Nice restaurant in the heart of Greenport, food was good, service was quick, overall good experience.

We had a great meal here- so family friendly with quick service. We ordered the crispy chicken sandwich, chicken paillard salad and chicken tenders for my daughter. The vibe is casual and chill, and they have an outdoor seating option. Would recommend to others. read more

Came to Andy's last night for dinner with my husband & sons. It also just so happened to be bingo night!! We had such a great time. From the service to food all 5 stars. I ordered the French dip sandwich and my husband ordered steak. We both really enjoyed It. My son had spaghetti & chicken meatball and finished with the brownie sundae! Great time and will definitely be back when we're in the area. read more

See all

A great choice to stop for a few drinks, watch a game, for lunch, casual dinner, or pre dinner drinks. Good choice of draft and bottled beer, friendly bartenders, and I really liked the popcorn machine that was behind the bar, and the steady supply of fresh popped snacks! read more

I really enjoyed my first time at this place. The waiters were very nice and attentive. The food was very good and well prepared. For my appetizer I had the chicken dumplings and they were very tasty. For my entree I had the Fried Kickin Chicken Sandwich with French Fries. It was delicious and well seasoned. The restaurant was fairly quiet for a Saturday afternoon. People started coming in shortly after I got there. I would definitely visit this place again whenever I'm in Greenport. It is such a beautiful town. read more

See all

Andy's was a great place to hang out and enjoy the food and excellent drinks Andy is a great host, and takes great care of his guests Service was outstanding read more

The food... Terrific, Clam Chowder absolutely great-homemade and over the top... Calamari yummy and perfectly prepared... AND the Chili... Andy;s chili is "made in heaven"... fyi... we're seniors and eat out often... these guys do a great job...COMPLIMENTS TO THE CHEF! The service... Superb... we felt welcome and were greeted with a smiling and professional Service Professional... his cheerful and informative persona was really appreciated... THANK YOU! The ambiance... okay guys, if you are looking for comfortable, warm, friendly this is your place... In summary... When in Jamesport you gotta go... if you are looking for pretentious minimalism this isn't your place... VALUE (the elephant in the room)... Andy's is an excellent value and you should give 'em a try! read more

Nice eatery with sports and divey vibes in the town of Greenport. I went with all specials presented by the server and was not disappointed. It wasn't your average bar food to have chicken dumplings and/or gyro at a bar. The server handled the crowd very well and we were seated by the bartender upon walking in. He also jumped on tables to help the one server that was overloaded by the sudden rush of customers. I had the chicken dumplings with teriyaki and it was great! The teriyaki was on the thicker side but still a great dip for the dumplings. The beef gyro was unexpected. Packed with seasoning and side of fries was the most top notch I've had for the ambiance of a bar in ever. I would recommend in the small town for a quick relaxed comfort eat. read more

I cannot fathom how this establishment got 2025 Awards??? with ceiling tiles ajar and a server who can't stop whistling?? Please, if you are whistling while serving customers, your spittle and germs are being spread onto your customers food The New England Clam Chowder was pasty with one clam piece... please list as potato starch chowder, visable flour balls. The Mac & Cheese was over cooked shells stirred with an orange cheese sauce...gross... Many other choices in Greenport, go elsewhere. read more

We had a really great time here yesterday. No frills bar with a nice outdoor patio in the back. Our waitresses was great and even had treats for the dog! Food and drinks were a solid choice and it wasn't busy at all for a beautiful Sunday afternoon. We started off with the Buffalo cauliflower which was awesome! The blue cheese was really fantastic too! I had the kickin chicken sandwich with fries and it was a solid choice. The others at the table ordered fish tacos which were so fresh, the burger and the French dip. Kids enjoyed the food as well! Great choice for a lunch spot in greenport! read more

See all

This place never disappoints me. it's my favorite spot in Greenport all around. The grilled octopus salad is really yummy. loved the fried pickles. It's just such a feel good place read more

