While the original Aurelio's Pizza was in Homewood IL, that pizza was superb! Lots of wonderful mozzarella cheese and other fine ingredients. When you become a chain, you lose some of your individuality and perfection. However, that does not mean that Aurelio's, the chain of pizza parlors is bad. It's different than it was originally meant to be. Aurelio's is a great place to enjoy excellent pizza! I found this pizza to be very good. We loved the pizza. It was a tad salty but not overly salty. Definitely NOT greasy. as I have previously read posted. Our service was extraordinary. Our female server was responsive, came with refills for our iced teas and was bubbly and friendly. We were most pleased with the quality of our pizza and ravioli as well as the service we received. Definitely would return! Very pleased! I highly recommend this Aurelio's location! read more

What has happened to the Aurelios of the past? I am a longtime Chicagoan and used to frequent the locations around town and the suburbs. This place definitely didn't meet the standards I remember. The service was on point. read more

I don't know I tried this place couple nights ago. I don't think it was all that. I mean for pizza joint that's not franchise. It should've been better. Honestly, Papa John's, and Domino's it's 100% better but it might've just been the people that is preparing a pizza read more

Once again pizza was on point tasting like Aurelio's original recipe sauce and sausage up front. I live in Orland Park and lived in Tinley/Frankfort area for over 30 years and always enjoyed the food and pizza at the local Aurelio's location's. Cedar lake location has it right on. Thanks Aurelio's read more

Stopped in for lunch while having the car serviced next door. There were a few people already seated but otherwise it was wide open. The service was good. No issues there. We had a small pizza which we shared and it came out pretty quickly and was hot out the oven. Their pizza is always consistent and over all it was good. They must have a buffet on some days and they do have plenty of tvs to watch any games. Perfect place for lunch while getting your car worked on. read more

The pizzas are way too salty .They have runny greasy cheese. I quit ordering here because it is inconsistent. Sometimes it has almost no pizza sauce . It is hard to believe they are a pizza place. read more

Unfortunately, this aurelios pizza is not nearly as good as the one in Homewood.(don't forget to ask for the original oven.) This Cedar Lake Pizza is not as crispy, the cheese doesn't taste as good, and they don't add enough sauce. The people are nice, the service is fine, but I would definitely drive to Homewood to get a way better pizza! read more

Just love their pizza! The pasta is also amazing. This is one of my favorite places to eat, or order from.

Something needs to be updated on the app or in the store in regard to wait times. I'm sitting in my car waiting 45 min past the quoted wait time for my pizza. I had already pre paid unfortunately. I have no issue waiting if the prep times were accurate so I don't waste my time in my car. Last few times I've been here it's been like this. Quality is down too so it's a true disappointment. I do not plan on coming back to see if changes have been made for a long while. read more

We had a pizza delivered to our hotel room! That was the best pizza we have had in a very long time! If we're ever near again, we will definitely be ordering again! read more

Very consistently good pizza. Their sauce is amazing and their ingredients are always fresh and tasty. The only strike to keep them from 5 stars, is their prices are a little high for me. I still get pizza from them and will continue to do so, but it's more of a treat for me. Good people and great pizza! read more

Always amazing. Since I was a child, this has always been a staple. Great pizza, friendly staff.

i would like an apology from the franchise owner and delivery guy. he drove a red BMW. I work nights, delivery guy gets here, i quickly put on T-shirt. It was a Pray for Trump t-shirt, i just grabbed the closest thing possible. the delivery guy shoved the pizza boxes into my chest and said no prayer here. read more

What did they do to their pizza? Up until July, we've had good pizzas, including gluten free. Last night we got a pizza there that was awful. The sauce on it tasted like, well, soup from a can. And the cheese (or whatever it was) looked and tasted like rubber. We won't be back. read more

Food is always amazing. People working there seem very genuine and friendly. It's always a good time when we dine in. We usually have a big group and they are always able to accommodate us. read more

