My first Yelp of the year goes to Another Broken Egg! This was not my first visit, and will not be my last! I've been here a number of times, but there was something special about it this day. I went alone for brunch because I was craving their crab cake Benedict and city grits. I walked in and got seated immediately. They had their tables/guests social distanced. They had hand sanitizer for the guest as soon as you walked in the door. My server so very quick and efficient. However, my food, my food was AMAZING! I tried to get a picture of each thing, but I forgot as soon as my main course arrived. I got the pomegranate mule, city grits, crab cake Benedict, and a side order of bananas foster pancakes. Everything was delicious. I definitely had some leftover that I ate the next day for breakfast, but I enjoyed every bite. I cannot wait to go back, because I also love their lobster and Brie omelette. Thank you ABE, that brunch really made my day. read more

See all

1. Beignets are ok, at best. cant taste flavor because of it being drenched in powdered sugar and how long it takes to chew. Otherwise it was good food, and good flavor. Crab cake Benedict was 3.5/5. Pancakes are FIRE!!! Shrimp & grits BOMB too, just extremely creamy. Good atmosphere and drinks! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - oops all gone lol - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Davneet was a great server. fantastic food , outdoor seating on a beautiful fall day!

You know what- I like this place. There's something low-key and simple about it that reminds me of a small town diner with an elevated menu out of New Orleans. Think: crawfish, shrimp and grits on the menu. Oh, and how could I forget the biscuit beignets topped with powdered sugar and honey marmalade? A few of my favorites include the granola, fruit and quinoa convo with coconut milk w d fresh bananas. Pretty much anything you order will be tasty and at a reasonable price. Outdoor patio seating is available and the menu offers several options for those who are gluten free and veggie friendly. read more

This is the best place ever! Covid brought us here during the summer and we are still coming every Wednesday to have brunch. We are comfortable in the environment with the staff friendly and efficient! We are usually here for a couple of hours, just chatting with each other and the staff never seems to mind. They just keep filling our coffee cups and tell us to stay as long as we like. (We have left when we have seen that it is busy and need the table. . . we do have manners!) If you are ever near here and want a good meal - stop in. Coffee is hot and fresh, food is served quickly and can't say enough good things about all the wait staff (Elizabeth, David, Hailey, Marco and all the other I forgot their names!) This place is top notch!!! read more

Great spot! Delicious food with a great menu selection. Good healthy options too, so you don't feel jipped for cutting calories. I enjoyed the "black bean eggs Benedict" which was delicious! Just the right amount of mild spice mixed into in the hollandaise. Also, it's worth upgrading to the Mediterranean Potatoes -- wedge potatoes pan fried with garlic and feta. Delish! Also, my favorite part is how they present tea. See photo! They bring a big velvet lined box of Mighty Leaf tea for you to choose from. Nice clean interior. Ample parking, too. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Food was great. Have had breakfast there a few days and always good. Chicken and waffles at last visit was really good. Staff was friendly. read more

Summary: Don't overthink this, just do it. Solid breakfast. Met here for an early morning business meeting. As it was cold, I appreciated a nearby hook for my coat. We jumped right into our discussion. The server was VERY patient with us, which I appreciated. We (finally) ordered and I got the Mardi Gras Omelet and man was it good! I wish I wasn't working, I would have enjoyed it more. The tomato hollandaise sauce was great paired with the crawfish and shrimp. Coffee refills came frequent. Service was great. I'll be back, for sure! read more

One of my favorite breakfast spots in Indy, hands down! It has the small town cafe feel - you can either sit inside or outside! I am an iced coffee junkie, theirs is great here. I am also an avid seafood lover and their lobster omelet is my go-to every time! I have brought several friends and family members here and they all love it! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Lobster and brie omelet - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Love another broken egg cafe usually great service but today has been terrible. I decided to bring my dad to another broken egg we got seated around 12:45pm. Excited to get my usual order cinnamon roll drench toast, my dad ordered a Omelet. We have been watching everyone else around us who got seated after us get there food. Their excuse was the tickets got mixed up. Highly disappointed with the service. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Cinnamon roll French toast! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

If for no other reason, the City Grits earn these folks a top notch rating. Honestly though, everything I've ever ordered is great. Service is pleasant, prices are reasonable, and did I mention the grits?? Yum! read more

