Service is absolutely top notch! My Caesar salad is just so so, lobster bisque has a great flavor but very little lobster. And thank you for the tip about the Old Fashioned, these are indeed quite good. If loud is a problem, it gets very much so even on a Tuesday at 7:30. There are too many hard surfaces for me. The wagyu tartare is out of this world! That was my main course knowing it would be rich and it was. So worth it. RRR had the chef's special of pasta with seafood in a cream sauce. Not enough sauce, too much salmon, too little shrimp, once weensy bit of lobster. For $50 plus. He loved the mussels, 5 of them, and the flavor of the sauce. We shared the sauteed mushrooms aside that was good. They definitely DO something special for a birthday but maybe it was because I turned 77 today. And, as I said, the service is outstanding. read more

Reviewed the reviews to make sure it wasn't "just me." Tops is the decor. I pretty much concur with what is consistently posted on food and service coming in after "looks." read more

I put off Anthony's Chop House for years because I thought it was going to be some overpriced mediocre steak that the people of Carmel obsessed over for no good reason. I was soooo wrong. Anthony's makes you feel as though you are receiving a personalized experience from the start. Our waitress was amazing. Some people don't like the long drawn out menu explanations, but I, for one, LOVE them. Please, tell me about the food in detail. And she did it so well. We started off with the Lobster Bisque. It was incredible!! The steak was devine. Dare I say, the best steak I ever had. We also got the brussel sprouts - which were the best Brussels sprouts I ever had - and the horseradish whipped mashed potatoes. So good! Now, Anthony's is pricey but for the quality and deliciousness of the food, I think the value for the price is there. I would 10/10 recommend Anthony's for a fancier date night! read more

See all

I am going to keep it shorter and simple. From the amazing food to the impeccable service, this place is absolutely wonderful and is a beautiful establishment to dine in. Everything is delicious, the sides & appetizers are shareable portions and my steak wedge salad was delicious! read more

Anthony's Chophouse - Steak wedge salad - Steakhouses Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

The service at Anthony's is up to par with what you expect and pay! Very friendly and unrushed. However I would pick several other Carmel spots before the his one. It's certainly a very special occasion space and targets the wealth of Carmel. The food was delicious but not my favorite in this genre. read more

Anthony's Chophouse - Brussel sprouts - Steakhouses Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Medium rare is what I ordered. It was the ribeye provincial- with a beautiful crusty sear in a cast iron pan. What was served was a thick sear (and that was fine) with a rare, cold interior. I asked that it be cooked a little longer- and what they brought me 15 min later was a steak that was moments away from well done- it was horrible. I had no entree . A meal for 2 for $250 should be a delightful experience I can share that the starters, and lobster bisque soup were delicious. The side dishes were also done well. Ruth's Chris, St Elmo's, Del Frisco's and STK Steakhouse have never disappointed- and I always order medium rare with a sear. read more

An upscale establishment with a nice selection of appetizers, sides, and entrées - including several butcher block selections. Our waiter made our first visit enjoyable - he checked on us often, was attentive and ensured we had everything we needed. The food was mouthwatering and flavorful - everything was prepared and presented nicely, the ingredients were fresh, and our meals were cooked to perfection. I recommend saving room for a dessert, as they have several amazing ones to pick from! Stop by Anthony's Chophouse when you get a chance, you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

Tonight we celebrated Galentines at Anthony's Chophouse. It's one of my favorite places to get cocktails. They have some of the best bartenders in town (shout out to Zack). The atmosphere is great. If you are looking for a fun night out on the town-stop by Anthony's and have a seat at the bar. read more

Anthony's Chophouse - Extra Credit - Steakhouses Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Wow. The best way to describe Anthony's is "attention to detail". From the moment you walk in, you feel the difference. The service is as impeccable as the food and it quickly made its way to the top of our list. We have been a few times now for special events and each time, we had a fantastic time. My husband got the Waygu and (reluctantly) let me try it- literally melt in your mouth. I tend to get the filet and it is by far the best I've had. Apps are great, sides are shareable and everything we've tried has been delicious. Timing of the courses is very planned out, I would just caution you to be ready to spend some time (and money) here. It's an experience and you'll want to plan for it. Can't wait to go back!! read more

See all

Well this was an experience not just a meal! My bf took me for my birthday and we had a blast we their soup. Beet salad and we both ordered steaks! Overall ambiance and service was amazing and for the price it was worth it as a treat! Definitely recommend this place to anyone celebrating special moments read more

