Went to redeem my free 12" sign-up pizza. Added pepperoni to the free cheese pizza with a small upcharge. Overall the pizza tasted very good. I'm not a fan of thin crust, but it wasn't bad. Since it was our first time there, we wanted to sample some other items too, we got: 1. Meatball app (4) - not the best I've ever had but really good, especially the sauce 2. Eggplant Marino - couldn't really tell there was eggplant between the layers of fried coating - way too thin! 3. Spinach & Artichoke dip - It's probably the best I've ever tasted, but then I don't get it often. The star of the meal was our server Aileen. She was fun, patient, cooperative and efficient. Overall, we think its worth another try. read more

Great pizza. I was visiting town and really enjoyed their Pizza. Stop in have a seat at the bar and enjoy!

Stopped for lunch and waited for awhile before a server came to take a drink order. We ordered a meatball appetizer and a gluten free crust cheese pizza. Their meatballs are very good and this time didn't disappoint either. The gluten free pizza was odd. The crust was fine, but it was covered with cheese and just a dab of sauce on it. It wasn't at all what I expected. Fortunately there was a lot of sauce with the meatballs so I spread it on top of the cheese. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

the food was amazing and came really fast, great customer service from Keryi, the environment is really cozy and welcoming. I had an amazing experience here, will be returning! read more

My boyfriend and I split wings and a pizza here and it was really good! We also had a glass of wine and if you're a ranch with pizza lover, you're in luck -- they have pretty good ranch! Vibes could be a little better, it's definitely a family restaurant nothing fancy although a little pricey for that kind of atmosphere. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Garlic Romano Chicken wings - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I stayed the evening at a hotel by the airport and ordered from Anthony's. I love a coal fired pizza and Anthony's did not disappoint. I had the thick cut pepperoni and they had a great flavor. If I'm back in the area I'll order from them again. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pepperoni thick sliced - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

The restaurant is spacious. There is plenty of seating and a big bar. We got an Italian salad and a hot honey pizza. The pizza was a little watery, but good. The salad had celery and garbanzo beans in it, which I didn't really care for. Wish I would have noticed beforehand. The service was pretty good. It was alright but pricey. read more

See all

This place is pretty decent - got a basic dish, spaghetti and meatballs (was afraid a pie might be too much!) with some seasoned bread. The bread was better than expected and went well with the tomato sauce. The meatballs were pretty big (two was enough) and had great tomato-savory flavor. The pasta wasn't bad either. I would come back here to try their pizza based on the quality of the entree I got. (Can't comment too much on service or ambiance since the dining area was closed due to the water boil advisory, but the young man at the counter was friendly and restaurant was clean; I didn't wait too long for my food.) read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Spaghetti and meatballs (Robinson was under a boil advisory, had to do takeout so no plate picture) - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

basic pizza not the worst not the best. sauce tasted watery like it was old from the fridge. Service was horrible by the server we had. Had to keep asking other servers for assistance. Never got a drink refill. Not worth the price for the service and food I got. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Receipt - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Server was fine, wings were great but I won't be back anytime soon. The ladies room floor was filthy, crud that looked like it had been there for a while. Makes me leery about the kitchen. read more

I hate leaving negative reviews. I contacted the restaurant on 3 separate occasions and was told the manager was busy, then not available then was issuing a refund, that never came. Ordered 2 pizzas with 1 being a Margherita. No Basil. Just cheese. With tip ended up spending $40 for a cheese pizza. Too much pizza competition to choose Anthony's again. read more

Worst service I have ever had. Waited 45 minutes for our salad and brought out first pizza at the same time. When I commented on the fact the salad and pizza came out at the same time, the server told me no one specified that we wanted our salads first. We then waited an additional 15 minutes for our second pizza. Absolutely no accountability. Horrible. read more

Joe was our waiter tonight. Very friendly! Got a couple pizzas- the eggplant ( yummy) and the house salad -- pretty much our standard :) All was very good and did not have to wait for a table. Success! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza gone! - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Traveling through area. First time trying coal fired pizza. We utilized delivery and ate at a nearby hotel. Delivery was through Uber, and was on time and app provided good updates. Pizza was fresh and not flawed, it was good but not great. It had a little more char than we prefer. One pizza was completely black on bottom, not a speck of brown. Good amount of toppings. I may try again next time we are near one. But it will probably be a challenge with the family. read more

Food was average. Nothing really special. The pizza was not as flavorful as expected given its in the name of the place. Food and pace of delivery of food does not justify the price. read more