Whhhhy am I just now dining here?!! Okay so first off don't "judge" but I had to start with a mimosa at 9:30 in the morning to give a proper review, lol! That mimosa was not only good but all I needed was one and I was done! I'm a sugar and buttered grits gal, BUT the city grits here have opened my eyes to savory! They were creamy, balanced with the salty and crunchy toppings of scallions and bacon. I took off the tomatoes that also come on it (not a fan of raw tomatoes). However my eyes saw the glory when I tasted the seasonal pancake: CARROT CAKE!! The pancake was like eating a thin slice of carrot cake with a light drizzle of icing. Not overly sweet at all. If you like carrot cake this is a must try. Oh and the baked bacon is thick and crunchy without all the grease. This place gets a two thumbs up from me all around! I'm coming back with friends! read more

See all

Honey lemon blueberry French toasts excellent sounding name looks amazing and tastes as good. Excellent service place is clean highly recommend. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Honey lemon blueberry French toasts looks as good and tastes as good as it sounds and looks so come and get it. Excellent service also. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Happy Saturday! The best is being off and Not cooking! We like to switch it up-sometimes! This is up there with our best "Saturday ordering breakfast places!" Everything was tasty! read more

See all

We went to this place for our anniversary brunch! First off the service is impeccable! We had on shirts that showed our wedding date and the Manager noticed them and came to our table with the biscuit beignets and wished us a happy anniversary! It was so nice that he noticed that small detail about us! The food was awesome! The shrimp and grits OH MY GOODNESS!!!! So amazing, the waffles and pancakes were good too! Definitely returning soon!!!! read more

See all

Amazing food and great service . I enjoy dining at their bar area . Good vibes all around . read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Pound cake French toast - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The atmosphere, the customer service and the food was exceptional. We most definitely will be like boomerangs on continued return read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I have actually been here twice and each time I got this pumpkin waffle, AMAZING. The wait here can be a little while especially if you're going on Saturday which is normally when I go but there is an option to get on the waiting list before you arrive, I absolutely adore this place. Good food, and great service every time. I always go here when I'm in the area. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Pumpkin Waffle - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The customer service and food were great! I tried the shrimp Benny and would highly recommend. We also got a side of beignets served with an orange marmalade that was pretty good! read more

Visited here twice while in town and I must say the food is very good. Would recommend to anyone looking for great tasting food. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Bacon Lover's BLT&A, grits - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Very disappointing!! Should've turned around and walked out when the hostess was rude and unwelcoming but we thought, "hey that's not our server so let's give it a try." Our server wasn't terrible but he wasn't good either. I've worked in the service industry my entire adult life so I have an idea of how it all works. Ordered the peppered Bloody Mary which our server made himself and it tasted like watered down tomato juice...it was really bad. My omelet was ok but the potatoes were cold along with the toast which was also covered in black toaster buildup which grossed me out. I would never serve that to a customer. One thing I can say is the coffee was really good. Other than that I was no impressed and I really was hoping this place was going to be a winner. I won't be returning. read more

My first trip to Another Broken Egg was fantastic. Weekday morning wait wasn't insignificant (15-20 minutes) so arrive early. It's a busy and trendy location and the food makes it worth the wait. The restaurant has limited outdoor seating and a smallish interior - not tiny by any means, but not exactly the Cracker Barrell. There were many dishes to choose from, and ultimately I ordered the Florida Omelet. Three eggs, sautéed crab meat, cream cheese. I happen to be eating Keto Diet and while I wasn't confident in my order's taste, I knew it was a great keto option. I skipped all the sides, so I can't speak to them, but the omelet was amazing. Good enough I tried (unsuccessfully) to recreate it at home a few days later. Coffee was plentiful and very good as well. It's on my breakfast list now anytime I'm on the north side of Indianapolis. Well worth the wait, and a great business meeting location as well. read more

Great place! Not your run of the mill breakfast places. Louisiana inspired items. Gave us some complimentary beignets since it was our first time. Everything top notch. Delicious. read more

