So I'm back. Didn't disappoint a second time. Today's choice: shrimp n grits for bar for Bae and Louisiana crawfish skillet pour moi. Très délicieux! It was raining today so it wasn't super crowded, which is a usual for a Sunday morning brunch. This is my second time and I wasn't disappointed. I also had coffee with Baileys Irish cream, which pretty tasty. With the commute time, this is certainly one of those places to visit every once in while. The drive is worth it, esp with the features on yelp and now wait that can notify wait times & reserve a spot before arriving. read more

See all

i had such high hopes... unfortunately the pancakes and French toast were both burnt and the eggs were cold by the time we received them. plus, it took a long time to get the food. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Good food yes. I like the food here. I got the Benedict burger and it was well cooked not dry like it like it.

I incidentally stumbled upon this place while driving back from kokomo. I was very impressed. This is one of my new go to breakfast places. First off, they make an amazing smoked salmon benedict which is probably one of my all time favorite breakfast item. Perfectly poached egg with a lightly toasted muffin on the bottom and a good serving of smoked salmon. I tried two of their omelettes as well. I love seafood and having crab meat for breakfast is a definite plus. I will say the portions are smaller than expected and i can easily eat two entrees without being full but i think the flavor and taste more than makes up for the difference. read more

See all

I think I found a new breakfast spot!! Off top, this was a great experience. I was feeling sad when I arrived at the restaurant but once my food arrived my mood quickly changed. A good meal is definitely good for the soul. I ordered the shrimp and grits without sausage over the city grits. Needless to say, it was AMAZING. Grits, Gouda cheese, shrimp, onions, red and green peppers and just the right amount of spice! Since I was a little down I also treated myself to a blueberry lemonade mimosa...... Delicious!!! The service was on point. This visit really turned my frown upside down! I definitely will return, there are other menu items I'm eager to try. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Shrimp n city grits! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Bad service Food cold Nobody came to check on us Had to ask for coffee and what on the world happened to our food Sat there for over a 1/2 hour until they finally figured they screwed up HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE read more

Carmel location...we just got up and left after sitting for 10 minutes and not even being offered coffee. The kicker was when the table next to us, who got there after we did got service. read more

Jesse, our waitress was bomb! She is the ideal representation of what a waiter should be like! She was friendly, very attentive but not overbearing, and most importantly, she made suggestions from food to drinks! They have so many different mimosas and Bloody Mary pitchers and drinks from traditional mixes! The menu is very good and versatile- something for everyone! I ordered the lemon zest blueberry pancakes without goat cheese and there wasn't a problem at all with modifying it. Definitely recommend to try. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Mimosa strawberry st. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The restaurant was neat and tidy. There was a bit of a strange smell in the entry way but when we got to our seats the smell went away. Our waitress was very nice and attentive. We got a complimentary beignet with like a lemon marmalade. It was very good. The food came quickly and everything was really tasty. I would for sure come back in the future. read more

See all

What a great breakfast experience! We were seated right away and greeted by our waitress. She promptly brought us some drinks and asked if we had been there before. I had not but the other two guests had been. Since I was a first time guest, she gave us a complimentary beignet dish with a honey marmalade sauce- it was delicious! She gave us enough time to look over the menu and answered any questions. There were plenty of original choices as well as some adventurous others. I ordered the broken egg biscuit sandwich which comprised of a chicken tender, flaky biscuit, gravy and your choice of egg. You get a side with the sandwich and I opted for fruit which was an up charge but it was seasonal fruit that cleansed the heavy breakfast palate. Everyone enjoyed their meals and cleared their plates. Since I was a first time guest, I also received a coupon to redeem for the next time I came. Great customer service and when I'm on this side of town I will come back! read more

See all

Food was great and the service attentive the wait was less than desirable but worth it once we received our order.