The food is always on point and the service is top notch. I typically go with the double baked wings and then a slice of the pizza. Last time we settled for a salad and a slice and it was delicious. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Love this pizza spot while we're staying in Pittsburgh. Close to the hotel we always stay at - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Sometimes you just need garlic knots Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza does them right leaving you with that fire garlic breath for the rest of the evening! A Friday night pizza night well spent. read more

You could fire Mike for starters because he has an attitude problem and is idiotic . Bad manners and no respect or customer service skills. He can't understand stand English and was very rude. He said he couldn't understand me what I was saying. So you might want to take a white board or piece of paper so you can draw a picture for him! What you would like to order. He needs customer service training. A very unpleasant experience I will get my food from other pizza places. It is a shame because the pizza was amazing and the lady that did help me was wonderful and nice. I will not be coming back here again and my family and friends will not be back here either again. Go elsewhere folks not worth the money for the way you get treated. read more

We had a wonderful late dinner last Friday. We sat at the bar and our bartender was fabulous. She was always making sure we had drinks and anything else we needed including the Pirates game. We shared meatballs and a pizza and both were delicious and just the right amount of food for us. We also signed up for the rewards and got an email a day later for a free small pizza! We will use that so be back soon! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Small pizza with a smile on it - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Salad and 2 person pizza - $60? Not worth it. Barely worth it if the prices were half as much. Our waitress was way too busy- too many tables while other workers were screwing off. Just about any other Italian place I can think off is better and cheaper and more professional. read more

The wait staff is very good the food is very good my only disappointment or concern is I was there twice this week and their bathroom has the same dirt it had earlier in the week so nobody is cleaning the bathrooms. That makes me wonder are they not cleaning other places ? This would be sad to loose their business over this! Cleaning is a basic fundamental practice to running a successful restaurant. This is management and corporate not doing their jobs read more

The food has always been decent, but the cleanliness of the restaurant is rather disturbing. Very worn, furnishings, doorways, and pretty much everywhere you look. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Restroom door - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I had a work dinner here last week and it was pretty good! I've had takeout from the McMurray location in the past but have never dined inside. The only semi-disappointing part of my meal was my martini which I ordered dirty and it came straight up; being one of the first folks in the party to arrive, there was a long lag in service and I didn't bother asking for the drink to be remade which is something I hate to do anyways. Food was awesome. We all tried a little of everything. Anything I tasted was delicious from caesar salad, to the garlic knots, to the buffalo wings, to the classic cheese pizza to the uncle pauli's. The wings were the standout for me, they were almost grilled, def not a crispy wing. The buffalo sauce was perfect. Server was nice and our food came quick! read more

I ordered a large pizza and it was dry and paper thin. like eating cardboard! what happened to the thicker, blackened crust, delicious pizza you used to make? This is the second pizza in a row from Anthony's that was horrible. I will never go back! read more

Came in for lunch with some coworkers. We shared salad, wings, a cheese pizza, and a pepperoni pizza. The food was good! The salad was very lightly dressed. We asked for extra dressing and it was brought over promptly. The service was friendly and quick. The wings are my favorite. They were perfectly crisp and had a light seasoning on them, no sauce. There were pieces of bread, maybe focaccia, under the wings and they were amazing too. The bread had the right amount of chew with great seasoning, as well. The pizza was nice! The sauce was a little sweet and the crust was small/thinner. The outer crust kind of reminded me of a breadstick in size and texture. They had the inside decorated for Christmas and you could tell there were several others who decided to host get togethers there for the season too. I will definitely be back. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Wings - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Business doors were locked on a Sunday at 6 PM There seem to be people inside, but no one seemed to come open the door for us so we had to go somewhere else extremely disappointed read more

Great fun place to eat and it was hopping on a Friday evening. Even though this is at Settlers Ridge, parking was bit difficult (it is located across from the theater), so we are assuming that's why the lot was really full. We did get seated quickly and ordered the most delicious tuna salad sandwich and the Pauli's pizza. We chose half hot and half sweet peppers but had to immediately take off the hot because they were CRAZY hot. Food took a little while but expected, since all the tables and most of the bar seats were full. We took home most of the pizza and look forward to having it for leftovers. We had missed the tuna salad sandwich (we haves out of state) and was not disappointed. Great great great sandwich. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Awesome! This is a place if you are true pizza, lover, like me, this is where you need to go in Pittsburgh