See all

Slowest service ever... took over an hour from the time we ordered until food was brought out to the table. Waiter was hustling but apparently there was a one man show happening in the kitchen. And that was on a busy Saturday. Food was extremely overpriced and underwhelming. The ridiculously overcooked Thai linguine was skimpy on seafood and spices and noodles were mushy. Teriyaki chicken cutlet was small, salad wilted and rice overcooked. The bland shrimp burger likely came from the frozen food section of the local grocery store and was served on a plain bun with a few french fries. We are no strangers to dining out and our party collectively agreed this was, hands down, perhaps the worst restaurant meal we have ever eaten. It was painful paying top dollar for such a dismal dining experience. Avoid this extremely overrated and overpriced restaurants at all costs. Greenport has much better places to offer! read more

The food was great! The hot chicken sandwich was one of the best we've had. The chicken & fish tacos were also really good. The fried pork & chicken dumplings were good as well. We would go back and have it all again. Unfortunately there is no ambience, it is a bar not a restaurant so it doesn't have that nice dining experience so we ordered it as a takeout & ate on our boat. read more

I was crazing wings in Greenport and this was recommended. They gave us popcorn rather than a starter like chips or something which I am not used to but it was cool. We got the wings and they were pretty good. I asked for an extra side of buffalo sauce because it was a little dry for my liking. The servers were real nice and had a whole conversation because the rest of the restaurant was almost empty. Very good overall and I would go again. read more

Andy's - Waiting for food - Gastropubs Near Me - Greenport, New York

By far best lobster roll in town! Perfect butter dipped roll topped with a large fresh delicious portion of lobster meat!

Clean bar/restaurant atmosphere. Very low key. Typical bar menu. Ordered the the potato skin shots, they were delicious. My husband ordered the chimichanga, he loved it. We will come back. I ordered the Andy's Daly for a drink also great. read more

See all

Great little sports bar ordered some chicken nuggets for my child and he loved them I couldn't even take a picture of them he scarfed it all down! Great employees! Supper clean inside! Very helpful staff! And the best chicken nuggets ever is what my son said! read more

Andy's - Front door entrance! - Gastropubs Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

Second time in Greenport First place to go is Andy's Greenport New York I feel like I want to get greedy with the food! Very nice place Cozy Deliciousness A definite five star in my book read more

See all

We were a large group, and Andy's had something for everyone. I had a reuben sandwich which was tender and delicious, and there were a variety of other options including the fresh, local catch of the day. The service was excellent and food was prepared fresh, but quickly. read more

Sad. This place used to be good. Bartender acted like I was the one that killed his dog bc he had to serve a table. Food was horrendous. Roast beef in French dip was pure chewy fat. Ear of corn? That will be $10... great value. Chicken wings you can't really mess up... but 6 for $15. Lol Sad. Try somewhere else. read more

Andy's is a great place. The owner is always friendly and service is great. We love the oysters!

Terrible service. My daughter and I asked to sit by the window and the server said "For f--ks sake." Really? No wonder why there were only two other parties in the restaurant where other's were busy. We got up and left. Who says that ever, but especially when you are with your daughter. read more

We were looking for a place for lunch recently and with so many choices in this little area and all for some reason with four stars, it was tough. We scanned this place and instantly I was lurched into the calamari appetizer on the menu...It looked SOOO good!!! Turns out, I felt like Ralphie in the Movie the Christmas Story when he met Santa at the Mall and was told he would "...Shoot Your Eye Out Kid"...completely crushed. I sent back the calamari which resembled White Castle clam strips. There was three tablespoons of oil on the bottom, two slices of cherry peppers on the side, and they forgot the mayo. I couldn't figure out what could have been the lemon, and there were a few charred garlic chips (or leftover french fry chips from the last order of fries possible as it had no flavor) but nothing to write home about.....terrible. "Gussied-Up Chicken Sandwich was ok. Still think it was missing the brie cheese, unless they spread it like a schmear of cream cheese on a bagel, but overall when dipped in the vinaigrette that the side salad came with was pretty good. Only reason this place gets 3 stars is the sandwich. That and the fact that although we were alone, it was a great place if we were with the kids so I'd recommend it if you are with kids, just buyer beware. Pictures are worth a thousand words, so I have gleefully provided one of our grease trap... read more