I went here on a Saturday morning for brunch. Since I was alone, I ended up eating at the bar, so I was able to sit down straight away. It's your basic chain style restaurant, and although I didn't see a lot of families there, it seemed like it would be a good place for families to eat. Nothing fancy, just good food with interesting names served promptly. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Hey Lucy Omelette - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Finally went here today for brunch. I recommend getting on the waitlist on Yelp, as it was busy and on a wait. I would assume this is the case every Sunday. When we sat down, our server asked if we had been there before. After telling her I had not, she brought out beignets for the table. What a nice touch. (Also, they were delicious. The marmalade they come with is top notch.) I ordered the Hey Lucy Omelette. It came with potatoes and I subbed the English muffin for a biscuit. My meal was VERY good. The omelette comes topped with avocado, and sides of salsa and sour cream. The biscuit was huge, hot, soft, and really good. Potatoes were crispy and tasty! After our meal, the manager came over, asked how our meals were, and gave me a sealed envelope. He said since it's my first time, it was for me. On my next visit, I can open it for a prize...ranging from free coffee to a gift card. Overall, I thought my meal was very good. I was VERY impressed with how out of their way the staff went to make my first time special. I'll definitely be back!!! read more

Phenomenal food- flavor and quality. And service was outstanding especially our server Dave. We will be back! If we lived here we would be living across the street from this place. read more

See all

This place is one of my favorites for weekend breakfast. From the staff to the cute coffee mugs I've never had a bad experience here. Some of my favorites are the shrimp and grits and the sausage. The sausage is just....my gosh I could honestly eat it every day. The cinnamon roll French toast is really delicious as well it's just super sweet. The beignets are good too just sometimes they're fried a bit too hard. All in all I recommend this place and I recommend getting there for an early brunch to avoid the crowds! read more

I had the best brunch experience at this staple today. The wait time was reasonable for a Saturday afternoon. We were greeted and seated quickly. Our server went above and beyond to ensure our experience was a delight. I enjoyed the country power bowl, one of their new additions, which our server recommended. My date had her usual southwest omelet, which was reliably delicious according to her. We always get a full order of their beignets and marmalade dipping sauce, which never disappoints. The cherry? Our server gave us a gift card for a commentary order or beignets the next time we visit. Can't beat that! read more

I really enjoy having brunch at Another Broken Egg. Their food is so fresh and flavorful - even a basic omelet is more than basic here! The coffee mugs are adorable and their coffee is great. I highly recommend making reservations on the weekends because they're busy! read more

We were in town for a concert and decided to get brunch before heading out. Another Broken Egg was one of the best decisions we made all weekend! The food was fantastic, service was attentive, and because it was our first visit, we received complimentary beignets! Everything was delicious. We ordered the house Bloody Mary and it was one of the better mixes I've had. We also ordered a cold brew, which was infused with liquor. Everything was good from start to finish. I also love the option of adding ourselves to the waitlist via Yelp! read more

See all

Really great breakfast option. They seemed to have some really great unique options and of course all of your classics. Our waiter was awesome. I had the Lucy omelet and loved it. It was really filling. They serve coke products and I will say my Diet Coke was delicious too. I would go again. My regret was not putting myself on the waitlist via the yelp app prior to walking in! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Breakfast was very good.....BUT what was even better was the waitress Haley was the best waitres I remember EVER having.....freindly, pleasant, informative, accurate, quick, on top of things, she knew what I needed without me having to ask...always asking before clearing a plate.....a restaurant can have the best food in the world.....and the food here is very good.....but what keeps people coming back is the wait staff.....Thank You Haley ! You are truly an asset to the business read more

See all

The food is good, the wait staff are attentive, and they were very focused on customer service. When the kitchen messed up my order, the waitress apologized and the manager comp'd my breakfast. At a time when service-oriented businesses are struggling to offer quality customer service, I appreciated their ownership of the mistake and their proactive steps to make it right. I've been a customer for years, and I'll be back. read more

I LOVE Another Broken Egg Cafe. The brunch here is always delicious and fresh. The place is relatively small, so expect a wait on the weekends. Luckily, you can add yourself to the wait list via Yelp. It is great! I usually opt for the Hey Lucy omelette with potatoes and a biscuit. The omelette is full of delicious ingredients and served with fresh salsa and avocado. The biscuits are my favorite, as well. They're big and fluffy. I have also had the biscuits and gravy, which I highly recommend. The manager of this location is outstanding. He is always accommodating for customers and makes sure a great experience is enjoyed by all. Great service all around. If you haven't been to Another Broken Egg Cafe, make sure you go soon! It is a must if you want to enjoy a delicious brunch. read more

This is a great breakfast place. The food is good, it has a good atmosphere and great service. It gets busy, so if we can't get a seat we will sit at the bar. I love the cinnamon roll French toast and the powdered sugared beignets! This trip I got eggs which were cooked just like I like them. read more

Food was amazingly good. We met for a girls brunch and it did not disappoint. Our Mimosa's were an added bonus and the staff was friendly , courteous , made our trip with it. We had a nice window seat, plenty of room for a nice leisurely brunch. read more