Sides are great and 2items are unique: garlic knots and the broccoli Rabe w/italian sausage. All the other apps are done better pretty much everywhere else. Pizza's only: if you have a taste for a great fired flat bread pizza, they have a delicious and unique taste and the pizza dough is tasty. However, stick to the traditional pre-made red sauce varieties or make your own: every white sauce pizza is so oily to make it uncomfortable, and they were incredibly skimpy on the shrimp scampi pizza (a signature "special" offering for July!) with less than 1 shrimp per piece for a $24 large pizza (8 slices). The pasta dishes we ordered were also done better pretty anywhere else. Shrimp scampi was greasy vs savory flavorful, again a "signature" dish with 6 medium 21-25 size shrimp for $19.50! The ceasar small portion was enough for 3 people, again the $6 shrimp add was 4 shrimp. Chicken sandwich with broccoli rabe (see a theme here? ;-)), so they made it with a pizza dough that was huge! Creative and I liked that but they didn't increase the portion of chicken breast (1 medium sliced), and it was too much. I ended up packing that , adding isley's ham, ceasar dressing and my own arugula the next day and it was amazing. Again, their dough is delicious & compliments anything well. They should make a pizza dough sandwich that is unique and I'd go for that. All in- we went for the garlic knots and broccoli dishes. 2 adults 2 pre-teens with non-soecific appetites, (think baby sharks), no alcoholic drinks, set us back $139.00. (2 orders of knots and 2 appetizers broccoli raves so looking at it it wasn't bad pricing actually. We just happen to like 2 of the more expensive apps. I will say that have a great veterans discount (50% off the most expensive item) which I really appreciated. Bringing the bill to 119.00 plus ~22% tip, ~$145.00 for 4 people or $36/person. No worth it for the experience or portions... as I said.. we certainly weren't hungry afterwards and we took 2 apps home so a decently filling meal. Not something I would travel for if it weren't for the 2 apps we love. read more

We can't get enough of this place! This time we did not get pizza, but we LOVE their pizza. We got the chopped salad - amazing. I got the spaghetti and meatballs - yum! One in our party got the eggplant appetizer and couldn't stop raving about it. Server was great! Anytime I am in town, I will make a point to visit Anthony's!! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - chopped salad - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

High quality pizza, very delicious. Our waiter was nice and the service was great. Also had a spinach dip which was pretty good. Wings are also pretty tasty. Would definitely get pizza from their again read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - The Square Margherita 16" - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Food was so so, service was bad. We've been to the Anthony's in Monroeville and love it. This one was awful.

We've have been here at least 10 times and the food is always good. My favorite is the coal fired wings with caramelized onions. The BEST wings ever. Great charred chicken flavor tans the onions melt on your mouth. Theo house salad is made with romaine lettuce and is always crisp (how do they do that?) the vinegarette is light and they even put the most underused vegetable (celery) in the salad. Sooo good. My husband is a big fan of the pizza with sausage, onions and olives. Don't let the 3.5 star rating keep you from missing this unique spin on Italian. read more

This place is a gem! The pizza is spot on and the meatballs are amazing! Definitely will be back to visit!!! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Paulies pies - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I usually go to the Thai place across the street but this time I decided to have pizza and I'm so glad we did. It was a good place to drink a few beers and have good pizza. I do think that if you want to have a conversation it's a little tough because it's a little loud but other than that, enjoyable spot, good location, the service was good. Everything was truly just good. read more

Why is there NO AIR CONDITIONING in this restaurant? Food and service was excellent but was practically sweating eating my pizza. Please fix it or we will NOT be returning. We are rewards Members !! read more

Decent food, decent environment, decent service. We went around 11:30 to get a quick lunch before heading to the airport. Everyone else in the restaurant, about 2 other parties, we're all regulars. We ordered a large chicken salad to split between the 2 of us. It took about 20 minutes to come out. The regular behind us, who ordered 5 minutes after us, received his pepperoni pizza 5 minutes before us. The salad was missing the cheese we asked for and only had about 4 pieces of chicken. The salad got the job done, but it was nothing to write home about. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Very disappointed with our food. Order was supposed to be ready at 8:45 pm I got there at 8:53 pm and had to wait for garlic knots until 9:15 pm when my other food was ready. Pizza was too overcooked and cold by the time I got home. Wings were decent but the garlic knots are the only reason for 2 stars or it would be 1 star. Female who went to get my food wasn't friendly until the end of the interaction. read more

I was there today I ordered 20 pieces wings who was a blood inside the wings it wasn't cooked. I asked them to make it well done and then make a different food. Still very bad. I don't eat anything. I don't like it. They charge me $40. read more

Came here at a Thursday night for a glass of wine before the movies. The bartender, Jordan was great! She had great recommendations and was very personable! Will be back! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania