Brunch, without a doubt, is my favorite meal of the day and at Another Broken Egg Cafe they truly deliver great flavors and wonderful service. As a self proclaimed brunch conneiseur-groupie I tend to know my way around several of Indy's brunch "hot spots" and ever since my first visit I was charmed! Presentation, friendly service, and even adorable monogrammed hot chocolate mugs. The space is quaint and cute with many tables and some booths, and a bar tucked into the back; bright and very open with lots of windows and a door leading back to their outdoor patio. The decor looks very "a la le peep" (can I say that?) but with definitely more personality and their food is spot on. The menu selections are pretty consistent but packed with flavors. I tend to not deviate from the traditional Belgian waffle and I've had their amazing Cinnamon Roll french toast but nothing compares to their huevos rancheros. I was blown away by the flavors in this dish last time I stopped in. I love the prompt, warm, courteous service, the tiny monogrammed mugs, and truly their amazing food is the reason weekend lines are out the door. They now have a live wait-list feature through Yelp to be able to snag a table at a much faster rate. We will be back! read more

See all

My first time here i thought it was nice for them to ask if this was your first visit i was in for a surprise i got 4 fried biscuits of some sort with powdered sugar and a citrus sort of jelly...i later found out the biscuits were called benays of some sort, they were pretty tasty. I was surprised they had more to offer than the normal just orange juice and champagne mimosas they had apple, raspberry and a couple more, i had the apple which was delicious. After looking over the many selections the waitress recommended shrimp and grits which my friend got and i had the Belgium waffles that had caramelized pecans and crispy bacon pieces, it came with 2 eggs and a meat selection which i had 2 strips of nice crispy bacon. I enjoyed my meal and took the other half home for breakfast the next day. I didnt taste my friends shrimp and grits which also had sausages in it, it had a very good taste but was a bit too spicy for me. Overall everything was good our waitress was wonderful and even a manager i think came to see if everything was good, offered my friend more free garlic bread as well....i will be back read more

See all

Great classic breakfast and brunch options with unique twists. I loved the beignets, Lucy omelette, and crawfish scramblers. Our servers were kind and attentive. They were patient with our toddlers, and the restaurant was very clean. Definitely recommend. read more

AMAZING FOOD!! I ate at Another Broken Egg Cafe in Michigan years ago and I remember it being one of the best breakfasts I'd ever eaten. I never made the connection that we had one in Indianapolis until I ate here the other day. I'm over the moon to have one so close. The food here is top notch! My friends and I all tried the huevos rancheros and they were delicious. We also split a cinnamon roll that was very tasty. HUGE BONUS...they offer gluten free pancakes and they taste good :)! I'll be a regular customer here for years to come. read more

Great spot for breakfast. Will definitely need to come back. Had the opportunity to come here with a friend and we really enjoyed ourselves. She's a regular patron and was quite familiar with the menu but I challenged her to try something new. They have great brunch options. I saw some very different items that I haven't seen on any menu; to include lobster and Brie omelette; crawfish skillet (too many for me to recall) Service is excellent. Wait staff was very attentive and on point. ^^^^^^^^^^^^ So the above portion was from the first time I visited another broken egg. But didn't get a chance to finish my review. I have been several times now. It has become a little obsession of my husband's. He really enjoys their city grits and we go every opportunity we get. I've had their lobster omelette with champagne butter sauce - it's amazing. Here was the first time I had fried-green tomatoes and I gotta say-they were pretty good. I like the zesty sauce they put with it. I think that's what made it work. I've had their crawfish skillet absolutely delicious-amazing! Their French toast-probably some of the best that I've had around here - amazing. Just everything is really good about another broken egg. Please, please, do not deny yourself some of their beignets. Oooo me oh my! So good. If you don't know what a beignet (been-yay) is it is basically a square fried doughnut covered in powdered sugar (very popular in New Orleans); And another broken egg did a great job in theirs. They have this marmalade that they serve with it-amazing!!!! You'll want a full order of these bad boys I went to breakfast there with a friend and now she's hooked on them . So good. If you have some time, get up go there; it's a great way to start your day. The prices are reasonable and the portions are great. You'll probably have leftovers depending on what you get. If Frankie P is a waiter-ask for him. He's awesome! He wasn't even our waiter a couple times when we came in but was always so helpful and willing to help us if our waiter/waitress wasn't available. I hope he's still working there; I feel like he helps make the place feel welcome. Check it out, it's a great place. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Can't go wrong with crab cakes and fried green tomatoes - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