Mom and I went here for a Saturday morning breakfast. We had come to this location when it was the only one years ago. Mom was only semi-impressed then, so hadn't had much of a desire to go back. We decided to give it another chance. We arrived around 9 AM and there were quite a few empty tables. I could tell this was not due to lack of servers as I saw many servers standing around waiting for tables to wait on. I imagine this place probably gets busier between 10 and 11AM once people are up. We were promptly seated and then greeted by our sever shortly after. She was very sweet and attentive. I ordered the Floridian Omelette which was filled cream cheese and topped with garlic butter crab meat (not krab/fake crab meat), jack cheese, and scallions. It was flavorful, creamy, and they did not skimp on the crab meat. I opted for fruit instead of potatoes or grits for my side. I was pleasantly surprised to see a healthy serving of berries and mango. It's nice to see a place go outside the usual honeydew and pineapple route. It also came with a toasted English muffin that was very fresh and fluffy. The coffee was your usual breakfast joint coffee and I was okay with that. Mom opted for the hash brown benedict, which she seemed to like but wasn't raving about it. There were definitely other items on the menu I'd like to return to try. They had multiple seafood breakfast options, which you don't see everyday. The atmosphere was pleasant, and there was even an actual bar here. They also have a few tables outside the front of the restaurant as well. Since this is in a strip, it doesn't have a separate designated "patio," but it's adequate if you'd like to eat outside. You'll just get a view of the parking lot. All in all, a pleasant experience. read more

See all

I love this restaurant! I went with my family and as usual they did not disappoint! We were able to get on the waitlist before we arrived, which during peak brunch hours kept our wait time at maybe 20 minutes. We had a hard time choosing what we wanted to eat but we all decided on crab cakes with city grits on the side. So good!! Our servers are so friendly and it was just a great brunch experience ! read more

I wanted something to eat that was quick and easy. When I arrived the host said that I can sit at the Bar which is fine. I sat there for about 5 minutes no one asked me if I wanted anything. Waiters kept walking around and ignoring me. Finally when I got help it was rushed, my Coffee was ok but once I got one cup I did not get a refill. My Bagel was not toasted the Salmon was a joke with Capers and minimal cream cheese. I had to flag down the waitresses just to get a refill and the place was not crowded or busy. Just a bunch of slow lazy wait staff and manager. What a joke!!!! read more

Met a friend here for brunch and apparently I've been sleeping on this place! Well I won't be missing out on Another Broken Egg any longer! I had a cup of hot chocolate to start which was lovely. Then I got the chocolate stuffed waffle, sausage patties and scrambled eggs. (Do you think I like chocolate? Lol.) It was all tasty! I was especially impressed by the sausage patties, they were so flavorful! I felt the waffle was just the right size and delicious. I definitely look forward to coming back and trying other items and the mimosas! I also appreciate that they use the Waitlist function. If you are looking for a tasty brunch then check out Another Broken Egg Cafe! read more

Great menu service was great food was excellent the omelet's are great atmosphere is nice the menu is great

I chose this spot for breakfast because it seemed like their food was more fresh and healthy than the other breakfast places in the area. It lived up to that expectation and more! I was overwhelmed by the unique breakfast options. I mean how many other places have crab, crawfish, and lobster as options for your Eggs Benedict? After much debate I settled on the Sausage and Fennel Omelet. It was the best Omelet I have ever had! I would have eaten the Fennel, Mushroom, tomato, and Onion topping for the Omelet by itself. Not sure what sauce pulled it all together, but it was pure creamy deliciousness! Another Broken Egg Cafe is also known for their breakfast beverages. Mainly their wide variety of unique Bloody Mary's and Mimosa's. I did not get a chance to have one today, but I will definitely be back to have one next time! The service was also stellar. The Hostess and Waitress were both very friendly and on point. I had another beverage before mine was ever empty and was offered one for the road. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Sausage and Fennel Omelet with Wheat Toast - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Another fine breakfast place, close by. Always clean, bright and friendly. A big choice of breakfast items, and if you like, some nice Bloody Mary's read more

Randomly stopped in because I was in the area. Since I was dining alone I chose to sit at the bar. There were a few regulars seated there, love that!! I too want to find a local restaurant to be my second home. Breakfast foods are my favorite especially the sweet stuff. On this visit I opted to stray from my usual by ordering a savory dish. As I sat at the bar the server must've noticed my struggle because she graciously helped me make a decision. With her suggestion I selected the Mardi Gras omelette; Louisiana crawfish, gulf shrimp, andouille and red peppers, topped with tomato hollandaise, tomatoes and green onions....with loaded country potatoes. The omelette was huge and overflowed with filling. The andouille provided the right amount of spice and the hollandaise was scrumptious..I thought about licking the plate. Mardi Gras didn't make me regret my decision to go savory. On to why I rated this 4 stars. The country potatoes weren't seasoned very well. I was glad that I opted to add bacon, cheese, sour cream and green onions. The toppings jazzed it up but I still added ketchup because they were a little dry. The omelette while tasty was a bit over cooked. The eggs were a bit overcooked; the texture took away from the tasty filling. Overall, it was a great experience. I chatted with a very nice older gentleman at the bar, the staff was great, and the atmosphere was cozy! I will be back to sample some sweet stuff!! read more