See all

If you want fine dining, look no further than @Anthony's Chophouse. It's best that you get reservations. This place fills up fast, and there's a reason for that. The food is excellent. The atmosphere is elegant and quiet, but it proudly states that you are eating in a fine-dining restaurant. The prices match the experience, but I wasn't sorry to pay. It may not be your every day choice for dinner, but for those special occasions and celebrations, you won't go wrong with Anthony's. read more

My husband and I went here for his birthday. We did make reservations prior but it wasn't too busy for a Wednesday evening. When we arrived, we used the valet for $7. Our server was super friendly! I wished if I had taken down her name. Our drinks were amazing! I had the Marie Antoinette and my husband had a gin drink. For food, we ordered the following: 1. Shrimp Sambal - AMAZING 2. Crab Bake - best crab cake I've ever had! 3. Lobster Tail - ok, we have never had this before and we didn't really enjoy it. They were kind of bland for us, but that's obviously not the restaurants fault, its just our taste buds! 4. Gnocchi - so so good! Highly recommend this side.. 5. Twice baked potatoes - melts in your mouth! 6. Complimentary bread pudding - best bread pudding I've ever had! Served warm with whipped cream read more

See all

Some of the best steaks around. They also have an amazing bread pudding. The sides were so-so, but overall a great experience.

this place is perfect for date nights or celebrations . its dimly lit , with small lamps on each table . our server olaf was amazing. i told him my name and that it was my birthday. he made sure to remember it and call me by it the rest of the night. the staff here is amazing and very attentive. all of my guests thoroughly enjoyed their food. i did bring in cupcakes and they wanted to charge $15 for bringing my own dessert. which i thought that was ridiculous, considering i didn't see that on the site and staff didn't tell me when i asked them to refrigerate them . anyway, the server said i could just take them back and not be charged the $15. no biggie as rules are rules. I had a great experience overall, so i plan to come back. read more

See all

Anthony's was our cap of our evening and Shawn waited on us and handled our group with top notch customer service. I didn't expect to get a Burger there but I'm so glad I did. It was DELICIOUS-- along with the garlic aioli. 10/10!! read more

Love this spot - it's my go-to for big nights' out. They do all things 'carnivore' really well - and the staff are pros, too. The bar at the top floor is fun for after dinner. read more

We attended a holiday dinner here and had a wonderful evening. The family hosting the dinner booked the upstairs private room and it was beautiful. There was a huge table and a private bar for us alone. The service was also amazing. Our server had the perfect balance of continually filling drinks and timing the meal right, while also leaving us alone to catch up. A team of people brought all of our apps and meals out at the same time like a parade, which was also impressive. I got the Fumo & Flora cocktail which had gin and elderflower. The bartender lit a piece of rosemary on fire, which made the drink nice and smoky. We also had some great red wine that was continually topped off for everyone. The host ordered the broiled goat cheese, tempura cauliflower, Charlie's pounders (meatballs), buttery bread, and Caesar salad appetizers. They were all amazing... specifically the meatballs, bread, and salad. Don't miss those! I had the filet with truffle butter and it was well-seasoned and melted in my mouth. Sooo good. My husband got a ribeye and agreed that the filet was his favorite. Our host ordered the twice broiled yukons, shoestring frites, calle corn, and creamy mac sides for the table as well. You better believe that I tried everything! The mac and corn were my personal favorites. The twice broiled yukons were the only side that I'd change, as I would've preferred creamy mashed potatoes and not the thick potato. We were so excited to have had this experience and hope to return in the future! read more

See all

This could very well be the best meal i have eaten in my entire life. The ribeye was absolutely spectacular, we had some great glasses of wine, the yukon potatoes and brussel sprouts were to die for, the crab cakes were off the charts and the mussels were fabulous as well. Our server Kris was amazing too. The interior of the place was awesome, such a great ambiance. I can't wait to come back read more

Anthony's Chophouse - Ribeye - Steakhouses Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Perfect for a date night or special occasion. The food and service was exactly what you would expect for a high-end dinning experience. Must try the Lobster Bisque! The entrees were perfect and the sides complemented them smoothly. The Brussels were good, but had a lot of flavors going on. Must try the baked Mac! read more