What a wonderful addition to the neighborhood. Outstanding service, good breakfast good and the pitcher of mimosas is a must! The city grits are so good and a guilty pleasure. If you like smoked salmon, get the Salmon Benedict! Easy parking. Friendly servers and staff. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Salmon Benedict, City Grits, side of fruit, fresh-brewed coffee, and a pitcher of Mimosas. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Excellent service thanks to Aubrey! She wasn't even my waitress but took amazing care of me as my waitress was a bit slower coming out but she was lovely too but I'd certainly ask for Aubrey next time! read more

Soo happy my sister and I decided to try this place, it did not disappoint! I hear it commonly referred to as "broken egg" but totally missed the memo about how good the food is. The menu had so many options to choose from which made it a struggle to choose my meal. They also have creative seasonal dishes & alcoholic breakfast beverages. Our server was super sweet & accommodating. The restaurant is cozy & kid friendly so the whole family can make a trip. We absolutely loved our food, I was so ready to eat that I took a few bites before stopping to take picture lol. Please stop in & treat yourself to breakfast at another broken egg. read more

See all

Our server James did an amazing job and gave me a positive experience during my meal! If you come here say hi to James!

The seating is kind of crowded if you aren't in a booth, which may not matter to some people. The food is amazing! I had the biscuits and gravy. read more

Great menu, nice staff, pleasant ambiance! The perfect place for brunch! Plenty of parking.

I came here for brunch early on a Sunday morning and it was such a pleasant surprise! The vibe was very welcoming and cozy. The food was delicious (highly recommend the huevos rancheros),and we even got complimentary beignets because it was our first visit! Our waitress, Abby, was excellent! She was very attentive, knew the menu, and super easy to talk to. Can't wait to go back again! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Huevos rancheros and lobster brie omelette - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Another Broken Egg - Another yummy meal Another Broken Egg Cafe is one of those places I always meant to visit, but never got around to. I was fortunate enough to meet a friend there for her birthday, and I was not disappointed. The restaurant was cheery and bright, and the servers were friendly and welcoming to me as a first-timer. They even brought us complimentary beignets! My food was delicious, and came out hot and well-seasoned. The menu offered a wide variety of choices, and the breakfast cocktails were yummy, as well. I'd vote Another Broken Egg Cafe as one of the top places to visit for breakfast on the North side of the city. read more

Great Spot for Breakfast A couple years ago some friends and I discovered this little spot and fell in love. We used to have monthly brunches on Saturdays just to catch up with life. The restaurant is ALWAYS busy on Saturdays so one of the servers recommended using the No Wait app for our next visit and we've used it ever since. It makes waiting in line so much easier. All the servers are very nice and make sure to check on their tables even during the big rush. For appetizers go with the biscuit beignets. Sooo good especially with the dipping sauce. It's an sweet orange-y taste but it's very good. Don't eat to many because you will be full half way through your regular meal. I typically get a Belgium waffle with scrambled eggs and a slice of ham. Oh yea definitely some mimosas. Pitchers are offered for the mimosas and I highly recommend it. This time I went with the signature cocktail Strawberry Lemonade Sparkler. Although very sweet, it was good. read more

See all

Came for brunch and was seated promptly. Plenty of options to choose from. The food to me was average and lacked some flavor. The best part of my meal was the Bloody Mary. The best I've had in a long time. Asked for it to be extra spicy and they didn't disappoint. I'd return just for the Bloody Mary !!! Service was friendly and attentive. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Finally tried Another Broken Egg! Yay. My friend recommended it to me for my brunch with my girls and I am so glad that he did. When I walked in, I asked the staff if we could sit outside. At first he was hesitant and said the patio was closed.. it was a Wednesday at 1oclock.. I was bummed. Then he must have read my non verbals and said "let me check with the manager".. the manager was SOO accommodating and let us sit outside. I had a hard time deciding what I wanted to order. Our server was excellent and recommended so many plates to try. Finally I decided to order the spinach omelette and got turkey sausage instead of bacon. The food was delicious!!! The sausage could have been chopped up a little better but besides that I thought it was great!!!! Let's talk about the MIMOSAS. Yum yum! They offer a variety of different options and gave us a pitcher. It was such a cute, intimate and chill spot. I will be back! :) read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Yummmm. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Hands down the BEST breakfast spot in Indy!!!!!!!!! I've turned at least 10 ppl on to this spot and the have all said the same thing!!!!!! They Never disappoint..... read more