See all

Lobster and grits are so delicious I could eat them every day ! Good customer service food season good! I love this this place and would come again read more

Huge rip off. I ordered a an omelette and asked the server about it. She said she was new and could not answer my questions. It was brought to me and I was questioned that it looked funny. I tried it and didn't like it and they refused to take it off my bill, even though they took it away, so I want to pay $28 for two eggs and two pieces of bacon. Two pieces of bacon was $5.19 by itself. The manager was a jerk and unprofessional. read more

Love Another Broken Egg! The food is always stellar and using the wait list through Yelp has been a painless process. Service is excellent. Highly recommend! read more

Omg I can only hope St. Louis opens one of these. First, the service could not have been better. Our server, Hayley, was helpful navigating us through the menu and offering suggestions as we asked. The cucumber Mary is the perfect blend of refreshing and spice. The beignets they offer made us feel welcomed as first timers. The food was just amazing. Again just have to mention how great the service was from start to finish. 5 stars aren't enough!! read more

See all

Another Broken Egg isn't what I thought it would be. It's a restaurant from the South, and the decor feels like Florida...bright colors, plants, almost Spanish style. Lots of seafood on the menu, like crawfish and shrimp in omelettes (although there are plenty of options w/o seafood if it's not your thing.) But then...there's a bar. With a big screen TV playing sports. You can order alcoholic drinks. I was a little thrown off, because I was expecting a quaint cafe. Definitely a different take. Service was okay. The waitress wasn't overly friendly, and seemed rushed to take our orders. I got the "Hey Lucy" w/ chorizo, avocado, cheese, onions, chilies, and cheddar jack. It came w/ a side of sour cream and spicy salsa, 2 English muffins, and there seasoned potatoes that taste JUST like french fries (in a good way). Overall a good lunch/brunch serving for around $12. I would go for something less spicy in the future because this was a little too much for me in the brunchtime hours. read more

See all

This is one of my favorite breakfast places on the north side. For one thing, they make the best Bloody Mary cocktail I have had. Just the perfect amount of spicy, flavor and served up with a nice thick piece of bacon and pickled okra. They even have variations of the drink which I have yet to try, you can order them by the pitcher and if you come in on Sundays, you can get them discounted! Apart from the yummy breakfast cocktails, the menu is amazing as well. A lot of places that I go to, I have one favorite and that is the one thing I order every time I go there... With Another Broken Egg, I have had to try a lot of things because everything sounds so good. And everything IS so good! One of my favorites is the Broken Egg Biscuit Sandwich, which is just the right amount of food at a reasonable price. Everything has a cajun spin on it, so you can get favorites like crab cakes, andouille sausage, and other southern favorites. I also find the staff to be friendly and efficient. Even when you are sitting at the breakfast bar. I have yet to have a bad experience! read more

I love breakfast/ brunch! The service here is always nice but there's always a wait. I stuck to my go to which is their supreme omelette but hold the bacon with a side of potatoes. It was good and fulfilling. Anything off this menu is worth the eats. You won't be disappointed at all. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - The Supreme Omelette - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Went today and was told 20 min wait - I can handle that no big deal- when told table is ready then was told only one set of silverware is clean and someone will bring us another set. Never happened even after food delivered and asked waiter for some, we had to go get ourselves - 2 parties were seated after us, asked to order, served and checked out before us- we had to tell waiter we were ready to order and also had to ask for check- First time there , food was fine however will not return- read more

Went for Sunday brunch at 10:30A. Had a 30 minute wait which was quite acceptable. Waitress was very informative. Started with beignets which were good (not as good as down in NOLA...but hey...it's Indy). I love powdered sugar and they had a honey orange marmalade dipping sauce that was so delicious. Hot tea selection is good. Morning spirits selection is too and I wish I had partaken. Had Floridian omelet. It was just ok. I thought the crab was a bit fishy. Those city grits though are a close second to my husband's cheesy grits. I snarfed those down and would have loved to just had that instead of my omelet!! Overall though -- I would go back. Just would steer clear of seafood. Imitation crap meat would have tasted better honestly. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Floridian. Don't recommend...the crab was fishy. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all