See all

Nice steakhouse in a prime location in Midtown Carmel. The decor is very modern and upscale, and the service is great. Don't really love the food though, it feels overpriced and there are better options out there. Came here for a business dinner and got crab cakes and scallop shells for appetizers. Tasted good, but nothing special. The best thing here is definitely the lobster bisque, probably the best I've had anywhere - super rich and creamy. For dinner, we got the lamb rack which was okay - just felt like it was mostly bones and very little meat. We also got the beef Wellington, which was way too salty and just had too much going on. Overall, it's mediocre food in a really nice restaurant and location. read more

Anthony's Chophouse - Lamb Rack - Steakhouses Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Amazing experience! My wife and I went to Anthony's Chophouse to celebrate her birthday. Micci was an amazing server and very knowledgeable. She recommended a wine that my wife loved. All the food was delicious! We started with the carpaccio, which was awesome. My wife even loved the gluten free bread! She loved her filet, and I had the chef's special, a Kansas City Strip with red chimichurri, which was a unique and incredible dish. Mike Johnston visited our table to make sure we were having a great time. I highly recommend Anthony's Chophouse for a wonderful dining experience read more

Went here this evening with two associates and had the best steak and overall dining experience that I have ever had Adam took excellent care of us and I will definitely come again read more

Our night here started out so great with our first cocktails, but gradually went downhill from there. So first of all, the "Misery Loves Company" cocktail is AMAZING! I wasn't quite sure what to expect from a drink made with beet juice, but it was so good, and one of the only reasons I'm giving Anthony's 3 stars instead of 2. Ok, on to the food. The Oysters Asado appetizer was fantastic. We also ordered the Bourbon Mussels, which were delicious. The mushrooms that had soaked in the broth were especially good, but unfortunately about a third of the mussels were still closed up in their shells and inedible. I would've mentioned something to our server about it, but we ended up not even finishing it because we had so much other food, so I felt silly complaining that a large portion of the mussels were no good when we still had some good ones in the bowl that we didn't eat. (But if you're wanting to feed more than two people with this, you may be out of luck.) The lobster bisque was not the best I've had, but still very good. It was right on the verge of being way too sweet and way too thick (almost custard-like), but I still ate most of it. They could've been a little more generous with the lobster meat in it (The lobster shell on top in the picture is purely a garnish.), but there were some discernible bits of lobster in there. We also ordered the Calle Corn and Creamy Mac. The corn was fine. Possibly frozen? I'm not sure, but it had a chewier consistency than I usually get from fresh corn. The Creamy Mac was delicious, but we almost sent it back because we thought they had forgotten that we added the lobster. But then I found a few little shreds of lobster meat. That's it -- a few shreds here and there that you really had to go searching for to find. Nowhere near $12 worth of lobster in that dish. (That's the upcharge to add lobster.) Overall we, spent a huge chunk of money on a mostly underwhelming meal. Service was very good, though they need a bit more wine training. Our server repeatedly said that the Gavi we had ordered was a really good Pinot Grigio. (Gavi is not Pinot Grigio; it's made from the Cortese grape.) But our server was very attentive and friendly, and he is the other reason for the 3rd star in this review. read more

Anthony's Chophouse - Misery Loves Company cocktail - amazing! - Steakhouses Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

This by far was one of the best steakhouses I've been to. I went with a group of 6 to celebrate a birthday and the customer service was amazing. The staff really made you feel like you were important. Staff has on masks the entire time. I ordered a Magnum PI drink which turned into 2 and eventually the entire table ordered one. That's how good it was. My husband and I shared an appetizer of the pork belly with polenta and corn. The pork belly was so tender. This could literally be a meal all by itself. We also got to get a taste of the seafood tower that another couple ordered and it did not disappoint. The oysters were yummy. For dinner I went with the filet and my husband chose the wagyu filet. I took a bit of his and was instantly jealous! I see why it has a high price tag because it was just that good. Don't get me wrong, my little bitty filet mignon was good too. We all shared sided of Brussel sprouts, asparagus, mashed potatoes, and mac and cheese. The mac & cheese had an interesting spicy kick to it. Now lets get to this dessert. Bourbon Bread Pudding!! OH EM GEE. Why did I share this with my husband? I was so full by the time dessert came but I pushed through for this deliciousness. Next time I'll just order one for myself and eat later if I'm too full. This place was fantastic! I really haven't been out to eat to a 'fancy' dinner since the onset of Covid so it was really refreshing to have that wonderful experience with my friends. read more

