells was half full, 6 bucks for a short order. read more

Pepino's Restaurant - Half full, full price check before you leave - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

I love the beef sandwiches and the pizza ain't bad either. Large portions of beef on the beef sandwich and very filling, it was a good challenge trying to eat but very delicious. read more

Stopped coming here because old owner was rude to my wife because my daughter, 4 years old at the time, was trying to open the door for guest coming in. Staff had a fit because they just replaced the door because the old one was damaged. As great as the food was, I refused to ever step in there again. FFWD 8yrs.... Read new management, tried again! We were treated nice, food still good, tables were clean, and maybe I need to reconnect! read more

Pepino's Restaurant - Pasta and meatballs! Nice - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

See all

Went in to get a sandwich with extra hot peppers and the aggravated employee came back and did not give me what I asked for even gave me a hard time with her nose, lip hearing and having a difficult time fighting Had a conversation with owner and he couldn't believe like it was my fault when it was actually his employees and horseshit service that sound good. read more

My so fantastic! Service was amazing! Friendly and helpful. Presentation was exquisite. The Ambience was really nice. Upbeat a little eclectic. The menu was over the top! Our meal was served hot and delicious! So Beautiful! read more

Pepinos originally from Calumet City was very well known for it's Italian beefs. This was not the case at the new location in Indiana. If you're looking for what that once was in Calumet City go to Portillo's. The fries are amazing! The lasagna sauce was good yet it could have used more meat. The ladies at the front desk were very nice and it was a very clean location. Overall, I give this place 2.5 stars out of 5. It's not the worst place to get this kind of food but again...there's a Portillo's right down the street. I'm just going there from now on. read more

See all

Best beef sandwich around so much meat. It's hard to even finish it.. Lasagna and stuffed shells remind me of my Sicilian grandmother's recipe. read more

There's some decent food here. I like some stuff a lot like the pasta salads and the pizza is underrated. I don't care for a lot of the menu, but I think that's a personal preference thing, I think most people would like it more than I do. I do like the mostaciolli, though. Prices are okay. The beef is HUGE but wasn't super flavorful TO ME, but I know others who love it. read more

People ask me what I look forward to about coming home to Indiana and Italian beef sandwiches sit near the top of that list. I don't think people get it until they've tried one from northwest Indiana and Pepinos does it well! You can choose from Italian beef, Italian sausage or both. Your choice of cheese, mozzarella is standard. And then your choice of topping. I do giardiniera. Next time I might also try a side of red sauce. This shop was straight forward, clean, friendly, and delicious! Would happily return when back in town. Thank you! read more

Pepino's Restaurant - Combo sandwich- Italian beef and Italian sausage - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

I should have read the description of this place more carefully.Didnt know it was more of a fast food type place.Order at the counter and they bring it to you.Portion was very large,however they don't serve wine which I prefer to have when eating Italian.Seems like most people order through the drive through. read more

Good food. Reasonably priced. Huge Italian Beef Combo Sandwich - with sausage. Fries were really good for a pizza type place. Service was friendly and ridiculously fast. read more

Pepino's Restaurant - Italian Beef and Sausage Sandwich with Sweet Peppers and Side of Fries - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

We did a catering order for work and it was so amazing! The shells, meatballs, chicken and more were phenomenal! Everyone was super happy! Thanks to the staff and cooks who catered! read more

The Ribeye Steak Sandwich is to die for, I would like to have it once a month but I get busy. It does stay on my mind They Grill and Prepare The Sandwich in front of you behind a sealed glass. The meat is juicy, the charred marks will send you to the moon after the 1st Bite as the melted cheese, grilled onions, and grilled peppers hit your taste buds. Soda is Free Refills #WinWin read more

Ate here one time and the food was amazing the next time I went there not so good so I never went back again

We tried Pepinos for the first time today. Everyone raves about it. I found the mostaccioli sauce flavor less and noodles tasted like unseasoned water. The beef sandwich had a large portion of beef but again tasteless. Portillo's is much better! Tried and disappointed read more