My wife and I went here the morning after our wedding several months ago, and we didn't really love it. One of their specialties seemed to be seafood omelettes and the like. My wife loves seafood and breakfast, so it seemed like a good choice. She got some sort of lobster omelette, and she didn't dislike it, but didn't think it was anything phenomenal either. I'm not a huge seafood guy (not me: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gIxIfZdqr8A), but every once in a while I enjoy it, and again, it was what they were supposed to do well. I got an omelette with crab. It tasted like straight fish. I mean there was no flavor of eggs, seasoning, onions, peppers, or anything else that was supposed to be in it. It came with sour cream, and I basically coated the omelette with the sour cream to make it palatable, so I wouldn't be starving when we left. I really don't think this is probably a one-star restaurant, but I could hardly choke down my food. I ended up taking about half of it as leftovers when I couldn't get through anymore, and ended up throwing it away without eating anymore. This isn't necessary a one-star-I'd-never-come-back kind of review, but I wouldn't be eager to revisit, and I would never get any of their seafood brunch dishes again. read more

Food was very average. Not seasoned like at all. we split the bloody mary pitcher between the 3 of us. our server said it would give us 5 drinks total. well we barely for 3. we would have been better off just each ordering our own drinks. Not pleased with this place at all. large parking lot so plenty of parking avaiable. inadequate wait seating. can say the chances of me returning are pretty slim read more

Always good but this time it was hot and that's important. Service was excellent. That little girl working was working a little too hard, but she got it done. read more

For the price point, the food and service left a lot to be desired. Food and drinks: I ordered the crab cake benedict. The crab cakes themselves had an acceptable crab/filling ratio, but were under seasoned. The hollandaise also did nothing for the overall flavor profile. My friend actually liked her dish - shrimp and grits - so I asked for a side of the sauce used for that and it did help. My side of grits were ok, but a bit runny for my liking. We also ordered bellinis. They came out fast, but had too much purée and were overly sweet. Service: Our order was taken pretty much immediately but that the only time our server was attentive. We literally had to ask another server to get our server on three separate occasions (the other servers were INCREDIBLY attentive). She did however came back immediately for the bill and I also noticed that when we left she was already clearing the table even though there was no line/no one waiting. So I guess she came around for the things she cared about. We were also never offered complimentary beignets even though it was our first visit. Facilities: Outdoor seating was limited, but available. Also, the restrooms were not clean. Anywho, this place has relatively good reviews which is what drew me, so I'll probably try it again later. But read more

I really enjoy breakfast here, often coming out of my way to do so! They offer free beignets for first time guests. When they weren't brought out before our entrees, they brought us a piping hot whole fresh order (8 total when the free offering is usually about 4) AND a coupon for another free order on our next visit! I had a very good spiked coffee drink and ordered the Creole Omelette. If you're a grits person, they have a specialty order that's loaded called City Grits. There's something on the menu here for everyone. In fact it's often hard for me to choose! You can go traditional or get a Cajun-inspired dish. Only challenge is it's very busy. We have had to wait a long time before so make sure to check the live check-in list on Yelp before you go! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Mardi Gras omelet - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I forgot how much I like this place since the pandemic. They have a lot of good Benedict recipes (which I am a sucker for). The vibe is casual and the service is good. This cafe is in my mile radius so I will be back read more

k Atmosphere: lovely with lots of apparent business people having a breakfast. Quiet enough for conversation and tables spaced. Food: Excellent. I had a traditional breakfast and each item was properly prepared. Bacon was delicious and no potatoes were left behind. We tried the Biscuit Beignets and they were tasty although only a marmalade sauce was offered. Nice that they brought them as an "appetizer". Service: 5 star. Elizabeth was a great server and made us feel welcome. I noticed the servers were friendly and could explain the various options. Timing was excellent and no waits for bill or paying. Coffee refilled promptly. I would eat there again and husband said we need to try the lunch offerings. read more