See all

Everything was fine but my expectations were higher. Service was excellent. My cocktail was fine, but not memorable. My dinner companions loved their steaks. The goat cheese appetizer was hands down winner. My tuna was pretty bland, it appeared to have been seared but was served cold which I found off-putting. read more

I called to make reservations. They asked for my CC number which I have never experienced. I asked why. They then told me I'm charged $100 ($25/person) to make a reservation, but it's credited towards the meal. The audacity to ask for my CC without first telling me why.... So if I show up on time (as I always do) and my table isn't ready, as it usually isn't for another 5-15 min even with reservations, do I get my $100 back and a $100 discount? Seems one sided. Just another cash grab by restaurants. Like them starring at you asking you to select 20%, 25%, 28% preset tip amounts. The entitlement of restaurants now-a-days is astounding. Anthony's used to be my favorite steak place in town. I happily spent $200+ per person here. I won't be going back. They need to treat guests better and not be entitled. I hope the restaurant industry gets hit by a bus, and there is a hard reset, giving us places who once again value their guests and not bully them. I'll be making my wife's birthday dinner at home: open bar, homemade meal at 1/10th the cost, bon fire, smores, music, friends, etc. No need to be treated like trash in addition to paying $200+ person for a meal at Anthony's Chophouse. read more

The restaurant was beautiful! The food was delicious. From start to finish the food just kept getting better. Being in the food industry you can have the best food but if your service isn't great it definitely affects your experience and your food especially when going to a fine dining restaurant. I can say I have been to a lot of finer steakhouses and Anthony's is hands down top notch! Our waiter Olaf was incredible and took the time to explain menu items and didn't rush us and also genuinely engaged in conversation about life. Yes I know that's their job especially at nice restaurants and most of the time you leave places saying he or she was great and so nice. But Olaf was definitely outstanding and you know he enjoys his job and getting to know people. In todays world that is rare to find and they are lucky to have them on there team! We will be back soon! read more

You want elegant? You have it here. We reserved a table for a celebration meal and did not disappoint. Jason our server was superb. There when needed and not when not. Food was amazing as always. I had the lobster bisque as I just can't say no. So good. Tonight I tried the lamb and was so happy I did. It's one of the chef's specialities and it was so tasty. I highly recommended this one. Atmosphere is both casual and elegant. This is one of the best spots for a meal or a drink in Carmel. Try it. You won't regret your decision and I know you'll be a fan. read more

See all

Great atmosphere! Service was impeccable...we celebrated our 25th anniversary there. Starter was amazing (bacon something) I had the 12 oz filet..my word the bone marrow butter, crispy Brussels sprouts were a tad too crispy but overall a great experience. My husband had the filet sandwich which he enjoyed as well. Parking is bad in the is area especially with all the construction. We had to park on a parking garage about a block over. read more

We went to Anthony's Chophouse for our anniversary and had a wonderful time. The food was amazing. The truffle arancini has me in a chokehold. Forgot to take a picture of the drinks, I got Rosemary's baby and partner tried the smoked old fashioned. Both were good. We will definitely be back to try some other items! read more

See all

We went to Anthony's Chophouse to celebrate a birthday and they went above and beyond and really impressed us! The presentation of the food was excellent, they had some unique dishes you can't find at other high-end restaurants, our server was personable and knowledgeable about the menu, and he even went the extra mile to get the valet to pull the car around and fold our napkins in a fun presentation when someone left the table. Beyond that, the food was delicious and served family style some everyone could try everything. Highly recommend if you're looking for somewhere memorable to celebrate a loved one or just have a very quality meal. read more

See all

Found this place via Yelp and had a great business dinner over some steak, chops and drinks. The atmosphere was wonderful as was the relaxed service. I happens to have a seat with a view of the kitchen and was pleased to see the cleanliness and amount of attention that went into keeping all surfaces clean polished and clean as the night grew long. A place to visit and worth the $$$. read more

The ambience is nice and service was fine; the food is pretty good but can't justify the price. The apps were ok, and the lobster bisque soup I did enjoy. However, the steaks were disappointing. Four of the five of us all had steak significantly overcooked. It seemed like putting a "crust" on the steak meant burning it even for rare / medium rare (with little to no pink in the middle). Only one of us sent it back, and even on the second attempt he said the temperature was better but still didn't taste like anything special. At least I had bankers foot the bill for dinner, which seems like what this restaurant was primarily made for. There are other steakhouses I would rather go to for a special occasion personally. read more