See all

Call ahead does not work! Don't bother! Came with a baby and a 95 year old. Still waiting. Nice for them that they are so busy, but we won't be back. We have been here for years. Service seems worse. read more

The manager at Another Broken Egg Café was so rude to my little girl and I... sweet thing left crying and I am literally shaking with frustration. While my boys were at Sunday morning religious education, I traditionally take my preschooler to brunch. Last week she and I came here and she really liked it. So, we came back again today. The wait for two of us was over 20 min, leaving us a very questionable margin of time before we had to be back at church to get the boys once food arrived. So, I asked to place a to-go order, but if a table opened up for seating and we had enough time.... that we would love to stay and dine-in with our order. Well, the manager had a problem with that. He said he would not allow us to do that because he 'didn't like the "perception" that having a to go box at a table would give'. I suggested that we be brought plates, if a table opened up and there was still enough time for us to eat. ...My suggestion was not acceptable to him and he forced me to make a choice. I said, "So, you're worried how it will look if I have a to-go box at the table - along with a plate?!" (Newsflash sir... Most parents with small children who eat small amounts will end up with a to-go box at their table anyway!) Apparently he'd rather lose business than accommodate some compassion. He continued to be condescending with his tone and backed me into a corner with a descision when timing was impossible to determine. So, I left... and my little one cried the whole way out saying, "But I want my French toast mommy!" UGH! I had been a patron for years, but as long as they employ managers like this guy - no thanks! (I won't post his name out of respect, even though he gave me very little.) read more

I love this location! The service is always fast, and staff is so friendly! I have been here many times with family and friends who are visiting and we all walk out with happy bellies. I love their crab cakes Benedict, and heovos rancheros. They have a pretty big selection and everything is categorized by food type. If you are "hangry" I'd suggest checking out their menu prior to getting their because you WILL get confused on what to order :) read more

I have been here twice now. So let me warn you. This Place is VERY VERY POPULAR! There is going to be a 30 - 45 minute wait if you don't get here before 11am. The environment is very homely and comfy. First time. I came here to celebrate my friend's birthday because this restaurant is his favorite place. We both ordered the lobster omelette, gluten free banana(nana Batman) pancake, BACON, eggs, and a mimosa. The food arrived in less than 15 minutes and the server was super nice and chatted with us telling us. Let me first say - the Lobster omelette is amazing! Seriously. Order it. and then devour it. Because the truth is I make pretty good omelettes and my friend say my omelettes are 'Little drops of heaven'. But Omelettes from this restaurant made me cry! IT IS SOOO GOOD! The banana pancake... Get it regular, I didn't like the gluten free - it felt a little dense and sandy in my mouth. 1st time Overall Service: 4/5 Food: 5/5 Ambiance: 4/5 Second time. I came here for brunch with another friend because of how much I liked this restaurant and hope she enjoyed it as much as I do. We had to wait 45 minutes because we got there at noon. She ordered a shrimp and grits and I ordered a craw fish & sausage skillet. Sadly she is allergic to canola oil and everything was cooked in it. After a bite she felt sick. Her misery is my happiness. My craw fish and sausage skillet was delectable, I only ate half of it, so I can help my friend eat half of the shrimp and grits. Oh Man Oh MANNN! Get both the craw fish and sausage skillet and shrimp and grits, then pour the shrimp and grits on top of the sausage skillet. It makes the best seafood & sausage grit skillet! Sucks for my friend though! 2nd time Overall Service: 4/5 Food: 5/5 Ambiance: 4/5 read more

See all

Pre Mother's Day Brunch with my mom. I wanted to take her somewhere unique with good food options. She had never been to Another Broken Egg so she was in for a treat! We started off with the fried green tomatoes and that was a hit. She got the crab cakes and more green tomatoes. I tried the lobster bisque omelet. It was good but it was not my favorite. I love the shrimp and grits there! I also had a mimosa from the full bar. This is not your typical brunch restaurant it's very unique and my mom loved it! She said she'll be back! Lol read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Lobster Brie omelette. Yum! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Clean, bright atmosphere. Seemed like a long wait for food to arrive but the place was bustling. A wide range of menu selections from classics to health conscious to creative funk. The oatmeal was calling me but.....I fought it off in favor of the Avocado Toast with Salmon. I was suitably rewarded with an incredible delicacy. Staff are extremely pleasant and we will most assuredly return. read more