Went here three times in one trip to Indianapolis. The food was great. Definitely get an order of beignets. They were amazing!! Served warm with a dipping sauce. I got one of their omelettes. The quality of food was excellent and the service was great each time. I would definitely go back and highly recommend it if you are looking for a breakfast place. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

To be honest, it was kind of a forgettable breakfast experience. There was nothing wrong with the food or the service, but I would not go there again. There seem to be no shortage of breakfast and brunch places around Indy and Carmel, thankfully. Our table got the Popeye's Favorite (scrambled eggs, spinach, onions, bacon), the Classic Biscuits & Gravy, and the kids pancakes with bacon. Everything tasted fine, except the bacon tasted off, which is weird because ... bacon. The Popeye's Favorite was really salty, and yet lacked flavor, somehow. I did really enjoy the coffee, though. I take my coffee black, so the coffee really needs to be able to hold up on its own. We didn't have to wait at all when we visited on a Saturday at 9 a.m. By the time we left, though, there was a long wait. It pays to be an early-bird when you're dining at a breakfast place. read more

See all

Stopped in for breakfast on my way to work. Quickly b realized there were limited options for me as I don't really eat eggs anymore. I settled on the potatoes and an English muffin. I should have checked my bag before I left but they didn't give me any flatware. Thankfully found a fork at work. The potatoes needed some salt at least and some butter for the muffin would have been nice. read more

This is worth the wait. We had to wait more than 30 minutes but I can understand why. Everybody goes there I will bd returning as soon as possible! read more

Went on a Saturday and anticipated very long line but we were seated on 15 minutes. Waiter : Brandon was phenomenal! He was very professional, helpful and was quick to address our needs. Ask for Brandon on your next visit. Food: My partner and I were meeting for lunch on the first Saturday after New Years. She had an omelette ( cannot recall which one) and a Mimosa. I had the Shrimp and Grits and at Brandon's suggestion- had it city style so good! Wrapped it up with beignets which were quite tasty! Another Broken Egg has one the the best menus around - a nice variety and the meals are always well executed' The only con I have in that the two seater tables are too small in proportion to the size of plates! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Shrimp and Grits - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Took my whole family to breakfast here the other day before my parents returned to Texas. This place is awesome. A very Southern feel to the breakfast menu. Everything looked delicious, so it was impossible to know what to try. I ended up going with the Smoked Salmon Benedict which had a poached egg with hollandaise on top of a bagel. The grits were unreal as well, loaded with smoked gouda, bacon, tomato, and green onion. My wife and dad had they Daystarter which they both loved and my mom had the Bacquezo Omelette, which she loved with cream cheese in it. Great kids menu as well, very close to the house and awesome breakfast. We will come back here often. read more

See all

Excellent service, food was hot, fast, and seasoned well. Customer Service was over and beyond accommodating during the Mother's Day rush! We will definitely be back! read more

I really wanted a breakfast sandwich traditional bacon egg & cheese on an English muffin. I didn't want anything that was McMuffin . So I went in and asked for just that it wasn't on the menu and they didn't hesitate to create exactly what I wanted. I'm so blown away by dedication to service and not just meeting expectations but surpassing them. Now I know what you're thinking....umm how does it taste. ITS AMAZING & DELICIOUS. The bacon is real the eggs are delicious and the cheese was cheddar and not American. I went back ordered pancakes for me and my little and asked for powdered sugar and let's just say....Monroe LOVED IT- we will be back to try their beignets! We got a free coupon so we're excited about that. It's breast cancer awareness month and they gave my daughter a breast cancer bracelet. #breastcancerstrong I just love the friendly staff and amazing food read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Inside - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Love this place the food was delicious and strawberry mimosas was just as tasty. We'll be back soon. Crab cakes mmm mm good read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Crab Cakes and Fried Green tomatoes . City Grits and Chorizo stuffed omelette - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

So this another amazing visit to ABE, and this time I brought friends.! They loved it. We had amazing mimosas and great breakfast before heading to the track for Carb day! We decided to sit at the bar and have our meal and we had an amazing bartender. He was super knowledgeable and made our visit worth while. The food is amazing as usual. Super flavorful and unique, nothing like your normal breakfast places. How does Shrimp and grits sound for breakfast! The more I visit, the more I love it! Highly recommended and try the lemon blueberry mimosa read more