Andy's - Gastropubs Near Me - Greenport, New York

Place was understaffed, Food was lousy, undercooked, so therefore, I didn't eat after one bite of the food. Waiter was never to be found, and finally when he was, we told him we never received our app, he never brought our wing order and he said "well you don't need it anyway you ordered enough food." So he was very rude. Needless to say we will never go back there! read more

The Quick: Impressed that Andy's is more than just typical bar food! The outside patio was great, pretty spacious. We love the fried cauliflower wings, the tomato soup really is famous, and of course the french fries. they had a grilled vegetable option which was appreciated but of course we devoured the mac and cheese first read more

See all

Took a drive out to Greenport for a birthday luncheon ,we left town hungry and disappointed ... I ordered a med rare marinated burger only to be served a dry hockey puck . The burgers were inedible ALL our burgers were well -done /dry . When our server asked how things were we told him that they were not cooked right ect . He responded "I'll relay the feedback to the kitchen " never did he ask if he could get us new items or a redo . When the bill arrived, they had the audacity to charge us for all three burgers at $20 a pop. When I say we all had one bite and that was it . We were the only table in the restaurant and now I know why.My dog made out pretty good. We however won't be returning . read more

Andy's - Dry burger - Gastropubs Near Me - Greenport, New York

Nice location. Nice selection of good foods. Nice service with a smile. Nice-nice-Baby! read more

I just visited this place today with my boyfriend because we were looking for lunch in Greenport. When we were seated, we were sitting at a high top table and one of waiters brought us a small bag of buttered popcorn along with our two drinks we ordered. We figured out what we wanted to order food wise but the waiter didn't come until maybe 10-15 minutes later. The service was slow in the beginning and it looked like they didn't have enough wait staff in the restaurant. Initially when we first walked in there were a couple of people but then it started to fill up and get busy. When we finished our first round of drinks and the popcorn, our waiter finally showed up. We both ordered sandwiches. I got the Guissed Up Grilled Chicken Sandwich w/ fries. It was a large grilled chicken breast with lettuce, Brie cheese spread, and pickled onions on a toasted baguette. The chicken was tender, juicy and the Brie went so well with it all combined on the sandwich. My boyfriend got their BLT which had a ton of bacon on it, on toasted potato bread. Besides the service being really slow here, the food was very good! Nice atmosphere, nothing fancy. Low key and friendly staff. Would probably come here again but hope the service improves. read more

Andy's - Grilled Chicken Sandwich w/ Brie cheese spread, pickled onions. And French fries - Gastropubs Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

Great location for what could be a great sushi bar like SUGARFISH. Instead, this is a very disappointing restaurant with a promising menu that doesn't live up to its expectations. Octopus was chewy and almost in edible. I would've sent it back if I wasn't starving. Boyfriend's salad with grilled chicken was tasteless and seemed cheesy. The waitress needs a personality infusion and she was coughing. I hope we don't get sick Very under impressive and overpriced salad. Cocktail list looked better than the food menu. read more

See all

The potato skins were good! That was the only good thing. The waiter was nice, but not really attentive. we waited over 20 min for a salad to come out, and it was just ok. Then people who came in 15 min later were served before us (they got burgers). We got the octopus salad and the octopus was super tough. We also literally waited over 20 minutes just to receive the check. We asked over 3 people and finally received a check. Don't recommend going here. read more