I love this place for breakfast or brunch! The food is reliably good - with some of the best pancakes that are not your "run of the mill". I particularly love the lemon, blueberry and goat cheese!! I often crave them and just have to go! Great thing is that while they don't take reservations - we can get in line via the app and reduce our wait time dramatically. They stay busy but the servers are quick and managers are happy to pitch in to make sure that even when they are swamped, the service is good and the food is fresh and hot! We've never had a bad meal here and we've had plenty! I hesitated to write this for fear I'd encourage more to go and make it harder for me to get my favorite table...but that's just selfish and I'm really trying to work on that! read more

This place is delicious and totally worth the wait. This was the second time my hubby and I came to eat here on our visits to Carmel. We like to stop in for brunch. We waited 45 minutes for a table but we're able to see the live waitlist and our place on line. Our waiter was okay. I would have preferred someone to check on us more frequently, but she was nice and attentive. I ordered the Mardi Gras Scramble with the city grit and a mimosa and latte. The only thing, you have to remember to order it with cheese, as it does not come with cheese. I ended up getting cheese on the side to add. It was still delicious. Definitely a must try out! read more

I'll be dreaming about the Monterey Omelette tonight wishing I could eat it again tomorrow morning for breakfast! This was a great brunch spot this Sunday morning. It was our first time trying it out and we will definitely be back! The staff was friendly and although there was about a 15 minute wait, we didn't mind. We were delighted that our food came out so quick and the orders were both spot on (I highly recommend asking for a side of their salsa with the Monterey Omelette). The next time I do go back I would like to try the Biscuit Beignets, I hear they're delicious! read more

Great attentive service. The server and manager made it clear they wanted us back. We go out for breakfast every Sunday morning and we agreed they made it on our top 3 behind Ruth's and Rosie's. read more

Visited location after running a half marathon in downtown Indianapolis and let me tell you this was sooooo worth the visit. I had their pancake breakfast with eggs and bacon. Delicious, service was exceptional as well. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Pancakes with cheesy eggs and bacon! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This place is always packed so exercise patience. The food is worth the wait though. We love their seafood omelets and the biscuit beignets! My Granny loved it too! read more

This was a really nice breakfast spot! I would suggest putting in a reservation due to them being really busy (I went on a Sunday). When it's your first time going they offer you complimentary beignets... they were so amazing and good! It came with a sauce that taste kind of like caramel apple. I ordered the crab cakes benedict's and was scrapping my plate before I knew it. Great service, beautiful atmosphere, delicious food and great parking! I will be back read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Crab cake benedict with loaded potatoes - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The only thing that is wrong is the word "another" in the name of Another Broken Egg Cafe. Anything but another tired breakfast, brunch and lunch place. This place managed to bring zest, innovation an the flavor of New Orleans to a the ancient concept. Out of breakfast items, Granola, Fruit and Quinoa was pretty close to life changing. For one, it gently forced me try coconut milk and now I have replaced regular milk in my fridge with an almond/coconut blend. OK, let me read this out to you: house made honey roasted granola, blueberry quinoa (the color of blueberries, too!), strawberries, blueberries, toasted coconut crushed bananas served with coconut milk and greek yogurt drizzle. The crunch of granola, smooth grains of quinoa, fresh cool fruit and heavy consistency of coconut milk mixed with yogurt was a divine surprise fir the palate. I even took whatever was left home, although this is one of the least likely items for leftovers. For lunch, loved Fried Green Tomatoes from the appetizer menu, with a crab cake and served on a bed of spinach. Classic green tomatoes, crunchy on the outside, hot and tangy on the inside. Drizzle of creole remoulade sauce and goat cheese crumbles completed the picture of deliciousness. And then comes Death to Diet, aka Biscuit Beignets. With a bit of crunch and buried under powdered sugar, impossible to stop eating until all are gone. Very friendly staff on every occasion. Great job, Another Broken Egg Cafe! Will make an effort to stop by every time I am in the neighborhood. Eggs Benedict are on my lust to try next time - there are six types of these on the menu... read more

See all

Came for a late breakfast and was really impressed with how great this place is. Very short wait for a table for 4 and service was great. Food was just as good as well. I had the eggs benedict with a side of andouille sausage, boys had biscuits and gravy and cinnamon roll french toast. All dishes were fantastic. Will be back here for sure. read more

I have been here a few times and the food is consistently good. The last visit was for business and we were able to reserve the private room which was lovely. read more