Sorry for this review. I had your pizza the other night again I would really hope that you kicked it up a notch. it's very hit and miss this time was a miss. Seriously bar pizza was better than this. It's somewhat reminding me of eating cheese and cardboard. I must say I do like the sauce it's on the sweeter side and I do like that. read more

This place used to be the best pizza joint around! Sadly I believe the work force is changing and this will close very soon. If you order for delivery it will be over their estimated time the food is rarely cooked all the way or is cold. It's very upsetting considering the entire family could always agree to get their pizza but we have had too many issues lately maybe we will try again after some time if they can fix how the place is ran. read more

Don't usually use this place because there's another pizza place closer but my wife just had to have Aurelio's for some reason. We used to order from here all the time because the pizza is decent but it's been a couple years since, and I forgot why we stopped. Today I was reminded. Ordered a medium pizza and 2 apps for delivery. Website says 1 hour wait for delivery. 1.5hrs go by and I call. I'm out on hold for 8 minutes to be told that the food is with the driver. Food is delivered just shy of 2 hours after ordering and I open the pizza box to see it's smashed to the lid of the box and ice cold. The apps are also ice cold. Called and got a refund. Awful experience 2 times in a row now. read more

Go to Lowell the cedar lake one sucks ordered takeout and they forget to put the order in so went to franks

Phones lines absolutely suck. Try to call and it won't go through. After trying 3 or 4 times it finally goes through they answer and put you on hold for 5 minutes. Hang up try again goes through after 3 times they answer the phone thanks for calling can I put you on hold I say No explain what happens and the girl says there are 3 people ahead of you and put me on hold again. Why ask if you are just going to put me on hold. Owner needs to up his phone game and spend some money. Place is backed dont so he can't say it doesn't have any. read more

I'm from Chicago and you really can't find anything like Chicago Pizza! When you want great pizza, Chicago is the best! Sorry Aurelio's.......the pizza wasn't very cheesy, the crust tasted like hard tack, it just wasn't very good pizza. The bottom line is I wasn't a big fan, sorry! I am sure the Cedar Lake Locals like it. read more

You can't go wrong with Aurelio's pizza!! Fam fave for my entire existence. Thanks Aurelio's Cedar Lake!!

Standard family pizza place. Casual no frills family oriented dining. The menu is large with many options. For the first time I think the gluten free pizza was actually better. They use a deeper dish dough, that was not chalkboard thin or dry. It also did not fall apart and held together so you could eat the pizza by hand. I had the Hawaiian which was tasty and went well with their pizza sauce. The pizza sauce has a sweet tangy flavor to it. My husband had a bite of the gluten free and said it was one of the better gluten free pizzas he has had, but that the normal pizza was just so - so. read more

Aurelio's Pizza - Yummy gluten free pizza - Hawaiian. One of the better gluten free crusts I have had. - Pizza Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Have 4 kids and was ignored at the sign where we were told to wait to be seated. Others came in and got their names in ahead of ours. We were told 30 minutes. After 40 minutes we left. I wish I could review the food but I'll never know. This is not a place to bring a family try other places read more

I haven't been a fan of Aurelio's Pizza for years. Other then the one in Homewood, they all seemed to have lost the recipe for good pizza, service and cleanliness. So, for some reason, I decided to give the new Aurelio's in Cedar Lake a try while I was in the area. Wow, it was like the good old days. The pizza was perfect and very good. Service was great and the place was totally remodeled so it was very clean. If I wanted to complain about anything, it would be the noise level. But that's only because everybody was having a good time and there were a few birthday parties. Can't complain about that! Parking could be better. Only three parking spots in front so you have to park behind the building and walk around to the front to enter. In the cold and snow it wasn't very good. Keep up the good work guys. I want to go back the next time I'm in town. read more

We just move to St John & we were weekly Aurelio's customers at our old house. We are so happy we found this Aurelio's close to our new home. We've dined in & was very pleased with the service & pizza! This is our second delivery & once again very pleased with everything! Thank You for your fast friendly service & pizza just the way we like it! read more

This is a great spot to eat if you have some money to spend. it's a little more expansive then I thought but the food was great and are server was very nice and was there when we needed. read more

I use to goto this place as a kid! Went back to visit family. We had to stop in and see if it still tasted the same. It did! Loved the mozzarella sticks. Our server was sweet and had a cool accent. To top it off they had $2 IPAs. Was nice to feel at home again. read more

Ordered pizza, salad and spaghetti over the weekend, the pizza was over cooked and very dry (no sauce). The lettuce in the salad was slimy. I used to love the pizza from this location but I'm very dissatisfied with the most recent order. read more

A great place to eat, friendly people, amazing pizza, a true cant go wrong. I would recommend to anyone and everyone it's a 5/5 for me!!

Went for the buffet it was great the pork chops were grilled and had a garlic herb sauce that knocked it out, bread shrimp was great salad regular and antipasto spicy caluflower packed a punch in a good way and the great Aurelio's Pizza all this plus desert for just 10.99 you can't beat that!!!!!! read more

Haven't had this in years because had it too much in Illinois. Decided to give it a try tonight. Phoned in order and picked it up in drive thru. I liked that very much since I wasn't dressed all that great.... lol!! Cheese sausage and onion. Enjoyed it for sure!! Thank you Aurelio's read more

Pizza was really good and I am not a pizza girl. I couldnt decide between a four or five cuz my beef was only okay. It tasted like beef you buy at a store but the pizza was good. Appetizers are really good also . And the reason I gave you a 5-star is cuz our waitress Kimberly was just absolutely awesome read more

Tried the online order. It said an hour for delivery. An hour and 20 minutes later I called and they couldn't tell me if my pizza was out for delivery, in the oven or not even made. A manager got on the phone was still struggling to find information on my order. He finally said it was out for delivery and it should be there within half an hour. He did give me half off my order and delivery driver was very apologetic. Which is why the 2 stars. read more

Went with friends today to check-out their new lunch buffet (Mon thru Fri 11am - 2pm $9.00 plus drink). Pizza was as good as I remember from the Homewood and old Beecher locations. 4 kinds of pizza, salad bar, mostaciolli, garlic bread, fried chicken, dinner fries, and Italian beef sandwiches. Also (very sweet) apple pie pizza for dessert. Considering the quality of other pizza joints in the area, this place will be favorite for us. They serve beer and wine, but have no bar so it's a good place to go with kids, unlike the Zuni's that was formerly in this location. Back then the obnoxious and loud drunks at the bar chased away anyone with kids or wanted a quiet evening with conversation. read more

Oh the Italian wedge salad. I think we eat here 3 nights a week. So good!!! The buffet is always good.

Horrible delivery service...waited 1 1/2 hours for a pizza.. Had to call to see where it was... Was told they had to remake... 1 1/2 hours later.. Still waiting... don't bother with this place!! read more

I don't know how anyone says this tastes or looks like Aurelio's Pizza. Got one today and it was so greasy and salty. I had to sponge the grease off with paper towels. Absolutely disgusting. I've been a customer of Aurelio's for over 20 years. I will say that the Homewood location bar none is THE best Aurelios. The manager did give us a credit for next time but very unsure if we will use it. $17 down the drain. read more

Great Pizza! My family's personal favorite - Super Six, extra sauce, extra cheese, well done. Can't beat it!!

Always great. Always friendly. I loved the Homewood Aurelio's growing up and wasn't a fan of Beecher's Aurelio's. I am always very pleased with the experience at Cedar Lake's Aurelio's. The food is exactly like Homewood, I'd go as far as even arguing better. The stuffed pizza is my personal favorite from here. Perfection. And to top it off, the service is amazing: very helpful, never a long wait, and friendly. I love coming back. I definitely recommend this location to anyone and everyone. read more