Was in the area checking out the lavender field and decided to stop by the area for lunch as our group was hungry. Decided to come here as lots of other places are closed during that time between lunch and dinner. We were seated near the front of restaurant in the high tables so it was harder to get staff attention. Ordered nachos, wings, fries, chicken sandwich, fish and chips, salad. Everything tasted mediocre. The highlight was the music playlist they had- throwback 90s songs. read more

Opened promptly at Noon for lunch with seating either inside or out. We chose inside and were seated immediately. Long bar area separated from the dining room so noise from bar non existent. We ordered the large pretzel and the spicy fried pickles to start off. Pickles are a must and was a large serving. Beer is mandatory. Known worldwide (or at least Greenport wide) for the Fried Chicken Sandwich you owe it to yourself to order one. Again you will be happy you ordered that beer. My wife ordered the less well known but still delicious fish tacos. Portions were generous and staff was attentive. Parking was easy just behind the restaurant. Go. read more

Andy's - Bar - Gastropubs Near Me - Greenport, New York

Never coming back. Sat outside in the back Sun 10/25/21 3pm. Service was slow though only 1 other table inside. Hair in the tomato soup... waiter said "oh..ok" and took it. No apologies no I'm so sorry. We didn't even know if he was bringing another one. Undercooked chicken in the Sammie. Will update later if I get food poisoning. Overcooked chicken and missing Brie in the other chicken sandwich which was mostly bread. Wife didn't even bother finishing it. Only OK things were the kids cheeseburger meals and the trio sliders. Waiter was the dude that used to work at lucharitos. Tattoo on his right wrist. Never said you're welcome or thank you. Or asked if we needed anything else. He seemed almost upset that we recognized him when we first sat down. From then on he basically made as few sounds/noises as possible. Brought stuff to table and didn't speak. read more

Andy's Pub- Super friendly service, tasty French fries, awesome soft pretzel and popcorn to boot! I stopped in for a couple beers, I will be back! @noodlesoupreview Follow me on social media as I search for the perfect bowl of noodle soup. read more

Happened upon this bar while visiting friends in Greenport for the day. The bartender, who I later realized was the owner, Andy, turned a TV to the NFL game I wanted to watch and was quick with a drink and bonus, popcorn. A nice crowd of locals gathered to enjoy the various games that were on. I didn't order food but everything I saw looked delicious and I look forward to lunch another time. Nice owner, nice people and a fun Sunday venue for football. This would be my local bar if only I was a local. read more

Food was Fair. That is where the 3 Stars come from. It was very loud people were yelling over each other. Not just one table either. Bartender/waiter needs hygiene lessons. Bartender yells out only I can yell around here. More yelling ensued. This was on a Sunday Sunday afternoon and It was not crowded. read more

Our first trip to Greenport was worth it. Andy's serves good food and he is very friendly and accommodating. The Veggie Burger is a must try. You will not be disappointed or even miss your beef read more

See all

Worst service from a young server that wasn't sure what cucumbers were. Took 10 minutes to get water. He forgot our beer order. The mixed drinks were terrible. The food was D+ at best. Avoid this trash heap at all costs. Total dump. Crap food. Terrible service and way overpriced. I wish I could go back in time and keep walking passed this door. read more

i really wanted to like this place but it fell pretty short. honestly, it was pretty overpriced for the quality of food and drinks i received. the specialty drinks were okay, i was not a big fan of a watery Jack & Coke especially for the price i paid. i don't know if i came on a bad/slow day, but it seemed that customer service was an afterthought. now for the food, i have never been so disappointed. i have never in my life had a shrimp po boy that had absolutely NO flavour, honestly shocking. the only thing i could taste was the bread and slight lettuce. the french fries could be compared to frozen fries you get in a bad TV dinner. not all is bad, the atmosphere and location are okay. go to another place if you want food with flavour. read more

See all

Really nice and clean restaurant. The staff treated us very well. The menu is a twist on regular meals. Every thing was perfect looking forward to going back read more