Had a wonderful experience here...we only went to Carmel to pass our time until the time of our reservation to another restaurant. We just checked in to see if we can be seated & we were! List in their menu is enticing so we decided to have our dinner here instead. We ordered what our waiter recommended, i loved their shelled scallops , lobster bisque and enjoyed their chocolate quake. Their steak is so-so, Sean's service is excellent and the restaurant is very posh & elegant...ohh hubby ordered this smoking drink (which I forgot the name lol)- but its so gooodd!! read more

See all

Wow, just wow! Love the atmosphere of this place to start. Absolutely gorgeous inside and the perfect restaurant to celebrate any special occasion I happened to be celebrating my birthday. We started off with drinks and their delicious bread. My husband enjoyed their old fashioned and I tried their spicy version of a dirty martini. They use a stuffed olive that's filled with a very spicy pepper. Tou have been warned I love soocr and I was definitely not expecting it but as far as martinis it was one of the best I've ever had. Let's talk about the food. I can not believe for a moment I doubted this place. How do you go to a steakhouse and manage to order a burger and short rib? Well you smell something amazing and you're hooked. Wagyu beef burger. Can we take a moment. Hands down best burger my husband said he's ever hard. I had order envy but absolutely plan to go back to enjoy one. I decided to go with the short rib. It was delicious it melts in your mouth. The flavor was amazing. I didn't care for the grits but the short rib can hold its own. Their bread pudding is divine the sauce YUM, I think a scoop of vanilla ice cream would've complimented it well. Either way everyone deserves to treat themselves and this is the restaurant to do so! read more

See all

We have never had anything but excellent food and service here! It's perfect for a date night or for dinner with friends. If you bring kids, I would definitely recommend they at least be a little older so that they are able to sit for the duration of the meal. Drinks, appetizers, and steaks were absolute perfection every time we have been. read more

See all

I know everybody loves it there, but I'm not really a big fan, the food's not bad it's just OK. It's probably just me.

Went here for Valentine's Day and it was my first time here. We got a reservation for 4:30 and I would highly recommend getting a reservation! The service was absolutely amazing and our waiter was very kind and attentive. The food was so good. We both got filets and I got it crab Oscar style and was extremely happy with it. We got 2 slides, Calle Corn and The Garden, and both were great!! Gorgeous and classy atmosphere. Such a great place and can't wait to go back!! read more

Anthony's Chophouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Alright y'all so Anthony's is the real deal. Best lobster bisque I've ever had. Very creamy and full of flavor. Savored every bite and would get it again in a heartbeat. For the entree, I got the "flight of beef" which is 3, 4 oz filets (prime, grassfed and wagyu). You can add "personalization" to the steaks, and I tried the Chop sauce (their version of steak sauce) and Horseradish cream. My favorite of the three was the prime, followed by wagyu, then grassfed (slightly too chewy for my liking). I'd recommend trying to eat most of the steak when it first arrives at the table. The plates are room temperature, and the steaks quickly go from piping hot to room temperature once you cut into them. I really enjoyed the horseradish cream and for those familiar with some that have a kick, this one wasn't too overpowering. The sides are a la carte, and serve 2-3 people. We tried the shoestring fries, twice broiled yukon potatoes and broccolini. The yukon potatoes were my favorite, and they are served mashed with sour cream and some other spices. I would probably pass on the broccolini next time, they were kind of dry in my opinion. For dessert we tried a chocolate raspberry cheesecake with oreo crust. It had a light rich flavor and was enjoyed by everyone at the table. Overall, we had a wonderful experience. My only gripe would be that the service was a tad slow (we had a reservation at 7pm and didn't finish up until 930pm). However, the price point of this restaurant caters toward special occasions, so I'm guessing most guests wouldn't mind an extended dinner. read more

See all

As always, Anthony's Chophouse NEVER disappointments. Honestly, if I could eat here every night I would. The service is always amazing. You're not just a customer when you walk in the door, you're a friend /part of the family. The food is always to die for and served to perfection. The atmosphere is so cozy and inviting while still being open and modern. You walk in knowing you're going to have a top quality experience. Already looking forward to our next meal there! read more

See all