This was recommended to me as an alternative and better option for Italian beef. This place is all Italian, period, and it all looked so good. My goal was to try to beef and so did. It was really good... I wouldn't say better than other options but maybe slightly different. I will say the sandwich was huge. I would like to come back to try some of the other delicious dishes we saw other patrons eating. read more

Been a customer since it was originally in Calumet City IL. Authentic homemade Italian sausage. Excellent homemade hot giardiniera. Great homemade potato salad. Wonderful Italian beef. ONLY Italian restaurant in No West IN w REAL Italian food. I would know since I started making sausage, pasta, & canning ciabot w my mother before I was even old enough to go to school! Only drawback is no AC in there. It's a long ride for me but if I'm out that way it's well worth it! Hard to believe Buona Beef is run by an Italian family bc the ONLY good items in there are the hamburgers, fries, Chicago dogs, & chili! Nothing on their menu that's supposedly "Italian" is any good-- unless ur NOT Italian & don't know any better! Highly recommend Pepinos! An anecdote-- when I was flying to Vegas to perform at Mandalay Bay (shortly before 911) I brought Pepinos sausage sandwiches & beef sandwiches on the plane. OMG! U wouldn't believe how much cash I was offered for them! Even the flight attendants were drooling over them! Hey-- the sandwiches were for me! Not even the hot guy sitting next to me (he looked like an even hotter Billy Baldwin) could persuade me to selll him one! He was flying there to attend a family wedding & invited me to be his date. Great flight for a single gal who thought she'd just be enjoying a great meal on her way to perform at a great place! But--I do have to agree w R Kevin S's updated review about the staff. Never a complaint about the food-- but it's a crap shoot re how staff will treat u! I had the SAME experiences R Kevin S did about going there at 7:20, 7:30pm-- staff was already putting chairs up on tables. When I'd go there at those times it was strictly for take out. Even if I just wanted potato salad to go-- which just had to be scooped out of container at the counter-- rude attitude. Approximately half of staff is friendly but others are rude. I had one female employee actually yell at me once! How dare anyone come in & expect to get take out when we don't want to be bothered 30mins before closing? That's the attitude. I tend to stay away for a long time after an unpleasant experience there. Like I said-- the food is great-- or else I wouldn't go back! read more

I ordered this pizza on a lazy Sunday because I saw it had many great reviews. I always try out new pizza places, thin crust is my go to. Overall, I would give this place an "ok." The crust was hard and stale, but if you ate the pizza from the inside of the pie then it tasted great. One great thing from this place that I appreciated was the fast delivery time, so I will say that part was great. read more

Pepino's Restaurant - Thin crust pizza - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

You never fail to disappoint!!!! FANTASTIC!!!! I'm not even going on and on, you must go here!! You MUST try this food!!! I've been going here since they were in Cal City and I'll follow them anywhere!!! The BEST beef sandwiches EVER!!! Service... eh. She could've been more friendly and a simple thank you for the tip? The kid who gave us our food... very very nice read more

Pepino's Restaurant - Beef sandwich dry.. hot peppers on the side FF... to die for!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

See all

Food was average at best! Service was atrocious! Where did you get these people? Rude, snippy and a care less attitude! As for ambiance, the place could use a little freshening up! What restaurant do you go to and they give ya a big old honkin roast beef bun with a pasta dish? And, God forbid ya ask for butter! A snippy NO and she walked away! read more

April 2021 - I found this place based on its Yelp reviews. We had a medium pepperoni pizza on a thin crust. The crust was hard enough to use a knife and fork. The cheap quality knife was worthless and painful to use. The sauce and pepperoni and cheese was excellent! This did not appear to be a hand tossed dough. There was no raised edge on the pizza. I had a side salad with ranch dressing and the salad was small but good. The drinks were self service and Coke products. The deli type service was also very good. Next time I will have pasta or a sandwich. read more

Pepino's Restaurant - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

Pepinos is a Region staple. The food is always very good and the service is top notch. I always like to get the Italian sausage and some fries. By looking at the fries, you'd think they'd be bland, but somehow they always pack a flavor punch. read more

I got a tiramisu from Pepino's tonight and I'm disappointed to inform that it's not real tiramisu. Instead it's a cake with what looks and tastes like whipped cream. It's still good, don't get me wrong, it's just not what I was expecting or wanted. read more

Pepino's Restaurant - Tiramisu with no ladyfingers. - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

Beef sandwich ecellent and packę with beef, tomaty bread was also very good. Pepino's is always consistent and we have never been disappointed with our order read more

Good food and a lot of it good prices too, great service as well. I was very pleased with my dinner that included salad. I would come back.

Great place. Great food and great people everything is fabulous we go there all the time

I think pepinos has the best beef sandwich in NWI. There is way more meat than Portillos, the bread is better and the garlic in the Gardena is so good. Hands down the best around. Wish they were in valpo!!! Come to Porter country please. read more

Pepino's Restaurant - Beef sandwich with red sauce, cheese and peppers - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

Fries were soggy and disgusting, tasted like dry wall plaster. Sorry excuse for a beef sandwich too. Tasted like you were eating a tire. Girl at the counter seemed not too happy to be there. If I was around that food I guess my attitude would suck too. If someone wants to take you to Pepino's, do yourself a favor - RUN. read more

Great fresh food. Sandwiches, homemade salads, pasta and pizza. The sandwiches are made to order and everyone I've had is great. I love their potato salad and pasta salads. I've never tried their pizza and I'm not a fan of their pasta, way too saucy for me. read more

They now have a menu you can see without having to scan some stupid barcode. Food is excellent as always.

Just had a turkey burger from pepinos. It was waaaaay too salty!! It would have been good probably if not for that. A burger bun also would have been better, they put it on long sub bun..? The size was very generous. The sweet potato fries were very generous as well. What it boils down too is the salt, and the roll, otherwise it could have been good. Most of the bun and burger went into the garbage unfortunately. read more

I've loved Pepino's since they were in Cal City. Their grilled chicken sandwich is phenomenal and there's an addictive quality to their fries that I can't get enough of read more

Went here for the first time, it was so good! My friend had the ready to eat pizza slices and they were delicious. I had the meatball sandwich with sweet peppers. You can tell that everything was homemade, except for the bread, which was amazing. There was so much food in our portions that I could only eat half of my sandwich. I also had the garlic cheese curds and omg, they were so fresh and melt in your mouth good. These were also hand dipped with a breading that was a proven recipe from years gone by. The place was busy, the helpers were very good at their jobs and the prices were crazy low, we got all that I mentioned and two fountain drinks for $22. I will definitely be back in the future. read more

Ever since there has been new ownership, this place has gone downhill. I think the place is run by a bunch of young kids who don't know anything about business. It is amateur hour at this place. Walked in on a Sunday night at 7:25 and found out that they were out of basic food items, so we had to order differently. I got a Turkey sub sandwich that was soggy with tons of mayo and mustard and tasted bad. My friend came in just as I was finishing ordering at 7:28 pm and they told hime they were closing and he was the last order. It says clearly right on the door that they close at 8 pm, but to the kids who don't want to work and want to get out of there, they take that to mean that they will actually stop serving people at 7:30pm so they can clean up and get out of there. People were coming in after us and were told that they were closed and they left. If you advertise that you close at 8 pm, it means you take orders up to 8 pm!. Very uncomfortable sitting there with the employees running around and stacking chairs and sweeping around our feet just because they don't want to work. I am going to figure out who actually owns the place and talk to them. If this nonsense of running out of food and closing early isn't remedied, we will not be back. read more

I came because of a recommendation by a member of an Italian Beef page on Facebook. I got the Italian Beef Sandwich and it was big, flavorful and delicious. The fries were very good too. The place was moderately busy and the service was friendly especially considering they were a bit shorthanded. read more

Highly recommend !! Love everything on the menu !!! The meatball sub for example is mouth watering

Always very consistent food quality and execution. Staff is friendly. Solid menu. The combo sandwich with grilled onions and homemade hot pepper mix is where it's at! read more

Great beef sandwich! Everything here is good! Old school Chicago food in Schererville Indiana. Prices are fair and the place is clean. Check this place out if you're in the area... read more

We haven't been here in a long time. Have Always had awesome food here! Great to see the food is still just as amazing! I had the Italian beef and my wife had the tortellini. 100% satisfied! Thank you! read more