See all

My order was wrong. My drink was wrong. I got the smallest eggs I've ever seen and I am 64 years old. I paid over $ 50 for one person and am still hungry. I won't be back read more

It looks like I found another place for breakfast and brunch close by. My coworker and I had breakfast at Another Broken Egg Cafe to catch up and talk about work. I had the Monterey Jack omelet and my co-worker had the eggs Benedict. The hollandaise sauce was too heavy for my coworker, so she had to send her entree back. The server was very nice and accommodating and had the cook take off the hollandaise sauce and come back with a fresh dish and a substitute sauce that my coworker liked very much. My entrée was fabulous and very fresh!! I was very impressed with the coffee because it is very difficult to find a breakfast place with great coffee!! It was so good that I did not need to put cream and sugar in the coffee to make it taste better. That is saying something about this establishment! If you do not like anything else about Another Broken Egg Cafe, you should come for the coffee! They also sell their coffee mugs which are very nice and unique. I would recommend buying one of their coffee mugs to have at your house. I will get one the next time I come here for breakfast. The customer service is excellent and the staff is very friendly! You will love Another Broken Egg Cafe and not be disappointed!!! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Coffee - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Came in for brunch, seated quickly. My husband has to eat breakfast first no matter the time. He enjoyed his lemon goat cheese pancakes with blueberries and side of scrambled eggs. My eggs Benedict looked beautiful but , was pretty tasteless. It came with grits that had a funny texture. Almost like oatmeal. It's a cute place, convenient parking and close to businesses so I would try again. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

My first time visiting this restaurant...my waiter was Brandon and his energy was so pleasant. They started me off with their beignets on the house. I was debating between chicken and waffles and shrimp and grits and Brandon recommended the shrimp and grits. They were different but really good. My friend ordered breakfast tacos and she said they were amazing... they came with a watermelon salsa that she was very skeptical of but was pleasantly surprised by. They do have a decent beverage menu to include mimosas but I did not partake in it this morning. I enjoyed my overall experience here. read more

See all

I suggested this place to a friend and got on their website ahead of time to check out dine-in issues related to COVID. But because their site isn't particularly mobile friendly (the screen gets dark and jumps around a lot), I kind of gave up too soon. What I didn't see is that they prefer call-ahead reservations in an effort to keep the restaurant's waiting room clear. They ask that you wait outside and then they give call-backs for seating. That's all fine and good when this policy went into effect last May, but it was in the 20's when we were there last weekend. I walked in, gave my name for the first time and was asked to wait in my car. My car? That was a little off-putting. Luckily my friend arrived within 2 minutes and we decided to skirt the system by grabbing coffees at the bar. Simple enough, right? But there's no sitting or even standing at the bar currently. Uggh. I hadn't brunched in Indy since we could do so outside and just wanted to relax. Oh how the two of us health workers wished we could just flash our vaccination cards carried in our purses. With their ceramic-mugged coffees in hand as leverage, we found a spot with two chairs near the waiting area and hoped we wouldn't get asked to leave. They do as good as any place I've seen maintaining social distancing, keeping every other table or so free. Between that and the tables that were reserved for folks who had yet to answer/arrive from their call-backs, it seemed like they were always well under 50% capacity at any one time. I had a specialty egg dish, the lobster and Brie omelette. The lobster and Brie sauce is layered on top with cream cheese filling the actual inside of the omelette. That's a bit over-the-top rich, and I might have ordered something else had I read the menu thoroughly. But we were there to catch up not scour the menu and though busy gabbing, we weren't rushed by our server. She noticed I mentioned a desire to be gluten free when I ordered grits as my side, so she took the liberty of adding GF toast instead of the standard English muffin. That was appreciated. We asked for something just about every time she checked on us, and she always met it with a smile. This is a very solid brunch place, with some specialty dishes you won't find at too many other places and a great location just off of 465-exactly what we needed. read more

I've attended this location Multiple Times and each time it's delicious. I usually get the banana foster pancakes but this time I decided to try the banana foster French toast! It was delicious! I typically like my French toast to be EXTRA saucy whether it be maple or foster sauce. (I opted into additional foster sauce on the side) we also love the mimosa pitchers! Perfect for breakfast and brunch. You get about 6 glasses in the pitcher all together. Update: SETH! The manager is absolutely amazing! He gives the best service! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Banana foster French toast - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana